Transplantation of cultured sympathetic ganglionic neurons into parkinsonian rat brain: survival and function of graft

Cell based therapies in Parkinson's Disease

Parkinson’s disease (PD) is the second most common neurodegenerative disorder after Alzheimer’s disease. It is characterized by bradykinesia, hypokinesia/ akinesia, rigidity, tremor, and postural instability, caused by dopaminergic (DA) striatal denervation. The prevalence of PD increases from 50 years of age with steep rise after age 60 years. Current treatment of PD relies heavily on replacing lost dopamine either with its precursor L-dopa or dopamine agonists (ropinirole, pramipexole, bromocriptine, lisuride etc). Other pharmacological measures like catechol-O-methyltrasferase (COMT) inhibitors like entacopone, telcapone and monoamine oxidase B (MAO-B) inhibitors like selegiline and rasagiline are also useful, while L-dopa remains the gold standard in the treatment of PD. Emerging therapies are focusing on cell based therapeutics derived from various sources.

Cell replacement therapy for Parkinson's disease: how close are we to the clinic?

Cell replacement therapy (CRT) offers great promise as the future of regenerative medicine in Parkinson´s disease (PD). Three decades of experiments have accumulated a wealth of knowledge regarding the replacement of dying neurons by new and healthy dopaminergic neurons transplanted into the brains of animal models and affected patients. The first clinical trials provided the proof of principle for CRT in PD. In these experiments, intrastriatal transplantation of human embryonic mesencephalic tissue reinnervated the striatum, restored dopamine levels and showed motor improvements. Sequential controlled studies highlighted several problems that should be addressed prior to the wide application of CRT for PD patients. Moreover, owing to ethical and practical problems, embryonic stem cells require replacement by better-suited stem cells. Several obstacles remain to be surpassed, including identifying the best source of stem cells for A9 dopaminergic neuron generation, eliminating the risk of tumor formation and the development of graft-induced dyskinesias, and standardizing dopaminergic cell production in order to enable clinical application. In this article, we present an update on CRT for PD, reviewing the research milestones, various stem cells used and tailored differentiation methods, and analyze the information gained from the clinical trials.

Tracking extranigral degeneration in animal models of Parkinson's disease: quest for effective therapeutic strategies

Sporadic Parkinson's disease (PD) is now interpreted as a complex nervous system disorder in which the projection neurons are predominantly damaged. Such an interpretation is based on mapping of Lewy body and Lewy neurite pathology. Symptoms of the human disease are much widespread, which span from pre-clinical non-motor symptoms and clinical motor symptoms to cognitive discrepancies often seen in advanced stages. Existing symptomatic treatments further complicate with overt drug-irresponsive symptoms. PD is better understood by assimilation of extranigral degenerative pathways with nigrostriatal degenerative mechanisms. The term 'extranigral' appeared first in the 1990s to more rigorously define the nigral pathology by process of elimination. However, as clinicians progressively identified PD symptoms unresponsive to the gold standard drug l-DOPA, definitions of PD symptoms were redefined. Non-motor symptoms prodromal to motor symptoms just as pre-clinical to clinical, and conjointly emerged the concept of nigral versus extranigral degeneration in PD. While nigrostriatal degeneration is responsible for the neurobiological substrates of extrapyramydal motor features, extranigral degeneration corroborates a vast majority of other changes in discrete central, peripheral, and enteric nervous system nuclei, which together account for global symptoms of the human disease. As an extranigral site, spinal cord degeneration has also been implicated in PD progression. Interconnected to the upper CNS structures with descending and ascending pathways, spinal neurons participate in movement and sensory circuits, controlling movement and reflexes. Several clinical and in vivo studies have demonstrated signs of parkinsonism-related degenerative processes in spinal cord, which led to recent consideration of spinal cord as an area of potential therapeutic target. In a nutshell, this review explores how the existing animal models can actually reflect the human disease in order to facilitate PD research. Evolution of extranigral degeneration studies has been succinctly revisited, followed by a survey on animal models in light of recent findings in clinical PD. Together, it may help to develop effective therapeutic strategies for PD.

Cell-based therapies for Parkinson's disease: past, present, and future

Parkinson's disease (PD) researchers have pioneered the use of cell-based therapies (CBTs) in the central nervous system. CBTs for PD were originally envisioned as a way to replace the dopaminergic nigral neurons lost with the disease. Several sources of catecholaminergic cells, including autografts of adrenal medulla and allografts or xenografts of mesencephalic fetal tissue, were successfully assessed in animal models, but their clinical translation has yielded poor results and much controversy. Recent breakthroughs on cell biology are helping to develop novel cell lines that could be used for regenerative medicine. Their future successful clinical application depends on identifying and solving the problems encountered in previous CBTs trials. In this review, we critically analyze past CBTs' clinical translation, the impact of the host in graft survival, and the role of preclinical studies and emerging new cell lines. We propose that the prediction of clinical results from preclinical studies requires experimental designs that allow blind data acquisition and statistical analysis, assessment of the therapy in models that parallel clinical conditions, looking for sources of complications or side effects, and limiting optimism bias when reporting outcomes.

Transplantation of autologous sympathetic neurons as a potential strategy to restore metabolic functions of the damaged nigrostriatal dopamine nerve terminals in Parkinson's disease

Grafting of catecholamine-producing cells can be a possible therapeutic strategy for attenuating motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease (PD). The potential of autologous sympathetic neurons has been investigated as a donor for cell therapy of PD. The clinical trials of autotransplantation of sympathetic ganglion cells in PD have revealed that the grafts increase the duration of L-DOPA (L-dihydroxy phenyl alanine)-induced beneficial effects, and that the graft-mediated effect is detectable during a follow-up period of at least 1 year postgrafting. In an in vitro analysis of the ability of human sympathetic neurons to release catecholamines, although DA was not detectable under basal conditions, DA levels were significantly increased upon exposure to exogenous L-DOPA. Furthermore, animal experiments with xenografting of human sympathetic ganglionic neurons in the DA-denervated striatum of rats demonstrated that a significant increase in striatal DA levels is noted after systemic L-DOPA treatment, and that the DA levels remain high for longer periods of time in the grafted rats than in control animals with sham surgery. The L-DOPA-induced rise of striatal DA levels was significantly attenuated when given reserpine pretreatment. This suggests that DA derived from exogenously administered L-DOPA is subjected to, at least in part, vesicular storage in grafted sympathetic neurons. Histological examinations indeed showed that the grafts express aromatic-L-amino acid decarboxylase and vesicular monoamine transporter-2, both of which are important molecules for the synthesis and the storage of DA, respectively. Taken together, grafted sympathetic neurons can provide a site for both the conversion of exogenous L-DOPA to DA and the storage of the synthesized DA in the DA-denervated striatum. This might be an explanation for a mechanism by which sympathetic neuron autografts can increase the duration of L-DOPA effects in PD patients. This review article summarizes the clinical effect of transplantation of autologous sympathetic neurons in PD and discusses the underlying mechanism for the effect based on experimental evidence previously obtained.

Cells of the sympathoadrenal lineage: Biological properties as donor tissue for cell-replacement therapies for Parkinson's disease

Sympathoadrenal (SA) cell lineage encompasses neural crest derivatives such as sympathetic neurons, small intensely fluorescent (SIF) cells of sympathetic ganglia and adrenal medulla, and chromaffin cells of adrenal medulla and extra-adrenal paraganglia. SA autografts have been used for transplantation in Parkinson's disease (PD) for three reasons: (i) as autologous donor tissue avoids graft rejection and the need for immunosuppressant therapy, (ii) SA cells express dopaminotrophic factors such as GNDF and TGFbetas, and (iii) although most of SA cells release noradrenaline, some of them are able to produce and release dopamine. Adrenal chromaffin cells were the first SA transplanted cells in both animal models of PD and PD patients. However, these autografts have met limited success because long-term cell survival is very poor, and this approach is no longer pursued clinically. Sympathetic neurons from the superior cervical ganglion have been also grafted in PD animal models and PD patients. Poor survival into brain parenchyma of grafted tissue is a serious disadvantage for its clinical application. However, cultured sympathetic cell grafts present a better survival rate, and they reduce the need for levodopa medication in PD patients by facilitating the conversion of exogenous levodopa. SA extra-adrenal chromaffin cells are located on paraganglia (i.e., the Zuckerkandl's organ), and have been used for grafting in a rodent model of PD. Preliminary results indicate that long-term survival of these cells is better than for other SA cells, exerting a more prolonged restorative neurotrophic action on denervated host striatum. The ability of SA extra-adrenal cells to respond to hypoxia, differently to SA sympathetic neurons or adrenal medulla cells, could explain their good survival rate after brain transplantation.

The ability of grafted human sympathetic neurons to synthesize and store dopamine: a potential mechanism for the clinical effect of sympathetic neuron autografts in patients with Parkinson's disease

We have investigated the potential of autologous sympathetic neurons as a donor for cell therapy of Parkinson's disease (PD). Our recent study demonstrated that sympathetic neuron autografts increase the duration of levodopa-induced "on" periods with consequent reduction in the percent time spent in "off" phase. We also found that human sympathetic neurons grown in culture have the ability to convert exogenous levodopa to dopamine and to store the synthesized dopamine. This may explain the clinically observed prolongation in the duration of levodopa effects. To further analyze the mechanism for the graft-mediated effect, the present study investigated the metabolic function of human sympathetic ganglionic neurons xenografted into the dopamine (DA)-denervated striatum of rats by monitoring striatal levels of DA and its primary metabolite, 3,4-dihydroxyphenylacetic acid (DOPAC), after systemic administration of levodopa. We also explored whether the graft-mediated effect above may last in four PD patients who had been given the grafts and followed for 12-36 months postgrafting. Clinical evaluations showed that an increase in the duration of levodopa-induced "on" phase is detected during a follow-up period of 12-36 months postgrafting in all the four patients tested. Accordingly, the percent time spent in "off" phase exhibited a 30-40% reduction as compared to the pregrafting values. The animal experiment showed that a significant increase in striatal DA levels is noted after systemic levodopa treatment, and that the DA levels remain high for longer periods of time in the grafted rats than in control animals. When given reserpine pretreatment, the levodopa-induced rise of striatal DA levels was significantly attenuated with concomitant increase in DOPAC levels. Histological examinations demonstrated that the grafts contain some tyrosine hydroxylase (TH)-positive cells. These cells were also found to express aromatic-l-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) and vesicular monoamine transporter-2 (VMAT), both of which are important molecules for the synthesis and the storage of DA, respectively. These results indicate that grafted sympathetic neurons can provide a site for both the conversion of exogenous levodopa to DA and the storage of the synthesized DA in the DA-denervated striatum, explaining a mechanism by which sympathetic neuron autografts can increase the duration of levodopa-induced "on" phase in PD patients.

Dopaminergic cells of the carotid body: physiological significance and possible therapeutic applications in Parkinson's disease

Parkinson's disease is a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by the progressive loss of dopaminergic neurons in the substantia nigra projecting to the striatum. One therapeutic approach to this disease has been the intrastriatal transplantation of dopamine-secreting cells. We have investigated the suitability of glomus cells of the carotid body for dopamine-cell replacement in animal models of Parkinson's disease. Carotid body glomus cells are physiologic arterial oxygen sensors that release large amounts of dopamine in response to hypoxia. We have used hemi-Parkinsonian rats, induced by injection of 6-hydroxydopamine into the substantia nigra, and 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine treated monkeys with chronic Parkinsonism. In both cases we made transplants of carotid body cell aggregates into the putamen. Functional recovery of the grafted animals was observed after the surgery and was stable for several months. Although the study was more detailed in the rat, in the two animal models the amelioration of the motor deficits was paralleled by striatal dopaminergic reinnervation and survival of grafted glomus cells. Our results suggest that intrastriatal autotransplants of carotid body tissue could be a feasible technique to treat some cases of Parkinson's disease in humans.

Enhancement of the response to levodopa therapy after intrastriatal transplantation of autologous sympathetic neurons in patients with Parkinson disease

OBJECT

There is growing evidence to indicate that tissue transplantation can potentially be a restorative neurosurgical treatment for patients with Parkinson disease (PD). In this study the authors investigated the clinical effect of unilateral intrastriatal grafting of autologous sympathetic neurons in patients with PD.

METHODS

Four patients with PD who had been observed for 1 year after graft placement of autologous sympathetic neurons were selected for an analysis of the effect of that procedure. Sympathetic ganglion tissue was endoscopically excised from the thoracic sympathetic trunk and grafted into the unilateral caudate head and putamen of the PD patients. No changes were made in the patients' preoperative regimens of antiparkinsonian medications, and clinical evaluations were made principally according to those established by the Core Assessment Program for Intracerebral Transplantation Committee. Whereas the sympathetic neuron grafts failed to affect clinical scores reflecting the patients' motor performance, which was evaluated during either the "on" or "off' phases, the grafts significantly increased the duration of the levodopa-induced on period with consequent reduction in the percentage of time spent in the off phase. This beneficial effect may be explained by the results of the present in vitro experiment, which show that human sympathetic neurons have the ability to convert exogenous levodopa to dopamine and to store this synthesized dopamine.

CONCLUSIONS

Sympathetic neuron autografts were found to improve performance status in patients with PD by reducing the time spent in the off phase. This clearly indicates that sympathetic ganglion tissue, the use of which involves few ethical issues, can be an efficacious donor source in cell transplantation therapy for PD. Further studies are needed to determine whether the grafts may provide long-lasting clinical benefits.

Xenografting human T2 sympathetic ganglion from hyperhidrotic patients provides short-term restoration of catecholaminergic functions in hemiparkinsonian athymic rats

Previous studies have suggested that allografting peripheral sympathetic ganglia, such as superior cervical ganglia, partially relieves clinical or behavioral deficits in parkinsonian patients and animals. However, removal of these ganglia can cause Homer's syndrome, which limits the utilization of this approach. Hyperhidrosis, a disease of excessive sweating, is commonly seen in young Orientals. Treatment of hyperhidrosis often involves surgical removal of the second thoracic sympathetic ganglia (T2G), which contain catecholaminergic neurons. The purpose of our study was to investigate behavioral responses and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH) immunoreactivity in hemiparkinsonian rats at different time points after transplantation of human T2G from hyperhidrotic patients. Athymic Fisher 344 rats were injected unilaterally with 6-hydroxydopamine into the medial forebrain bundle to destroy the nigrostriatal dopaminergic (DA) pathway. The effectiveness of lesions was tested by measuring methamphetamine (MA)-induced rotations. These unilaterally lesioned rats were later transplanted with T2G or T2 fiber tract (T2F) obtained from adult hyperhidrotic patients. Animals grafted with T2G showed a reduction in MA-induced rotation by 2 weeks; however, rotation returned to the pregrafting levels by 3 months. Animals receiving T2F grafts did not show any reduction of rotation over a 3-month period. Animals were later sacrificed for TH immunostaining at different time points. Tyrosine hydroxylase-positive [TH(+)] cell bodies and fibers were found in the lesioned striatum 2-4 weeks after T2G grafting, suggesting the survival of transplants. Two to 3 months after grafting, TH(+) fibers were still found in almost all the recipients. However, TH(+) cell bodies were found in only three of seven rats studied. Animals receiving T2F grafting did not show any TH immunoreactivity in the lesioned striatum over the 3-month period. These data indicate that T2G transplants from adult hyperhidrotic patients can survive and provide transient normalization of the motor behavior in the hemiparkinsonian athymic rats. Because of the short-term improvement in behavior after grafting, the use of T2G in human trials should be cautious at the present time. Further laboratory research is required.

Recovery of chronic parkinsonian monkeys by autotransplants of carotid body cell aggregates into putamen

We have studied the effect of unilateral autografts of carotid body cell aggregates into the putamen of MPTP-treated monkeys with chronic parkinsonism. Two to four weeks after transplantation, the monkeys initiated a progressive recovery of mobility with reduction of tremor and bradykinesia and restoration of fine motor abilities on the contralateral side. Apomorphine injections induced rotations toward the side of the transplant. Functional recovery was accompanied by the survival of tyrosine hydroxylase-positive (TH-positive) grafted glomus cells. A high density of TH-immunoreactive fibers was seen reinnervating broad regions of the ipsilateral putamen and caudate nucleus. The nongrafted, contralateral striatum remained deafferented. Intrastriatal autografting of carotid body tissue is a feasible technique with beneficial effects on parkinsonian monkeys; thus, this therapeutic approach could also be applied to treat patients with Parkinson's disease.