Does the timing of aneurysm surgery neglect the real problems of subarachnoid haemorrhage?

Factors affecting outcome in poor grade subarachnoid haemorrhage: An institutional study

Context:

Poor grade subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH) is usually associated with unfavorable outcomes and optimal management is deemed complicated. Most centres follow an expectant management strategy or a less aggressive approach till patients improve to good clinical grades. This approach has been associated with higher mortality and morbidity. However, not all patients with poor clinical condition fare badly. Identification and early aggressive management of this select group of patients may lead to favorable outcomes.

Settings and Design:

Prospective non-randomized study.

Materials and Methods:

We prospectively analyzed 19 cases presented in WFNS grade 4 and 5 and factors affecting their outcome at a tertiary care centre in south India. This study was aimed at identifying those few poor grade patients who are probable candidates for a good outcome.

Statistical Analysis Used:

All the variables were analyzed for possible correlations with the SPSS version 13 software. The Chi-square test with a P < 0.05 was taken as statistically significant.

Results:

Of 19 cases, 13 were operated and good outcome was seen in 53.8% of the patients who underwent surgery and aggressive management. All 7 patients who were managed conservatively died. 15.8% of the patients had low density changes (P = 0.625). Absence of such changes was associated with a good long term outcome (P = 0.004). 9 patients had intraventricular hemorrhage at presentation and 5 patients having hydrocephalus underwent extra-ventricular drainage. Statistically significant factors precluding good outcome were the presence of infarcts and thick SAH in the cisterns.

Conclusions:

Poor grade (WFNS 4 and 5) SAH patients with or without ICH, IVH, if operated within 3 days can give rise to favorable outcome in around 50%. However, presence of patchy infarcts associated with thick subarachnoid blood (Fisher grade 3) precludes long term survival or meaningful recovery. Hence, aggressive management is unlikely to alter the natural history of such patients.

Outcomes of Endovascular Coiling in Patients with Intracranial Aneurysms Presenting with Poor Clinical and SAH Grade

Although the treatment of intracranial aneurysms has made significant advances, prediction of outcomes in poor grades has always been difficult. We present our findings of patients in poor clinical and SAH grade treated with endovascular coiling. We aimed to evaluate the clinical outcomes in patients presenting with poorer neurological and SAH grades treated by endovascular techniques. Of 190 patients who presented with SAH over a period of nine years, 34 were of poorer clinical grade (Hunt & Hess Grades 4 and 5), of whom 30 presented with H&H grade 4 and four with grade 5. 44.1% of the 34 patients belonged to Fischer grade 4. We assessed the technical success and final outcomes based on the Glasgow outcome scale. Of the 30 patients with grade 4, 81.4% had a good outcome. Two out of four patients with grade 5 had a poor outcome. 82.5% of the patients with Fischer grade 4 had a good outcome. None of the poor outcomes were procedure-related. Endovascular treatment with its higher rates of technical success, lower complication rates and better outcomes should be recommended as the treatment of choice in patients with intracranial aneurysms even in patients with poorer clinical and SAH grades.

Predicting outcome in poor-grade patients with subarachnoid hemorrhage: a retrospective review of 159 aggressively managed cases

To determine what factors predict outcome, the authors retrospectively reviewed the management of all 159 poor-grade patients admitted to Harborview Medical Center at the University of Washington who suffered aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage between 1983 and 1993. Favorable outcome (assessed by the Glasgow Outcome Scale) occurred in 53.9% of Hunt and Hess Grade IV, and 24.1% of Grade V patients. Outcome was largely determined by the initial hemorrhage and subsequent development of intractable intracranial hypertension or cerebral infraction. Using multivariate analysis, the authors developed three models to predict outcome. It was found that predicting outcome based only on clinical and diagnostic criteria present at admission may have resulted in withholding treatment from 30% of the patients who subsequently experienced favorable outcomes. It is concluded that aggressive management including surgical aneurysm obliteration can benefit patients with poor neurological grades and should not be denied solely on the basis of the neurological condition on admission.

Multiple intracranial aneurysms in a defined population: prospective angiographic and clinical study

Multiple intracranial aneurysms (MIA) have been detected in up to one-third of patients with cerebral aneurysms. Three main external factors influence these figures as follows: the quality of angiographies, the quantity of vessels studied, and referral policy. In a 1-year prospective study, we determined the incidence of MIA in a defined catchment area in East Finland by investigating all of the patients with intracranial aneurysms with panangiography. In 114 unselected patients, a total of 170 intracranial aneurysms were detected, and, of these, 39 (34%) harbored MIA. In contrast to most other reports, there was a male predominance in patients with MIA, and half of these men had hypertension. Intracavernous carotid and pericallosal aneurysms were more frequent in patients with MIA. The number of asymptomatic vertebrobasilar aneurysms was extremely low, and most of the nonruptured aneurysms were found in bilateral carotid angiograms. In spite of the active search, the proportion of vertebrobasilar aneurysms remained at 6%. Although our surgical policy was most active, one-third of the asymptomatic aneurysms remained untreated, mainly because of the poor condition of the patient.

Management results attained by predominantly late surgery for intracranial aneurysms

In contrast to previous studies conducted by various authors, who recommended early surgery for all patients admitted to the hospital within 72 hours of an aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage, several more recent studies have declined to advise early surgery for the treatment of patients with impaired consciousness. In our series, early surgery was undertaken for patients who were rated at Grades 1 to 2 (Hunt and Hess) at admission and who did not exhibit any additional risk factors (e.g., evidence of incipient vasospasm, giant aneurysm, unfavorable aneurysm location, or a severe concomitant disease). Only three patients rated Grade 3 at admission with a favorable aneurysm location and shape underwent early surgery. The management results attained in this series (n = 131), in which the early surgery rate was 17%, have been analyzed. The management mortality rate of patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage was 13%, and it was 7.7% for patients admitted at Grades 1 to 3 on the Hunt and Hess scale. Good results (Glasgow Outcome Scale, 1 or 2) were attained in 75% of the entire study population, in 85% of patients admitted at Grades 1 to 3, and in 53% of those patients who were admitted at Grades 4 to 5 and who underwent late surgery after their condition had improved to Grades 1 to 3. At an average interval of 3 years after the operation, 83% of the patients discharged with Glasgow Outcome Scale ratings of 1 or 2 reported no significant restriction of their "stress resistance."(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

One-year outcome in early aneurysm surgery: a 14 years experience

In a consecutive series of 1150 patients with cerebral aneurysms diagnosed in our department by angiography or autopsy between the years 1977-1990, 1007 patients underwent definitive operative treatment of their aneurysms mainly by early surgery. More than half (55%) were operated on during the first three days after subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH), and more than three quarters (77%) during the first week. The surgical mortality at 30 days was 9%; at one-year follow-up 13% had died. The total management mortality was 22%. The 618 patients presenting in Hunt and Hess Grades I-II had a 4% mortality, and 90% had an independent life at follow-up; 270 Grade III patients had a 19% mortality and 68% were independent. There were 99 patients operated on in Grades IV-V with a 46% mortality and 30% were independent. Age of the patient and size of the aneurysm were strongly related to outcome; however, many of the giant aneurysms were operated on as an emergency because of large intracerebral haematomas. Best results were obtained in the anterior communicating artery (ACA) area; the lowest rate of useful recoveries was in the vertebro-basilar artery (VBA) area (71%). Early surgery did not prevent delayed ischaemic deficits. During the first 72 hours patients in Grades I-III can be operated on safely with good results. The results in Grades IV-V are poor, and we suggest that only cases with large haematomas or considerable hydrocephalus or those improving should be operated on in the first days after SAH, with limited hopes of functional recovery.

Intraventricular haemorrhage caused by aneurysms and angiomas

More than 200 intraventricular haematomas (IVH) have been treated in the Homburg Neurosurgical University Clinic since computed tomography was available and facilitated the diagnosis. Among 200 consecutive cases, which are analysed and presented in this publication, there were 71 patients with subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH)--58 of whom with angiographically and/or pathologically verified aneurysms--, and 21 cases with intraventricular angiomas. IVH without concomitant intracerebral haematoma (ICH) and without evidence of SAH is highly suggestive of intraventricular angioma. In our experience panangiography [if available digital subtraction angiography (DAS)] should be done as soon as possible in all cases of IVH. It is a precondition for early diagnosis and operative elimination of the source of bleeding, because the retrospective analysis of our material shows that rebleeding is by far the highest single risk factor in cases with IVH caused by aneurysms or angiomas. We therefore recommend early microsurgical occlusion of the aneurysms and exstirpation or intravascular embolisation of the angioma. The best survival rate (76%) was achieved in IVH cases caused by angiomas. In aneurysms with IVH the survival rate was 35%, in IVH caused by other diseases 37%. The worst prognosis occurs in SAH with IVH without proven aneurysm or angioma. The survival rate of this group was only 8%.

Normovolaemic induced hypertension therapy for cerebral vasospasm after subarachnoid haemorrhage

We showed that normovolaemic induced hypertension therapy was effective in reducing ischaemic symptoms attributed to cerebral vasospasm in 41 patients after subarachnoid haemorrhage. By inducing hypertension to 25% to 50% above normal systolic arterial blood pressure, we observed that in 17 of 24 cases (71%) neurological deficits improved. In four cases of haemorrhagic infarction, the blood pressure rose to over 50% of systolic arterial pressure, and a low density area was confirmed on computerized tomography (CT) scan prior to vasospasm. Induced hypertension was therefore not considered when a low density area was revealed on CT scan. Restriction of fluid input is usually a factor in producing hypovolaemia after a neurosurgical operation. Intravascular volume expansion has been reported effective in reversing ischaemic deficits. However, according to Poiseuille's equation, increasing blood volume to a state of hypervolaemia can not enhance flow. The cerebral blood flow (CBF) was raised by increasing perfusion pressure, reducing viscosity, or increasing blood vessel diameter. Intravascular volume expansion elevates not only systemic arterial pressure, but also pulmonary artery wedge pressure over 18 mmHg and cardiac index over 2.2. Since pulmonary oedema and congestive heart failure may develop, one should monitor haemodynamic parameters with the Swan-Ganz catheter as a preventive measure. We emphasize that normovolaemic induced hypertension, maintaining haemodynamics subset 1 of the comparable haemodynamic subsets, is effective in raising perfusion pressure of CBF.