DNA investigations on fetal material from paternity cases

Forensic DNA expertise of incest in early period of pregnancy

Proving incest from tissue obtained by abortion early in pregnancy can be a challenge. Problems include the small quantity of embryonic tissue in the products of conception, and the mixing of DNA from mother and embryo. In many cases, this amorphous material cannot be grossly segregated into maternal and fetal components. Thus, morphological discrimination requires microscopy to select relevant tissue particles from which DNA can be typed. This combination of methods is reliable and efficient. In this article, we present two cases of incest discovered by examination of products of conception.

Laser capture microdissection in forensic research: a review

In forensic sciences, short tandem repeat (STR) analysis has become the prime tool for DNA-based identification of the donor(s) of biological stains and/or traces. Many traces, however, contain cells and, hence, DNA, from more than a single individual, giving rise to mixed genotypes and the subsequent difficulties in interpreting the results. An even more challenging situation occurs when cells of a victim are much more abundant than the cells of the perpetrator. Therefore, the forensic community seeks to improve cell-separation methods in order to generate single-donor cell populations from a mixed trace in order to facilitate DNA typing and identification. Laser capture microdissection (LCM) offers a valuable tool for precise separation of specific cells. This review summarises all possible forensic applications of LCM, gives an overview of the staining and detection options, including automated detection and retrieval of cells of interest, and reviews the DNA extraction protocols compatible with LCM of cells from forensic samples.

DNA analysis of abortion material assisted by histology screening

In cases of rape leading to fertilization, paternity testing can retrospectively identify the assailant. Abortion material commonly represents a mixture of maternal and fetal tissue and blood, which cannot be differentiated with the naked eye. Consequently, DNA typing of abortion material may be complicated, including band overlap if maternal tissue predominates. Therefore, histology screening of the abortion content for typical fetal tissue components, such as chorionic villi, followed by selected DNA typing of this sample is suggested. This combined approach is illustrated by a selected case demonstrating the reliability and concurrence of the histology and genetic results.

Sibling incest and formulation of paternity probability: case report

Paternity determination of a fetus whose mother was admitted to an institution for the welfare and health of handicapped persons was requested of us by a doctor and lawyer of the institution. The fetus was recovered by a legal artificial abortion based on the Act on Maternity Health and Welfare (Japan) with the permission of the custodian. Commercially available MCT118, HLADQA, PM, and 9 STRs were tested for DNA samples from the fetus, the mother, her younger brother, her father, her grandfather, and 4 staff members of the institution. Only the brother was not excluded and the paternity probability was estimated at 99.857% on the basis of newly formulated expressions for multiallelic loci on the assumption of sibling incest. We concluded then that the fetus was fathered by the brother. DNA fingerprinting with multilocus and single locus minisatellite probes which were performed to confirm the paternity also support the conclusion. Bandsharing frequencies between the family members, however, did not necessarily reflect their actual kinship, which findings suggest that multilocus DNA fingerprinting requires further accumulation of data for consanguineous cases such as incest. Universal formulation for calculating paternity probability for a sibling incest case on the basis of multiallelic monolocus polymorphisms is also presented.

Observation of null alleles apparently due to deletions

After examining 2 paternity cases in 17 classical, 4 RFLP and 5 PCR-VNTR systems, isolated pseudo-exclusions were observed in the polymorphism D2S44 (YNH24). In both cases the "exclusions" were due to apparent opposite homozygosity. The application of different restriction enzymes, PCR amplification and varying electrophoretic conditions each led to an equivalent result of a 1-band-pattern with a mismatch between both father/child pairs. From these results the authors conclude that a complete or almost complete loss of the alleles is the most probable explanation.

Prenatal paternity testing with DNA analyses

Two PCR amplified loci and 3 single locus DNA probes were applied in a paternity case in which a married woman became pregnant after being raped. DNA analysis were performed using samples from the woman, her husband and amniotic fluid cells taken during the 16th week of pregnancy. The combined probability of paternity for her husband was calculated as 0.999997107. The application of PCR analyses and single locus DNA probes were considered to be extremely informative in prenatal paternity testing.