Evaluation of various brain structures in multiple sclerosis with multimodality evoked potentials, blink reflex and nystagmography

Supratentorial multiple sclerosis lesions affect the blink reflex test

INTRODUCTION

The Blink Reflex Test (BRT) is a neurophysiological examination used for evaluation of brainstem reflex circuits. MRI is the most precise modality for evaluation of MS lesion anatomy. Our study objective was to investigate how the functional results of the neurophysiological BRT relate to the anatomy of MS lesions in routine MRI studies.

METHODS

65 MS patients underwent the BRT within 2 months of a brain MRI showing demyelinating lesions.

RESULTS

The overall sensitivity of the BRT was 90.8%, while in patients with at least one brainstem lesion and no brainstem lesions it was 91.4% and 90%, respectively.

DISCUSSION

The presence of brainstem lesions does not significantly affect BRT sensitivity. This points to the influence of supratentorial MS lesions on the BRT. Gender, age, disease duration, type of MS, acuteness of an MS event and whether MS diagnosis was recent or not were not variables affecting the results.

Binocular saccadic eye movements in multiple sclerosis

We attempted to increase the sensitivity for detection of abnormal binocular saccadic eye movements, particularly of the internuclear ophthalmoplegia (INO) type associated with multiple sclerosis (MS). Saccades of 10 and 20 degrees were binocularly recorded with scleral sensor coils in 10 normal control subjects and 26 patients with definite or probable MS, seven of whom had a clinically manifest INO in one or both directions. In the cases in which this was accompanied by a dissociated nystagmus of the abducting eye, our recordings showed that such secondary saccades were also expressed, in a strongly reduced form, by the adducting eye. The patients with manifest INO showed lower average peak velocities and peak accelerations, especially for adduction of the eye on the affected side, but the distribution of these parameters overlapped with the normal distribution. A much sharper distinction between normals and patients with INOs was found by considering the ratios between peak accelerations and velocities of saccade pairs (abducting eye/adducting eye). These ratios, which eliminate much intra- and inter-individual variability, had a narrow range in normals, and all values for INOs were outside this range. On this basis, the 19 patients without clinically manifest INO were easily separated into subgroups of 14 patients with completely normal interocular ratios and five patients with elevated peak velocity and acceleration ratios, identified as sub-clinical (uni- or bilateral) INOs. Measurements of vertical saccades and of interocular timing differences provided no useful criteria for disturbances of binocular coordination in MS. We conclude that in particular, the acceleration of the adducting eye is strongly reduced in patients with an INO, and that this reduction is best identified by interocular comparison between binocular pairs of saccades.

Diagnostic value of paraclinical tests in multiple sclerosis: relative sensitivities and specificities for reclassification according to the Poser committee criteria

The yield of paraclinical tests was evaluated in a prospective study of 189 consecutive patients referred for suspected multiple sclerosis (142 patients with multiple sclerosis, 47 non-multiple sclerosis patients on discharge). Patients were first classified according to the Poser criteria by the clinical findings. Subsequently, the results of paraclinical tests (cranial MRI, visually evoked potentials (VEPs), somatosensory evoked potentials by tibial nerve stimulation (SSEPs), motor evoked potentials (MEPs), and analysis of CSF for oligoclonal banding and IgG-index (CSF)) were taken into account. The percentage of reclassified patients (reclassification sensitivity, RS) was always lower than the percentage of abnormal results (diagnostic sensitivity, DS), and the divergence of RS v DS differed between the tests (60% v 84% in MRI, 31% v 77% in CSF, 29% v 37% in VEPs, 20% v 68% in MEPs, and 12% v 46% in SSEPs respectively). False reclassifications of non-multiple sclerosis patients to multiple sclerosis would have occurred with all tests (MRI: six of 47 patients, (reclassification specificity 88%); CSF: one (98%); VEPs: two (96%); MEPs: two (96%); SSEPs: four (91%); P < 0.05). Although MRI had superior diagnostic capacity, 57 of the 142 patients with multiple sclerosis were not reclassified by the MRI result, 12 of whom were reclassified by CSF and 18 by one of the evoked potential (EP) studies. Of the 98 patients not reclassified by CSF, 53 were reclassified by MRI and 39 by EPs. The results suggest that for the evaluation of paraclinical tests in suspected multiple sclerosis, comparison of diagnostic sensitivities is inappropriate. In general, a cranial MRI contributes most to the diagnosis; however, due to its comparatively low specificity and its considerable number of negative results, EP or CSF studies are often useful to establish the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis.

Multimodality electroneurophysiological findings in intra-axial and extra-axial lesions of the brain stem

In 330 patients with a space occupying lesion of the posterior cranial fossa, the blink (BR) and masseter (MR) reflexes and brain stem auditory (BAEP) and somatosensory evoked potentials (SEP) were registered. The aim of our study was to look for electrophysiological criteria of differentiating between lesions within or outside the brain stem. The ipsilateral loss of BAEP in cerebellopontine angle tumours and the altered SEP in tumours within the brain stem turned out as frequent, almost specific findings. Prolonged ipsi-and contralateral late BR responses and prolonged MR responses, a long somatosensory central conduction time of the SEP and a prolonged wave III latency as well as a prolonged interpeak latency of the BAEP are not indicative but highly suspicious for a lesion within the brain stem. Prolonged early responses of the BR together with prolonged interpeak latencies of the BAEP are characteristic findings in cerebello-pontine angle tumours.

Primary progressive versus relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis in Japanese patients: a combined clinical, magnetic resonance imaging and multimodality evoked potential study

Thirty-five Japanese patients with relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis (RRMS) and 11 Japanese patients with primary progressive MS (PPMS) were compared by a combined clinical, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and multimodality evoked potential (MEP) study. Patients with PPMS showed a more common occurrence of gait disturbance as the initial symptoms as well as a more common occurrence of cerebellar symptomatology than did those with RRMS, while spinal cord symptomatology was frequently observed in both conditions. On brain MRI, patients with PPMS had 3 times more lesions than did those with RRMS (P < 0.001, chi 2-test). The percentage of infratentorial lesions was also significantly higher in PPMS than in RRMS on MRI. Moreover, we found a significantly higher frequency of abnormal records in visual, brainstem auditory and somatosensory evoked potentials in PPMS than in RRMS. Interestingly, clinically unexpected abnormalities were significantly more common in PPMS than in RRMS throughout all modalities of MEPs. Thus, in Eastern MS, there exists a distinction between PPMS and RRMS in the MRI and MEP findings as well as in the clinical findings. Our result therefore suggest that there may be two distinct subtypes in MS.

Electronystagmography in the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis

The aim of our study was to define the diagnostic importance of a complete electronystagmographic (ENG) examination (visual-vestibular, vestibular and visual suppression tests on caloric nystagmus) in patients affected by MS. Of 144 patients examined, 116 were definite and 28 possible. Descriptive data of the instrumental findings showed very frequent alterations of one or more subtests: pursuit movements and visual suppression test were especially pathological, in respectively 56% and 58% of the cases; spontaneous and/or evoked nystagmus was present in 45%. A comparison between clinical and instrumental evidence of brainstem/cerebellar involvement indicated that 18% of the definite and 32% of the possible MS cases presented a negative clinical examination with positive instrumental findings. The usefulness of including a comprehensive ENG examination to obtain paraclinical evidence of a second lesion in the CNS in early MS is discussed.

Role of saccadic analysis in the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis in the era of magnetic resonance imaging

Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has recently been recognised as the most sensitive method with which to detect clinically silent lesions in patients affected by multiple sclerosis. Visually guided horizontal saccadic eye movements (SEM) were studied, together with MRI, in 57 multiple sclerosis patients. A very similar sensitivity was found for both MRI (78.2%) and SEM analysis (76.3%). Significant associations between peak saccadic velocity and brain stem signs and between saccadic latency and visual signs were observed.

The contribution of saccadic eye movements analysis, visual and auditory evoked responses to the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis

A number of tests have been used to identify paraclinical evidences of central nervous system (CNS) lesions in multiple sclerosis (MS). The present study was aimed to test and compare the diagnostic value of saccadic eye movements (SEM) analysis, and visual and auditory brain stem evoked responses (VER, ABER) in MS, and to study the correlation between electrophysiologic findings and clinical data. The reference group for epidemiological and statistical analysis was selected from the group of 109 suspected MS patients included in the study. SEM analysis resulted at least as sensitive as VER and ABER. SEM analysis showed good sensitivity and positive predictive value. Saccade latency resulted the most sensitive SEM parameter. Subclinical internuclear ophthalmoparesis resulted highly specific. We suggest that SEM analysis could be included into the electrophysiologic tests for identifying paraclinical evidences of CNS lesions in MS. Correlations between electrophysiologic findings and clinical data are discussed.

Cerebral evoked potentials in multiple sclerosis

Multimodal evoked potentials were analyzed from 58 possible, 62 probable and 100 definite (total 220) multiple sclerosis (MS) patients. Visual evoked potentials (VEP) were most frequently abnormal yielding 39%, 69%, 84% in the three diagnostic groups respectively. Median nerve sensory evoked potentials (SEP) yielded abnormalities in 26%, 65%, 79% respectively. Brainstem auditory evoked responses (BAER) were abnormal in 17%, 39%, 66% respectively. We measured the combined amplitude (CA) of waves III, IV, V in the BAER of these patients as an objective measure of amplitude asymmetry. The CA was considered abnormal if it was 1SD below the lowest CA value in the control group. The CA was abnormal in 9.2% of BAER with normal central conduction time. The BAER diagnostic yield in MS patients increased 11% by using CA analysis.

The diagnosis of multiple sclerosis. Contribution of non-clinical tests

A group of 89 patients in whom multiple sclerosis (MS) has been clinically diagnosed with varying degrees of certainty, and 25 patients with optic neuritis (ON), were subjected to the following electrophysiological tests: visual evoked response (VER), auditory brainstem-evoked response (ABER), somatosensory-evoked response (SSER), blink reflex and electronystagmography (ENG). All these patients also underwent computerized tomography (CT scan) and analysis of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). A new diagnostic procedure is proposed, combining optimum detection of definite MS with optimally economical use of the above-mentioned non-clinical tests. The results for the MS patients show that definite MS can be diagnosed much more frequently (72%) if abnormal results in the above-mentioned tests are accepted as evidence of a (subclinical) CNS lesion. Application of the clinical diagnostic criteria of McAlpine yielded "definite MS" only in 27% of our patient material. Our diagnostic criteria showed evidence for MS in 36% of the patients clinically diagnosed as having ON. The test results were inconclusive as regards the possibility of the remaining ON patients developing MS in the future.

An evaluation of laboratory investigations in patients with multiple sclerosis

The contribution of VEP, CT and oligoclonal bands (OB) to the diagnosis of MS was studied in a group of 213 hospitalized patients. Whereas the diagnostic values of VEP and OB were both in the same range, the combination of both methods increased the proportion of cases with "definite MS" from 58 to 75%, whereas CT did not contribute significantly to diagnostic ascertainment. Vitamin B12 absorption was less than 10% in 27% of cases. A slight tendency towards increased serum IgG and IgM levels was found, and the rheumatoid factor was demonstrated in 6% of cases.

Jaw, blink and corneal reflex latencies in multiple sclerosis

Jaw, blink and corneal reflexes, which all involve the trigeminal system, were recorded in 54 patients with multiple sclerosis; thirty-seven of these patients were classified as having definite multiple sclerosis and 17 as indefinite multiple sclerosis, according to Schumacher's criteria. The jaw reflex was abnormal less frequently than either of the other two reflexes, but in four cases it was the only abnormal reflex found. Testing a combination of two or three trigeminal reflexes did not yield a higher incidence of abnormalities than testing the blink or corneal reflex alone. Nine patients showed abnormal reflexes which were unexpected on the basis of clinical symptoms. The combined recordings demonstrate at least one abnormal reflex in 74% of the patients. The various types of reflex abnormalities reflect major damage to different parts of the trigeminal system and may therefore make an important contribution to the diagnosis of multiple sclerosis.

Electrophysiological disorders in multiple sclerosis and optic neuritis

Visual evoked response (VER), auditory brainstem evoked response (ABER), somatosensory evoked response (SSER), blink reflex and electronystagmographic (ENG) investigative methods were applied to a group of 89 patients with Multiple Sclerosis (MS) and Optic Neuritis (ON). The MS patients were classified as definite (n = 31), probable (n = 31) and possible (n = 27). The aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic value of the five electrophysiological tests in MS. VER and ABER recordings were found to reveal the highest number of asymptomatic abnormalities (33 and 31 percent respectively). The combination of VER, ABER and ENG revealed all possible electrophysiological disorders. As these tests are completely non-invasive it is proposed, that a combination of two of these three tests is useful for the detection of a second silent lesion in patients with suspected MS showing purely spinal signs (VER, ENG, ABER) and/or a history of uncomplicated ON (ABER, ENG).

Brainstem involvement in multiple sclerosis: a clinical and electrophysiological study

A major aim of this study was to determine the diagnostic value of 4 electrophysiological tests in MS, and particularly their effectiveness in detecting signs of brainstem involvement. Therefore, auditory brainstem evoked response (ABER), somatosensory evoked response (SSER), blink reflex and electronystagmographic (ENG) investigative methods were applied to a group of 89 patients with definite, probable or possible multiple sclerosis (MS). The 4 methods yielded interdependent data, especially where the brainstem function was concerned, thus it can be concluded that a single demyelinating lesion may cause a combination of electrophysiological disorders within a small structure such as the brainstem. ENG recordings were found to reveal the highest number of asymptomatic abnormalities. The combination of ABER and ENG tests revealed electrophysiological disorders in 81% of all patients. The blink reflex and the SSER tests gave hardly supplementary information.

Neuropathies of the optic nerve and visual evoked potentials with special reference to color vision and differential light threshold measured with the computer perimeter OCTOPUS

The contrast evoked potentials (VEPs) to different check sizes were recorded in about 200 cases of discrete optic neuropathies (ON) of different origin. Differential light threshold (DLT) was tested with the computer perimeter OCTOPUS. Saturated and desaturated tests were applied to evaluate the degree of acquired color vision deficiency. Delayed VEP responses are not confined to optic neuritis (RBN) alone and the different latency times obtained from other ON are confluent. The delay may be due to demyelination, to an increasing dominance of paramacular VEP subcomponents or to an increasing dominance of the upper half-field responses. Recording with smaller check sizes has the advantage that discrete dysfunctions in the visual field (VF) center are more easily detected: a correlation between amplitudes and visual acuity is best in strabismic amblyopias, is less expressed in maculopathies of the retina and weak in ON. The absence or reduction of amplitudes to smaller check sizes, however, is an important indication of a disorder in the VF center of ON in an early or recovered stage. Acquired color vision defects of the tritan-like type are more confined to discrete ON, whereas the red/green type is reserved to more severe ON. The DLT of the VF center is reduced in a different, significant and non significant extent in discrete optic neuropathies and the correlation between DLT and visual acuity is weak. A careful numerical analysis is needed in types of discrete ON where the central DLT lies within normal statistical limits: a side difference of the DLT between the affected and the normal fellow eye is always present. Evaluation of visual fatigue effects and of the relative sensitivity loss of VF center and VF periphery may provide further diagnostic information.

Success and failure of evoked potentials in detecting clinical and subclinical lesions in multiple sclerosis patients

The value of visual, brain stem auditory and somatosensory potentials in detecting clinical and subclinical lesions as compared to the routine neurological, ophthalmological and vestibular examinations was investigated in 100 M.S. patients. It would appear that the VEP and SEP are far superior to the routine techniques in demonstrating lesions. On the other hand, the BAEP is inferior to the clinical and vestibular test as an indicator of brain stem lesions. All clinically manifest posterior column lesions are associated with abnormal SEP. However a substantial proportion of clinically evident lesions in the visual pathways or the midbrain and pons are not detectable by the VEP and BAEP.