Interaction of an antimutator gene with DNA repair pathways in Escherichia coli K-12

Memories of a senior scientist: on passing the fiftieth anniversary of the beginning of deciphering the genetic code

2011 marked the fiftieth anniversary of breaking the genetic code in 1961. Marshall Nirenberg, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) scientist who was awarded the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1968 for his role in deciphering the code, wrote in 2004 a personal account of his research. The race for the code was a competition between the NIH group and Severo Ochoa's laboratory at New York University (NYU) School of Medicine, where I was a graduate student and conducted many of the experiments. I am now 83 years old. These facts prompt me to recall how I, together with Joe Speyer, an instructor in the Department of Biochemistry at NYU, unexpectedly became involved in deciphering the code, which also became the basis of my PhD thesis. Ochoa won the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine in 1959 for discovering polynucleotide phosphorylase (PNP), the first enzyme found to synthesize RNA in the test tube. The story of how PNP made the deciphering of the code feasible is recalled here.

Mismatch repair in the antimutator Escherichia coli mud

Antimutators are genetic mutants that produce mutations at reduced rates compared to the wild type strain. They are interesting because they may provide insights into the mechanisms by which spontaneous mutations occur. We have investigated a reported antimutator strain of Escherichia coli termed mud for its possible mechanism. The mud strain exhibits a decrease in both spontaneous mutagenesis and mutability with alkylated agents and base analogs. These types of DNA lesions are known to be the substrates for the E. coli methyl-directed mismatch repair encoded by the mutHLSU system. We investigated whether the putative antimutator effect results from the increased expression or activity of the mutHLSU system. To directly measure the mismatch repair capacity of mud cells, we have transfected them with phage lambda heteroduplexes and scored the fraction of mixed (unrepaired) infective centers. This transfection system has been used routinely to assay mismatch repair capacity in E. coli and other organisms. No difference between mud and wild type cells is observed. From the results of the experiments we conclude that the reported antimutator effect of mud does not result from enhanced mismatch repair capacity. This conclusion is consistent with recently published evidence that the mud effect does not represent a real antimutator effect, but is an artifact due to impaired growth of mud cells under certain selective conditions.

The antimutator phenotype of E. coli mud is only apparent and results from delayed appearance of mutants

Antimutator strains are strains that have a lower mutation rate than the wild-type strain. We have reexamined the properties of one reported antimutator strain of Escherichia coli, termed mud [Mol. Gen. Genet. 153 (1977) 87]. This strain contains a temperature-sensitive mutation in the purB gene, leading to adenine-dependent growth at higher temperature. When grown at permissive or semi-permissive temperature in the absence of adenine it displays large reductions in the number of both spontaneous and mutagen-induced mutants (e.g. several hundred-fold for valine-resistant mutants). However, our studies show that strains containing the purB allele generate mutations at the same level as the wild-type strain, and that the apparent antimutator effect is the consequence of the delayed appearance of mutants on the selective plates. This delay likely results from the combined stress exerted by the adenine deficiency and the presence of the selective agent (i.e. valine).

An aerobic recA-, umuC-dependent pathway of spontaneous base-pair substitution mutagenesis in Escherichia coli

Antimutator alleles indentify genes whose normal products are involved in spontaneous mutagenesis pathways. Mutant alleles of the recA and umuC genes of Escherichia coli, whose wild-type alleles are components of the inducible SOS response, were shown to cause a decrease in the level of spontaneous mutagenesis. Using a series of chromosomal mutant trp alleles, which detect point mutations, as a reversion assay, it was shown that the reduction in mutagenesis is limited to base-pair substitutions. Within the limited number of sites than could be examined, transversions at AT sites were the favored substitutions. Frameshift mutagenesis was slightly enhanced by a mutant recA allele and unchanged by a mutant umuC allele. The wild-type recA and umuC genes are involved in the same mutagenic base-pair substitution pathway, designated "SOS-dependent spontaneous mutagenesis" (SDSM), since a recAumuC strain showed the same degree and specificity of antimutator activity as either single mutant strain. The SDSM pathway is active only in the presence of oxygen, since wild-type, recA, and umuC strains all show the same levels of reduced spontaneous mutagenesis anaerobically. The SDSM pathway can function in starving/stationary cells and may, or may not, be operative in actively dividing cultures. We suggest that, in wild-type cells, SDSM results from basal levels of SOS activity during DNA synthesis. Mutations may result from synthesis past cryptic DNA lesions (targeted mutagenesis) and/or from mispairings during synthesis with a normal DNA template (untargeted mutagenesis). Since it occurs in chromosomal genes of wild-type cells, SDSM may be biologically significant for isolates of natural enteric bacterial populations where extended starvation is often a common mode of existence.

Antimutator mutants in bacteriophage T4 and Escherichia coli

Antimutators are mutant strains that have reduced mutation rates compared to the corresponding wild-type strain. Their existence, along with mutator mutants that have higher mutation rates compared to the wild-type strain, are powerful evidence that mutation rates are genetically controlled. Compared to mutator mutants, antimutators have a very distinguishing property. Because they prevent normally occurring mutations, they, uniquely, are capable of providing insight into the mechanisms of spontaneous mutations. In this review, antimutator mutants are discussed in bacteriophage T4 and the bacterium Escherichia coli, with regard to their properties, possible mechanisms, and implications for the sources of spontaneous mutations in these two organisms.

AICAR is not an endogenous mutagen in Escherichia coli

A number of observations in the Escherichia coli and Salmonella typhimurium literature could be explained by the hypothesis that a particular purine ribonucleotide precursor can be converted to the corresponding deoxyribonucleotide triphosphate, thereby becoming a base-analogue mutagen. The metabolite in question, AICAR (5-amino-4-carboxamide imidazole riboside 5'-phosphate), is also a by-product of histidine biosynthesis, and its (ribo)triphosphate derivative, ZTP, has been detected in E. coli. We constructed E. coli tester strains that had either a normal AICAR pool (pur+ his+ strains cultivated without purines or histidine) or no AICAR pool (purF hisG mutant strains, lacking the first enzyme of each pathway and cultivated in the presence of adenine and histidine). Using a set of lacZ mutations, each of which can revert to Lac+ only by a specific substitution mutation, we found that no base substitution event occurs at a higher frequency in the presence of an AICAR pool. We conclude that the normal AICAR pool in E. coli is not a significant source of spontaneous base substitution mutagenesis.