The small scarred kidney of childhood. A congenital or an acquired lesion?

Interplay between vesicoureteric reflux and kidney infection in the development of reflux nephropathy in mice

Vesicoureteric reflux (VUR) is a common congenital defect of the urinary tract that is usually discovered after a child develops a urinary tract infection. It is associated with reflux nephropathy, a renal lesion characterized by the presence of chronic tubulointersitial inflammation and fibrosis. Most patients are diagnosed with reflux nephropathy after one or more febrile urinary tract infections, suggesting a potential role for infection in its development. We have recently shown that the C3H mouse has a 100% incidence of VUR. Here, we evaluate the roles of VUR and uropathogenic Escherichia coli infection in the development of reflux nephropathy in the C3H mouse. We find that VUR in combination with sustained kidney infection is crucial to the development of reflux nephropathy, whereas sterile reflux alone fails to induce reflux nephropathy. A single bout of kidney infection without reflux fails to induce reflux nephropathy. The host immune response to infection was examined in two refluxing C3H substrains, HeN and HeJ. HeJ mice, which have a defect in innate immunity and bacterial clearance, demonstrate more significant renal inflammation and reflux nephropathy compared with HeN mice. These studies demonstrate the crucial synergy between VUR, sustained kidney infection and the host immune response in the development of reflux nephropathy in a mouse model of VUR.

Evolution and prognosis value of intrarenal reflux

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the prognostic significance of intrarenal reflux (IRR) regarding urinary tract infection (UTI), renal scarring and spontaneous resolution after 3 years of follow up.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

33 patients (42 refluxing units) with IRR were compared to 27 children (44 refluxing units) with high-grade vesicoureteral reflux (VUR) without IRR (controls) matched for gender, age and VUR grade. All patients received antibiotic prophylaxis during observation and antireflux surgery was performed in children with recurrent UTI. DMSA scan was performed at study entry, and 18 and 36 months.

RESULTS

DMSA scores at entry showed a higher proportion of moderate and severe damage in the IRR group (25/42) compared to the control group (16/44) (Chi squared, P < 0.03). During follow up the incidence of UTI was similar in the two groups, as well as the stability of DMSA scintigraphy and the rate of spontaneous disappearance of the reflux. A similar proportion of patients underwent surgery (18/33 patients with IRR and 13/27 control patients; Chi squared, not significant).

CONCLUSIONS

Under medical management, the prognosis for IRR is not different from high-grade VUR without IRR. The presence of IRR does not justify more aggressive management than a high-grade VUR without IRR.

Relationship Among Vesicoureteral Reflux, Urinary Tract Infection and Renal Damage in Children

PURPOSE

We studied the relationship among vesicoureteral reflux, urinary tract infection and permanent renal damage in children.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed 303 children younger than 2 years with a first time, nonobstructive, culture verified urinary tract infection. The protocol included ultrasonography and voiding cystourethrography within 3 months after urinary tract infection, and (99m)technetium dimercapto-succinic acid scintigraphy after 1 to 2 years.

RESULTS

Vesicoureteral reflux was found in 36 of 163 boys (22%) and in 44 of 140 girls (31%). Of the 303 patients 80 (26%) had permanent renal damage according to dimercapto-succinic acid scintigraphy. The rate of abnormality increased significantly with grade of vesicoureteral reflux in boys and girls. The relative risk of renal damage was significantly increased in patients with vesicoureteral reflux grade II and higher. Maximum C-reactive protein concentration, maximum temperature during urinary tract infection, presence of vesicoureteral reflux and febrile recurrences of urinary tract infection were significantly related to permanent renal damage. In stepwise logistic regression vesicoureteral reflux was the only independent variable for boys, while C-reactive protein and vesicoureteral reflux were independent factors for girls.

CONCLUSIONS

There was a significant relationship between grade II vesicoureteral reflux and higher and permanent renal damage in boys and girls. However, while the association between renal damage and vesicoureteral reflux was evident in boys, the role of urinary tract infection and renal inflammation seemed to be equally or more important in girls. These findings support the concept that renal damage is associated with vesicoureteral reflux and is often congenital in boys, while in girls it is more related to urinary tract infection with vesicoureteral reflux as a reinforcing factor.

Vesicoureteric reflux and urinary tract infection in children

An association between vesicoureteric reflux (VUR) and renal damage was found in 1960. In 1973, the term reflux nephropathy (RN) was first used to describe the renal damage caused by VUR. Follow up studies show that about 10%-20% of children with RN develop hypertension or end stage renal disease. It is now evident that there is a sex difference in the development of RN. In most males with RN, the kidneys are congenitally abnormal. In females it is an acquired condition, the most severe damage being sustained by recurrent urinary tract infections (UTIs). The purpose of current UTI guidelines is to identify VUR or any other abnormality of the urinary tract. Since the advent of routine antenatal ultrasonography, there is no longer a need to identify an abnormality of the urinary tract after the first reported UTI. Routine investigations are not required. Recurrent UTIs and a family history of VUR need further evaluation. There is also an urgent need to establish the long term value of prophylactic antibiotics in children with VUR.

Histological study of fetal kidney with urethral obstruction and vesicoureteral reflux: A consideration on the etiology of congenital reflux nephropathy

PURPOSE

A recent subject of interest regarding reflux nephropathy is the presence of renal abnormalities in neonates and infants who have no history of urinary tract infections. Debates have centered on the etiology of this renal abnormality - congenital reflux nephropathy; regarding whether it is the result of abnormal ureteral budding or of back pressure effect from sterile reflux. We examined the renal pathology of fetuses with urethral obstruction and vesicoureteral reflux, and we suggest herein a possible etiology of congenital reflux nephropathy.

METHODS

The renal pathology of seven autopsied fetuses with vesicoureteral reflux was studied. Reflux was demonstrated at autopsy by slow injection of contrast medium into the bladder. Severe urethral obstruction, either atresia or urethral valves, was evident in six of the subjects.

RESULTS

In six subjects, abnormality of the urinary tracts was detected by prenatal ultrasonography. Of these six subjects, three revealed characteristics of prune belly syndrome. Reflux was graded as moderate in five subjects, and severe in two. In three subjects autopsied at 21 weeks gestation or earlier, the kidneys were well-developed with normal corticomedullary configuration, and nephrogenesis was retained. In three cases autopsied at over 25 weeks of gestation, the kidneys were grossly cystic, and the nephrogenic zone was completely absent. Contrast medium was observed not only in the dilated ducts and tubules, but also in the subcapsular cysts. Extravasation of the contrast medium was seen in the peritubular space. In the last subject with normal lower urinary tract, abnormal segments among normal cortical structures were observed.

CONCLUSION

Our findings of renal pathology in fetuses with reflux are quite similar to those seen in fetal hydronephrosis. Back pressure from reflux probably damages the developing kidney leading to a degeneration of the ampullae and a reduction in the number of nephrons. Both dilatation of the collecting ducts and tubules, and extravasation of the urine may result in interstitial fibrosis. We postulate that one of the important etiologies of congenital reflux nephropathy may be the result of back pressure from sterile reflux.

Long-term follow-up of reflux nephropathy in adults with vesicoureteral reflux--radiological and pathoanatomical analysis

PURPOSE

To study the long-term development of urographic renal morphology in adults with vesicoureteral reflux, to investigate the relationship between renal damage and reflux grade, and to analyse the association between the long-term urographic outcome and the occurrence of acute pyelonephritis and reflux during follow-up. The purpose was also to try to distinguish between acquired and developmental renal damage, based on analyses of renal histological specimens and urographic features, and to analyse associated congenital urogenital abnormalities and family history of reflux, reflux nephropathy, urological malformation or death from end-stage renal disease.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Renal damage was identified in 100 (83 women) of 115 adults, selected because of documented reflux. Eighty-seven patients had two urographies done (median interval 14.3 years). The extent and progression of renal damage were assessed and features of developmental renal damage were determined. Histological renal specimens were available in 23 patients with renal damage.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

The extent of renal damage correlated positively with the severity of reflux. No renal damage developed during the follow-up in 45 previously undamaged kidneys and progression of renal damage was rare (4 of 120 previously damaged kidneys), despite persisting reflux in half of the cases and episodes of acute pyelonephritis during follow-up. Thus, repeated renal imaging is rarely justified in adults with reflux nephropathy. Histological examination showed "chronic pyelonephritis" in all 23 cases and co-existing renal dysplasia in 1 case. The detailed urographic analysis did not reveal support for developmental renal damage. High frequencies of associated congenital urogenital abnormalities and of a positive family history were found. Thus, congenital and/or hereditary factors cannot be discarded as background factors for the development of renal damage.

[Parenchymatous cicatrix and urinary tract infection: physiopathology and clinical implications]

Renal scarring is the main long term complication of acute pyelonephritis in children. The prevalence rate is hazardous since data from the literature are confusing with respect to reflux nephropathy, chronic pyelonephritis and renal hypoplasia. The pathology of such lesions consists in focal interstitial fibrosis. When the first pyelonephritic attack occurs during infancy, renal growth may be compromised. The current approach of renal scar assessment is based on dimercaptosuccinic acid (DMSA) scan. Bilateral extensive lesions may be responsible for altered glomerular filtration rate (GFR) and/or arterial hypertension. The management of overt scarring is conservative and careful prevention must be based on early and aggressive treatment of acute pyelonephritis.

Evaluation and management of pediatric urinary tract infections

Urinary tract infections (UTIs) are relatively common in children. We describe the evaluation and management of children with UTIs, as well as the risks and consequences related to the UTI. This article describes a rational approach to the evaluation and management of childhood UTIs with the relation to the natural history and risk factors.

Urinary tract infections. Old and new concepts

The recommendations for evaluation and management of pediatric patients with UTIs are summarized in Table 5. These recommendations were designed to minimize the risk of kidney damage in children with UTIs based on current perceptions of the pathogenesis of renal injury. The children at greatest risk for kidney damage are the infants and young children with febrile UTIs in whom effective treatment is delayed, those with gross VUR, and those with anatomic or neurogenic urinary tract obstruction. These recommendations likely will be modified as more is learned about the pathogenesis of renal injury associated with UTIs, as new therapeutic approaches are developed, and as imaging technology improves.

Congenital nephropathies and uropathies

Although congenital nephropathies and uropathies only represent a fraction of possible genitourinary diseases detected during childhood, they have serious and sometimes avoidable morbidity and mortality. Advances in genetic, molecular, and cellular biology research continue to better define embryologic insults to normal organogenesis and offer the promise that many of these conditions might be avoided in the future. For now, awareness of these entities and their varied presentations and manifestations is crucial so that prompt evaluation and aggressive multidisciplinary management assures the affected child optimal growth and development.

The small scarred kidney in childhood

Reflux nephropathy is now a generally accepted term to describe small scarred kidneys discovered during childhood; it recognises the close association between this renal lesion and vesicoureteric reflux (VUR). This paper briefly reviews the pathogenic factors involved in reflux nephropathy and suggests that at least two main mechanisms operate: acquired segmental scarring due to intrarenal reflux and congenital maldevelopment (renal dysplasia). The spectrum of renal changes associated with VUR can be usefully divided on this basis and the opportunity to recognise by fetal ultrasound those renal lesions acquired in utero may further enhance our understanding of the congenital maldevelopment group.