Vagotomy or gastrectomy for elective treatment of benign gastric ulceration?

Ten-year follow-up of a prospective, randomized trial of selective proximal vagotomy with ulcer excision and partial gastrectomy with gastroduodenostomy for treating corporeal gastric ulcer

Between 1975 and 1980, 30 patients with type I corporeal gastric ulcer were randomly allocated to undergo selective proximal vagotomy with ulcer excision or partial gastrectomy with gastroduodenostomy. Sixteen patients underwent selective proximal vagotomy (1 was excluded from the follow-up since microscopic examination of the excised ulcer revealed an early gastric cancer) and 14 underwent partial gastrectomy. No significant differences in the clinical results were found 3 years after surgery. During a median follow-up of 10 years, ulcer recurred in 3 patients after selective proximal vagotomy and in 2 after partial gastrectomy. One patient in each group had recurrent ulcer without symptoms and received no treatment. Two selective proximal vagotomy patients and three partial gastrectomy patients had epigastric pain with or without ulcer. One patient with selective proximal vagotomy underwent a second operation because of epigastric pain and recurrent ulcer. Bowel habits remained unchanged in all but one patient in each group, and mild or moderate dumping was recorded for two patients in each group. Very good or good results (modified Visick scale) were recorded for 11 of 15 patients after selective proximal vagotomy and for 10 of 14 patients after partial gastrectomy. Except for one patient in each group who had moderate dumping, patients classified as Visick III or IV had no symptoms during treatment with antacids or H2-blockers, or had asymptomatic ulcers and needed no treatment. Selective proximal vagotomy reduced the median acid response to insulin hypoglycemia and to pentagastrin by 100% and 80%, respectively, for at least 3 to 5 years, and partial gastrectomy reduced the median acid response to pentagastrin by 97%. In our opinion, selective proximal vagotomy with ulcer excision is an alternative to partial gastrectomy for surgically treating type I gastric ulcer.

Parietal cell vagotomy as an emergency procedure for bleeding peptic ulcer

Twenty-three selected patients presenting with massive bleeding from peptic ulcers underwent emergency parietal cell vagotomy (PCV). Nineteen patients had a duodenal ulcer, two a prepyloric ulcer, and one a gastric ulcer. The patients were studied retrospectively with regard to postoperative mortality and morbidity, early rebleeding, and recurrent ulceration. Two patients (9%) died after operation, one of rebleeding. No others suffered rebleeding. One further patient had major respiratory complications and 14 others developed minor complications. The remaining 21 patients were followed for between 2 and 72 months. Two patients (10%) developed recurrent ulcers. The authors conclude that parietal cell vagotomy may be used as an emergency operation for bleeding peptic ulcer in selected cases with an acceptably low mortality, rebleeding rate, and incidence of recurrent ulceration.

Impact of endoscopy on mortality from occult cancer in radiographically benign gastric ulcers. A probability analysis model

Endoscopy is commonly used in the management of patients with radiographically benign gastric ulcers to detect occult malignancy. Clinical studies examining the cost-effectiveness of using endoscopy in such patients, however, have not been done. To address this issue using probability analysis, a probability tree was designed incorporating the possible clinical courses of patients with radiographically benign gastric ulcers managed with and without endoscopy, and probability estimates for each course were derived by compiling data from the literature. Probability and sensitivity analysis was used to compare the impact on overall mortality rate and cost-effectiveness of six commonly practiced methods of using endoscopy to manage patients with radiographically benign gastric ulcers: (1) all follow-up by upper gastrointestinal x-ray only; (2) endoscopy for nonhealing ulcers only; (3) endoscopy for all ulcers before medical therapy with all follow-up by upper gastrointestinal x-ray; (4) endoscopy for all ulcers after an initial trial of medical therapy; (5) endoscopy for all ulcers before therapy and for nonhealers; (6) endoscopy before therapy, and all follow-up by endoscopy. This analysis predicts that the greatest decrease in mortality rate occurs when endoscopy is used before medical therapy and for all follow-up, reducing the estimated number of deaths per 1000 patients with radiographically benign gastric ulcers from 36.7 with follow-up by upper gastrointestinal x-ray only to 27.2. However, initial endoscopy with all subsequent follow-up by upper gastrointestinal x-ray increased the overall death rate by only a small amount, to 28.0, and was consistently the most cost-effective method, requiring 116 endoscopies and approximately 60,000 diagnostic dollars per additional 5-yr survivor.