Yeast and mammalian replication intermediates migrate similarly in two-dimensional gels

Analysis of Replicating Mitochondrial DNA by In Organello Labeling and Two-Dimensional Agarose Gel Electrophoresis

Our understanding of the mechanisms of DNA replication in a broad range of organisms and viruses has benefited from the application of two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis (2D-AGE). The method resolves DNA molecules on the basis of size and shape and is technically straightforward. 2D-AGE sparked controversy in the field of mitochondria when it revealed replicating molecules with lengthy tracts of RNA, a phenomenon never before reported in nature. More recently, radioisotope labeling of the DNA in the mitochondria has been coupled with 2D-AGE. In its first application, this procedure helped to delineate the "bootlace mechanism of mitochondrial DNA replication," in which processed mitochondrial transcripts are hybridized to the lagging strand template at the replication fork as the leading DNA strand is synthesized. This chapter provides details of the method, how it has been applied to date and concludes with some potential future applications of the technique.

In vivo conformation and replication intermediates of circular mitochondrial plasmids in Neurospora and Cryphonectria parasitica

The in vivo conformation and replication intermediates of fungal circular mitochondrial plasmids and plasmid-like mitochondrial element (plMEs) were analyzed by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis and electron microscopy. Plasmids with circular restriction maps exist predominantly as circular molecules and were found to replicate by rolling circle mechanisms. However, the reverse transcriptase-encoding Mauriceville plasmid of Neurospora crassa was observed to replicate by two possible mechanisms: one that is consistent with a reverse transcriptase-mediated process and a second one might involve rolling circle DNA replication. Like the mtDNA-derived plasmid-like elements of N. crassa (Hausner et al. 2006a, b), a plasmid-like element of Cryphonectria parasitica (plME-C9), which consists predominantly of a 1.4 kb nucleotide sequence different from mitochondrial DNA, also was found to replicate by a rolling circle mechanism. Although the techniques used in this study were not suited for the establishment of the in vivo conformation and mode of replication of the mtDNAs of Neurospora or Cryphonectria, we surmise that the rolling circle mechanism might be the predominant mode of DNA replication in fungal mitochondria.

A winding road to origin discovery

Studies in our laboratory over the last three decades have shown that the Chinese hamster dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) origin of replication corresponds to a broad zone of inefficient initiation sites distributed throughout the spacer between the convergently transcribed DHFR and 2BE2121 genes. It is clear from mutational analysis that none of these sites is genetically required for controlling origin activity. However, the integrity of the promoter of the DHFR gene is needed to activate the downstream origin, while the 3' processing signals prevent invasion and inactivation of the downstream origin by transcription forks. Several other origins in metazoans have been shown to correspond to zones of inefficient sites, while a different subset appears to be similar to the fixed replicators that characterize origins in S. cerevisiae and lower organisms. These observations have led us to suggest a model in which the mammalian genome is dotted with a hierarchy of degenerate, redundant, and inefficient replicators at intervals of a kilobase or less, some of which may have evolved to be highly circumscribed and efficient. The activities of initiation sites are proposed to be largely regulated by local transcription and chromatin architecture. Recently, we and others have devised strategies for identifying active origins on a genome-wide scale in order to define their distributions between fixed and dispersive origin types and to detect relationships among origins, genes, and epigenetic markers. The global pictures emerging are suggestive but far from complete and appear to be plagued by some of the same uncertainties that have led to conflicting views of individual origins in the past (particularly DHFR). In this paper, we will trace the history of origin discovery in mammalian genomes, primarily using the well-studied DHFR origin as a model, because it has been analyzed by nearly every available origin mapping technique in several different laboratories, while many origins have been identified by only one. We will address the strengths and shortcomings of the various methods utilized to identify and characterize origins in complex genomes and will point out how we and others were sometimes led astray by false assumptions and biases, as well as insufficient information. The goal is to help guide future experiments that will provide a truly comprehensive and accurate portrait of origins and their regulation. After all, in the words of George Santayana, "Those who do not learn from history are doomed to repeat it."

Analysis of mitochondrial DNA by two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis

In higher vertebrates, the DNA of mitochondria takes the form of circular molecules of approximately 16 kbp. These circles are arranged in multigenomic nucleoprotein complexes or nucleoids. It is envisaged that nucleoid superstructure makes a critical contribution to the twin processes of replication and segregation of mtDNA. Replication intermediates can be isolated from cells or solid tissues and separated on agarose gels in two dimensions to reveal a wealth of data on mechanisms of DNA replication. Using this technique we have demonstrated that many molecules of replicating mtDNA have extensive regions of RNA: DNA hybrid in higher vertebrates. More recently, we have extracted mitochondrial nucleoprotein and analyzed it by the same method to derive information on the distribution of DNA-binding proteins on mitochondrial DNA. Here we describe the procedures used to isolate intact mitochondrial replication intermediates from liver and cultured cells of higher vertebrates and the process of separating DNA fragments on neutral two-dimensional agarose gels.

Analysis of replicating mitochondrial DNA by two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis

Replication intermediates can be separated on agarose gels in two dimensions to reveal a wealth of data on mechanisms of DNA replication. When applied to mitochondrial DNA of higher vertebrates, this technique unearthed a host of unexpected findings, the full implications of which are still being absorbed. Here, we describe the procedures we use to isolate intact mitochondrial replication intermediates from liver of higher vertebrates and the process of separating DNA fragments on neutral two-dimensional agarose gels.

Biogenesis and replication of small plasmid-like derivatives of the mitochondrial DNA in Neurospora crassa

For reasons that are not obvious, sets of related, small, plasmid-like elements appear spontaneously and become amplified in the mitochondria of some cytochrome-deficient and/or UV-sensitive mutants of Neurospora crassa. These plasmid-like DNAs are multimeric series of circular molecules, each consisting of a finite number of identical tandem repeats of a relatively short mtDNA-derived nucleotide sequence (monomer). The plasmid-like elements that have been characterized in this study consist of monomers that vary in length from 125 to 296 base pairs, depending on the strain of origin. Each monomer includes a GC-rich palindrome that is followed by the promoter and a short section of the 5' terminal region of the mitochondrial large-subunit rRNA gene (rnl). Analyses of the nucleotide sequences of variants of this group of elements indicates that they are not generated by intra-molecular recombination, but are the result of single- or double-strand DNA breaks that are produced by a mismatch or base excision repair process. These elements do not appear to contain a defined origin of replication, but replicate by a recombination-dependent rolling-circle mechanism. One- and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of the plasmid-like element derived Hind III and Pst I fragments combined with S1 nuclease treatments suggest that the intergenic GC-rich palindromes, which are ubiquitous in the mtDNA Neurospora, could be replication fork pausing points.

A bidirectional origin of replication maps to the major noncoding region of human mitochondrial DNA

In solid tissues of vertebrates, initiation of mitochondrial DNA replication encompasses a broad zone downstream of the major noncoding region (NCR). In contrast, analysis with two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis of mitochondrial DNA replication intermediates in cultured human cells revealed initiation concentrated in the NCR. Mapping of prominent free 5' ends on the heavy strand of mitochondrial DNA identified two clusters of potential start sites. One mapped to the previously assigned origin of strand-asynchronous replication (O(H)); the other lay several hundred nucleotides away from O(H), toward the other end of the NCR. The latter cluster is proposed to be the major site of bidirectional replication initiation on the basis of the following: its prominence is enhanced in cells amplifying mitochondrial DNA after experimentally induced mitochondrial DNA depletion; free 5' ends are found in corresponding positions on the opposite strand; it is transient in nature; and it is associated with bubble arcs.

Bidirectional replication initiates at sites throughout the mitochondrial genome of birds

Analysis of mitochondrial replication intermediates of Gallus gallus on fork-direction gels indicates that replication occurs in both directions around circular mitochondrial DNA. This finding was corroborated by a study of chick mitochondrial DNA on standard neutral two-dimensional agarose gels, which yielded archetypal initiation arcs in fragments covering the entire genome. There was, however, considerable variation in initiation arc intensity. The majority of initiation events map to regions flanking the major non-coding region, in particular the NADH dehydrogenase subunit 6 (ND6) gene. Initiation point mapping of the ND6 gene identified prominent free 5' ends of DNA, which are candidate start sites for DNA synthesis. Therefore we propose that the initiation zone of G. gallus mitochondrial DNA encompasses most, if not all, of the genome, with preferred initiation sites in regions flanking the major non-coding region. Comparison with mammals suggests a common mechanism of initiation of mitochondrial DNA replication in higher vertebrates.

Bi-directional replication and random termination

Two-dimensional (2D) agarose gel electrophoresis was used to study termination of DNA replication in a shuttle vector, YRp7', when it replicated in Escherichia coli, Saccharomyces cerevisiae and Xenopus egg extracts. In E. coli, the 2D gel patterns obtained were consistent with uni-directional replication initiated at a specific site, the ColE1 origin. In consequence, termination also occurred precisely at the ColE1 origin. In Xenopus egg extracts, the particular shape of the bubble arc as well as the triangular smear detected to the left of the simple-Y pattern indicated random initiation and termination. In S.cerevisiae, initiation occurred at the ARS1 origin and replication proceeded in a bi-directional manner. However, termination did not always occur at a specific site 180 degrees across from the origin, but almost all along the south hemisphere of the plasmid. Inversion, deletion or replacement of DNA sequences located throughout this hemisphere did not eliminate random termination. Analysis of the replication intermediates of another yeast plasmid bearing a different origin, ARS305, also exhibited random termination. We propose that the random termination events observed in S.cerevisiae could be due to an asynchronous departure of both forks from the bi-directional origin in addition to differences in the rate of fork progression. These observations could be extended to all bi-directional origins.

Coupled leading- and lagging-strand synthesis of mammalian mitochondrial DNA

Analysis of mammalian mtDNA by two-dimensional agarose gel electrophoresis revealed two classes of replication intermediate. One was resistant to single-strand nuclease digestion and displayed the mobility properties of coupled leading- and lagging- strand replication products. Intermediates of coupled, unidirectional mtDNA replication were found in mouse liver and human placenta and were the predominant species in cultured cells recovering from transient mtDNA replication. Replication intermediates sensitive to single-strand nuclease were most abundant in untreated cultured cells. These are presumed to derive from the orthodox, strand-asynchronous mode of mtDNA replication. These findings indicate that two modes of mtDNA replication operate in mammalian cells and that changes in mtDNA copy number involve an alteration in the mode of mtDNA replication.

Mapping replication origins by neutral/neutral two-dimensional gel electrophoresis

Neutral/neutral two-dimensional gel electrophoresis is a sensitive physical mapping technique that has been successfully used to unambiguously identify replication initiation sites in genomes of widely varying complexity in vivo. The technique exploits the fact that restriction fragments containing different classes of replicative intermediates (single forks, initiation bubbles, or termination structures) migrate to different and characteristic positions in agarose gels. The replication pattern of any region of interest can then be determined by sequential hybridization with appropriate radioactive probes from that region.

Composite patterns in neutral/neutral two-dimensional gels demonstrate inefficient replication origin usage

The neutral/neutral two-dimensional (2-D) gel replicon mapping technique has been used to great advantage to localize and characterize origins of replication. Interestingly, many yeast origins display a composite pattern consisting of both a bubble arc and a single-fork arc. Moreover, in every instance in which neutral/neutral 2-D gels have been used to analyze origins in higher eukaryotic cells, two or more adjacent fragments display these composite patterns. We believe that composite patterns signal inefficient origin usage in yeast cells because the replicators in question are not active in every cell cycle and in higher eukaryotic replicons because initiation sites are chosen from among many potential sites lying within a zone. However, others have suggested that the single-fork arcs in these composite gel patterns arise from nicking activity that converts replication bubbles to branched structures that comigrate with bona fide single forks. Here, we have used three different replicon mapping strategies to show that broken simian virus 40 replication bubbles trace unique arcs that are clearly distinguishable from classic, intact single forks. Thus, it is likely that composite 2-D gel patterns represent origins that are inefficiently utilized.

Characterizing replication intermediates in the amplified CHO dihydrofolate reductase domain by two novel gel electrophoretic techniques

Using neutral/neutral and neutral/alkaline two-dimensional (2-D) gel techniques, we previously obtained evidence that initiation can occur at any of a large number of sites distributed throughout a broad initiation zone in the dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR) domain of Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. However, other techniques have suggested a much more circumscribed mode of initiation in this locus. This dichotomy has raised the issue whether the patterns of replicating DNA on 2-D gels have been misinterpreted and, in some cases, may represent such noncanonical replication intermediates as broken bubbles or microbubbles. In an accompanying study (R. F. Kalejta and J. L. Hamlin, Mol. Cell. Biol. 16:4915-4922, 1996), we have shown that broken bubbles migrate to unique positions in three different gel systems and therefore are not likely to be confused with classic replication intermediates. Here, we have applied a broken bubble assay developed from that study to an analysis of the amplified DHFR locus in CHO cells. This assay gives information about the number and positions of initiation sites within a fragment. In addition, we have analyzed the DHFR locus by a novel stop-and-go-alkaline gel technique that measures the size of nascent strands at all positions along each arc in a neutral/neutral 2-D gel. Results of these analyses support the view that the 2-D gel patterns previously assigned to classic, intact replication bubbles and single-forked structures indeed correspond to these entities. Furthermore, potential nascent-strand start sites appear to be distributed at very frequent intervals along the template in the intergenic region in the DHFR domain.