On the physical origin of biological handedness

Spin-polarized electron induced asymmetric reactions in chiral molecules

Understanding the origin of chirality in nature has been an active area of research since the time of Pasteur. In this chapter we examine one possible route by which this asymmetry could have arisen, namely chiral-specific chemistry induced by spin-polarized electrons. The various sources of spin-polarized electrons (parity violation, photoemission, and secondary processes) are discussed. Experiments aimed at exploring these interactions are reviewed starting with those based on the Vester-Ulbricht hypothesis through recent studies of spin polarized secondary electrons from a magnetic substrate. We will conclude with a discussion of possible new avenues of research that could impact this area.

Spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking in early molecular networks

BACKGROUND

An important facet of early biological evolution is the selection of chiral enantiomers for molecules such as amino acids and sugars. The origin of this symmetry breaking is a long-standing question in molecular evolution. Previous models addressing this question include particular kinetic properties such as autocatalysis or negative cross catalysis.

RESULTS

We propose here a more general kinetic formalism for early enantioselection, based on our previously described Graded Autocatalysis Replication Domain (GARD) model for prebiotic evolution in molecular assemblies. This model is adapted here to the case of chiral molecules by applying symmetry constraints to mutual molecular recognition within the assembly. The ensuing dynamics shows spontaneous chiral symmetry breaking, with transitions towards stationary compositional states (composomes) enriched with one of the two enantiomers for some of the constituent molecule types. Furthermore, one or the other of the two antipodal compositional states of the assembly also shows time-dependent selection.

CONCLUSION

It follows that chiral selection may be an emergent consequence of early catalytic molecular networks rather than a prerequisite for the initiation of primeval life processes. Elaborations of this model could help explain the prevalent chiral homogeneity in present-day living cells.

The origin of life and the left-handed amino-acid excess: the furthest heavens and the deepest seas?

The origin of life is an extraordinary problem that leads back to the structure and dynamics of the cosmos and early development of organic molecules. Within that wider question lies an unsolved problem that has troubled biologists for 150 years. What is the origin of the dominant presence of left-handed stereoisomers of amino acids in nature even though their synthesis normally results in an equal mixture of the right- and left-handed molecular forms? We propose that asymmetric Earth rotation caused at dawn and dusk circularly polarized UV light (CPUVL) of opposite polarity and reversed temperature profiles in the oceans. Destruction of the d-isomer by CPUVL at dusk in a sea surface hotter than at dawn created a daily l-isomer excess protected from radiation by nightfall, preserved by down-flow (diffusive, mechanical) into cold, darker regions, eventually initiating an l-amino-acid excess embodied in early marine forms. Innumerable mechanisms have been proposed for the origin of l-chiral dominance in amino acids and none proven. Since the thalidomide tragedy, homochirality of amino acids has been a growing practical issue for medicine. Understanding its origin may bring further and unexpected benefits. It may also be a modest pointer to the possibility of positive answers to whether intelligent life will have the capacity to continue to protect itself from conditions inimical to survival.

Demonstration of the parity-violating energy difference between enantiomers

Racemic mixtures of (+) and (-) sodium potassium tartrate, tris(1, 2-ethanediamine)cobalt(III), and tris(1,2-ethanediamine)iridium(III) molecules were crystallized, and the optical activities of the resulting crystalline materials, dissolved in water, were carefully measured to study the influence of the parity-violating energy difference in the crystallization process. Although no effect was found in the case of tartrate, enantiomeric excess appeared in the crystallization of the cobalt and iridium complexes. These investigations, performed in our laboratory, demonstrated the contribution of the parity-violating neutral weak current to the forces acting in molecules.

Origin of the homochirality of biomolecules

Molecules built up from a given set of atoms may differ in their three-dimensional structure. They may have one or more asymmetric centres that serve as reference points for the steric distribution of the atoms. Carbon atoms, common to all biomolecules, are often such centres. For example, the Cα atom between the carboxyl and amino groups in amino acids is an asymmetric centre: looking ON ward (i.e. from the carbOxyl to the amiNo group, with the Cα oriented so that it is above the carboxyl and amino groups) the radical characterizing the amino acid may be to the right (D-molecules) or to the left (L-molecules). Nineteen of the 20 amino acids occurring in proteins have such a structure (the exception is glycine, where the radical is a hydrogen atom). These pairs of molecules cannot be brought into coincidence with their own mirror image, as is the situation with our hands. The phenomenon has therefore been named handedness, or chirality, from the Greek word cheir, meaning hand. The two forms of the chiral molecules are called enantiomers or antipodes. They differ in rotating the plane of the polarized light either to the right or to the left. The sense of rotation depends on the wavelength of the measuring light, but at a given wavelength it is always opposite for a pair of enantiomers. Chirality may also occur when achiral molecules form chiral substances during crystallization (for example, quartz forms D-quartz or Lquartz). A detailed theoretical treatment of molecular chirality is given by Barron (1991).

Stereoselectivity of X-irradiated amino acid enantiomers in H218O aqueous solution

Asymmetric radiation-induced decomposition of D,L-alanine and D,L-phenylalanine in isotope-enriched H218O aqueous solution has been investigated by use of a new method involving detection of 18O-marked products by nuclear reactions. X-irradiated D-enantiomers are revealed to be more sensitive for 18O trapping than their L-type counterparts.

Reflections on the origin of optical asymmetry on earth

The importance of optical purity, which was stressed in an earlier review, is reassessed in the light of recent evidence concerning the optical configuration of amino acids in biological systems. The most significant fact to emerge in recent years that bear on the origin of optical asymmetry is the experimental evidence for the Salam-Weinberg theory. However, the problem remains: is the effect of PNC-interactions too small to be detectable, and if it is so small, can it be of any significance? In view of the contradictory and confusing nature of the evidence on the induction of optical activity, it is suggested that the Bremen Symposium should agree on some experimental protocols.

Review of the origin of asymmetry of biomolecules through weak interaction: latest developments

New results and discussions since 1977 are reviewed. It is stated that--excepting Kovács's crystallization experiments not yet repeated in independent laboratories--positive, unconfuted results do not exist. Considering also the results of the different amplification theories it seems to be very improbable that the weak interaction played any role in establishing the nearly complete asymmetry of biomolecules.

Beta irradiation may induce stereoselectivity in the crystallization of optical isomers

A novel approach has been introduced to detect the manifestation of symmetry breaking weak interactions at molecular level. In the racemic conglomerate crystallization of D,L-sodium-ammonium tartrate the effect of 32P irradiation was studied by measuring the weight and optical purity of the crystalline phase as well as the size distribution of the crystallites. The high number of independent experiments (over 1000) permitted statistical analysis of the results. The following observations have been made: 1. Beta irradiation influences the crystallization process, irradiated samples yield more crystalline material. 2. The effect involves presumably crystal seed formation because from the irradiated solutions more and smaller crystallites are formed. 3. The presence of beta particles induces stereoselective crystallization, the crystalline phase shows optical activity characteristic of the "unnatural" L-isomer. 4. The above changes are attributed to the beta irradiation as the magnitude of the effects depends on the amount of added radioactivity. Optically active contaminants are highly unlikely sources of the differences between irradiated and control series. 5. In the absence of 32P the tartrate enantiomers have equal probability to form crystals, i.e., the contribution of mixing of weak interaction into the electromagnetic one is not measurable in this system.

Critical evaluation of mathematical models for the amplification of chirality

The main types of models related to the origin of biological asymmetry are reviewed and new models are proposed. It is shown that in polymerization (in contrast to Yamagata's hypothesis) only a temporary amplification of asymmetry occurs. Models have been constructed in which always the same enantiomer survives, independently of any fluctuations or asymmetric initial conditions. Therefore, the question of the "by chance" or the causal origin of biological asymmetry remains still open, although with a slight preference for a causal origin.