Evidence for indirect involvement of thymidine kinase in excision repair processes in mouse cell lines

FISH comets show that the salvage enzyme TK1 contributes to gene-specific DNA repair

Thymidine kinase 1 (TK1) is a salvage enzyme that phosphorylates thymidine, imported from surrounding fluids, to create dTMP, which is further phosphorylated to the DNA precursor dTTP. TK1 deficiency has for a long time been known to cause increased cellular sensitivity to DNA damage. We have examined preferential strand break repair of DNA domains in TK1(+) and TK1(-) clones of the Raji cell line, by the Comet-FISH technique, in bulk DNA and in the actively transcribed tumor suppressor (TP53) and human telomerase reverse transcriptase (hTERT) gene regions, over 1 h after 5Gy γ-irradiation. Results showed that repair of the TP53 and hTERT gene regions was more efficient in TK1(+) compared to TK1(-) cells, a trend also reflected to a lesser degree in genomic DNA repair between the cell-lines. The targeted gene-specific repair in TK(+) cells occurred rapidly, mainly over the first 15 min repair-period. Therefore, TK1 is needed for preferential repair of actively transcribed regions, through a previously unsuspected mechanism. In principle, TK1 could exert its protective effects through supply of a supplementary dTTP pool for accurate repair of damaged genes; but Raji TK1(+) cells in thymidine free media still show preferential repair of transcribed regions. TK1 therefore does not exert its protective effects through dTTP pools, but through another unidentified mechanism, which affects sensitivity to and mutagenicity by DNA damaging agents.

Regulation and functional contribution of thymidine kinase 1 in repair of DNA damage

Cellular supply of dNTPs is essential in the DNA replication and repair processes. Here we investigated the regulation of thymidine kinase 1 (TK1) in response to DNA damage and found that genotoxic insults in tumor cells cause up-regulation and nuclear localization of TK1. During recovery from DNA damage, TK1 accumulates in p53-null cells due to a lack of mitotic proteolysis as these cells are arrested in the G(2) phase by checkpoint activation. We show that in p53-proficient cells, p21 expression in response to DNA damage prohibits G(1)/S progression, resulting in a smaller G(2) fraction and less TK1 accumulation. Thus, the p53 status of tumor cells affects the level of TK1 after DNA damage through differential cell cycle control. Furthermore, it was shown that in HCT-116 p53(-/-) cells, TK1 is dispensable for cell proliferation but crucial for dTTP supply during recovery from DNA damage, leading to better survival. Depletion of TK1 decreases the efficiency of DNA repair during recovery from DNA damage and generates more cell death. Altogether, our data suggest that more dTTP synthesis via TK1 take place after genotoxic insults in tumor cells, improving DNA repair during G(2) arrest.

The effect of folate deficiency on the cytotoxic and mutagenic responses to ethyl methanesulfonate in human lymphoblastoid cell lines that differ in p53 status

Folic acid deficiency acts synergistically with alkylating agents to increase genetic damage at the HPRT locus in Chinese hamster ovary cells in vitro and in rat splenocytes in vivo. The present studies extend these observations to human cells and, in addition, investigate the role of p53 activity on mutation induction. The human lymphoblastoid cell lines TK6 and WTK1 are derived from the same parental cell line (WI-L2), but WTK1 expresses mutant p53. Treatment of folate-replete or deficient WTK1 and TK6 cells with increasing concentrations (0-50microg/ml) of ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS) resulted in significantly different HPRT mutation dose-response relationships (P<0.01), indicating that folate deficiency increased the EMS-induced mutant frequency in both cell lines, but with a greater effect in TK6 cells. Molecular analyses of 152 mutations showed that the predominant mutation (65%) in both cell types grown in the presence or absence of folic acid was a G>A transition on the non-transcribed strand. These transitions were mainly at non-CpG sites, particularly when these bases were flanked 3' by a purine or on both sides by G:C base pairs. A smaller number of G>A transitions occurred on the transcribed strand (C>T=14%), resulting in 79% total G:C>A:T transitions. There were more genomic deletions in folate-deficient (15%) as compared to replete cells (4%) of both cell types. Mutations that altered RNA splicing were common in both cell types and under both folate conditions, representing 33% of the total mutations. These studies indicate that cells expressing p53 activity exhibit a higher rate of mutation induction but are more sensitive to the toxic effects of alkylating agents than those lacking p53 activity. Folate deficiency tends to reduce toxicity but increase mutation induction after EMS treatment. The p53 gene product did not have a major influence on the molecular spectrum after treatment with EMS, while folate deficiency increased the frequency of deletions in both cell types.

Fewer chromosome aberrations and earlier apoptosis induced by DNA synthesis inhibitors, a topoisomerase II inhibitor or alkylating agents in human cells with normal compared with mutant p53

The human lymphoblastoid cell lines TK6 (normal p53) and WI-L2-NS or WTK1 (mutant p53) differ in sensitivity to killing and induction of gene mutations and chromosome aberrations by ionizing radiation. This may be related to decreased apoptosis in the cells with mutated p53, such that more damaged cells survive. We compared the response of the two cell types to various chemicals. First, to ensure that the thymidine kinase deficiency does not increase the sensitivity of TK6 tk+/- cells to mutagens, we demonstrated that they were not hypersensitive to aberration induction by altered DNA precursor pools or DNA synthesis inhibition, by aphidicolin (APC), methotrexate, hydroxyurea (HU), cytosine arabinoside and thymidine. TK6 cells were then compared with WI-L2-NS or WTK1 cells. With APC, HU, methyl methanesulfonate (MMS), ethyl nitrosourea (ENU) and etoposide (etop), TK6 cells had more apoptosis in the first two days after treatment. Fewer aberrations were seen in normal p53 TK6 cells than the mutant p53 WI-L2-NS cells, ranging from very little difference between the two cell types with MMS to very large differences with ENU and etop. For MMS and ENU we followed cultures for several days, and found that WI-L2-NS cells underwent delayed apoptosis 3 to 5 days after treatment, in parallel with published observations with ionizing radiation. WI-L2-NS cells also had a delayed increase in aberrations (up to 5 days post-treatment) when no aberrations remained in TK6 cells. Colony forming efficiency was measured for APC, MMS and ENU, and was greater in the p53 mutant cells. Our results show that normal p53 function is required for rapid and efficient apoptosis in these lymphoblastoid cells with DNA synthesis inhibitors, alkylating agents and a topoisomerase II inhibitor, and support the hypothesis that induced levels of aberrations are higher in p53 mutant cells because of a failure to remove damaged cells by apoptosis.

Thymidine kinase deficient cells with decreased TTP pools are hypersensitive to DNA alkylating agents

The effect of mutational loss of thymidine kinase (TK) on the sensitivity to alkylating agents was investigated in promyelocytic, HL-60, and T-lymphoblastoid, Molt-3, human leukemia cell lines. Although both cell lines exhibited approx. 1% residual TK activity, only HL-60 TK deficient cells had a decreased intracellular TTP pool, i.e., 20% of that of the wild-type. When treated with N-methyl-N'-nitronitrosoguanidine or ethyl methanesulfonate, HL-60 TK deficient cells showed significantly increased killing and mutation frequencies at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (HGPRT) locus relative than did wild-type. Pretreatment of cells with O6-benzylguanine, an inhibitor of O6-alkylguanine-DNA alkyltransferase, partially abolished those differences. Molt-3 wild-type and TK deficient cells had similar cell survivals and HGPRT mutation frequencies following treatment with alkylating agents. These results indicate that TK deficiency, only when a concomitant decrease of TTP pool is detected, plays a pivotal role in the sensitivity to the cytotoxic and mutagenic effects of alkylating agents.

Effects of thymidine kinase and methyltransferase deficiency on mutagenesis in a human lymphoblastoid cell line

In this study the effect of thymidine kinase (TK) deficiency on mutagen sensitivity was examined in the human lymphoblastoid cell line Raji. Wild-type and TK-deficient Raji cells were treated with a range of concentrations of ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS) and a range of doses of ultraviolet (UV) light, then examined for mutagen sensitivity as measured by cell survival and mutation to HGPRT deficiency. Dose-dependent responses were observed and TK-deficient cells exhibited decreased survivals and increased mutant frequencies relative to wild-type cells. TK-deficient Raji cells are also deficient in O6-methylguanine-DNA-methyltransferase. This may partially account for their sensitivity to EMS but does not account for the results obtained with UV. It is therefore likely that an additional factor, such as alterations in supply of deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates, may affect the mutagen sensitivity of Raji cells.

International Commission for Protection Against Environmental Mutagens and Carcinogens. Deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate levels: a critical factor in the maintenance of genetic stability

DNA precursor pool imbalances can elicit a variety of genetic effects and modulate the genotoxicity of certain DNA-damaging agents. These and other observations indicate that the control of DNA precursor concentrations is essential for the maintenance of genetic stability, and suggest that factors which offset this control may contribute to environmental mutagenesis and carcinogenesis. In this article, we review the biochemical and genetic mechanisms responsible for regulating the production and relative amounts of intracellular DNA precursors, describe the many outcomes of perturbations in DNA precursor levels, and discuss implications of such imbalances for sensitivity to DNA-damaging agents, population monitoring, and human diseases.

Why do most primary bladder neoplasms first appear around the ureteric orifices?

The majority of primary bladder neoplasms are known to arise within the mucosa around the ureteric orifices and bladder base. This may be due to the mucosa in this area being more susceptible to carcinogens than other areas of the bladder. Deficiency in the nucleotide salvage pathway enzyme thymidine kinase (TK), and especially its TK1 isozyme, has been shown to predispose cell lines to increased mutagenesis. Total TK and TK1 activities were measured in mucosal samples taken adjacent to the ureteric orifices and dome in 32 normal bladders and both total TK and TK1 were shown to be significantly decreased in the mucosa adjacent to the ureteric orifices. This may explain why primary bladder neoplasms occur more commonly in this site.

DNA damage in mammalian cell lines with different antioxidant levels and DNA repair capacities

A wide range of DNA damage is known to be caused by reactive oxygen species (ROS). Defence against the effects of such damage include damage prevention (e.g. antioxidant activity) and the removal of damaged moieties from DNA (DNA repair). Radiation (X-ray) sensitive murine lymphoma (LY) cells were seen to be more susceptible to ROS-induced damage than were radiation resistant cells. This difference was unlikely to be due to the marginally decreased DNA excision repair capacity of the sensitive cells. Radiation sensitive cells did, however, have lower endogenous antioxidant enzyme levels. Thus, the importance of assessing all levels of a cell's response to ROS, in determining the major factors leading to increased mutagen sensitivity, is emphasised.

Nucleotide pools and mutagenic effects of alkylating agents in wild-type and APRT-deficient Friend erythroleukaemia cells

Wild-type Friend mouse erythroleukaemia cells (clone 707) were compared with adenine phosphoribosyltransferase (APRT)-deficient mutant subclones (707DAP8 and 707DAP10) for sensitivity to cell killing and mutagenesis by ethyl methanesulphonate (EMS) and methyl methanesulphonate (MMS). Cells were exposed to 0-300 micrograms/ml EMS and to 0-20 micrograms/ml MMS for a period of 16 h. A slight difference was found between wild-type cells and the two APRT-deficient subclones in terms of sensitivity to cell killing by both mutagens. The APRT-deficient subclones were, however, significantly more sensitive than wild-type cells to mutagenesis to 5-bromo-2-deoxyuridine resistance and 6-thioguanine resistance by EMS and MMS. The APRT-deficient subclones were found to have significantly decreased levels of dATP and dTTP nucleotides and decreased levels of all four ribonucleoside triphosphates (ATP, GTP, CTP and UTP) relative to wild-type cells. Wild-type Friend cells were found to have insignificant levels O6-methylguanine-DNA methyl transferase and it is suggested that the increased mutagen sensitivity of APRT-deficient cells may be due to imbalance of deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate pools during DNA excision-repair processes, or more probably due to deficiency of ATP for ATP-dependent DNA excision-repair enzymes.

Role of the viral and cellular encoded thymidine kinase in the repair of UV-irradiated herpes simplex virus

A strain of herpes simplex type 1 (HSV-1:KOS) encoding a functional thymidine kinase (tk+) gene and a thymidine kinase deficient (tk-) mutant strain (HSV-1:PTK3B) were used as probes to examine the repair of UV-damaged viral DNA in one tk- (143) and two tk+ (R970-5 and AC4) human cell lines. UV survival for each HSV-1 strain was similar for infection of both tk- and tk+ cells suggesting that the repair of viral DNA was not dependent on the expression of a functional cellular tk gene. In contrast, UV survival of HSV-1:PTK3B was substantially reduced compared to HSV-1:KOS when infecting all 3 human cell lines, as well as Vero monkey kidney cells and LPM1A mouse cells. These results suggest that the repair of UV-irradiated HSV-1 in lytically infected mammalian cells depends, in part at least, on the expression of the viral encoded tk.

Thymidine kinase deficient human cells have increased UV sensitivity in their capacity to support herpes simplex virus but normal UV sensitivity for colony formation

A thymidine kinase deficient (tk-) and two thymidine kinase proficient (tk+) human cell lines were compared for UV sensitivity using colony-forming ability as well as their capacity to support the plaque formation of herpes simplex type 1 (HSV-1). The tk- line (143 cells) was a derivative of one of the tk+ lines (R970-5), whereas the other tk+ line (AC4 cells) was a derivative of the 143 cells obtained by transfection with purified sheared HSV-2 DNA encoding the viral tk gene. 143, R970-5 and AC4 cells showed a similar UV sensitivity for colony-forming ability. In contrast, the capacity to support HSV-1 plaque formation immediately (within 1 h) after UV-irradiation was reduced to a greater extent in the 143 cells compared to the R970-5 and AC4 cells. Capacity curves for plaque formation of the HSV-1: KOS wild-type (tk+) strain were similar to those for the HSV-1: PTK3B mutant (tk-) strain in the 3 cell strains, indicating that the viral tk gene does not influence the ability of HSV-1 to form plaques in UV-irradiated compared to unirradiated human cells. Cellular capacity for HSV-1 plaque formation was found to recover in both tk- and tk+ cells for cultures infected 24 h after UV-irradiation. These results suggest that repair of UV-damaged DNA takes place to a similar extent in both tk- and tk+ human cells, but the kinetics of repair are initially slower in tk- compared to tk+ human cells.

Differential response of excision proficient and deficient L5178Y cells to UVC irradiation and benzamide

L5178Y-R and L5178Y-S cells differ in sensitivity to UVC radiation (D0 values: 2.8 and 9.0 J m-2 respectively, exposure in Fischer's medium). The UVC sensitivity is related to the excision repair ability. Benzamide (Bz), an inhibitor of adenosine diphosphoribosyl transferase (ADPRT), does not modify the lethal effect of UVC radiation in L5178Y-R cells, whereas it sensitizes L5178Y-S cells. The content of NAD+ after irradiation decreases only in the latter cells and this decrease can be prevented by 2 mM Bz treatment. In agreement with the survival data, in L5178Y-R cells neither the proportion of abnormal cells nor the frequency of chromatid aberration are affected by 2 mM Bz treatment, in contrast with L5178Y-S cells. Bz slightly reverses inhibition of 3H-thymidine incorporation only in L5178Y-S cells, but it does not affect the proportions of cells in the different phases of the cell cycle in either cell strain after UVC exposure. These data could be taken as an indirect indication of the involvement of ADPRT in DNA repair in UVC-irradiated L5178Y-S cells. However, the increase in the number of DNA strand breaks in UVC-exposed, Bz-treated cells compared with UVC-exposed untreated cells is the same in both L5178Y strains.

The molecular basis of mutations induced by deoxyribonucleoside triphosphate pool imbalances in mammalian cells

Alterations of the balanced supply of the precursors of DNA synthesis, the deoxyribonucleoside triphosphates, have dramatic genetic consequences for mammalian cells including the induction of mutations, the sensitization to DNA damaging agents, and the production of gross chromosomal abnormalities. The use of recombinant DNA techniques has allowed the analysis of some of these effects and has revealed further mechanisms by which mammalian cells control the accuracy of DNA replication.

Sensitivity to cell killing and the induction of cytogenetic damage following gamma irradiation in wild-type and thymidine kinase-deficient Friend mouse erythroleukaemia cells

Wild-type Friend erythroleukaemia (clone 707) cells and 2 thymidine kinase-deficient subclones, 707BUE and 707BUF, having thymidine kinase activities of 1.4% and 0.7% that of clone 707, were compared for sensitivity to killing and the induction of cytogenetic damage following gamma irradiation. Three doses of gamma irradiation were used (150, 300 and 450 cGy), and cells were harvested for metaphase spreads after 4, 8, 12, 15, 29 and 43 h. G2 delay was evident at 4 h following gamma irradiation in the 3 cell clones examined, and recovery of mitosis was observed to be dose-dependent. G2 delay was found to be most prolonged in subclone 707BUE and most prompt in clone 707. Increased sensitivity to the induction of cytogenetic aberrations at all three doses was apparent in the 2 thymidine kinase-deficient subclones (as compared to wild-type cells) at 15, 29 and 43 h. Th thymidine kinase-deficient subclones also showed increased sensitivity to gamma radiation-induced cell killing. Furthermore, subclone 707BUE consistently exhibited greater resistance to gamma irradiation than did the subclone with lower thymidine kinase activity, 707BUF. The importance of thymidine kinase levels and extended G2 delay for DNA repair processes is discussed.

Mutagenesis and deoxyribonucleotide pool imbalance

Numerous studies have demonstrated that DNA-precursor pool imbalances are mutagenic and can modulate the lethality and mutagenicity of DNA-damaging agents. In addition, physical and chemical mutagens can induce alterations in DNA-precursor levels. Such findings suggest that regulation of intracellular concentrations of DNA precursors may be an important factor in environmental mutagenesis. In this article, results linking mutation and disturbances in DNA-precursor pools are reviewed.

Aberrant DNA repair and enhanced mutagenesis following mutagen treatment of Chinese hamster Ade-C cells in a state of purine deprivation

Ade-C is a Chinese hamster ovary cell line auxotrophic for purines because of a mutation in the de novo synthetic pathway. We now show that, in the absence of exogenous hypoxanthine, replicative DNA synthesis is rapidly shut down. Various aspects of DNA repair have been studied in purine-starved cells. Incision, the first step of excision repair of UV damage, appears normal, as do the later steps, repair synthesis (demonstrated following chemical damage as well as UV-irradiation) and ligation. However, removal of UV-induced pyrimidine dimers is not detected, and it seems that the repair that occurs is aberrant. This behaviour is associated with an increase in cell killing by UV light, and a several-fold increase in the frequency of mutations induced by UV.

Synergism between U.V. and thymidine treatments in the induction of cytogenetic damage in wild-type Friend erythroleukaemia cells

The cytogenetic aberration-inducing effect of excess thymidine and U.V. light in Friend erythroleukaemia (clone 707) cells was investigated. Three doses of U.V. were utilised, namely 2.4, 4.8 and 7.2 J/m2. Thymidine, at 1 X 10(-5) M, was present for 48 h prior to U.V. treatment and for 15 h following it. Although no significant increase in metaphase aberrations was observed following thymidine treatment alone, relative to the spontaneous frequency, clone 707 exhibited increased sensitivity to U.V.-induced cytogenetic damage, when grown in the presence of 1 X 10(-5) M thymidine. The observed synergism between U.V. and thymidine treatments may be due to thymidine-induced nucleotide pool imbalance with consequent inaccuracies in DNA repair.

Abilities of wild-type and thymidine kinase-deficient Friend mouse erythroleukemia cells to undergo unscheduled DNA synthesis following mutagen treatment

The abilities of wild-type and thymidine kinase-deficient Friend mouse erythroleukemia cells to perform unscheduled DNA synthesis (UDS), through the incorporation of [3H]deoxycytidine, were measured following damage with methyl methane sulfonate (MMS), ethyl methane sulfonate (EMS), and ultraviolet (UV) irradiation. For each mutagenic treatment, a positive and quantitatively similar response was observed for both wild-type and thymidine kinase-deficient cells. The extent of the response varied greatly, however, depending upon the mutagen used. The results contrast with the unscheduled incorporation of [3H]thymidine in wild-type cells following mutagen treatment, where less variation between the positive UDS responses elicited by MMS, EMS, and UV treatments was observed. Nevertheless, the results clearly indicate that thymidine kinase deficiency does not prevent excision repair (UDS) from occurring.

Resistance to mutagenesis of cells biochemically transformed by herpesvirus DNA fragments

LM(TK-) mouse fibroblast cells that were biochemically transformed to the dThd kinase-positive phenotype by restriction nuclease fragments of herpes simplex virus or marmoset herpesvirus DNA, all of which contained the virus dThd kinase coding region, or by HeLa S3 DNA were more resistant to mutagenesis by N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine or 5-bromodeoxyuridine than were dThd kinase-positive LM and LM(TK-) cells. Measurements of dNTP pool sizes did not reveal relative imbalances for representative cell lines under several conditions of growth.