Problems in prenatal diagnosis of the ichthyosis congenita group

Congenital Ichthyosis: Current Approaches to Prenatal Diagnoses

INTRODUCTION

Congenital ichthyosis represents a wide spectrum of diseases. This article reviews prenatal testing for ichthyosis.

METHODS

We used pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov to search for 38 types of congenital ichthyosis combined with 17 words related to prenatal testing.

RESULTS

Search resulted in 408 publications covering 13 types of ichthyoses and four types of tests.

DISCUSSION

Biochemical testing is diagnostic in trichothiodystrophy, but nonspecific in X-linked ichthyosis and Refsum syndrome. Except in X-linked ichthyosis, biochemical testing requires invasive procedures to obtain fetal skin biopsy, amniocytes, or chorionic villus samples. It is superior to histological and cytological examination of fetal skin biopsy or amniocytes because keratinization occurs later in pregnancy and microscopy cannot differentiate between ichthyosis types. Imaging is more acceptable due to noninvasiveness and routine use, although ultrasonography is operator-dependent, nonspecific, and captures abnormalities at late stage. Molecular tests are described in at-risk pregnancies but testing of free fetal DNA was not described.

Harlequin Ichthyosis among the Navajo: Counseling issues

Harlequin Ichthyosis is a rare, fatal congenital disorder of keratinization characterized by thickened, scale-like plaques of skin with a diamond configuration. Autosomal recessive inheritance has been established, and prenatal diagnosis for this disorder remains controversial. Five infants with this disorder were born among approximately 25,000 Navajo women who delivered in Gallup, New Mexico from 1970 to 1989. The incidence of 1 in 5000 among the Navajo in Gallup is high compared to previous reports in other populations. Two families with affected infants were seen in a genetics outreach clinic. Two important counseling issues were raised: (1) reluctance to discuss the possibility of recurrence for fear of affecting the outcome, and (2) feelings of guilt caused by cultural beliefs which attributed the birth defect to paternal behavior during pregnancy. Such issues are encountered in many traditional cultures, and they can be addressed by tailoring the timing and content of counseling.

De novo deletion of chromosome 18q in a baby with harlequin ichthyosis

Harlequin ichthyosis, (MIM 242500), is a rare, autosomal recessive skin disorder due to an inborn error of epidermal keratinization. The gene for this condition has not been localized. We present a case of HI in which there was a de novo deletion of chromosome 18q: the karyotype was 46, XY, del(18)(q21.3). We postulate that the gene for HI may lie at, or distal to 18q21.3 and that the deletion observed in this case may have unmasked this autosomal recessive disorder.

Epidermal barrier in disorders of the skin

The water permeability barrier of the stratum corneum (SC) seems primarily to be regulated by the lamellarly arranged lipid bilayers between the corneocytes, which originate largely from polar lipid precursors provided by the cells of stratum granulosum via exocytosis of the lamellar body (LB) content. In particular, the structural organization of these intercellular lipid lamellae seems to be responsible for the very low water permeability of the intact skin, and these lipid-rich structures might also influence the desquamation process in the SC. The aim of this study was to obtain further insight into the distribution and organization of the epidermal lipids (EL) and the mechanism involved in desquamation and barrier function in normal human skin and scaling skin disorders. Biopsies of healthy human skin (n = 12), of inflammatory skin diseases (atopic dry skin (n = 9), psoriatic skin lesions [n = 2]), and of hereditary keratinization disorders (autosomal recessive ichthyoses congenita (n = 3), X-chromosomal ichthyosis (XCI) [n = 3]) were analyzed utilizing a special fixation protocol with ruthenium tetroxide (RuO4) postfixation. While the atopic dry skin revealed normal barrier structures, the psoriasis lesions were characterized by severe alteration of the lipid structures leading to an abnormal interaction with the desmosomal unit. While the intercellular domains in some of the studied keratinization disorders showed an impaired distribution of the EL (autosomal recessive ichthyoses), X-chromosomal ichthyosis showed normal lipid architecture. Dry and scaly skin disorders are therefore not always accompanied by an impairment of the water permeability barrier.

Clinical, light and electron microscopic features of recessive congenital ichthyosis type I

Based on electron microscopic features, recessive congenital ichthyoses have recently been divided into four subgroups designated ichthyosis congenita (IC) types I, II, III and IV. Type II is characterized by cholesterol clefts in the horny cells, type III by perinuclear elongated membranes in the granular and horny cells, and type IV by masses of lipid membranes in granular and horny cells. Clear electron microscopic criteria for type I are lacking, although the presence of lipid droplets in the horny cells has been suggested as a criterion. In the present study we included ichthyosis patients with (i) recessive inheritance, (ii) erythrodermic fine scaling, (iii) lack of fine structural markers of IC types II-IV. Patients with ichthyotic syndromes were excluded. The case material consisted of 21 patients from 14 families. Eight were collodion babies at birth, but three were normal. Nine had ectropion, the flexures were affected in 12, and the palms and soles were thickened in all but one patient. On electron microscopy lipid vacuoles in the horny cells were common, but were absent in four patients. Changes in other lipid-related structures, including keratinosomes, were common. We conclude that currently type I can be diagnosed only by excluding the other types of ichthyosis. Clinically, IC type I corresponds to classical non-bullous congenital ichthyosiform erythroderma, but there is marked heterogeneity among affected individuals.

Clinical, light and electron microscopic features of recessive ichthyosis congenita type III

The recessively inherited congenital ichthyoses have ultrastructural features which indicate abnormal epidermal lipid metabolism. The ultrastructural markers of the three recessive congenital ichthyosis groups are lipid droplets in horny layers (type I), cholesterol clefts (type II) and membrane structures (type III). We describe six patients from five families belonging to the last group. The variable clinical phenotype alone does not allow the delineation of this disease, but together with the ultrastructural characteristics the subtype is unequivocal. In addition to the membrane structures, half of the cases showed abnormal keratinosomes and vesicular complexes. Membrane-bound vacuoles and needle-like slits were exceptionally found. The onset of the ichthyosis was variable, in contrast to other patients described under the heading recessive congenital ichthyosis.

Recessive ichthyosis congenita type II

In the heterogeneous group of recessive congenital ichthyoses the disorder of desquamation seems to be a basic problem. Desquamation is strongly dependent on the normal lipid metabolism of the keratinocytes. We describe a group of patients who have a typical clinical picture of large scale ichthyosis and cholesterol clefts in the thickened corneal layer, evidencing a disturbance of the lipid metabolism of the skin. The corneocytes also show a thin or absent cornified envelope, which could indicate a disturbance of protein synthesis. These patients have a severe ichthyosis, but good general health and no associated symptoms. This disorder has recently been named 'ichthyosis congenita type II' by the Heidelberg group on the basis of electron microscopic findings. According to the present examination this group corresponds clinically to the currently used diagnosis 'lamellar ichthyosis'.

Fetal skin biopsy in prenatal diagnosis of some genodermatoses

Various methods of obtaining fetal skin for prenatal diagnosis of certain autosomal-recessive congenital genodermatoses have been assessed. An attempt was made to obtain fetal skin by fetoscopy in 15 patients prior to pregnancy termination for a variety of medical reasons at 18-26 weeks. Specimens were obtained only in five cases (8 successful attempts out of 48). In twelve cases, of which five had a history of a child with junctional (Herlitz type) or dystrophic (Hallopeau-Siemens type) epidermolysis bullosa or non-bullous congenital ichthyosiform erythroderma at 16-25 weeks of pregnancy, fetal skin was obtained without fetoscopy under direct ultrasonic control. Specimens were obtained in all cases (33 successful attempts out of 39). In three cases, fetal pathology was diagnosed by the method of semi-thin and ultra-thin skin sections, and the respective pregnancies were terminated.

The expression of congenital ichthyosiform erythroderma in second trimester fetuses of the same family: morphologic and biochemical studies

The first born offspring of first-cousin parents was affected with a keratinization disorder thought to be nonbullous congenital ichthyosiform erythroderma (CIE). In each of three subsequent pregnancies, the parents elected to have prenatal diagnosis based on evaluation of fetal skin biopsies. The epidermis of fetus 1 was identical to normal 21-wk estimated gestation age (EGA) fetal epidermis, but because keratinization begins normally around 24 wk EGA, the procedure was repeated 4 wk later. A thin epidermis with a few layers of stratum corneum indicated a normal fetus and a healthy infant was born at term. Skin biopsy samples from fetus 2 gave conflicting results; the epidermis of one sample appeared normal but the second had 5-15 layers of incompletely keratinized cells superficial to basal and intermediate layers. The hair canals of both samples were hyperkeratotic. Pelleted amniotic fluid cells contained aggregates of incompletely keratinized epidermal cells and concentric rings of keratinized cells. The fetus was thought to be affected and the pregnancy terminated. Regional variation in epidermal thickness and keratinization was noted upon gross examination of the fetus and by histology of the skin. Marked hyperkeratinization of follicles was evident in all regions. No abnormal keratins were expressed in the affected epidermis but epidermal lipids analyzed from two body regions had a lower triglyceride content and a higher content of free sterols compared with age-matched, normal fetal epidermis. Immunolabeling for markers of differentiation revealed variable stages of epidermal differentiation according to region. Four structurally identical biopsy samples were obtained from a third fetus. The epidermis appeared normal for age and hair canals were keratinized to various extents. The pregnancy was continued and at 33 wk a male infant was born with a severe ichthyosis of the face and scalp and fine, white scaling on the body. The epidermis of both the severely and mildly affected regions of the newborn had a thick, compact stratum corneum and other features of CIE. Scars from all four fetal biopsies were identified on the trunk, in areas which appeared less affected clinically. This study reports, for the first time, the criteria for prenatal diagnosis of CIE and the variable expression of this disorder in the midtrimester fetus. More importantly, it demonstrates the risks and pitfalls of this in utero diagnosis based on epidermal morphology.

Ultrastructure of first trimester chorionic villi with regard to the prenatal diagnosis of genodermatoses

Hopes are held out for chorion villus sampling, a technique which is gaining more and more importance for the first trimester prenatal diagnosis of chromosomal aberrations and metabolic abnormalities. A variety of inherited skin diseases can be diagnosed postnatally and prenatally (in the second trimester) by ultrastructural diagnostic markers. For evaluation of prenatal diagnosis in the first trimester, we investigated chorionic villi derived from the trophoblast layer of the early pregnancy by light microscopy and conventional electron microscopy. The ultrastructure of the cellular layers covering the villi, i.e., the inner cytotrophoblast and the outer syncytiotrophoblast, as well as that of the connective tissue of the inner extraembryonic mesoderm, are thoroughly described in relation to the ultrastructural changes in certain genodermatoses including epidermolyses and keratinization disorders. We found that chorionic villi have only a few of the characteristics differentiated in skin, and none of the structures which are relevant to the diagnosis of genodermatoses. In our view, the ultrastructural approach is not suitable for first trimester prenatal diagnosis of genodermatoses in chorionic villi.