Internal radiation for bile duct cancer

Carcinoma das vias biliares extra-hepáticas

Os autores revisam os aspectos clínicos, a avaliação diagnostica e o tratamento de colangiocarcinoma hilar. São discutidos os exames indispensáveis para o estadiamento e escolha da melhor terapêutica. Com o avanço no conhecimento sobre a patologia surgiram novas técnicas curativas e paliativas que são apresentadas nesta revisão.

Impact of radiotherapy in the management of locally advanced extrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma

BACKGROUND

Optimal therapy for patients with unresectable locally advanced extrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma (ULAC) remains controversial. We analysed the role of radiotherapy in the management of such tumors.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the charts of patients treated in our institution with conformal-3D external-beam-radiotherapy (EBRT) with or without concurrent chemotherapy.

RESULTS

Thirty patients were included: 24 with a primary tumor (group 1) and 6 with a local relapse (group 2). Toxicity was low. Among 25 patients assessable for EBRT response, we observed 9 complete responses, 4 partial responses, 10 stabilisations, and 2 progressions. The median follow-up was 12 months. Twenty out of 30 patients (66%) experienced a relapse, which was metastatic in 75% of cases in the whole series, 87% in group 1, 60% in group 2 (p = 0.25). Twenty-eight patients (93%) died of relapse or disease complications. Median overall survivals in the whole group and in group 1 or 2 were respectively 12, 11 and 21 months (p = 0.11). The 1-year and 3-year progression-free survivals were respectively 38% and 16% in the whole series; 31% and 11% in group 1, 67% and 33% in group 2 (p = 0.35).

CONCLUSION

EBRT seems efficient to treat ULAC, with acceptable toxicity. For primary disease, the high rate of metastatic relapse suggests to limit EBRT to non-progressive patients after induction chemotherapy.

Liver transplantation for hilar cholangiocarcinoma

Hilar cholangiocarcinoma was accepted as an indication for liver transplantation at the beginning of the transplantation era. Owing to disappointing long-term results for this indication, and in parallel, encouraging results in patients with benign disease, hilar cholangiocarcinoma has generally not been accepted as an indication for liver transplantation in recent years. To improve results, more aggressive approaches have been used: "abdominal organ cluster transplantation" and "extended bile duct resection", which lead to increased long-term survival rates. However, with improving results after conventional extrahepatic bile duct resection in combination with partial hepatectomy, extended procedures in combination with liver transplantation never became a real option in the treatment of hilar cholangiocarcinoma. However, new awareness of liver transplantation in the treatment of this cancer has been raised for patients with hilar cholangiocarcinoma in the context of underlying liver diseases such as primary sclerosing cholangitis, which preclude liver resection. Current results show increased survival figures, in particular in well-selected patients with early tumor stages. Further improvements in long-term survival may be reached with new adjuvant and neoadjuvant protocols. Patients with neoadjuvant radiochemotherapy show long-term results similar to those for liver transplantation for other indications. Also, photodynamic therapy and the use of new antiproliferative immunosuppressive agents may be an approach for further improvement of the long-term results. Currently, liver transplantation for the treatment of hilar cholangiocarcinoma should be restricted to centers with experience in the treatment of this cancer and should be taken into consideration in patients with contraindications to liver resection.

Endoscopic intraluminal brachytherapy and metal stent in malignant hilar biliary obstruction: a pilot study

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Malignant hilar biliary obstruction carries a poor prognosis, as the disease is often unresectable at the time of diagnosis. Various palliative measures as surgical/radiological/ endoscopic drainage with or without radiotherapy/chemotherapy have been tried with dismal outcome. We prospectively studied the effect of unilateral metal stent with intraluminal high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy in patients with type II malignant hilar biliary obstruction.

METHODS

Eight patients with type II malignant hilar biliary obstruction were treated with contrast-free unilateral metal stenting followed by endoscopic intraluminal brachytherapy (ILBT). A retrospectively analyzed group of 10 patients treated only with contrast-free unilateral metal stenting served as historical controls.

RESULTS

A successful drainage was achieved in all, cholangitis occurred in none and no patient died within 30 days in both groups. The mean (+/-SD) patency of metal stent was 305 (+/-183.96) days and 143.9(+/-115.11) days in patients with and without intraluminal brachytherapy, respectively (P=0.03). Mean (+/-SD) survival of these patients was 310 (+/-192.68) days and 154.9 (+/-122.51) days in patients with and without intraluminal brachytherapy, respectively (P=0.05). Kaplan-Meier analysis showed estimated median survival of 225 (95% CI; 169.5, 280.4) days in brachytherapy and 100 (95%CI; 94.1, 105.8) days in control group (P=0.025). No major complications related to metal stent or ILBT were observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Contrast-free unilateral metal stenting with HDR ILBT in type II malignant hilar biliary obstruction is a safe and effective method of palliation and appears to prolong patient survival as well as patency of stent in these patients, however, a larger, randomized trial is required to validate the same.

Cholangiocarcinoma: the impact of tumor location and treatment strategy on outcome

The purpose of this study was to evaluate how the outcome of patients with extrahepatic cholangiocarcinoma (EHBC) may have been influenced by tumor location and treatment selection. The primary endpoint of this study is overall survival (OS). Between January 1983 and December 1997, 221 patients with biliary tumors were evaluated at Thomas Jefferson University Hospital. Of these, 118 fit the inclusion criteria for this study. The extent of disease was assessed by computed tomography, percutaneous transhepatic cholangiography or endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, magnetic resonance imaging, and ultrasonography. All patients had histologic confirmation of malignancy. Roux-en Y, hepaticojejunostomy, or choledochojejunostomy followed surgical resection of the primary tumor. Palliative measure (PS) included biliary catheter placement without brachytherapy or external beam irradiation (RT). RT was delivered via high-energy photons. Intraluminal brachytherapy was performed via percutaneous biliary catheterization with iridium-192 ribbon sources. Chemotherapy consisted of either intravenous 5-fluorouracil alone or in combination with doxorubicin, mitomycin C, or paclitaxel. PS consisted of metal bile duct stent placement. Median follow-up time for the entire group was 102 months and 43 months for patients who were still alive at the conclusion of the study period. Patients with proximal tumors underwent resection (n = 5), surgery and RT (n = 23), RT only (n = 31), chemotherapy only (n = 6), or PS (n = 12). Patients with distal tumors were treated with surgical resection (n = 17) or a combination of surgery and RT (n = 13), RT only (n = 6), or PS (n = 4). Median survival time (MST) for all 118 patients was 22 months. The MST for patients with distal tumors was 47 months versus 17 months for those with proximal tumors. The MST has not been reached for patients with distal EHBC treated with surgical resection and postoperative RT, whereas the median survival for those treated with surgery alone is 62.5 months. However, 4 of 17 of these patients had in situ carcinoma. Six patients had distal tumors treated with RT only with a MST of 6 months. Patients with proximal tumors treated with surgery and RT had a superior OS at 5 years compared to patients treated with RT alone (24 vs. 13 months; p = 0.007). There was an improved OS in patients with proximal tumors treated with surgical resection and RT compared to surgery alone (p = 0.023). There is no discernable influence of chemotherapy on outcome in patients with proximal EHBC. The MST for patients treated with PS was 3.5 months. Surgery and postoperative RT appear to be better than either surgery or RT alone in patients with proximal EHBC. In patients with distal EHBC, the addition of resection and RT appears to offer an advantage, which is increasingly apparent with longer follow-up time. The prognosis remains dismal for patients treated with palliative intent.

Palliative treatment of unresectable bile duct cancer: which stent? which approach?

Nonsurgical options for the palliative treatment of unresectable bile duct cancer are discussed. Despite all of the available approaches, the disease remains uniformly fatal. The goal of managing unresectable bile duct cancer is to treat the symptoms that still contribute to significant morbidity and mortality. Further development of new treatment strategies and modalities is needed to improve the quality of life and survival of patients with this disease.

High-dose-rate remote afterloading intracavitary brachytherapy for the treatment of extrahepatic biliary duct carcinoma

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to determine whether a dose response exists for extrahepatic bile duct carcinoma (EBDC) when treated with increasingly higher radiation doses delivered via a combination of external beam radiation (EBRT) and high dose rate intracavitary brachytherapy (HDRIB). To establish the best tolerated dose of HDRIB.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Eighteen patients with pathologically proven, locoregional but unresectable or incompletely resected EBDC were studied from 1991-1998 in this phase I/II trial. All patients received EBRT, delivered via megavoltage photons at standard fractionation schedules, for a total dose of 45 Gy. The HDRIB was delivered using the nucleotron HDR remote afterloading unit with a 10 Ci Ir192 source. Each treatment of HDRIB delivered 7 Gy at 1 cm depth. The first group of eight patients received one treatment of HDRIB (Group 1, total dose = 52 Gy). The second group of six patients received two weekly treatments (Group 2, total dose = 59 Gy). The last group of four patients received three weekly treatments of HDRIB (Group 3, total dose = 66 Gy). HDRIB was delivered once weekly concomitant with the EBRT. Acute adverse reactions were evaluated after for each group of patients before escalating to the next higher dose level of HDRIB.

RESULTS

The median follow up time for all 18 patients was 15 months. The median survival for all 18 patients was 12.2 months (range 2 to 79.6 months). Overall two-year survival was 27.8%. Three patients (16.7%) had survival of more than 5 years. Dose response is suggested by the median survival of the three groups (9, 12.2, and 20.3 months for Group 1, 2, and 3, respectively), although this did not reach statistical significance. Complete or partial response (>50% reduction in tumor size) was seen in 25% of patients receiving total of 52 Gy compared to 80% of patients (5 patients in Group 2 and 3 patients in Group 3) receiving greater than 59 Gy (P = 0.05). No patients developed Grade 4 complications. One patient in Group 2 developed Grade 3 toxicity after second treatment of HDRIB.

CONCLUSION

High dose rate brachytherapy of 21 Gy in three divided weekly treatments, plus 45 Gy of external beam radiation is well tolerated. A dose response is shown with significant increase of PR and CR rate for dose >59 Gy. This modality of treatment appears to be safe and effective for inoperable extrahepatic biliary duct carcinoma.

The role of brachytherapy for palliation

The goal of palliative radiation is to alleviate symptoms in a short amount of time and maintain an optimal functional and quality-of-life level while minimizing toxicity and patient inconvenience. Despite advances in multimodality antineoplastic therapies, failure to control the tumor at its primary site frustratingly remains the predominant source of morbidity and mortality in many patients with cancer. Escalation of doses of radiation using external beam irradiation has been shown to improve local tumor control, but limits are imposed by the tolerance of normal surrounding structures. The highly conformal nature of brachytherapy enables the radiation oncologist to accomplish safe escalation of radiation doses to the tumor while minimizing doses to normal surrounding structures. Thus, by enhancing the potential for local control, brachytherapy used alone or as a supplement to external beam radiation therapy retains a significant and important role in achieving the goals of palliation. Proper patient selection, excellent technique, and adherence to implant rules will minimize the risk of complications. The advantages realized with the use of brachytherapy include good patient tolerance, short treatment time, and high rates of sustained palliation. This article reviews various aspects of palliative brachytherapy, including patient selection criteria, implant techniques, treatment planning, dose and fractionation schedules, results, and complications of treatment. Tumors of the head and neck, trachea and bronchi, esophagus, biliary tract, and brain, all in which local failure represents the predominant cause of morbidity and mortality, are highlighted.

Benefits of adjuvant radiotherapy after radical resection of locally advanced main hepatic duct carcinoma

PURPOSE

The objective of this study was to determine the benefits of adjuvant radiotherapy after radical resection of locally advanced main hepatic duct carcinoma (Klatskin tumor).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We conducted a retrospective review of 63 patients who underwent surgical resection of Stage IVA Klatskin tumor. Of the 63 patients, 47 had microscopic tumor residue (RT1). Twenty-eight of the 47 patients with RT1 were treated by adjuvant radiotherapy and the remaining 19 patients were treated exclusively by surgical resection. Seventeen of the 28 patients with RT1 were treated by both intraoperative radiotherapy (IORT) and postoperative radiotherapy (PORT); of the remaining 11 patients with RT1, 6 underwent resection and IORT, and 5 underwent resection and PORT.

RESULTS

The major complication and 30-day operative death rates were significantly lower in the radiation group (9.5% and 0.0%, respectively) than in the resection alone group (28.5% and 9.5%, respectively). Of the eight 5-year survivors with RT1, 6 had adjuvant radiotherapy and the remaining 2 had resection alone. Adjuvant radiotherapy for patients with RT1 yielded significantly (p = 0.0141) higher 5-year survival rates (33.9%) than in the resection alone group (13.5 %). The best 5-year survival rate (39.2 %) was found in patients who underwent a combination of IORT and PORT after resection. The local-regional control rate was significantly higher in the adjuvant radiation group than in the resection alone group (79.2% vs. 31.2%).

CONCLUSION

Our data clearly suggest the improved prognosis of patients with locally advanced Klatskin tumor by integrated adjuvant radiotherapy with IORT and PORT to complete gross tumor resection with acceptable treatment mortality and morbidity.

The role of chemotherapy and radiation in the management of biliary cancer: a review of the literature

Carcinoma of the biliary tract is a rare tumour. To date, there is no therapeutic measure with curative potential apart from surgical intervention. Thus, patients with advanced, i.e. unresectable or metastatic disease, face a dismal prognosis. They present a difficult problem to clinicians as to whether to choose a strictly supportive approach or to expose patients to the side-effects of a potentially ineffective treatment. The objective of this article is to review briefly the clinical trials available in the current literature utilising non-surgical oncological treatment (radiotherapy and chemotherapy) either in patients with advanced, i.e. locally inoperable or metastatic cancer of the biliary tract or as an adjunct to surgery. From 65 studies identified, there seems to be no standard therapy for advanced biliary cancer. Despite anecdotal reports of symptomatic palliation and survival advantages, most studies involved only a small number of patients and were performed in a phase II approach. In addition, the benefit of adjuvant treatment remains largely unproven. No clear trend in favour of radiation therapy could be seen when the studies included a control group. In addition, the only randomised chemotherapeutic series seemed to suggest a benefit of treatment in advanced disease, but due to the small number of patients included, definitive evidence from large, randomised series concerning the benefit of non-surgical oncological intervention as compared with supportive care is still lacking. Patients with advanced biliary tract cancer should be offered the opportunity to participate in clinical trials.

External radiation therapy and transcatheter iridium in the treatment of extrahepatic bile duct carcinoma

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE

Review survival, prognostic factors, and patterns of failure in patients with extrahepatic bile duct (EHBD) carcinoma treated with external beam irradiation (EBRT) and transcatheter iridium.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The charts of 24 patients with EHBD cancer treated with EBRT and transcatheter boost were reviewed. All patients had transhepatic biliary tubes or endoprostheses placed. Two patients underwent hemihepatectomy with hepaticojejunostomy formation but had residual disease. Two patients had biopsy proven adenopathy. Five patients had Grade 1 adenocarcinoma, nine Grade 2, six Grade 3, and one Grade 4 disease. Median EBRT dose was 50.4 Gy delivered in 1.8 Gy/day fractions. Median transcatheter boost at 1 cm radius was 20 Gy. Nine patients received concomitant 5-Fluorouracil (5-FU) during EBRT.

RESULTS

Median survival was 12.8 months (range 7.5 months to 9 years). Overall 2- and 5-year survival rates were 18.8 and 14.1%, respectively (three disease-free survivors > or =5 years). One patient is still alive without relapse 10 years from diagnosis and 5 years after liver transplantation for liver failure (no cancer in specimen, underlying sclerosing cholangitis). Two additional long-term survivors had no evidence of relapse 6.9 and 8.2 years after diagnosis. Histologic grade, lymph node status, cystic, hepatic, common hepatic or common bile duct involvement, surgical resection, radiation therapy dose, and chemotherapy did not significantly effect survival due to the number of patients analyzed. There was a trend towards improved survival with the addition of 5-FU chemotherapy (5-year survival in two of nine patients, or 22%). Eight of 24 patients (33%) demonstrated radiographic evidence of local recurrence. Distant metastases developed in 6 of 24 (25%) patients. The most common complications were tube related cholangitis (50%) and gastric/duodenal ulceration or bleeding (42%).

CONCLUSION

External beam irradiation combined with a transcatheter boost can result in long-term survival of patients with EHBD cancer. Both distant metastases and local recurrence develop in 25-30% of patients despite irradiation. Survival may be improved by using chemotherapy in combination with EBRT to impact disease relapse (local and distant). Because there may be a dose response with irradiation, survival may also be improved by increasing the dose of radiation delivered by transcatheter boost. A Phase II trial is being developed using a combination of 45-50 Gy EBRT with concomitant 5-FU delivered by protracted venous infusion followed by a 25-30 Gy transcatheter boost.

Surgical treatment in proximal bile duct cancer. A single-center experience

OBJECTIVES

The authors evaluated the experience and results of a single center in surgical treatment of proximal bile duct carcinoma.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Whenever feasible, surgery is the appropriate treatment in proximal bile duct carcinoma. To improve survival rates and with special regard to liver transplantation, the extent of surgical radicalness remains an open issue.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Retrospective analysis of 249 patients who underwent surgery for proximal bile duct carcinoma via the following procedures: resection (n = 125), liver transplantation (n = 25), and exploratory laparotomy (n = 99). Survival rates were calculated according to the Kaplan-Meier method, uni- and multivariate analysis of prognostic factors, and log rank test (p < 0.05).

RESULTS

Survival rates after resection and liver transplantation are correlated with international Union Against Cancer (UICC) tumor stage (resection: overall 5-year, 27.1%; stage I and II, 41.9%; stage IV, 20.7%; liver transplantation: overall 5-year, 17.1%; stage I and II, 37.8%; stage IV, 5.8%). Significant univariate prognostic factors for survival after liver resection were lymph node involvement (N category), tumor stage, tumor-free margins, and vascular invasion; for transplantation, they were local tumor extent, N category, tumor stage, and infiltration of liver parenchyma. For resection and transplantation, a multivariate analysis showed prognostic significance of tumor stage and tumor-free margins.

CONCLUSION

Resection remains the treatment of choice in proximal bile duct carcinoma. Whenever possible, decisions about resectability should be made during laparotomy. With regard to the observation of long-term survivors, liver transplantation still can be justified in selected patients with stage II carcinoma. It is unknown whether more radical procedures, such as liver transplantation combined with multivisceral resections, will lead to better outcome in advanced stages. With regard to palliation, surgical drainage of the biliary system performed as hepatojejunostomy can be recommended.

Palliation of irresectable hilar cholangiocarcinoma with biliary drainage and radiotherapy

Twelve patients with irresectable or recurrent hilar cholangiocarcinoma were treated with internal biliary drainage followed by intraluminal (iridium-192) and external-beam radiotherapy. Biliary drainage was accomplished by means of a combined surgical and interventional radiological approach. Initial biliary decompression was performed surgically by tumour resection, intrahepatic biliary enteric bypass or distal biliary-enteric anastomosis with a temporary stent. Maintenance of internal biliary drainage and application of intraluminal radiotherapy were accomplished radiologically with the use of percutaneous dilatation and metallic expandable biliary endoprostheses. Median survival was 14.5 months; all 12 patients survived for at least 6 months. Early complications during radiotherapy were minor and included two patients with cholangitis and one with transient haemobilia. Jaundice was relieved in ten of 12 patients, while episodes of cholangitis were seen during long-term follow-up in 11 (median 1.5 episodes per patient). Internal biliary drainage, in conjunction with radiotherapy, appears to be safe and effective palliation of irresectable or recurrent hilar cholangiocarcinoma. Patients can maintain a reasonable quality of life with an acceptable incidence of cholangitis, without the hindrance of external drainage devices.

Perihilar cholangiocarcinoma. Postoperative radiotherapy does not improve survival

OBJECTIVE

The aims of this analysis were to determine prospectively the effects of surgical resection and radiation therapy on the length and quality of survival as well as late toxicity in patients with perihilar cholangiocarcinoma.

BACKGROUND

Retrospective analyses have suggested that adjuvant radiation therapy improves survival in patients with perihilar cholangiocarcinoma. However, in these reports, patients receiving radiotherapy tended to have smaller, often resectable tumors, and were relatively fit. In comparison, patients who have not received radiotherapy often had unresectable tumors, metastatic disease, or poor performance status.

METHODS

From 1988 through 1993, surgically staged patients with perihilar cholangiocarcinoma and 1) no evidence of metastatic disease, 2) Karnofsky score > 60, 3) no prior malignancy or radiotherapy, and 4) a patent main portal vein were analyzed. Fifty patients were stratified by resection (n = 31) versus operative palliation (n = 19) and by radiation (n = 23) versus no radiotherapy (n = 27).

RESULTS

Patients undergoing resection had smaller tumors (1.9 +/- 2.8 vs. 2.4 +/- 2.1 cm, p < 0.01) that were less likely to invade the hepatic artery (3% vs. 42%, p < 0.05) or portal vein (6% vs. 53%, p < 0.05). Multiple parameters that might have affected outcome were similar between patients who did and did not receive radiation therapy. Resection improved the length (24.2 +/- 2.5 vs. 11.3 +/- 1.0 months, p < 0.05) and quality of survival. Radiation had no effect on the length (18.4 +/- 2.9 vs. 20.1 +/- 2.4 months) or quality of survival or on late toxicity.

CONCLUSIONS

This analysis suggests that in patients with localized perihilar cholangiocarcinoma, resection prolongs survival whereas radiation has no effect on either survival or late toxicity. Thus, new agents or strategies to deliver adjuvant therapy are needed to improve survival in these patients.

Combined external beam radiotherapy and intraluminal high dose rate brachytherapy on bile duct carcinomas

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to investigate the effectiveness and complications of combined external beam and intraluminal high dose rate irradiation and various adjuvant biliary drainage techniques on patients with bile duct carcinomas.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Eighteen patients with carcinomas of the hepatic duct bifurcation and 12 patients with carcinomas of the choledochus duct or the common hepatic duct were treated with combined external beam radiotherapy and intraluminal high-dose rate brachytherapy. Nine patients received radiotherapy after palliative tumor resection and 21 patients were primarily irradiated. Twenty-five patients completed the full course of radiotherapy. On these patients, the reference doses for the external beam varied from 30 to 45 Gy and for brachytherapy from 20 to 45 Gy. Biliary drainage after radiotherapy was achieved either with percutaneous catheters, endoprosthesis, or stents.

RESULTS

The median survival for the entire group was 10 months. The actuarial survival was 34% after 1 year, 18% after 2 and 3 years, and 8% after 5 years. The subgroup with palliative tumor resection exhibit a significantly better survival (median: 12.1 months vs. 7.9 months). Three patients are still living without evidence of disease since 35 to 69 months. Major complications like bacterial cholangitis could be lowered from 37% to 28% through exchange of percutaneous transhepatic catheters to endoprosthesis or stents. The longest lasting drainages were achieved through stents. The frequency of radiogenic ulcera were lowered from 23% to presently 7.6% after the total dose of the high dose rate afterloading boost was reduced to 20 Gy.

CONCLUSIONS

The present standard treatment schedule 40 Gy for the external beam and 20 Gy (fourfold 5 Gy) for the afterloading boost seems to be appropriate and well tolerated. After radiotherapy, a permanent supply of drainage should be made with a stent.

Intraductal hepatocellular carcinoma treated by intralumenal brachytherapy

Hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) rarely presents as biliary tract occlusion [1,2]. Intralumenal iridium-192 brachytherapy has been used to treat extrahepatic bile duct carcinoma and may be curative if the macroscopic tumour has been resected surgically [3]. We describe a rare event, a case of HCC presenting with biliary tract occlusion treated with intralumenal iridium-192 brachytherapy.

Palliative treatment of extrahepatic bile ducts tumors

Extrahepatic bile duct (EHBD) tumors often become symptomatic in an advanced stage when curative resection is seldom possible. In a group of 111 patients, 7 (6.3%) received no treatment, 32 (28.8%) underwent non-operative biliary drainage (NOD), and 72 (64.8%) underwent surgical exploration. Radical resection was possible in only 25 cases (34.7%); 14 patients (19.4%) underwent a biliary digestive bypass (BDB), 15 (20.8%) received a transtumoral biliary prosthesis (TBP), and 18 (25.0%) an external biliary drainage (EBD). Average survival rates were: 6.5 months after BDB, 4.0 months after TBP, and 2.8 months after EBD. In a second group of 2,066 patients with primary and secondary malignant obstruction of the upper EHBD, treated with the insertion of a Carey-Coons transhepatic transtumoral biliary prosthesis, the average survival was 4.3 months. The early morbidity rate was 0.6%. Obstruction of the prosthesis occurred in 91 patients (4.4%), and the late morbidity rate was 3.6%. Although EHBD tumor treatment results are generally poor, surgical exploration should be performed in all patients with acceptable surgical risk, and without evidence of disseminated disease. When resection of the tumor is not feasible, we favor the use of a BDB or of a biliary prosthesis over that of an external drainage. In poor risk cases or cases with evidence of disseminated disease, we prefer the placement of an internal prosthesis (PTBD or endoscopic.

Intraoperative radiotherapy for unresectable cholangiocarcinoma--the Mayo Clinic experience

Thirteen patients with unresectable cholangiocarcinomas were treated with external beam radiation therapy (ERT) and intraoperative radiation therapy (IORT) in combination with biliary stenting. Local treatment failure occurred in 50% of the patients treated with curative intent and an additional two patients developed distant recurrent disease. Patient morbidity was primarily related to biliary sepsis and gastrointestinal complications. There was minimal morbidity related to the IORT. Although the median survival of 16.5 months seemed to be an improvement over our previous results for ERT alone or ERT with 5-fluorouracil, the survival data are still discouraging. Further improvements in treatment will require better means of biliary bypass and increased tumour response perhaps by the use of radiosensitizers or hyperthermia in conjunction with radiation therapy.

The management of problematic biliary calculi

Recent advances in modern medical technology have significantly reduced the number of patients with 'problematic calculi'. When a patient does present with a difficult bile duct stone, various non-surgical treatment options are now available. In experienced hands, with healthy or high-risk patients, percutaneous treatment is as safe and as efficacious as endoscopy or surgery. Since it does not require general anaesthesia, and patients recover much more quickly than after surgery, the percutaneous approach is preferred when endoscopy fails to achieve ductal clearance. Surgery is indicated for patients with lesions requiring surgical removal or correction, but seldom for removal of biliary calculi alone.

Radiation therapy for primary carcinoma of the extrahepatic biliary system. An analysis of 63 cases

From 1976 to 1988, 63 patients received radiation therapy for primary cancers of the extrahepatic biliary system (eight gallbladder and 55 extrahepatic biliary duct). Twelve patients underwent orthotopic liver transplantation. Chemotherapy was administered to 13 patients. Three patients underwent intraluminal brachytherapy alone (range, 28 to 55 Gy). Sixty patients received megavoltage external-beam radiation therapy (range, 5.4 to 61.6 Gy; median, 45 Gy), of whom nine received additional intraluminal brachytherapy (range, 14 to 45 Gy; median, 30 Gy). The median survival of all patients was 7 months. Sixty patients died, all within 39 months of radiation therapy. One patient is alive 11 months after irradiation without surgical resection, and two are alive 50 months after liver transplantation and irradiation. Symptomatic duodenal ulcers developed after radiation therapy in seven patients but were not significantly related to any clinical variable tested. Extrahepatic biliary duct cancers, the absence of metastases, increasing calendar year of treatment, and liver transplantation with postoperative radiation therapy were factors significantly associated with improved survival.

Therapeutic aspects of radio-isotopes in hepatobiliary malignancy

Liver tumours frequently present at a late stage and only a minority of patients are likely to benefit from resection or transplantation. Inoperable tumours carry a grave prognosis. External beam irradiation of the liver is dose-limited by the radiosensitivity of hepatocytes, particularly in the presence of cirrhosis, but internal radiation using radio-isotope sources can achieve more selective irradiation of the chosen field. Sealed sources are dose-limited by their effects on surrounding tissues, whereas with unsealed sources the dose of radio-isotope administered is limited by bone marrow suppression. Iridium-192 wires are most frequently employed as a sealed intracavitary source. They may be inserted surgically, transhepatically or endoscopically. Doses of up to 60 Gy can be delivered to a malignant biliary stricture without damage to the surrounding parenchyma. The incidence of cholangitis is low if treatment is administered after insertion of an endoprosthesis. Unsealed radio-isotope sources may be injected directly into the tumour, administered embolically via the hepatic artery in the form of microspheres or lipid droplets, or given via parenteral infusion attached to tumour-specific antibodies. Of these vehicles, the lipid agent Lipiodol appears to be the most effective and can deliver a potentially lethal dose of radiation to small tumours. Host reaction to the injected antibody remains a major drawback to the use of monoclonal antibodies as targeting agents. Iodine-131 is a beta- and gamma-emitter, producing a local tumoricidal effect and allowing accurate dosimetry by means of external scintigraphy. Yttrium-90 is a pure beta-emitter with a greater maximum beta energy and cytotoxic range; however, it is retained in bony tissues, resulting in a dose-related risk of marrow suppression. Bone absorption cannot be measured by external imaging owing to the absence of gamma emission. This lack of accurate dosimetry, coupled with the toxic side-effects of yttrium treatment, make iodine-131 the current isotope of choice.

Radiation therapy for primary carcinoma of the extrahepatic biliary system. An analysis of 63 cases

From 1976 to 1988, 63 patients received radiation therapy for primary cancers of the extrahepatic biliary system (eight gallbladder and 55 extrahepatic biliary duct). Twelve patients underwent orthotopic liver transplantation. Chemotherapy was administered to 13 patients. Three patients underwent intraluminal brachytherapy alone (range, 28 to 55 Gy). Sixty patients received megavoltage external-beam radiation therapy (range, 5.4 to 61.6 Gy; median, 45 Gy), of whom nine received additional intraluminal brachytherapy (range, 14 to 45 Gy; median, 30 Gy). The median survival of all patients was 7 months. Sixty patients died, all within 39 months of radiation therapy. One patient is alive 11 months after irradiation without surgical resection, and two are alive 50 months after liver transplantation and irradiation. Symptomatic duodenal ulcers developed after radiation therapy in seven patients but were not significantly related to any clinical variable tested. Extrahepatic biliary duct cancers, the absence of metastases, increasing calendar year of treatment, and liver transplantation with postoperative radiation therapy were factors significantly associated with improved survival.

Palliation of proximal malignant biliary obstruction by endoscopic endoprosthesis insertion

For four years up to December 1987, 190 patients (median age 73 years) with proximal malignant biliary obstruction were treated by endoscopic endoprosthesis insertion. Altogether 101 had cholangiocarcinoma, 21 gall bladder carcinoma, 20 local spread of pancreatic carcinoma, and 48 metastatic malignancy. Fifty eight patients had type I, 54 type II, and 78 type III proximal biliary strictures (Bismuth classification). All patients were either unfit or unsuitable for an attempt at curative surgical resection. A single endoprosthesis was placed initially, with a further stent being placed only if relief of cholestasis was insufficient or sepsis developed in undrained segments. The combined percutaneous-endoscopic technique was used to place the endoprosthesis when appropriate, after failed endoscopic endoprosthesis insertion or for second endoprosthesis placement. Full follow up was available in 97%. Thirteen patients were still alive at the time of review and all but one had been treated within the past six months. Initial endoprosthesis insertion succeeded technically at the first attempt in 127 patients, at the second in 30, and at a combined procedure in a further 13 (cumulative total success rate 89% - type I: 93%; type II: 94%; and type III: 84%). There was adequate biliary drainage after single endoprosthesis insertion in 152 of the 170 successful placements, giving an overall successful drainage rate of 80%. Three patients had a second stent placed by combined procedure because of insufficient drainage, giving an overall successful drainage rate of 82% (155 of 190). The final overall drainage success rates were type I: 91%; type II: 83%; and type III: 73%. The early complication rates were type I: 7%; type II: 14%; and type III: 31%. The principle early complication was clinical cholangitis, which occurred in 13 patients (7%) and required second stent placement in five. The 30 day mortality was 22% overall (type I: 14%; type II: 15%; and type III: 32%) but the direct procedure related mortality was only 3%. Median survival overall for types I, II, and III strictures were 21, 12, and 10 weeks respectively but survival was significantly shorter for metastatic than primary malignancy (p<0.05). Endoscopic insertion of a single endoprosthesis will provide good palliation of proximal malignant biliary obstruction caused by unresectable malignancy in 80% of patients. Second stents should be placed only if required. Extensive structuring because of metastatic disease carries a poor prognosis and careful patient selection for treatment is requires.

Role of radiation after operative palliation in cancer of the proximal bile ducts

Cancer of the proximal bile ducts continues to pose a formidable problem to even the most experienced biliary surgeon. From 1977 through 1985, 51 patients with histologically confirmed proximal bile duct cancers underwent surgical treatment. The lesion was confined to the hilar region in 30 patients; there was extensive hepatic infiltration or distant metastatic disease in 21 patients. One patient underwent resection. Biopsy only was performed in six patients. In the remaining 44 patients, transtumoral dilation and intubation were performed. These 44 patients were further analyzed with regard to how survival was affected by the presence of metastatic disease and by the adjunctive use of radiation therapy. Mean survival in those patients with metastatic disease (n = 16) was 6.1 months, and survival was not improved by the use of postoperative radiation. In the absence of metastatic or advanced local disease, however, the addition of external beam radiation did significantly extend the mean survival from 4.5 to 12.2 months and the median survival from 2.2 to 12.2 months. The operative mortality for the series was 14% and postoperative complications occurred in 18 patients. These findings suggest that the addition of external beam radiation improves survival in patients undergoing palliative treatment of hilar tumors. Further confirmation of the value of radiation awaits prospective investigation.

Cholangiocarcinoma

The diagnosis of cholangiocarcinoma can now be made with greater rapidity and accuracy. In the clinical setting of obstructive jaundice, a CT scan or sonogram may suggest cholangiocarcinoma if dilated intrahepatic ducts are seen with a nondilated extrahepatic biliary tree. The diagnosis is confirmed by cholangiography, and the tumor is staged by the combination of cholangiography and angiography. If the tumor extensively involves both lobes of the liver or involves the main portal vein or hepatic artery, the lesion is considered unresectable. These patients are best palliated nonoperatively, but they should still have an attempt at a tissue diagnosis, as various other lesions can masquerade as cholangiocarcinoma. In comparison, if the tumor is confined to or is distal to the hepatic duct bifurcation, extends into only one lobe of the liver, or involves only the right or the left portal vein or hepatic artery, the lesion may be resectable, and exploration is indicated. As many as half of all patients explored with curative intent will have a successful resection. Various surgical options are appropriate for patients undergoing tumor resection, depending on the site and extent of the lesion. Similarly, several surgical options are possible for palliation in patients with unresectable cholangiocarcinoma. The role of radiotherapy in the management of cholangiocarcinoma is uncertain. Our results, like those of many other retrospective analyses, suggest that radiotherapy prolongs survival after curative resection as well as after palliative stenting. However, further data from randomized studies are necessary to support or refute this impression. Further studies of adjuvant chemotherapy or hormonal therapy will also be necessary to improve patient survival.

Resective operations for biliary carcinoma

Records of 25 consecutive patients who underwent resection for proximal bile duct tumor (3 extended right hepatic lobectomies, 6 left hepatic lobectomies, 16 skeletonization resections) and records of 21 patients who underwent pancreatoduodenectomy for distal bile duct carcinoma were reviewed to assess the value of resective therapy. The operative mortality rate for patients with resected proximal bile duct tumor was 4 per cent (0 per cent for liver resection) and that of distal bile duct tumor, 4.6 per cent. The 3- and 5-year actuarial survival rates for patients with proximal bile duct tumor were 44 per cent and 35 per cent, respectively; all except one patient eventually died of disease. Survival was better for patients who had curative resection (margins microscopically free of tumor). The 5-year actuarial survival rate for patients with distal bile duct carcinoma was 58 +/- 12 (SE) per cent, with patients who had negative nodes surviving longer than patients with positive nodes. When major hepatic resection and pancreatoduodenectomy can be performed in selected patients with low operative mortality, patients with bile duct carcinoma should be assessed by an experienced hepatobiliary multidisciplinary group before a decision is made in favor of palliative, endoscopic, or percutaneous techniques because surgical resection appears to offer the best possible long-term survival and probably the best quality of palliation.

Management of proximal cholangiocarcinomas by surgical resection and radiotherapy

Ninety-six patients with proximal cholangiocarcinomas were managed surgically. Fifty-three patients (55 percent) were resected, 39 curatively (41 percent), and 43 (45 percent) underwent palliative stenting. The preoperative placement of Ring catheters and the operative use of silastic transhepatic biliary stents greatly facilitated the surgical management of these lesions. Sixty-three patients (66 percent) also received postoperative radiotherapy. Hospital mortality was 4 percent (four deaths). Hospital mortality was 2 percent after resection (1 of 53 patients) and 7 percent after palliative stenting (3 of 43 patients). All deaths resulted from sepsis. One, 3, 5, and 10-year survivals for the entire group were 49 percent, 12 percent, 5 percent, and 2 percent, respectively. One, 3, 5, and 10-year survivals in the resected group (66 percent, 21 percent, 8 percent, and 4 percent, respectively) were superior to those in the stented group (27 percent, 6 percent, 0 percent, and 0 percent, respectively). Radiotherapy appeared to significantly extend survival in those patients undergoing palliative stenting, but not in those undergoing resection. We conclude that surgical resection of proximal cholangiocarcinomas can be performed safely and that it significantly prolongs survival. Further improvement in long-term survival will depend on advances in adjuvant therapy.

Endoscopic management of inoperable cholangiocarcinoma using iridium-192

We report a well tolerated endoscopic technique of administering intraluminal radiotherapy to 14 patients with inoperable cholangiocarcinoma, in which the iridium-192 wire source was inserted down a nasobiliary catheter placed within a previously inserted endoscopic biliary prosthesis, thus allowing bile flow to continue during treatment. Radiotherapy was commenced 2 weeks after biliary decompression, when the median serum bilirubin level had fallen from 213 to 34 mumol/l. A total radiation dose of 6000 cGy at 0.5 cm from the source was administered over a median of 85 h (range 77-116 h). In four patients there was a transient increase in serum bilirubin during iridium treatment and, in two cases (14 per cent), this was associated with mild cholangitis. Both cases resolved rapidly once the iridium wire and nasobiliary catheter were removed. The median hospital stay after treatment was 2.5 days (range 0-28 days). The late complications associated with stent blockage were minimized by routinely changing stents at 4-6 monthly intervals; ten of the patients have so far undergone from one to five (median three) stent changes. Five patients have died at 3.6-8.2 months (median 4.8 months) following iridium treatment; four had extensive type III hilar lesions at diagnosis. Nine patients are still alive at 5.4-31.0 months (median 16.4 months). The overall median survival after iridium therapy is 10.5 months. This technique of endoscopic biliary decompression before internal iridium administration minimizes complications by allowing biliary drainage during treatment. The role of this treatment in patients with inoperable cholangiocarcinoma awaits the results of randomized, controlled trials.