A 14-year experience with kidney transplantation

Chronic hepatitis in end-stage renal disease: comparison of HBsAg-negative and HBsAg-positive patients

To determine the outcome of chronic hepatitis in ESRD we studied all 358 renal transplant recipients and 295 hemodialysis patients treated for greater than 1 year since 1970. The incidence of chronic hepatitis (elevated SGOT for greater than 1 year) was 15% (N = 54) in transplanted and 3.4% (N = 10) in dialysis patients. Forty-eight percent (26) of transplanted and 50% (5) of dialysis patients were HBsAg positive. In the transplanted group, the clinical outcome of chronic hepatitis was significantly better in HBsAg-negative compared to HBsAg-positive patients; 11% died, none from liver disease, and 32% remitted after a mean follow-up from start of liver disease of 77.3 +/- 8.2 months, whereas in the HBsAg-positive group 54% (14) died, nine from liver disease, and one remitted after a follow-up of 90.2 +/- 8.9 months. Adverse prognostic factors (age, duration of diabetes, and heart disease) present before ESRD treatment began were similar in both groups, as was duration of follow-up. Only 14% (2/14) of HBsAg-negative patients progressed to chronic active hepatitis on liver biopsy compared to 71% (15/21) of HBsAg-positive patients. Histological stability in those with serial biopsies occurred in 66% (4/6) of HBsAg-negative patients, but in only 18% (13/16) of HBsAg-positive patients with a similar duration of follow-up. No dialysis patients died from liver disease. We conclude that chronic hepatitis occurs more frequently in transplanted than dialyzed patients, and that HBsAg-negative chronic hepatitis has a more benign, clinical, and histological outcome than chronic HBsAg-positive hepatitis in renal transplant recipients.

Causes of death after kidney transplantation

During the five-year period September 1974 through August 1979, two hundred nine consecutive patients received their first kidney transplant in Denver. During 2.5 to 7.5 years of follow-up, 54 patients (26%) died. Infection was the leading cause of death during all intervals and was responsible for 22 (41%) of the 54 deaths. Pneumonia was primarily responsible for 14 of the 22 deaths from infection. The other causes of death were cardiovascular problems in 11 patients (20%), suicide in eight patients (15%), gastrointestinal (GI) tract problems in seven patients (13%), malignant neoplasms in two patients (4%), and miscellaneous problems in four patients (7%). Twenty-six (48%) of the 54 deaths occurred more than one year after primary transplantation; 12 of these 26 patients had already returned to chronic hemodialysis. To minimize mortality after transplantation, patients and their physicians must remain alert to the ongoing risks to which these patients are exposed, including the risks of sudden death from infection, myocardial infarction, pulmonary embolus, suicide, or GI tract perforation.

Renal isotransplantation without immunosuppression

Four renal isografts have been performed and all have had satisfactory function for 7 1/2 to 17 2/3 years without prophylactic or therapeutic immunosuppression. Three of these patients originally had glomerulonephritis, and in one there was histologic evidence of recurrent disease, 7 1/2 years after transplantation, without proteinura and without change in renal function. Although this experience is small, it suggests that prophylactic immunosuppression is not appropriate for recipients of renal isografts.

Should the ruptured renal allograft be removed?

During a 16-month period when 93 renal transplants were performed, eight kidney graft ruptures were detected within 18 days of transplantation, without evidence of venous obstruction. Six grafts were removed at the time of an exploratory operation for rupture and only one showed signs of probable irreversible rejection when examined by microscopy. Two graft ruptures were repaired and one of these grafts has had good long-term function 22 months later. These observations suggest that if bleeding at the site of grafts has had good long-term function 22 months later. These observations suggest that if bleeding at the site of graft rupture can be securely controlled and if the conditions of the patient and of the graft are favorable except for the rupture, it may be possible to save more than one of eight grafts.