Comminuted Colles' fractures treated with external fixation

The operative treatment of intraarticular Smith fractures

Twenty-one intraarticular palmar displaced fractures of the distal radius operated on between 1990 and 1995 were reviewed with a mean follow-up of 27.3 months (range, 8-54). Fifteen fractures were treated with palmar T-plates, two in combination with an external fixator. Five fractures were treated with external fixators and K-wires, and one fracture was treated with percutaneous K-wires and a cast. In six patients cancellous bone graft from the iliac crest was used. The most satisfactory clinical and radiological results were obtained by anatomical reconstruction of the articular surface. The favoured method remains stabilization with palmar T-plates. K-wires with a cast should only be used in simple articular fractures with a large palmar fragment.

Do we underestimate the predictive value of the ulnar styloid affection in Colles fractures?

Various radiographic factors have been suggested as predictively important when dealing with an unstable distal radius fracture. Accordingly, many classification systems have been established in order to give an accurate description of a fracture and to grade the seriousness of the injury. In this paper, we use the classification of Colles fractures introduced by Frykman to investigate the predictive value of a concomitant fracture of the ulnar styloid. We found styloid affection to be a better predictor of a poor outcome than intra-articularity, but the combination carries the worst prognosis. We therefore suggest that a fracture of the distal radius associated with those two types of injuries should be considered for surgical treatment.

Physiotherapy: an overestimated factor in after-treatment of fractures in the distal radius?

Supervision by physiotherapists, starting 4-6 weeks after cast removal, was compared with self-training in 110 patients treated for Colles' fracture. The patients guided by physiotherapists were all satisfied with the treatment, but no functional advantages could be discerned when compared with self-training.

[Treatment of comminuted fractures of the lower end of the radius with internal osteosynthesis, traction and early mobilization]

Goals for treatment of comminutive fractures of the distal radius include restoration of the articular profile of the proximal part of the joint, while axial loading forces must be avoided as much as possible to prevent secondary displacement. The choice of an internal fixation protected by an external wrist distractor-fixator, with early activo-passive mobilisation, seems to achieve the goal. Twelve patients with a comminuted fracture of the distal radius, including axial articular impigment displacement were reviewed for this study. All fractures were Frykman's type III, IV, VII or VIII. Distraction was done with a specific external apparatus, allowing an internal fixation, using an anterior plate and posterior Kirschner wires for the more complex cases. Distraction was released at the end of the surgical procedure, while the distractor was left in place. The wrist was mobilised early in the post-operative period, and the distractor was removed two months later. At a mean follow-up of 8.5 months, two patients were still painful. Mean motion of the wrist joint was 115 degrees for flexion-extension and 35 degrees for radio-ulnar deviation. Radiological results were good (10 cases), in both planes sagittal and frontal, and stable with time. The radio-ulnar index was correct in 11 cases. Only two cases of Sudeck's atrophy were noted. Authors use a specific external wrist distractor to obtain and maintain reduction in comminuted fractures of the distal end of the radius, using internal fixation in combination. Early motion of the wrist, protected by the wrist distractor seems to lower rates of Sudeck's atrophy.

Twelve years follow-up of fractures of the distal radius treated with the AO external fixator

From 1977 to 1982 a total of 55 patients suffering comminuted fracture of the distal radius were treated with the external fixator. Fifty of these were followed up in 1983/85 and 32 of them were available for assessment in this study (1992). The follow-up period was 11.6 years on average. All patients had suffered an intra-articular fracture (91% a C-fracture, 9% a B-fracture according to the AO classification), 27 patients had also fractured the ulnar styloid process and in 11 a dye-punch fragment was present. Both wrists were assessed on the basis of case history, clinical examination, radiographs in two planes and visual analogue scales (VAS). The results were evaluated using established scoring systems. On the Gartland and Werley scale 75% of the results were good or very good, 63% according to Castaing. In general, there was no statistically significant difference between the results of this study and those of 1983/85. It could be demonstrated that there was a relationship between arthritis as a late complication and the existence of an intra-articular step-off of at least 2 mm at implant removal. This also has a negative influence on the range of motion and strength. Radial shortening affects the functional result whereas a die-punch fragment does not. On VAS patients identified performance restriction and disability as the worst consequences of the accident; these criteria correlated best with the results of objective evaluations. In contrast, patients were more satisfied with the result of treatment than would be expected from the objective analyses. The overall results indicate that exact reduction was extremely important. Long-term follow-up showed that the use of the external fixator in the treatment of comminuted intra-articular fractures of the distal radius was an adequate method. Prospective and possibly multicentric studies would be required to investigate more detailed relationships between treatment and long-term results.

External fixator pin placement in the forearm: how safe is it? An anatomical study

An anatomical study was undertaken using cadaveric forearms to identify the best technique and angle of pin placement for external fixator pins. We have found that inserting pins through stab incisions risks transfixion of the underlying structures and leads to an increased morbidity. We conclude that inserting pins under direct vision is much safer and that the optimum angle of pin insertion is in the coronal plane, parallel to the plane of the metacarpals.

Open reduction and internal fixation for distal radius fractures

From a series of 650 dorsally angulated fractures of the distal radius, 32 intra-articular fractures were treated by open reduction and internal fixation. The 32 fractures were classified according to the Frykman criteria as type VII (5) or type VIII (27). On the basis of the location of intra-articular involvement, the fractures were further subdivided into Mayo type II (4), type III (18), and type IV (10). Results were analyzed by the methods of Gartland and Werley (functional) and Lidström (radiographic). After open reduction and internal fixation, 90% of the patients had satisfactory results on the basis of the subjective criteria of minimal deformity, absence of pain, and good strength. Objective assessment demonstrated that the patients had 80% of normal motion and 73% of normal grip strength at a minimum of 2 years after the operation. On the basis of radiographic and functional evaluation, results were good to excellent in 87%. When intra-articular step-off exceeded 2 mm or the radius was shortened more than 5 mm, the results were only fair and posttraumatic arthritis was evident.

External fixation of Smith's fracture. 16 patients followed for 2 years

External fixation of 16 Smith's fractures was evaluated after 22 (6-42) months. In 15 patients, the radiographic results were satisfactory. There was a definite correlation between the radiographic and clinical end results. However, 6 patients had residual signs of an upper limb dystrophy. Although external fixation of Smith's fractures results in good function, this method should be used with caution because it cannot prevent reflex dystrophy; indeed, it may even initiate it.

External fixation of distal radial fractures: results and complications

External fixation of unstable fractures of the distal radius yields satisfactory results but has a high complication rate. We studied thirty-five fractures in thirty-four patients to determine whether the results obtained with external fixation warranted it use. At a mean follow-up period of 31 months, the results of treatment were assessed by interviews and clinical and radiographic examination of both wrists. Twelve fractures had an excellent result, twelve had a good result, ten had a fair result, and one had a poor result. Radiographic results were graded excellent in ten fractures, good in thirteen, fair in five, and poor in seven. No correlation was found between the anatomical results and the clinical results or the patients' subjective ratings. Complications that were related directly to the fixation pins occurred in fourteen of the fractures. There were forty-five additional complications. The frequency of complications and the limitations of external fixation demand caution on the part of the surgeon to prevent iatrogenic morbidity, which would limit the benefits of the technique.

External fixation of Colles' fracture

Radiographic and functional results of external fixation of 32 Colles' fractures were compared with the results of plaster fixation of 189 Colles' fractures. Despite the fact that the fractures treated with the external device were more unstable and comminuted, the final results were equal in both groups, and the radiographic outcome of external fixation was superior. Pin loosening decreased with predrilling rather than self-tapping. We recommend external fixation for unstable fractures of the distal forearm.