Treatment of ventriculostomy-related infections

2017 Infectious Diseases Society of America's Clinical Practice Guidelines for Healthcare-Associated Ventriculitis and Meningitis

The Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA) Standards and Practice Guidelines Committee collaborated with partner organizations to convene a panel of 10 experts on healthcare-associated ventriculitis and meningitis. The panel represented pediatric and adult specialists in the field of infectious diseases and represented other organizations whose members care for patients with healthcare-associated ventriculitis and meningitis (American Academy of Neurology, American Association of Neurological Surgeons, and Neurocritical Care Society). The panel reviewed articles based on literature reviews, review articles and book chapters, evaluated the evidence and drafted recommendations. Questions were reviewed and approved by panel members. Subcategories were included for some questions based on specific populations of patients who may develop healthcare-associated ventriculitis and meningitis after the following procedures or situations: cerebrospinal fluid shunts, cerebrospinal fluid drains, implantation of intrathecal infusion pumps, implantation of deep brain stimulation hardware, and general neurosurgery and head trauma. Recommendations were followed by the strength of the recommendation and the quality of the evidence supporting the recommendation. Many recommendations, however, were based on expert opinion because rigorous clinical data are not available. These guidelines represent a practical and useful approach to assist practicing clinicians in the management of these challenging infections.

Role of external ventricular drainage in the management of intraventricular hemorrhage; its complications and management

Background:

External ventricular drainage (EVD) is the procedure of choice for the treatment of acute hydrocephalus and increased intracranial pressure in patients of subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) and intracerebral hemorrhage with hydrocephalus and its sequelae. We evaluated the use of EVD in patients of SAHs (spontaneous/posttraumatic with/without hydrocephalus), hypertensive intracerebral bleeds with interventricular extensions, along with evaluation of the frequency of occurrence of complications of the procedure, infectious and noninfectious, and their management.

Methods:

During the period of 2½ years, between September 2012 and February 2015, 130 patients were subjected to external drainage procedure and were prospectively enrolled in this study. Information was collected on each patient regarding age, sex, diagnosis, underlying illness, secondary complications, other coexisting infections, use of systemic steroids, antibiotic treatment (systemic and intraventricular), and whether any other neurosurgical procedures were performed within 2 weeks of EVD insertion or any time the duration of ventriculostomy.

Results:

The study population of 130 patients underwent a total of 193 ventriculostomies. Thirty-six patients had ventriculostomy infection (27.6%). Evaluation of the use of EVD was done by comparing preoperative and postoperative grading scores. Forty-nine patients survived and improved their score from Grade 3–5 to Grade 2–4. Twenty-nine patients were moderately disable, 16 were severely disable, and 5 were left in the vegetative state. Evaluation of outcome of patients revealed that there was an overall mortality of 61 (46.9%) patients both in the acute phase and later. 33 of the 39 patients having Glasgow Coma Score (GCS) 3–5 at the time of EVD insertion expired, as against 20 of the 51 patients in GCS 6–8. Patients in GCS 9–12 had an even better outcome, with 8 of the 35 patients in this group expiring.

Conclusions:

The use of EVD should be undertaken only in situation where it is absolutely necessary and ventriculostomy should be kept only for the duration required, and this should be monitored on a daily basis, given the exponential increase in infection after 5 days.

Comparison of ventricular drainage in poor grade patients after intracranial hemorrhage

OBJECTIVES

The selection of patients and treatment criteria for acute hydrocephalus and intracranial pressure (ICP) after intracranial hemorrhage remains unclear. In general neurosurgical practice, there is a tendency to use external ventricular drainage (EVD) for the patients. This study was undertaken to analyse the complications and efficiency of the different treatment modalities.

METHODS

The effects, complications and outcome of ventricular drainage on high ICP and hydrocephalus were analysed retrospectively in 109 patients with intracranial hemorrhage. All the patients were assessed using the Glasgow Coma Scale, computed tomography and ICP monitoring. We excluded patients over the GCS of 8. All patients underwent a procedure for ICP monitoring plus ventricular cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) drainage. Sixty-one patients were managed with one (single) EVD system; 12 patients needed two EVD systems consecutively, while 23 patients underwent an EVD procedure followed by permanent ventriculoperitoneal (VP) shunt insertion. Thirteen patients were treated only by VP shunt for ventricular drainage. The infection rate and outcome 9 months after hemorrhage were analysed.

RESULTS

The infection rates were 8.1% in the one-EVD group, 33.3% in the two-EVD group (one EVD versus two EVD, p<0.05), 8.6% in the EVD-VP group and 7.7% in the VP shunt group. The mortality rates were 73.7% in the one-EVD group, 83.8% in the two-EVD group, 47.8% (p<0.05) in the EVD-VP group and 53.8% (p<0.01) in the VP shunt group.

DISCUSSION

This study indicates that single and short-term use of EVD and/or early VP shunting are associated with a low risk of infection. Furthermore, early VP shunting may protect the brain from the irregular control of intracranial hypertension and may allow more time for resolution of CSF circulation and significantly lowers the mortality rates.

Risk factors for infections related to external ventricular drainage

BACKGROUND

External ventricular drainage (EVD) is frequently used in neurosurgery for cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) drainage in patients with raised intracranial pressure. The major complication of this procedure is an EVD-related infection, i.e., meningitis or ventriculitis. The purpose of the present retrospective single centre study is to assess the possible causes of these infections.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Two hundred and twenty-eight patients were included in the period from January 1993 until April 2005. Patient and disease demographics, as well as EVD data, and the occurrence of infection were reviewed, compared, and included in a risk-analysis study.

RESULTS

The population's mean age was 56 +/- 15 years and the sexes were equally distributed. Most frequently, the indication for EVD was hydrocephalus due to intraventricular haemorrhage (48.2%). An infection was documented in 23.2% of all patients. Duration of EVD drainage appeared to be a risk factor for infection (>11 days: OR 4.1; 95% CI 1.8-9.2, p = 0.001). CSF sampling frequency was also a significant risk-factor (no sampling: OR 0.2, 95% CI 0.2-0.5, p = 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

We found a relatively high percentage of EVD-related infections. After multivariate analysis there appears to be a relation with duration of drainage and frequent CSF sampling. As a result, a new EVD protocol is proposed in our institution that we believe will decrease the number of EVD-related infections to a minimum.

Efficacy of the Ghajar Guide revisited: a prospective study

OBJECT

The goal of this study was to compare the freehand technique of catheter placement using external landmarks with the technique of using the Ghajar Guide for this procedure. The placement of a ventricular catheter can be a lifesaving procedure, and it is commonly performed by all neurosurgeons. Various methods have been described to cannulate the ventricular system, including the modified Friedman tunnel technique in which a soft polymeric tube is inserted through a burr hole. Paramore, et al., have noted that two thirds of noninfectious complications have been related to incorrect positioning of the catheter.

METHODS

Forty-nine consecutive patients were randomized between either freehand or Ghajar Guide-assisted catheter placement. The target was the foramen of Monro, and the course was through the anterior horn of the lateral ventricle approximately 10 cm above the nasion, 3 cm from the midline, to a depth of 5.5 cm from the inner table of the skull. In all cases, the number of passes was recorded for successful cannulation, and pre- and postplacement computerized tomography scans were obtained. Calculations were performed to determine the bicaudate index and the distance from the catheter tip to the target point.

CONCLUSIONS

Successful cannulation was achieved using either technique; however, the catheters placed using the Ghajar Guide were closer to the target.

Prophylactic antibiotics with intracranial pressure monitors and external ventricular drains: a review of the evidence

BACKGROUND

The role of prophylactic antibiotics (PABs) in preventing infections associated with intracranial pressure (ICP) monitors and external ventricular drains (EVD) is not well defined.

METHODS

This study includes an analysis of published reports and a survey of current practices regarding the use of PABs with ICP monitors and EVDs. A computerized data search and a review of the abstracts from two major national neurosurgical meetings over the past decade yielded 85 related articles. Three independent investigators, blinded to the title, author(s), institution(s), results, and conclusions of the articles used predetermined inclusion criteria to select studies for meta-analysis. Thirty-six responses were returned from 98 questionnaires (37%) mailed to university neurosurgical programs.

RESULTS

Among the articles reviewed, only two studies met the predetermined inclusion criteria for the meta-analysis, and they were of insufficient size to produce statistically significant results. Among the 36 programs that responded to the survey, 26 (72%) used PABs, mainly cephalosporins (46%) and semisynthetic penicillins (38%), with ICP monitors and EVDs. Twenty-two (85%) used one drug, and 4 (15%) used two drugs. Twenty-two (61%) of the total group reported intra-institutional variation in practices among individual staff neurosurgeons. Nineteen (53%) expressed interest in a retrospective study, and 27 (75%) expressed interest in a prospective study on the role of PABs in minor neurosurgical procedures.

CONCLUSION

No consensus regarding the use of PABs with ICP monitors and EVDs is noted. Randomized controlled trials of sufficiently large size with appropriate blinding are needed to address this issue.

Relative risks of ventriculostomy infection and morbidity

Ventricular catheter placement is a common procedure for the management of increased intracranial pressure. Hypotheses regarding the etiology of infection of catheters center on two alternative assumptions: 1) contamination leading to infection occurs at the time of catheter insertion, implying that catheter duration has minimal effect on infection risk; and 2) infection of catheters derives from catheter contamination after insertion, suggesting that duration of catheter use may significantly affect infection risk. We have studied the relative complication rate of ventricular catheter insertions using a retrospective approach (n = 161 patients and 253 catheter insertion procedures). The overall infection rate was 4.1%, but the daily infection hazard increased exponentially with time, to a maximum daily rate of 10.3% by day 6 of catheter insertion. This increasing risk appears most consistent with the second hypothesis. The risk of non-infectious complications was 5.6%, including hemorrhagic occurrences and misplacement severe enough to require a new catheter insertion. The daily hazard of infection approximately equalled the non-infectious risk of routine catheter replacement by day 5. Additional prospective data on the daily risk of CSF infection and the appropriateness of antibiotic prophylaxis either at the time of ventricular catheter insertion or continued through the catheter's presence may be required to both definitively identify which hypothesis of infection risk is correct and whether antibiotics can significantly ameliorate this risk.

Continuous-pressure controlled, external ventricular drainage for treatment of acute hydrocephalus--evaluation of risk factors

Experience with a continuous-pressure controlled, external ventricular drainage system (EVD) in 100 patients (n = 49 female, n = 51 male; mean age, 56.3 yr) with acute hydrocephalus is reported. Cerebrospinal fluid circulation disturbances resulted from hemorrhages caused by subarachnoid hemorrhage (n = 45), parenchymal hemorrhages from angioma (n = 4), anticoagulants (n = 7), or hypertension or other reasons (n = 30); in addition, hydrocephalus developed from infections (n = 3), tumors (n = 2), infratentorial infarction (n = 5), or unknown reasons (n = 4); 52 patients had ventricular hemorrhages. No patient died of system-associated morbidity. Mean time of EVD treatment was 9.5 days, with 40 patients being treated for 10 to 29 days; routine refobacin (5 mg) flushing of the system was performed three times a day. Patients without cerebrospinal fluid leakage had a 2% rate of secondary infection compared with 13% in patients with cerebrospinal fluid leakage due to ventricular catheter placement (P < 0.05; overall infection rate, 5%). A clinical mortality rate of 29% during EVD treatment was observed in subarachnoid hemorrhage patients (Hunt and Hess Grades II, III, IV, and V; n = 9, 9, 18, and 9, respectively); recurrent hemorrhages during EVD treatment occurred in 19 patients (26 hemorrhages), and of these, 10 patients died. System occlusion was seen in 19 cases (12 of 45 patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage), requiring catheter and system renewal in 1 case; system extraction was seen in 3 cases, misplacement was seen in 11 cases, and disconnection was seen in 5 cases.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

CSF drainage in patients with posterior fossa tumours

The management of hydrocephalus secondary to a posterior fossa tumour is controversial. We audited recent practice with a retrospective analysis of 287 consecutive patients undergoing posterior fossa exploration for tumour. 85 shunts and 112 external ventricular drains (EVD) were placed. The overall CNS infection rate in the series was 6%. There was a significantly higher (p less than 0.01) infection rate in patients who had a drainage procedure, and a trend towards higher infection rates in patients with two drainage procedures. Early infection rates with EVDs and shunts were the same (7%). One third of patients with hydrocephalus had pre-operative drainage, a third had per-operative drainage but only a quarter required a permanent shunt. The majority of patients will not require a permanent shunt and where temporary CSF diversion is required EVD is reasonable.

Infected ventriculostomy: bacteriology and treatment

During a period of 6 years 256 patients underwent ventriculostomy as their first operative procedure. Twenty-seven patients (11%) developed CSF-infections, in almost 90% caused by Gram-positive cocci compatible with normal skin flora. The incidence of infection was distributed evenly in the postoperative period. All patients received intravenous and intrathecal antibiotic treatment simultaneously according to the sensitivity test. The treatment was highly effective, and without serious adverse effects.