Quantitative analysis of the chromosome damage at first division of human lymphocytes after 60CO gamma-irradiation

Effect of changing the radiation dose range on the in vitro cytogenetic dose response to gamma-rays

PURPOSE

To examine the distortion of the linear quadratic (LQ) model of in vitro cytogenetic dose response over an extended range of γ-ray doses by analyzing the available literature data, and to establish the dose ranges, in which the LQ dose response curve (DRC) can be most accurately fitted for biological dosimetry.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Data on yields of dicentrics (Dic) or dicentrics plus centric rings (Dic + CR) induced in vitro in human lymphocytes by acute γ-rays were extracted from 108 open sources. The overall dose response dataset in the dose range up to 50 Gy was fitted to a fractional-rational (FR) model, which included a 'basic' LQ function in the numerator, and a reduction factor dependent on the square of the dose in the denominator. Cytogenetic dose response data obtained at Grigoriev Institute for Medical Radiology, Kharkiv, Ukraine (GIMRO) in the range 0.1 - 20.3 Gy acute γ-rays were fitted to the LQ model with the progressive changing minimum or maximum radiation dose.

RESULTS

The overall dose response, as expected, followed the LQ function in the dose range ≤5 Gy, but in the extended dose range appeared to be S-shaped, with intensive saturation and a plateau at doses ≥22 Gy. Coefficients of the 'basic' LQ equation in FR model were very close to many published DRCs; calculated asymptote was 17. Fitting of the GIMRO dataset to the LQ model with the shift of the dose range showed the increase in linear coefficient with the increment of either minimum or maximum radiation dose, while the decline of the quadratic coefficient was regulated mostly by the increase of the highest dose. The best goodness of fit, assessed by lower χ2 values, occurred for dose ranges 0.1 - 1.0 Gy; 0.5 - 5.9 Gy; 1.0 - 7.8 Gy; 2.0 - 9.6 Gy, 3.9 - 16.4 Gy and 5.9 - 20.3 Gy. The 'see-saw' effect in changes of LQ coefficients was confirmed by re-fitting datasets published by other laboratories.

CONCLUSIONS

The classical LQ model with fixed coefficients appears to have limited applicability for cytogenetic dosimetry at radiation doses >5 Gy due to the saturation of the dose response. Different response of the LQ coefficients to the changes of the dose range must be considered during the DRC construction. Proper selection of minimum and maximum dose in calibration experiments makes it possible to improve the goodness of fit of the LQ DRC.

High-Accuracy Relative Biological Effectiveness Values Following Low-Dose Thermal Neutron Exposures Support Bimodal Quality Factor Response with Neutron Energy

Theoretical evaluations indicate the radiation weighting factor for thermal neutrons differs from the current International Commission on Radiological Protection (ICRP) recommended value of 2.5, which has radiation protection implications for high-energy radiotherapy, inside spacecraft, on the lunar or Martian surface, and in nuclear reactor workplaces. We examined the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of DNA damage generated by thermal neutrons compared to gamma radiation. Whole blood was irradiated by 64 meV thermal neutrons from the National Research Universal reactor. DNA damage and erroneous DNA double-strand break repair was evaluated by dicentric chromosome assay (DCA) and cytokinesis-block micronucleus (CBMN) assay with low doses ranging 6–85 mGy. Linear dose responses were observed. Significant DNA aberration clustering was found indicative of high ionizing density radiation. When the dose contribution of both the ¹⁴N(n,p)¹⁴C and ¹H(n,γ)²H capture reactions were considered, the DCA and the CBMN assays generated similar maximum RBE values of 11.3 ± 1.6 and 9.0 ± 1.1, respectively. Consequently, thermal neutron RBE is approximately four times higher than the current ICRP radiation weighting factor value of 2.5. This lends support to bimodal peaks in the quality factor for RBE neutron energy response, underlining the importance of radiological protection against thermal neutron exposures.

Biological dose-enhancement analysis with Monte Carlo simulation for Lipiodol for photon beams

Background

Previously, the physical dose-enhancement factor (D_physEF) enhancement was introduced. However, the dose enhancement considering the biological effectiveness was not shown.

Purpose

The aim of the current study was to evaluate the biological dose-enhancement factor (D_bioEF) by the dose rate and to compare the D_physEF and the D_bioEF in Lipiodol for liver Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy (SBRT).

Materials and methods

Flattening-filter-free (FFF) 6-MV (6MVX) and 10MVX beams were delivered by TrueBeam. A virtual inhomogeneity phantom and a liver SBRT patient-treatment plan were used. The D_physEF and lineal energy distribution ( y ) distribution was calculated from Monte Carlo simulations. Using a microdosimetric-kinetic (MK) model that is estimated based on the linear-quadratic formula for Lipiodol using human liver hepatocellular cells (HepG2), the biological dose and biological dose enhancement factor (D_bioEF) were calculated. The dose rate in the simulation was changed from 0.1 to 24 Gy/min.

Results

The D_bioEF (DR:2Gy/min) and D_physEF with 10MVX FFF beam were 23.2% and 19.1% at maximum and 12.8% and 11.1% on average in the Lipiodol. In the comparison of the D_bioEF between 0.1-24 Gy/min, the D_bioEF was 21.2% and 11.1% with 0.1 Gy/min for 6MVX and 10 MVX, respectively. The D_bioEF was larger than DEF for the 6MVX and 10MVX FFF beams. In clinical cases with the 10MVX FFF beam, the D_bioEF and D_physEF in the Lipiodol region can increase the in-tumor dose by approximately 11% and 10%, respectively, without increasing the dose to normal tissue.

Conclusions

The lower-energy and higher-dose-rate beams were contributed to the biological dose. The Lipiodol caused the enhancement of the physical dose and biological effectiveness.

Advances in knowledge

The biological dose enhancement (D_bioEF) should be considered in the high-density material such as the Lipiodol.

Calibration curves by 60Co with low dose rate are different in terms of dose estimation - a comparative study

Biological dosimetry aims to estimate individual absorbed doses due ionizing radiation exposure. The dicentric chromosomes are considered the most specific biomarker for dose estimation. This study aimed to compare calibration curves for linear low energy transfer (LET) radiation built from low dose rates and whether they vary in terms of dose estimation. For that we did a search in the literature of all calibration curves produced with low dose rates and we simulated the dose estimation from pre-established dicentric’s frequencies. The information on methodologies and cytogenetic results of each study were analyzed. As expected dose rate influence β coefficients, especially at higher doses. However, we have seen that some doses were not statistically different but they should be, because there is a significant association between the productions of dicentrics and dose rate. This comparative study reinforced the robustness of the dicentric assay and its importance in biological dosimetry. We also emphasized that the dose rate was an important factor in dose estimations. Thus, intercomparison exercises should take into account the dose rates of the participating laboratories, because the dose rates might explain why some results of estimated doses fall outside the recommendations.

Relative biological effectiveness study of Lipiodol based on microdosimetric-kinetic model

OBJECTIVES

We examine the contrast agent Lipiodol effect on the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) values for flattening filter free (FFF) and flattening filter (FF) beams of 6 MV-Xray (6 MVX) and 10 MVX.

METHODS

Lipiodol was placed at 5 cm depth in water. According to the microdosimetric kinetic model, the RBE values for killing the human liver hepatocellular cells were calculated from dose and lineal energy (yd(y)) from Monte Carlo simulations. RBE_200kVX and RBE_Co were defined as the ratios of dose using reference radiation (200 kVX, Co-ɤ) to the dose of test radiation (FFF and FF beams for 6 MV and 10 MV) to produce the same biological effects. The dose enhancement RBE (RBE_DE) was defined as the ratios of a dose without Lipiodol to with Lipiodol using to produce the same biological effects. The dose needed to achieve 10% (D_10%) and 1% cell survival (D_1%) was evaluated by cell surviving fraction (SF) formula.

RESULTS

The deviation of mean y‾_D values with and without Lipiodol were 3.9-4.8% for 6 MVX and 3.5-3.6% for 10 MVX. The RBE_200kVX and RBE_Co with Lipiodol were larger than that without Lipiodol. The RBE_DE was larger for FFF beam than for FF beam. The deviation of RBE_DE for FFF and FF beams of 6 MVX was larger than that of 10 MVX.

CONCLUSION

The presence of Lipiodol seemed to locally increase the absorbed dose and to also cause an enhancement of the relative biological effectiveness.

Calibration Curve for Dicentric Chromosomes Induced in Human Blood Lymphocytes Exposed to Gamma Rays at a Dose Rate of 12.5 mGy/s

To develop a calibration curve for induction of dicentric chromosomes by radiation, we have used a 60Co gamma-ray source with dose rate of 12.5 mGy/s. Whole blood from 15 healthy donors was collected. Whole blood from each donor was divided equally into 8 parts for exposing to supposedly physical doses 0, 0.30, 0.50, 1.00, 1.50, 2.00, 3.00 and 4.00 Gy for a independent calibration curve. Whole blood from 15 donors was used to calibrate dose – effect and statistical for general calibration curve. Using Poisson test (U-test) for the distribution of dicentric chromosomes in the metaphases to determine the uniformity of the radiation field. The average from 15 independent calibration curves of linear correlated coefficient was determined to be r (y, d) = 0.5136 ± 0.0038. The model equation derived is y = aD + bD² + C. The calibration equation of dose-effect was y = 1.01D + 4.43D² + 0.56.

Cytogenetic dose-response in vitro for biological dosimetry after exposure to high doses of gamma-rays

The dose response for dicentrics plus centric rings and total unstable chromosome-type aberrations was studied in the first mitoses of cultured human peripheral blood lymphocytes irradiated in vitro to doses of ∼2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 16 and 20 Gy of acute (60)Со gamma-rays. A dose-dependent increase of aberration yield was accompanied by a tendency to the underdispersion of dicentrics and centric rings among cells distributions compared with Poisson statistics at doses ≥6 Gy. The formal fitting of the data to a linear-quadratic model resulted in an equation with the linear and quadratic coefficients ranged 0.098-0.129×cell(-1)×Gy(-1) and 0.039-0.034×cell(-1)×Gy(-2), respectively, depending on the fitting method. The actual radiation-induced aberration yield was markedly lower than expected from a calibration curve, generated earlier within a lower dose range. Interlaboratory variations in reported dicentric yields induced by medium-to-high radiation doses in vitro are discussed.

RBE of thermal neutrons for induction of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes

The induction of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes irradiated in vitro with slow neutrons was examined to assess the maximum low-dose RBE (RBE(M)) relative to (60)Co γ-rays. For the blood irradiations, cold neutron beam available at the prompt gamma activation analysis facility at the Munich research reactor FRM II was used. The given flux of cold neutrons can be converted into a thermally equivalent one. Since blood was taken from the same donor whose blood had been used for previous irradiation experiments using widely varying neutron energies, the greatest possible accuracy was available for such an estimation of the RBE(M) avoiding the inter-individual variations or differences in methodology usually associated with inter-laboratory comparisons. The magnitude of the coefficient α of the linear dose-response relationship (α = 0.400 ± 0.018 Gy(-1)) and the derived RBE(M) of 36.4 ± 13.3 obtained for the production of dicentrics by thermal neutrons confirm our earlier observations of a strong decrease in α and RBE(M) with decreasing neutron energy lower than 0.385 MeV (RBE(M) = 94.4 ± 38.9). The magnitude of the presently estimated RBE(M) of thermal neutrons is-with some restrictions-not significantly different to previously reported RBE(M) values of two laboratories.

Implementation of a dose-response curve for γ-radiation in the Portuguese population by use of the chromosomal aberration assay

An in vitro dose-response curve following exposure to γ-radiation was determined at the IST/ITN, by use of the chromosomal aberration assay. This is the first study of this kind carried out among the Portuguese population. Un-irradiated and γ-irradiated peripheral blood lymphocytes from 16 healthy donors were cultured. A total of 22,395 metaphases were analyzed for frequency and distribution of dicentrics and centric rings, as a function of the radiation dose. The dose-response data for dicentrics and dicentrics plus centric rings were fitted by use of a linear-quadratic model: Y(dic)=(0.0011±0.0006)+(0.0105±0.0035)D+(0.0480±0.0019)D(2) and Y(dic+rings)=(0.0011±0.0006)+(0.0095±0.0036)D+(0.0536±0.0020)D(2). Also, calibration curves related to age and gender were determined, but no significant differences were found. Following the establishment of the dose-response curves, a validation experiment was carried out with three individuals. Real and estimated doses, obtained with the dose-response curves, were in agreement. These results give us confidence to apply both dose-response calibration curves in future biological dosimetry requirements.

The dose response of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes induced in vitro by very low-dose γ rays

This paper considers the dose-effect relationship for unstable chromosome aberration yields in human lymphocytes in very low-dose range. Data are presented for (60)Co γ-ray doses of 0, 10, 20, 40 and 1000 mGy. More than 5,000 metaphases were scored for each data point at the very low doses, and each cell was double-checked using a semi-automated metaphase finding/relocation system. Aberration yields of dicentrics plus centric rings followed an excellent linear dose response down to zero dose; the yields were significantly above the control frequency from 20 mGy.

RBE of low energy electrons and photons

Relative biological effectiveness (RBE) compares the severity of damage induced by a radiation under test at a dose D relative to the reference radiation D(x) for the same biological endpoint. RBE is an important parameter in estimation of risk from exposure to ionizing radiation (IR). The present work provides a review of the recently published data and the knowledge of the RBE of low energy electrons and photons. The review presents RBE values derived from experimental data and model calculations including cell inactivation, chromosome aberration, cell transformation, micronuclei formation and induction of double-strand breaks. Biophysical models, including physical features of radiation track, and microdosimetry parameters are presented, analysed and compared with experimental data. The biological effects of low energy electrons and photons are of particular interest in radiation biology as these are strongly absorbed in micrometer and sub-micrometer layers of tissue. RBE values not only depend on the electron and photon energies but also on the irradiation condition, cell type and experimental conditions.

The use of the dicentric assay for biological dosimetry for radiation accidents in Bulgaria

This paper details the construction of a 137Cs gamma calibration curve that has been established for dicentric assay and the testing and validation of the curve through biological dosimetry in three situations of suspected workplace overexposure that arose accidentally or through negligence or lack of appropriate safety measures. The three situations were: (1) suspected 137Cs contamination in a factory air supply; (2) suspected exposure to an industrial 192Ir source; and (3) accidental exposure of construction workers to radiation from a 60Co radiotherapy source in a hospital medical physics department. From a total of 24 potentially-exposed subjects, only one worker was found to have a statistically significant dose (0.16 Gy, 95% confidence intervals 0.02-0.43 Gy). In all other cases, the main function of the biological dosimetry was to reassure the subjects that any dose received was low.

Advances in the biophysical and molecular bases of radiation cytogenetics

PURPOSE

For more than 70 years radiation cytogenetics has continued to be a topic of major concern in relation to the action of radiation on living cells. To date, diverse cytogenetic findings have developed into orderly, quantitative interpretations and have stimulated numerous biophysical models. However, it is generally agreed that any one of the models used alone is still unable to explain all aspects of the observed chromosomal effects. In this review, a large number of radiation-induced chromosome aberration findings from the literature are reassessed with special attention given to the reaction kinetics and the relevant molecular processes.

CONCLUSION

It is now clear that DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) are an integral component of radiation-induced chromosome aberration. At the nexus of the maintenance of genome integrity, cells are equipped with excellent systems to repair DSB, notably non-homologous end-joining (NHEJ) and homologous recombination repair (HRR). These repair mechanisms are strictly regulated along with the DNA turnover cycle. NHEJ functions in all phases of the cell cycle, whereas HRR has a supplementary role specifically in S/G2 phase, where homologous DNA sequences are available in close proximity. The repair pathways are further regulated by a complex nuclear dynamism, where DSB are sensed and large numbers of repair proteins are recruited and assembled to form a repair complex involving multiple DSB. Considering such DSB repair dynamism, radiation-induced chromosome aberrations could be well understood as DSB-DSB pairwise interactions associated with the NHEJ pathway in all phases of the cell cycle and misrepair of a single DSB associated with the complementary HRR pathway in late S/G2 phase.

Dose-response relationship of dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes obtained for the fission neutron therapy facility MEDAPP at the research reactor FRM II

The biological effectiveness of neutrons from the neutron therapy facility MEDAPP (mean neutron energy 1.9 MeV) at the new research reactor FRM II at Garching, Germany, has been analyzed, at different depths in a polyethylene phantom. Whole blood samples were exposed to the MEDAPP beam in special irradiation chambers to total doses of 0.14-3.52 Gy at 2-cm depth, and 0.18-3.04 Gy at 6-cm depth of the phantom. The neutron and gamma-ray absorbed dose rates were measured to be 0.55 Gy min(-1) and 0.27 Gy min(-1) at 2-cm depth, while they were 0.28 and 0.25 Gy min(-1) at 6-cm depth. Although the irradiation conditions at the MEDAPP beam and the RENT beam of the former FRM I research reactor were not identical, neutrons from both facilities gave a similar linear-quadratic dose-response relationship for dicentric chromosomes at a depth of 2 cm. Different dose-response curves for dicentrics were obtained for the MEDAPP beam at 2 and 6 cm depth, suggesting a significantly lower biological effectiveness of the radiation with increasing depth. No obvious differences in the dose-response curves for dicentric chromosomes estimated under interactive or additive prediction between neutrons or gamma-rays and the experimentally obtained dose-response curves could be determined. Relative to (60)Co gamma-rays, the values for the relative biological effectiveness at the MEDAPP beam decrease from 5.9 at 0.14 Gy to 1.6 at 3.52 Gy at 2-cm depth, and from 4.1 at 0.18 Gy to 1.5 at 3.04 Gy at 6-cm depth. Using the best possible conditions of consistency, i.e., using blood samples from the same donor and the same measurement techniques for about two decades, avoiding the inter-individual variations in sensitivity or the differences in methodology usually associated with inter-laboratory comparisons, a linear-quadratic dose-response relationship for the mixed neutron and gamma-ray MEDAPP field as well as for its fission neutron part was obtained. Therefore, the debate on whether the fission-neutron induced yield of dicentric chromosomes increases linearly with dose remains open.

The depth-dependence of the biological effectiveness of 60Co gamma rays in a large absorber determined by dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes

Radiobiological evidence is shown concerning a significant depth-dependence of the maximum relative biological effectiveness at limiting low doses (RBE(M)) of (60)Co gamma rays in a cubic polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) phantom of 30 cm edge length. Using the dose-response curve for the dicentric data in human lymphocytes obtained in the present experiment at a depth of 20 cm, together with the comprehensive and consistent data set determined earlier at smaller depths of the PMMA phantom, there is an increase in the RBE(M) value by a factor of 2.18 +/- 1.25 at a depth of 20 cm relative to 1 cm in the phantom. All the dicentric data are based on identical exposure durations and irradiation temperatures as well as identical culture and evaluation conditions, with blood from the same donor.

Energy dependence of dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor for low-let radiations: potential importance to estimation of cancer risks and relationship to biological effectiveness

A dose and dose-rate effectiveness factor (DDREF) for low-linear energy transfer (LET) radiations (photons and electrons) is used in cancer risk assessments to represent an assumption that risks at low doses and low dose rates may be less than estimates that are based mainly on linear extrapolations of observed risks at higher acute doses. DDREF generally is assumed to be independent of energy. However, a variety of radiobiological data reviewed in this paper suggest that DDREF may decrease with decreasing energy. This effect, which parallels increases in biological effectiveness with decreasing energy of photons and electrons that have been observed in many radiobiological studies, has received little attention. The importance of an overestimation of DDREF at low energies of photons and electrons is that cancer risks at low doses and low dose rates could be underestimated. This paper also discusses (1) the link between DDREF and the usual assumption of a linear-quadratic dose-response relationship for low-LET radiations and (2) concerns about the validity of estimates of DDREF and biological effectiveness used in cancer risk assessments that are raised by results of recent studies that cast doubt on whether the underlying radiobiological data can be represented by a simple linear-quadratic model.

Radiation-induced late effects in two affected individuals of the Lilo radiation accident

Radiation exposure leads to a risk for long-term deterministic and stochastic late effects. Two individuals exposed to protracted photon radiation in the radiological accident at the Lilo Military site in Georgia in 1997 received follow-up treatment and resection of several chronic radiation ulcers in the Bundeswehr Hospital Ulm, Germany, in 2003. Multi-parameter analysis revealed that spermatogenetic arrest and serum hormone levels in both patients had recovered compared to the status in 1997. However, we observed a persistence of altered T-cell ratios, increased ICAM1 and beta1-integrin expression, and aberrant bone marrow cells and lymphocytes with significantly increased translocations 6 years after the accident. This investigation thus identified altered end points still detectable years after the accident that suggest persistent genomic damage as well as epigenetic effects in these individuals, which may be associated with an elevated risk for the development of further late effects. Our observations further suggest the development of a chronic radiation syndrome and indicate follow-up parameters in radiation victims.

Effective dose of A-bomb radiation in Hiroshima and Nagasaki as assessed by chromosomal effectiveness of spectrum energy photons and neutrons

The effective dose of combined spectrum energy neutrons and high energy spectrum gamma-rays in A-bomb survivors in Hiroshima and Nagasaki has long been a matter of discussion. The reason is largely due to the paucity of biological data for high energy photons, particularly for those with an energy of tens of MeV. To circumvent this problem, a mathematical formalism was developed for the photon energy dependency of chromosomal effectiveness by reviewing a large number of data sets published in the literature on dicentric chromosome formation in human lymphocytes. The chromosomal effectiveness was expressed by a simple multiparametric function of photon energy, which made it possible to estimate the effective dose of spectrum energy photons and differential evaluation in the field of mixed neutron and gamma-ray exposure with an internal reference radiation. The effective dose of reactor-produced spectrum energy neutrons was insensitive to the fine structure of the energy distribution and was accessible by a generalized formula applicable to the A-bomb neutrons. Energy spectra of all sources of A-bomb gamma-rays at different tissue depths were simulated by a Monte Carlo calculation applied on an ICRU sphere. Using kerma-weighted chromosomal effectiveness of A-bomb spectrum energy photons, the effective dose of A-bomb neutrons was determined, where the relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of neutrons was expressed by a dose-dependent variable RBE, RBE(gamma, D (n)), against A-bomb gamma-rays as an internal reference radiation. When the newly estimated variable RBE(gamma, D (n)) was applied to the chromosome data of A-bomb survivors in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, the city difference was completely eliminated. The revised effective dose was about 35% larger in Hiroshima, 19% larger in Nagasaki and 26% larger for the combined cohort compared with that based on a constant RBE of 10. Since the differences are significantly large, the proposed effective dose might have an impact on the magnitude of the risk estimates deduced from the A-bomb survivor cohort.

RBE of quasi-monoenergetic 60 MeV neutron radiation for induction of dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes

The production of dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes by high-energy neutron radiation was studied using a quasi-monoenergetic 60 MeV neutron beam. The average yield coefficient [see text] of the linear dose-response relationship for dicentric chromosomes was measured to be (0.146+/-0.016) Gy-1. This confirms our earlier observations that above 400 keV, the yield of dicentric chromosomes decreases with increasing neutron energy. Using the linear-quadratic dose-response relationship for dicentric chromosomes established in blood of the same donor for 60Co gamma-rays as a reference radiation, an average maximum low-dose RBE (RBEM) of 14+/-4 for 60 MeV quasi-monoenergetic neutrons with a dose-weighted average energy [see text] of 41.0 MeV is obtained. A correction procedure was applied, to account for the low-energy continuum of the quasi-monoenergetic spectral neutron distribution, and the yield coefficient alpha for 60 MeV neutrons was determined from the measured average yield coefficient [see text]. For alpha, a value of (0.115+/-0.026) Gy-1 was obtained corresponding to an RBEM of 11+/-4. The present experiments extend earlier investigations with monoenergetic neutrons to higher energies.

Relative biological effectiveness (RBE), quality factor (Q), and radiation weighting factor (w(R)). A report of the International Commission on Radiological Protection

The effect of ionising radiation is influenced by the dose, the dose rate, and the quality of the radiation. Before 1990, dose-equivalent quantities were defined in terms of a quality factor, Q(L), that was applied to the absorbed dose at a point in order to take into account the differences in the effects of different types of radiation. In its 1990 recommendations, the ICRP introduced a modified concept. For radiological protection purposes, the absorbed dose is averaged over an organ or tissue, T, and this absorbed dose average is weighted for the radiation quality in terms of the radiation weighting factor, w(R), for the type and energy of radiation incident on the body. The resulting weighted dose is designated as the organ- or tissue-equivalent dose, H(T). The sum of the organ-equivalent doses weighted by the ICRP organ-weighting factors, w(T), is termed the effective dose, E. Measurements can be performed in terms of the operational quantities, ambient dose equivalent, and personal dose equivalent. These quantities continue to be defined in terms of the absorbed dose at the reference point weighted by Q(L). The values for w(R) and Q(L) in the 1990 recommendations were based on a review of the biological and other information available, but the underlying relative biological effectiveness (RBE) values and the choice of w(R) values were not elaborated in detail. Since 1990, there have been substantial developments in biological and dosimetric knowledge that justify a re-appraisal of w(R) values and how they may be derived. This re-appraisal is the principal objective of the present report. The report discusses in some detail the values of RBE with regard to stochastic effects, which are central to the selection of w(R) and Q(L). Those factors and the dose-equivalent quantities are restricted to the dose range of interest to radiation protection, i.e. to the general magnitude of the dose limits. In special circumstances where one deals with higher doses that can cause deterministic effects, the relevant RBE values are applied to obtain a weighted dose. The question of RBE values for deterministic effects and how they should be used is also treated in the report, but it is an issue that will demand further investigations. This report is one of a set of documents being developed by ICRP Committees in order to advise the ICRP on the formulation of its next Recommendations for Radiological Protection. Thus, while the report suggests some future modifications, the w(R) values given in the 1990 recommendations are still valid at this time. The report provides a scientific background and suggests how the ICRP might proceed with the derivation of w(R) values ahead of its forthcoming recommendations.

Chromosome aberrations as biomarkers of radiation exposure: modelling basic mechanisms

The space radiation environment is a mixed field consisting of different particles having different energies, including high charge and energy (HZE) ions. Conventional measurements of absorbed doses may not be sufficient to completely characterise the radiation field and perform reliable estimates of health risks. Biological dosimetry, based on the observation of specific radiation-induced endpoints (typically chromosome aberrations), can be a helpful approach in case of monitored exposure to space radiation or other mixed fields, as well as in case of accidental exposure. Furthermore, various ratios of aberrations (e.g. dicentric chromosomes to centric rings and complex exchanges to simple exchanges) have been suggested as possible fingerprints of radiation quality, although all of them have been subjected to some criticisms. In this context a mechanistic model and a Monte Carlo code for the simulation of chromosome aberration induction were developed. The model, able to provide dose-responses for different aberrations (e.g. dicentrics, rings, fragments, translocations, insertions and other complex exchanges), was further developed to assess the dependence of various ratios of aberrations on radiation quality. The predictions of the model were compared with available data, whose experimental conditions were faithfully reproduced. Particular attention was devoted to the scoring criteria adopted in different laboratories and to possible biases introduced by interphase death and mitotic delay. This latter aspect was investigated by taking into account both metaphase data and data obtained with Premature Chromosome Condensation (PCC).

Is there reliable experimental evidence for a low-dose RBE of about 4 for mammography X rays relative to 200 kV X rays?

recently reported, on the basis of observations of neoplastic transformation in human hybrid CGL1 cells, a low-dose relative biological effectiveness (RBE(M)) of 4.3 for mammography X rays (29 kV) relative to 200 kV X rays. With reference to data in the literature, they inferred a factor of about 8 relative to 60Co gamma rays and concluded that this result is relevant to risk estimation. However, the conclusions do not appear to be valid. The data from the transformation study exhibit uncertainties in the statistical analysis that preclude any generalization of the inferred RBE(M). The data selected or inferred from the literature are likewise insufficient to support the stated RBEs. Our own uniform data set for the yields of dicentrics was obtained for widely varying photon energies with blood samples from the same donor, and it avoids interindividual variations in sensitivity as well as the differences in methodology that are associated with interlaboratory comparisons. Our data provide RBE(M) values for 29 kV X rays of 1.64 +/- 0.27 relative to 220 kV X rays and 4.75 +/- 1.67 and 6.12 +/- 2.51 relative to 60Co gamma rays.

The effect of 29 kV X rays on the dose response of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes

The induction of chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes irradiated in vitro with X rays generated at a tube voltage of 29 kV was examined to assess the maximum low-dose RBE (RBE(M)) relative to higher-energy X rays or 60Co gamma rays. Since blood was taken from the same male donor whose blood had been used for previous irradiation experiments using widely varying photon energies, the greatest possible accuracy was available for such an estimation of the RBE(M), avoiding the interindividual variations in sensitivity or differences in methodology usually associated with interlaboratory comparisons. The magnitude of the linear coefficient alpha of the linear-quadratic dose-effect relationship obtained for the production of dicentric chromosomes by 29 kV X rays (alpha = 0.0655 +/- 0.0097 Gy(-1)) confirms earlier observations of a strong increase in alpha with decreasing photon energy. Relating this value to previously published values of alpha for the dose-effect curves for dicentrics obtained in our own laboratory, RBE(M) values of 1.6 +/- 0.3 in comparison with weakly filtered 220 kV X rays, 3.0 +/- 0.7 compared to heavily filtered 220 kV X rays, and 6.1 +/- 2.5 compared to 60Co gamma rays have been obtained. These data emphasize that the choice of the reference radiation is of fundamental importance for the RBE(M) obtained. A special survey of the RBE(M) values obtained by different investigators in the narrow quality range from about 30 to 350 kV X rays indicates that the present RBE is in fairly good agreement with previously published findings for the induction of chromosome aberrations or micronuclei in human lymphocytes but differs from recently published findings for neoplastic transformation in a human hybrid cell line.

Electron spectra and the RBE of X rays

For an assessment of the possible difference in effectiveness between mammography X rays and conventional X rays, the energy and LET spectra of the released electrons are examined. At photon energies below 20 keV and above 100 keV, the energy of the electrons increases with increasing photon energy, which implies that higher-energy photons produce less densely ionizing radiation and are therefore somewhat less effective per unit dose. However, in the intermediate energy range from 20 keV to 100 keV-the range that is relevant to medical diagnostics-the change from the photoelectric effect to the Compton effect causes a transient decrease of electron energies. The ionization density is therefore similar for 200 kVp X rays and 30 kVp mammography X rays, and the distributions of dose in LET suggest an RBE of 30 kVp mammography X rays compared to 200 kVp X rays of up to 1.3. This is in line with an earlier assessment by Brenner and Amols in terms of microdosimetric data, but it is strongly at variance with a recent claim that X rays for mammography are about four times more effective at small doses than conventional X rays and that they cause a correspondingly greater risk for breast cancer. Since LET need not be the only relevant factor, general response functions are examined here that specify-at low dose-the effect per electron of initial energy E and account, for example, for a particular role of the electron range. It is shown that, with any response per electron track that is a nondecreasing function of its starting energy, the low-dose RBE of the mammography X rays relative to the 200 kVp X rays must be substantially less than 2. The Auger electron that accompanies most photoelectrons, but only a minority of the Compton electrons, may increase the effectiveness of the mammography X rays somewhat, but it cannot explain the reported high values of the RBE.

Chromosome aberrations induced in human lymphocytes by in vitro and in vivo X-rays

A dose-effect curve is presented obtained by analysis of dicentric chromosomes and centric ring chromosomes in lymphocyte metaphase spreads of three healthy volunteers after in vitro 100 kV X-ray-irradiation of peripheral blood samples. This calibration curve follows a linear quadratic equation, y=c+alpha D+beta D(2), with the coefficients: y=(0.0005+/-0.0001)+(0.0355+/-0.0066)D+(0.0701+/-0.0072)D(2). The model is based on 13.231 first-division metaphases analyzed after in vitro exposure to doses ranging from 0.1 to 2.0 Gy at a dose rate of 0.4 Gy min(-1). Significant overdispersion of the observed chromosomal aberrations was evident for dose points 1.0 and 2.0 Gy, respectively. The calibration curve was applied to derive equivalent whole body doses of three subjects after suspected extensive exposure to diagnostic X-rays.

Relative biological effectiveness of 144 keV neutrons in producing dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes compared with 60Co gamma rays under head-to-head conditions

The RBE for neutrons was assessed in a head-to-head experiment in which cultures of lymphocytes from the same male donor were irradiated simultaneously with 144 keV neutrons and with 60Co gamma rays as the reference radiation and evaluated using matched time, culture conditions, and the end point of chromosomal aberrations to avoid potential confounding factors that would influence the outcome of the experiment. In addition, the irradiation time was held constant at 2 h for the high-dose groups for both radiation types, which resulted in rather low dose rates. For the induction of dicentric chromosomes, the exposure to the 144 keV neutrons was found to be almost equally as effective (yield coefficient alpha(dic) = 0.786 +/- 0.066 dicentrics per cell per gray) as that found previously for irradiation with monoenergetic neutrons at 565 keV (alpha(dic) = 0.813 +/- 0.052 dicentrics per cell per gray) under comparable exposure and culture conditions (Radiat. Res. 154, 307-312, 2000). However, the values of the maximum low-dose RBE (RBE(m)) relative to 60Co gamma rays that were determined in the present and previous studies show an insignificant but conspicuous difference: 57.0 +/- 18.8 and 76.0 +/- 29.5, respectively. This difference is mainly due to the difference in the alpha(dic) value of the 60Co gamma rays, the reference radiation, which was 0.0138 +/- 0.0044 Gy(-1) in the present study and 0.0107 +/- 0.0041 Gy(-1) in the previous study. In the present experiment, irradiations with 144 keV neutrons and 60Co gamma rays were both performed at 21 degrees C, while in the earlier experiment irradiations with 565 keV neutrons were performed at 21 degrees C and the corresponding reference irradiation with gamma rays was performed at 37 degrees C. However, the temperature difference between 21 degrees C and 37 degrees C has a minor influence on the yield of chromosomal alterations and hence RBE values. The large cubic PMMA phantom that was used for the gamma irradiations in the present study results in a larger dose contribution from Compton-scattered photons compared to the mini-phantom used in the earlier experiments. The contribution of these scattered photons may explain the large value of alpha(dic) for gamma irradiation in the present study. These results indicate that the yield coefficient alpha(dic) for 144 keV neutrons is similar to the one for 565 keV neutrons, and that modification of the alpha(dic) value of the low-LET reference radiation, due to changes in the experimental conditions, can influence the RBE(m). Consequently, alpha(dic) values cannot be shared between cytogenetic laboratories for the purpose of assessment of RBM(m) without verification of the comparability of the experimental conditions.

Risk estimation for fast neutrons with regard to solid cancer

In the absence of epidemiological information on the effects of neutrons, their cancer mortality risk coefficient is currently taken as the product of two low-dose extrapolations: the nominal risk coefficient for photons and the presumed maximum relative biological effectiveness of neutrons. This approach is unnecessary. Since linearity in dose is assumed for neutrons at low to moderate effect levels, the risk coefficient can be derived in terms of the excess risk from epidemiological observations at an intermediate dose of gamma rays and an assumed value, R(1), of the neutron RBE relative to this reference dose of gamma rays. Application of this procedure to the A-bomb data requires accounting for the effect of the neutron dose component, which, according to the current dosimetry system, DS86, amounts on average to 11 mGy in the two cities at a total dose of 1 Gy. With R(1) tentatively set to 20 or 50, it is concluded that the neutrons have caused 18% or 35%, respectively, of the total effect at 1 Gy. The excess relative risk (ERR) for neutrons then lies between 8 per Gy and 16 per Gy. Translating these values into risk coefficients in terms of the effective dose, E, requires accounting for the gamma-ray component produced by the neutron field in the human body, which will require a separate analysis. The risk estimate for neutrons will remain essentially unaffected by the current reassessment of the neutron doses in Hiroshima, because the doses are unlikely to change much at the reference dose of 1 Gy.

Modelling chromosomal aberration induction by ionising radiation: the influence of interphase chromosome architecture

Several advances have been achieved in the knowledge of nuclear architecture and functions during the last decade, thus allowing the identification of interphase chromosome territories and sub-chromosomal domains (e.g. arm and band domains). This is an important step in the study of radiation-induced chromosome aberrations; indeed, the coupling between track-structure simulations and reliable descriptions of the geometrical properties of the target is one of the main tasks in modelling aberration induction by radiation, since it allows one to clarify the role of the initial positioning of two DNA lesions in determining their interaction probability. In the present paper, the main recent findings on nuclear and chromosomal architecture are summarised. A few examples of models based on different descriptions of interphase chromosome organisation (random-walk models, domain models and static models) are presented, focussing on how the approach adopted in modelling the target nuclei and chromosomes can influence the simulation of chromosomal aberration yields. Each model is discussed by taking into account available experimental data on chromosome aberration induction and/or interphase chromatin organisation. Preliminary results from a mechanistic model based on a coupling between radiation track-structure features and explicitly-modelled, non-overlapping chromosome territories are presented.

The effectiveness of monoenergetic neutrons at 565 keV in producing dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes at low doses

The induction of dicentric chromosomes in human lymphocytes from one individual irradiated in vitro with monoenergetic neutrons at 565 keV was examined to provide additional data for an improved evaluation of neutrons with respect to radiation risk in radioprotection. The resulting linear dose-response relationship obtained (0.813 +/- 0.052 dicentrics per cell per gray) over the dose range of 0.0213-0.167 Gy is consistent with published results obtained for irradiation with neutrons from different sources and with different spectra at energies lower than 1000 keV. Comparing this value to previously published "average" dose-response curves obtained by different laboratories for (60)Co gamma rays and orthovoltage X rays resulted in maximum RBEs (RBE(m)) of about 37 +/- 8 and 16 +/- 4, respectively. However, when our neutron data were matched to low-LET dose responses that were constructed several years earlier for lymphocytes from the same individual, higher values of RBE(m) resulted: 76.0 +/- 29.5 for (60)Co gamma rays and 54.2 +/- 18.4 for (137)Cs gamma rays; differentially filtered 220 kV X rays produced values of RBE(m) between 20.3 +/- 2.0 or 37.0 +/- 7. 1. The results highlight the dependence of RBE(m) on the choice of low-LET reference radiation and raise the possibility that differential individual response to low-LET radiations may need to be examined more fully in this context.

Chromosomal aberrations in peripheral lymphocytes from healthy subjects as detected in first cell division

Baseline frequencies of chromosomal aberrations were analysed in human peripheral lymphocytes and the influence of age, sex and smoking habits was considered. From 53 healthy subjects (29 males, 24 females) 54,689 exclusively first division cells (M1) were scored. The frequencies of chromosome aberrations per 1000 cells were 1.15 +/- 0.15 dicentrics (dic), 2.6 +/- 0.3 excess acentric fragments (ace) and 7.0 +/- 0.6 chromatid breaks (crb). An age dependency could only be established for ace. Between males and females no differences in any of the aberration types were observed. For heavy smokers (> 30 cigarettes per day) a significant increase was only found for dic (2.5 +/- 0.6 per 1000 cells). Dicentric frequency was compared with background levels of other studies in which results were reported also from exclusively M1 cells. Despite cell cycle control, differences between laboratories can be observed which may be partly influenced by environmental conditions. But on the other hand the mean frequency of dic (excluding heavy smokers) of 0.95 per 1000 cells reported here is consistent for more than one decade. Since such a consistency of the mean frequency of dic is reported also from another laboratory, the conclusion is drawn that especially for the detection of low-level exposures, each laboratory should establish its own base line data, otherwise, the interpretation of the findings is dependent on the selected background level from the literature.

Cytogenetic evaluation of occupational exposure to external gamma-rays and internal 241Am contamination

Chromosome analyses were performed on peripheral lymphocytes from seven radiation workers exposed to external gamma-radiation within maximum annual permissible dose limits during 11 to 22 years of employment. Five years prior to blood sampling, six workers had additionally incorporated the alpha-emitting radionuclide 241Am which contributed between five to 25% of the total accumulated whole body dose in five workers and about 70% in one worker. For the radiation workers as a group, both the mean frequencies of symmetrical translocations measured by fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH)/chromosome painting and dicentrics + ring chromosomes scored in first division metaphases of conventional preparations were significantly elevated compared with respective controls. The mean biodosimetry estimate for the group was 270 mSv when based on stable translocations which compares well with the mean dose of 247 mSv based on official dosimetry records. The lower mean dose estimate of 160 mSv based on unstable dicentrics is compatible with the well-known loss of dicentrics from the circulating blood with time after exposure.

Retrospective biodosimetry of Chernobyl clean-up workers using chromosome painting and conventional chromosome analysis

Blood samples of 52 Chernobyl clean-up workers were analysed by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) using whole-chromosome painting probes for chromosomes 1, 4 and 12, simultaneously with a pancentromeric probe and by conventional chromosome analysis, for radiation-induced symmetrical translocations and dicentrics in T-lymphocytes. Based on FISH measurements of translocations, individual biodosimetry estimates between 0.32 and 1.0 Gy were obtained from 18 cases. Pooled data for the total group of 52 workers provided a collective biodosimetry estimate of 0.23 Gy. For a group of 34 workers with documented doses, the mean dose estimate of 0.25 Gy compared well with the mean documented dose of 0.26 Gy. However, no correlation between individual translocation frequencies (FG) and documented doses could be found. A statistical analysis of the expected dose-response suggests exposures to higher doses than documented for a substantial fraction of workers with ascribed doses < 0.2 Sv. For subjects working repeatedly at the reactor site between 1986 and 1995 the mean translocation frequency was significantly higher than for those working only in 1986. A comparison of dicentric frequencies obtained by conventional scoring and by FISH measurements showed no significant difference, although only two of 52 cases revealed significantly higher yields than the mean control level. Based on conventionally scored dicentric frequencies, a collective biodosimetry estimate of 0.23 Gy could be derived only of the group of persons working at Chernobyl exclusively in 1986 for which a documented average dose of 0.19 Gy was reported.

Induction and persistence of cytogenetic damage in mouse splenocytes following whole-body X-irradiation analysed by fluorescence in situ hybridization. I. Dicentrics and translocations

Chromosome translocations (stable aberrations) can persist longer during cellular proliferation than dicentrics (unstable aberrations). It is important to know the kinetics of the elimination of dicentrics and to what extent translocations persist in an in vivo cell population after irradiation. The female Swiss mouse were used to study the induction and persistence of dicentrics and translocations in splenocytes up to 112 days after exposure to 2 Gy whole-body X-irradiation. Metaphase spreads at different time intervals were analyzed by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) using chromosome-specific DNA libraries for chromosomes 1, 11 and 13. The frequencies of dicentrics and translocations appear to be equal immediately after irradiation. Frequencies of dicentrics decreased exponentially with time according to the relationship D = ae(-kt). The rate of elimination was faster in the early period (days 0-14) than in the later period (> or = 14 days). The frequency of translocations was constant in the period 0-7 days and then decreased linearly or exponentially. For the whole period, the trend is highly significant. As mouse chromosome painting probes are becoming available and by using FISH, an in vivo mouse model for the analysis of translocations has become feasible. As translocations are involved in carcinogenesis and genetic disorders, risk estimation for induction of translocations by ionizing radiation can be made with greater confidence and extrapolated to the human situation.

Dicentric and translocation analysis for retrospective dose estimation in humans exposed to ionising radiation during the Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident

Chromosome analyses were carried out in peripheral blood lymphocytes obtained between September 1991 and March 1992 from 15 persons exposed to ionising radiation during the Chernobyl nuclear power plant accident. At present, all are being treated for symptoms of the delayed stage of the cutaneous radiation syndrome. Biological dose-equivalent estimates were determined, either by measuring the frequency of dicentric and ring chromosomes in first division unstable cells from conventional preparations (Qdr method), or by measuring the frequency of stable translocations using two-colour fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) with composite whole chromosome-specific DNA libraries for human chromosomes 1, 4 and 12 (chromosome painting) and a degenerate alpha-satellite pancentromeric DNA probe. With both methods fairly comparable individual estimates between 1.1 and 5.8 Gy were obtained for 12 of 15 individuals. Three individuals exhibited no elevated aberration frequencies. Perspectives and limitations of chromosome painting for dose reconstruction of past radiation exposures are discussed.

Chromosome aberrations in nuclear power plant workers: the influence of dose accumulation and lymphocyte life-time

Chromosome analyses were performed in blood lymphocytes of 22 nuclear power plant workers with a mean accumulated radiation dose of 390 mSv (270-530 mSv). Nineteen workers had received 300 mSv 4-16 years prior to sampling. The frequency of dicentrics and ring chromosomes (1.75 x 10(-3)) was significantly elevated as compared to a control group (0.58 x 10(-3)). Based on the initial slope of an in vitro 60Co gamma-ray curve, a biological dose estimate of only 110 mSv was derived. This can be interpreted in terms of an "equivalent-acute" dose at the time of blood sampling which can be derived by weighting annual doses during working periods of 12-30 years for a mean life-time m of lymphocytes. The annual doses were additionally weighted for a uniform distribution during a whole year. Using m = 10 years, a mean "equivalent-acute" dose of 90 mSv (64-157 mSv) is obtained, which compares more closely to the biologically estimated dose than 20 mSv (7-71 mSv) based on m = 4.3 years.

Radiation-induced chromosome aberrations analysed by two-colour fluorescence in situ hybridization with composite whole chromosome-specific DNA probes and a pancentromeric DNA probe

Fluorescence in situ hybridization with composite whole chromosome-specific DNA probes for human chromosomes 1, 4 and 12 and a degenerate alpha-satellite pancentromeric DNA probe labelled with digoxigenin was used to measure symmetrical translocations and dicentrics induced in vitro by 137Cs gamma-rays (0-6.0 Gy) in peripheral lymphocytes. Despite subtracting our mean background translocation frequency of 0.0016 per cell (11,411 cells scored from 11 individuals) from induced frequencies, about 1.3-1.8-fold more translocations were found than dicentrics at a given dose. Translocation frequencies determined only in stable cells agree well with total translocation frequencies determined also in cells containing additional unstable chromosomal changes. The linear quadratic calibration curve generated for total stable translocations is based on approx. 17,000 cells. The suitability of this curve for biological dosimetry of human radiation exposure can now be evaluated in comparison with dose estimates based on a conventional dicentric dose-response curve.

Chromosome aberrations in human lymphocytes induced by fission neutrons

The dose-response relationships of dicentrics and excess acentrics were analysed after exposure of human lymphocytes to a mixed fission neutron-gamma-ray beam. From the analysis of exclusively first division cells a linear-quadratic relation was obtained for dicentrics with the ratio of linear and quadratic components, zeta, equal to 2.76 Gy. Over the range of doses studied (0.04-1.97 Gy) intratrack events therefore predominated. This also applied to acentrics which were linearly related to dose. At the lowest level of observed effect and dose, r.b.e. values with respect to 60Co gamma-rays of up to about 11 were derived for dicentrics and acentrics. With increasing neutron dose the r.b.e. decreased.