Diuretic renography in the assessment of urinary tract dilatation in children

The different elements of the Urinary Tract Dilation (UTD) Classification System and their capacity to predict findings on mercaptoacetyltriglycine (MAG3) diuretic renography

INTRODUCTION

The UTD Classification System risk stratifies postnatal UTD into three groups: low risk (UTD P1), intermediate risk (UTD P2), and high risk (UTD P3). In the original consensus document, a functional scan is not recommended for UTD P1 and is left to the discretion of the clinician for UTD P2 and P3.

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to understand which patients with postnatal urinary tract dilation would benefit from a functional study. We investigated how different elements of the UTD classification system predict differential renal function (DRF) and diuretic half-life (T½) on MAG3 scan in infants undergoing evaluation for prenatally detected UTD.

STUDY DESIGN

This is a multicenter retrospective chart review of infants 6 months of age or younger evaluated for prenatal UTD, correlating their first MAG3 scan and first postnatal renal ultrasound (RUS). Multivariable logistic regression was used to find UTD elements predictive of DRF < 40% and/or T½ > 20 min.

RESULTS

A total of 517 patients met study criteria. Median age at time of RUS and MAG3 renal scan was 48 days (IGR 31-81) and 63 days (IQR 45-98), respectively. DRF < 40% was found in 6% of kidneys with UTD P2 and 35% of kidneys with UTD P3. T½ > 20 min was found in 31% of kidneys with UTD P2 and 79% of kidneys with UTD P3. An abnormal ureter (OR 2.7, 95% CI 1.2-6.0) and parenchymal thinning (OR 16, 95% CI 5.8-41.4) were significant at predicting DRF < 40%. Parenchymal thinning (OR 3.0, 95% CI 1.5-6.1) also predicted T½ > 20 min, as did each cm increase in the anterior-posterior renal pelvic diameter (APRPD) (OR 4.8, 95% CI 3.0-7.7).

DISCUSSION

The UTD system discriminates well and correlates with the likelihood of finding adverse features on diuretic renography. Patients in the UTD P3 high-risk category had a significantly higher incidence of decreased differential renal function and delayed drainage than those in UTD P1 and P2. Of the individual components of the UTD Classification system, the presence of parenchymal thinning was the most important factor in predicting both decreased differential renal function and delayed drainage.

CONCLUSION

Given the high incidence of poor function and delayed drainage seen in the UTD P3 group, we believe a functional study should be recommended in the evaluation of these patients. Our findings support leaving the performance of a functional study at the discretion of the physician for UTD P2.

Is a Reassuring MAG-3 Diuretic Renal Scan Really Reassuring?

Objective

The mercaptoacetyltriglycine-3 (MAG-3) diuretic renal scan is frequently used to diagnose obstruction in children with hydronephrosis. However, it remains unclear whether a reassuring MAG-3 diuretic scan in the presence of high-grade hydronephrosis accurately predicts the absence of obstruction. We sought to determine if a reassuring nuclear scan can accurately identify patients with high-grade hydronephrosis that can be safely observed.

Materials and Methods

We retrospectively reviewed the course of 22 children (25 renal units) ages 0-3 months with significant hydronephrosis (Society of Fetal Urology grade 3-4) detected prenatally. All patients underwent a MAG-3 diuretic nuclear renal scan.

Results

Twenty-two patients with 25 renal units were included, 19 with grade 3 and 6 with grade 4 hydronephrosis on ultrasound. Sixteen renal units had a reassuring nuclear scan (T ½ < 10 minutes, average 5.9, range 2-9). Nine renal units had indeterminate scans (T ½ 10-20 minutes, average 12.8, range 10-17). Fifteen of 16 (94%) kidneys with a reassuring nuclear scan had complete resolution of their hydronephrosis. One patient with an initially reassuring nuclear scan underwent pyeloplasty after persistent grade 4 hydronephrosis one year later prompted a repeat MAG-3 indicating obstruction. Eight of 9 (89%) patients with an indeterminate T ½ of 10-20 minutes had complete resolution of their hydronephrosis. One patient was lost to follow up. Average length of follow up and time to resolution was 23.6 months (range 4-61 months).

Conclusion

In pediatric patients with persistent antenatally detected hydronephrosis, a reassuring MAG-3 can allow for safe observation in the vast majority. Only one of 24 renal units with follow-up progressed to obstruction. All patients treated without surgery had complete resolution of their hydronephrosis. Observation with serial ultrasounds may be an appropriate alternative to operative management, even in patients with moderate to severe hydronephrosis in the presence of a reassuring or indeterminate MAG-3 diuretic scan.

Postnatal evaluation of intrauterine hydronephrosis due to ureteropelvic junction obstruction

PURPOSE: Fetal hydronephrosis is a frequent finding due to advances in prenatal ultrasonography. The definition of fetal and neonatal urinary tract obstruction is a very difficult task requiring confirmation of reduced renal function and hydronephrosis. In this study we followed a series of consecutive patients with intrauterine hydronephrosis that persisted during post-natal life. METHODS: 116 newborns with antenatal hydronephrosis diagnosed by ultrasound and submitted to a specific post-natal evaluative protocol with a follow-up period of 6 years. RESULTS: In 45 (38.8%) of 116 patients, ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) obstruction was confirmed and surgical correction of the UPJ obstruction was done in 19 patients. From 26 children who were initially submitted to non-surgical treatment, only 6 (23%) needed a surgical approach during follow up. Overall analysis showed that surgery was performed in 25 patients with UPJ obstruction, and the others 20 patients were kept under clinical observation, since normal renal function was confirmed by scintigraphy scans. CONCLUSION: Fetal hydronephrosis due to UPJ obstruction deserves careful postnatal evaluation. UPJ obstruction is the most frequent anomaly and its surgical treatment has very precise indications. The evaluative protocol was useful in identify patients that could be followed-up with a non-surgical approach.

Technetium-99m-L,L-ethylenedicysteine is more effective than technetium-99m diethylenetriamine penta-acetic acid for excluding obstruction in patients with pyelocalicinal dilation

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the utility of diuretic dynamic renal scintigraphy (DDRS) with technetium-99m-L,L-ethylenedicysteine ((99m)Tc-EC) in patients with indeterminate or possible false-positive results for urinary obstruction by technetium-99m diethylenetriamine penta-acetic acid ((99m)Tc-DTPA) DDRS.

METHODS

A total of 92 patients (63 male; mean age, 16.6 +/- 21.25 years) were studied, with a total of 103 kidneys presenting indeterminate (20/103) or possible false-positive results for obstruction attributable to reduced renal function or severe kidney dilation (83/103) by (99m)Tc-DTPA DDRS (<60% of radiopharmaceutical excreted in 20 minutes-half-time clearance [T(1/2)] >15 minutes). Patients were reimaged after intravenous injection of (99m)Tc-EC, with dynamic images before and after furosemide administration using the same acquisition parameters applied in the previous (99m)Tc-DTPA study. Time interval between (99m)Tc-DTPA and (99m)Tc-EC renograms was 2-64 days. The percentage of excreted material 20 minutes after furosemide was calculated using both radiopharmaceuticals, and were statistically compared using the paired samples t test.

RESULTS

The excretion after furosemide injection was 25.3% +/- 18.2% for (99m)Tc-DTPA and 41.2% +/- 26.1% for (99m)Tc-EC, with a statistically significant difference between both radiopharmaceuticals (P <.0001). Using (99m)Tc-EC obstruction was excluded in 36 of 103 kidneys, which excreted >60%. A total of 10 of 83 kidneys (12.0%) with an obstructive pattern by (99m)Tc-DTPA study turned out to be indeterminate by (99m)Tc-EC DDRS. There was an agreement between (99m)Tc-EC and (99m)Tc-DTPA studies in 54 of 83 kidneys with obstructive (65.1%) and in 3 of 20 (15.0%) with indeterminate patterns.

CONCLUSIONS

(99m)Tc-EC was more effective than (99m)Tc-DTPA for excluding obstruction, presenting less false-positive and indeterminate results. (99m)Tc-EC can substitute (99m)Tc-DTPA to evaluate patients with urinary tract dilation.

Diuretic renogram clearance half-times in the diagnosis of obstructive uropathy: effect of age and previous surgery

Diuretic renography with radiotracers has been used successfully to diagnose obstruction in patients with hydronephrosis. Controversy persists with regard to the best approach for the interpretation of renogram curves: visual analysis or a quantitative index, i.e. the clearance half-time. The latter is often reported to be in the intermediate or non-diagnostic range. It is important to measure the incidence of equivocal half-times in various subsets of patients with hydronephrosis in order to determine in which settings the measurement of this index may be clinically useful. We performed a retrospective study of diuretic renograms performed at our institution between 1997 and 2000 for the evaluation of suspected uretero-pelvic junction (UPJ) obstruction. Vigorous intravenous hydration, exceeding current guidelines, was employed in these patients. Three hundred and seventy-seven renogram curves in 205 patients were analysed. Patients were divided into three groups: >1 year of age; <or=1 year of age; and those who had previously undergone surgical correction of obstruction regardless of age. Patients with reflux or anatomical abnormalities of the urinary tract, those with chronic renal failure, those with bilateral normal clearances before furosemide administration and those with unilateral normal clearances before furosemide administration with contralateral poor renal function were excluded. In the remaining 119 patients, 205 clearance half-times were classified as normal before furosemide, normal after furosemide (half-time, <10 min), prolonged (half-time, >20 min) or intermediate (half-time, 10-20 min). In patients >1 year of age, 37% of 101 renograms showed normal half-times before furosemide, 20% showed normal half-times after furosemide, 44% showed prolonged half-times and none (0%) showed an intermediate half-time. In patients </=1 year of age, there was a statistically significantly different distribution, with 48% of 64 renograms showing normal washout before furosemide, 16% showing normal clearance after furosemide, 19% showing abnormal half-times and 17% showing intermediate half-times. In 33 renograms from patients who had undergone corrective surgery, 49% had normal half-times, 24% had prolonged half-times and 27% had intermediate half-times. It can be concluded that, when using the selection criteria, hydration, acquisition and processing protocols and half-time definition employed in this study, the addition of a clearance measurement in patients older than 1 year with suspected UPJ disease enhances patient classification and may improve the diagnostic confidence. There was a significantly higher incidence of intermediate half-times in patients with native disease aged <1 year than in those >1 year. Caution is advised when interpreting this finding in this age group. The measurement of washout was less useful in patients who had undergone a corrective procedure, because of the high rate of 'indeterminate' and 'abnormal' values in spite of successful surgery. Vigorous intravenous hydration, exceeding current standards, may have contributed to the lower incidence of intermediate half-times than reported previously.

Imaging for ureteropelvic junction obstruction in adults

The three goals of imaging for ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) obstruction are to determine the presence and degree of renal obstruction, to assess renal function, and to determine the cause of the problem. The diagnostic techniques are intravenous urography, which is unreliable; ultrasonography, with the addition of pulsed Doppler technology; diuretic scintigraphy; and pressure-flow studies (Whitaker test), which is the only direct clinical test of renal outflow resistance. Voiding cystography, retrograde ureteropyelography, and CT have utility in some patients. In determining the cause of obstruction, the patient often is evaluated for crossing vessels using angiography, endoluminal ultrasonography, or spiral CT. It is not possible to formulate a single algorithm for radiographic evaluation of suspected UPJ obstruction, but in the average adult patient, urography and diuretic scintigraphy are sufficient.

"Well-tempered" diuresis renography: its historical development, physiological and technical pitfalls, and standardized technique protocol

Differentiating the various causes of hydronephrosis from that of obstruction can be very difficult. Diuretic renography has been adopted as a noninvasive clinical management tool to assist in this differentiation. However, the correlation of the results of diuresis renography, the Whitaker test, and the surgical results has only been between 40% and 85%. This is believed to be due to the many physiological factors and technical pitfalls of the technique. These include variable renal function, variable compliance of the collecting system, the effect of back pressure from a full bladder, the state of hydration, the choice of radiopharmaceutical, and the timing of the diuretic injection. Even the technique of measuring the clearance half-time (T 1/2) is controversial, with at least eight different methods defined. In order to diminish the effect of these variables, a standardized protocol for diuretic renography has been proposed by a consortium of members of the Society for Fetal Urology and the Pediatric Nuclear Medicine Club of the Society of Nuclear Medicine. These include a standardized hydration with a dilute glucose solution, bladder catheterization and measurement of urine output response, uniform radiopharmaceutical choice, and diuretic dose with specific timing of the diuretic injection. The various methods for T 1/2 calculation are illustrated, and various stereotypical renogram and diuresis response curves are offered as aids in the interpretation of the study. Diuresis renography is one of the most complex functional studies in nuclear medicine today. A thorough understanding of the physiological basis for diuresis renography and the pitfalls of the technique is required for its appropriate use in the management of patients suspected of urinary tract obstruction.