Should bilateral nephrectomy be carried out in all children with diffuse mesangial sclerosis prior to renal transplantation in view of the connection with Drash syndrome and therefore the risk of a Wilms' tumour developing?

Prophylactic bilateral nephrectomies in two paediatric patients with missense mutations in the WT1 gene

BACKGROUND

Denys-Drash syndrome (DDS) is associated with mutations of the Wilms' tumour 1 (WT1) gene, and is characterized by pseudohermaphroditism, a progressive glomerulopathy, and the development of Wilms' tumour. More than 90% of patients with DDS who carry constitutional intragenic WT1 mutations are at high risk (90%) for the development of Wilms' tumour. WT1 is a signalling protein with 90% of WT1 mutations occurring in the WT1 zinc finger region as single nucleotide polymorphisms, the majority of which are missense mutations.

METHODS

Constitutional DNA was extracted from peripheral blood. Direct sequencing and restriction enzymes were employed to analyse mutations.

RESULTS

Two children, 46XY males who had evidence of pseudohermaphroditism, hypogonadism and renal failure with a glomerulopathy atypical for DDS, but no Wilms' tumour or nephroblastomatosis, on investigation, prior to transplant, were identified with missense mutations in the WT1 gene, in exons 8 and 9, respectively. The decision to do prophylactic nephrectomies was based on the genetic identification of WT1 mutations supporting a diagnosis of incomplete DDS, with the potential for increased risk of malignancy with the development of Wilms' tumour. The nephrectomy specimens demonstrated nephrogenic rests (nephroblastomatosis), which have a potential for malignant transformation.

CONCLUSIONS

WT1 missense mutations in exons 8 and 9 can be regarded as having the potential for malignant change supporting prophylactic nephrectomy in apparent incomplete DDS patients with end-stage renal disease.

The Denys-Drash syndrome

Images

Non-immunological risk factors in paediatric renal transplantation

In paediatric renal transplantation, non-immunological risk factors account for about one-third of graft losses. Recurrence of original disease is observed mainly in primary hyperoxaluria and glomerulopathies such as steroid-resistant nephrotic syndrome and membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis. In both glomerulopathies, 20% of grafts are lost from recurrence. Vascular thrombosis is, in most series, the second cause of graft loss in children, particularly in young recipients or with young donors (under 5 years of age). Non-compliance with treatment is a common non-immunological factor in adolescent recipients, which may trigger a severe rejection process resulting in graft loss. The role of factors related to graft preservation and intra- and post-operative management (ischaemia time, delayed graft function) or to cytomegalovirus infection is less obvious in our series. Prevention of vascular thrombosis and of non-compliance is most important in order to improve the results of paediatric renal transplantation.