Influence of cellular sequences on instability of plasmid integration sites in human cells

Illegitimate DNA integration in mammalian cells

Foreign DNA integration is one of the most widely exploited cellular processes in molecular biology. Its technical use permits us to alter a cellular genome by incorporating a fragment of foreign DNA into the chromosomal DNA. This process employs the cell's own endogenous DNA modification and repair machinery. Two main classes of integration mechanisms exist: those that draw on sequence similarity between the foreign and genomic sequences to carry out homology-directed modifications, and the nonhomologous or 'illegitimate' insertion of foreign DNA into the genome. Gene therapy procedures can result in illegitimate integration of introduced sequences and thus pose a risk of unforeseeable genomic alterations. The choice of insertion site, the degree to which the foreign DNA and endogenous locus are modified before or during integration, and the resulting impact on structure, expression, and stability of the genome are all factors of illegitimate DNA integration that must be considered, in particular when designing genetic therapies.

Telomere dynamics and telomerase activity in in vitro immortalised human cells

This article reviews the current understanding of the involvement of telomerase in in vitro immortalisation of human cells. In vitro immortalisation with DNA tumour viruses or chemicals usually occurs in two phases. The first stage is an extension of lifespan beyond that at which cells would normally senescence, after which the culture enters a period of crisis. The second stage involves the escape from crisis of a rare cell in the culture, which goes on to proliferate indefinitely. The hypothesis that telomere shortening acts as a signal for senescence and crisis, and that cells need to activate telomerase to survive these states, gained support from early studies examining telomere behaviour and telomerase activity in immortalised cell lines. In many cases, telomeres were found to continue to shorten during the phase of extended lifespan, and no telomerase was detectable. Cells which survived crisis had activated telomerase and had stable or lengthened telomerase. However, it is now clear that this model does not apply to all cell lines. Approximately a quarter of in vitro immortalised cell lines so far examined have no detectable telomerase activity, yet have very long and heterogeneous telomeres. These cell lines have acquired a novel mechanism for lengthening their telomeres, named ALT (Alternative Lengthening of Telomeres). The nature of ALT is not yet understood, but may involve non-reciprocal recombination between telomeres. ALT is not merely a phenomenon of in vitro immortalised cell lines, but has also been found in tumours and tumour-derived cell lines. Furthermore, there are a number of cell lines which have been shown to have low levels of telomerase prior to crisis while telomere shortening is still occurring, and the function of these low levels of telomerase activity is unknown.

Effect of telomere length on telomeric gene expression

Telomeres gradually shorten as human somatic cells divide and a correlation has been observed between the average telomere length and cell senescence. It has been proposed that the genes responsible for cell senescence are located near the telomere and are activated when telomere length reaches a critical point. This is consistent with evidence from Saccharomyces cerevisiae, in which genes are regulated differently depending on their distance from the telomere. We investigated the possibility that differential gene expression is conferred by telomere length in human cells. A plasmid containing the neomycin phosphotransferase (neo) gene was transfected into the SV40-transformed human fibroblast cell line LM217. In one transfectant the plasmid was integrated at the telomere of chromosome 13. Subclones of this cell line that had various lengths of telomeric repeat sequences on the end of this chromosome were isolated. No effect on neo gene expression was found when the length of the telomere varied between 25 and 0.5 kb, as demonstrated by colony forming ability, growth rates and RNA blot analysis. These results therefore suggest that putative chromatin structural differences conferred by telomere length do not affect the expression of genes located near telomeres.

Telomere dynamics in an immortal human cell line

The integration of transfected plasmid DNA at the telomere of chromosome 13 in an immortalized simian virus 40-transformed human cell line provided the first opportunity to study polymorphism in the number of telomeric repeat sequences on the end of a single chromosome. Three subclones of this cell line were selected for analysis: one with a long telomere on chromosome 13, one with a short telomere, and one with such extreme polymorphism that no distinct band was discernible. Further subcloning demonstrated that telomere polymorphism resulted from both gradual changes and rapid changes that sometimes involved many kilobases. The gradual changes were due to the shortening of telomeres at a rate similar to that reported for telomeres of somatic cells without telomerase, eventually resulting in the loss of nearly all of the telomere. However, telomeres were not generally lost completely, as shown by the absence of polymorphism in the subtelomeric plasmid sequences. Instead, telomeres that were less than a few hundred base pairs in length showed a rapid, highly heterogeneous increase in size. Rapid changes in telomere length also occurred on longer telomeres. The frequency of this type of change in telomere length varied among the subclones and correlated with chromosome fusion. Therefore, the rapid changes in telomere length appeared occasionally to result in the complete loss of telomeric repeat sequences. Rapid changes in telomere length have been associated with telomere loss and chromosome instability in yeast and could be responsible for the high rate of chromosome fusion observed in many human tumor cell lines.

The genomic instability associated with integrated simian virus 40 DNA is dependent on the origin of replication and early control region

DNA rearrangements in the form of deletions and duplications are found within and near integrated simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA in nonpermissive cell lines. We have found that rearrangements also occur frequently with integrated pSV2neo plasmid DNA. pSV2neo contains the entire SV40 control region, including the origin of replication, both promoters, and the enhancer sequences. Linearized plasmid DNA was electroporated into X1, an SV40-transformed mouse cell line that expresses SV40 large T antigen (T Ag) and shows very frequent rearrangements at the SV40 locus, and into LMtk-, a spontaneously transformed mouse cell line that contains no SV40 DNA. Stability was analyzed by subcloning G-418-resistant clones and examining specific DNA fragments for alterations in size. Five independent X1 clones containing pSV2neo DNA were unstable at both the neo locus and the T Ag locus. By contrast, four X1 clones containing mutants of pSV2neo with small deletions in the SV40 core origin and three X1 clones containing a different neo plasmid lacking SV40 sequences were stable at the neo locus, although they were still unstable at the T Ag locus. Surprisingly, five independent LMtk- clones containing pSV2neo DNA were unstable at the neo locus. LMtk- clones containing origin deletion mutants were more stable but were not as stable as the X1 clones containing the same plasmid DNA. We conclude that the SV40 origin of replication and early control region are sufficient viral components for the genomic instability at sites of SV40 integration and that SV40 T Ag is not required.

Acquisition of telomere repeat sequences by transfected DNA integrated at the site of a chromosome break

Previous analysis of plasmid DNA transfected into 108 cell clones demonstrated extensive polymorphism near the integration site in one clone. This polymorphism was apparent by Southern blot analysis as diffuse bands that extended over 30 kb. In the present study, nucleotide sequence analysis of cloned DNA from the integration site revealed telomere repeat sequences at the ends of the integrated plasmid DNA. The telomere repeat sequences at one end were located at the junction between the plasmid and cell DNA. The telomere repeat sequences at the other end were located in the opposite orientation in the polymorphic region and were shown by digestion with BAL 31 to be at the end of the chromosome. Telomere repeat sequences were not found at this location in the plasmid or parent cell DNA. Although the repeat sequences may have been acquired by recombination, a more likely explanation is that they were added to the ends of the plasmid by telomerase before integration. Comparison of the cell DNA before and after integration revealed that a chromosome break had occurred at the integration site, which was shown by fluorescent in situ hybridization to be located near the telomere of chromosome 13. These results demonstrate that chromosome breakage and rearrangement can result in interstitial telomere repeat sequences within the human genome. These sequences could promote genomic instability, because short repeat sequences can be recombinational hotspots. The results also show that DNA rearrangements involving telomere repeat sequences can be associated with chromosome breaks. The introduction of telomere repeat sequences at spontaneous or ionizing radiation-induced DNA strand breaks may therefore also be a mechanism of chromosome fragmentation.

Acquisition of telomere repeat sequences by transfected DNA integrated at the site of a chromosome break

Previous analysis of plasmid DNA transfected into 108 cell clones demonstrated extensive polymorphism near the integration site in one clone. This polymorphism was apparent by Southern blot analysis as diffuse bands that extended over 30 kb. In the present study, nucleotide sequence analysis of cloned DNA from the integration site revealed telomere repeat sequences at the ends of the integrated plasmid DNA. The telomere repeat sequences at one end were located at the junction between the plasmid and cell DNA. The telomere repeat sequences at the other end were located in the opposite orientation in the polymorphic region and were shown by digestion with BAL 31 to be at the end of the chromosome. Telomere repeat sequences were not found at this location in the plasmid or parent cell DNA. Although the repeat sequences may have been acquired by recombination, a more likely explanation is that they were added to the ends of the plasmid by telomerase before integration. Comparison of the cell DNA before and after integration revealed that a chromosome break had occurred at the integration site, which was shown by fluorescent in situ hybridization to be located near the telomere of chromosome 13. These results demonstrate that chromosome breakage and rearrangement can result in interstitial telomere repeat sequences within the human genome. These sequences could promote genomic instability, because short repeat sequences can be recombinational hotspots. The results also show that DNA rearrangements involving telomere repeat sequences can be associated with chromosome breaks. The introduction of telomere repeat sequences at spontaneous or ionizing radiation-induced DNA strand breaks may therefore also be a mechanism of chromosome fragmentation.

The role of recombinational hotspots in genome instability in mammalian cells

Genome instability has been associated with progression of transformed cells to high tumorigenicity. Although genome instability may result from a variety of factors, some studies suggest that DNA in the region of a chromosome rearrangement can subsequently have much higher rates of DNA deletions or gene amplification. One approach to studying the factors that produce these high rates of DNA rearrangement is by analysis of unstable integration sites for DNA transfected into mammalian cells. Integrated sequences commonly show a temporary instability, and at rare locations this instability is continuous and can be observed even after multiple subclonings. These continuously unstable locations undergo DNA amplification of both the integrated sequences and the surrounding cell DNA, and it can occur either at the original site or on episomes after looping out from the chromosome. Because the adjacent cell DNA plays a role in this instability, and the region can be shown to be stable before integration, the results indicate that these recombinational hotspots can be formed de novo by the process of integration. Current studies are attempting to determine which sequences are responsible for the high rates of recombination and whether similar types of event are involved in the instability associated with endogenous cellular genes in cancer cells.