Evolution of methionine initiator and phenylalanine transfer RNAs

Evolution of initiator tRNAs and selection of methionine as the initiating amino acid

Transfer RNAs (tRNAs) have been important in shaping biomolecular evolution. Initiator tRNAs (tRNAi), a special class of tRNAs, carry methionine (or its derivative, formyl-methionine) to ribosomes to start an enormously energy consuming but a highly regulated process of protein synthesis. The processes of tRNAi evolution, and selection of methionine as the universal initiating amino acid remain an enigmatic problem. We constructed phylogenetic trees using the whole sequence, the acceptor-TψC arm ('minihelix'), and the anticodon-dihydrouridine arm regions of tRNAi from 158 species belonging to all 3 domains of life. All the trees distinctly assembled into 3 domains of life. Large trees, generated using data for all the tRNAs of a vast number of species, fail to reveal the major evolutionary events and identity of the probable elongator tRNA sequences that could be ancestor of tRNAi. Therefore, we constructed trees using the minihelix or the whole sequence of species specific tRNAs, and iterated our analysis on 50 eubacterial species. We identified tRNA(Pro), tRNA(Glu), or tRNA(Thr) (but surprisingly not elongator tRNA(Met)) as probable ancestors of tRNAi. We then determined the factors imposing selection of methionine as the initiating amino acid. Overall frequency of occurrence of methionine, whose metabolic cost of synthesis is the highest among all amino acids, remains almost unchanged across the 3 domains of life. Our correlation analysis shows that its high metabolic cost is independent of many physicochemical properties of the side chain. Our results indicate that selection of methionine, as the initiating amino acid was possibly a consequence of the evolution of one-carbon metabolism, which plays an important role in regulating translation initiation.

Archetypical features in tRNA families

A compilation of known tRNA, and tRNA gene sequences from archaebacteria, eubacteria, and eukaryotes permits the construction of tRNA cloverleafs which show conserved structural elements for each tRNA family. Positions conserved across the three kingdoms are thought to represent archetypical features of tRNAs which preceded the divergence of these kingdoms.

A view of early cellular evolution

Some recent puzzling data on mitochondria put in question their place on the phylogenetic tree. A hypothesis, the archigenetic hypothesis, is presented, which generally agrees with Woese-Fox's concept of the common origin of eubacteria, archaebacteria, and eukaryotic hosts. However, for the first time, a case is made for the evolution of mitochondria from the ancient predecessors of pro- and eukaryotes (protobionts), not from eubacteria. Animal, fungal, and plant mitochondria are considered to be endosymbionts derived from independent free-living cells (mitobionts), which, having arisen at different developmental stages of protobionts, retained some of their ancient primitive features of the genetic code and the transcription-translation systems. The molecular-biological, bioenergetic, and paleontological aspects of this new concept of cellular evolution are discussed.

Primordial reading of genetic information

From the consideration of general features of the anticodon loop and stem in tRNA and the properties of present-day translation, we put forward a plausible scenario to explain the evolution of the genetic code from a highly ambiguous triplet code to the present refined decoding system. Our model based on the reading of the code suggests that the anticodon of primordial tRNA could adopt either the 3' or the 5' stacked conformation permitting the formation of the "best two out of three" base pairs, either the first and second codon position or the second and third. Progressive acquisition of precise structural constraint and the modification of bases in the anticodon loop would give way eventually to the less ambiguous "two out of three" reading mechanism having only the 3' stacked conformation. Further adjustments of base composition and modification leads inevitably to the present generalized code. In this way the primordial code encoding 4-8 amino acids or related derivates evolves smoothly to the present code having 20 amino acids.

Initiator tRNA may recognize more than the initiation codon in mRNA: a model for translational initiation

A special methionine tRNA (tRNAi) is universally required to initiate translation. Amongst species a tRNAi structural conservation is most apparent in the anticodon and T arms of the molecule but extends into the variable loop and the 3' strand of the D stem. This suggested that they could share a similar ancestral or current function in initiation of translation. We report that the sequence of bases neighboring the translational start codons of many eubacterial genes are complementary not only to the extended anticodon but also to the D and T loops of tRNAi. Study of the coding properties of tRNAi and of mutations that affect translation suggests that the translational start domain can be a mosaic of signals complementary to the loops of tRNAi. The hypothesis of multiple loop recognition suggests that unusual triplets can start prokaryotic and mitochondrial genes and predicts the occurrence of other reading frames. Furthermore, it suggests a unifying model for chain initiation based on RNA contacts and displacements.

Molecular organization of dinoflagellate ribosomal DNA: evolutionary implications of the deduced 5.8 S rRNA secondary structure

The 5.8 S rRNA gene of Prorocentrum micans, a primitive dinoflagellate, has been cloned and its 159 base pairs (bp) have been sequenced along with the two flanking internal transcribed spacers (ITS 1 and 2), respectively, 212 and 195 bp long. Nucleotide sequence homologies between several previously published 5.8 S rRNA gene sequences including those from another dinoflagellate, an ascomycetous yeast, protozoans, a higher plant and a mammal have been determined by sequence alignment. Two prokaryotic 5'-ends of the 23 S rRNA gene have been compared owing to their probable common origin with eucaryotic 5.8 S rRNA genes. Several nucleotides are distinctive for dinoflagellates when compared with either typical eucaryotes or procaryotes. This is consistent with an early divergence of the dinoflagellate lineage from the typical eucaryotes. The secondary structure of dinoflagellate 5.8 S rRNA molecules fits the model of Walker et al. (1983). Conserved nucleotides which distinguish dinoflagellate 5.8 S rRNA from that of other eucaryotes are located in specific loops which are assumed to play a structural role in the ribosome. A 5.8 S rRNA phylogenetic tree which is proposed, based on sequence data, supports our initial assumption of the dinoflagellates.

Phylogeny of transfer RNA

Phylogenetic trees of transfer RNA specific for phenylalanine, methionine initiator glycine and valine are constructed. Although the exact relationships between taxa cannot be obtained from the mere analysis of the sequences some conclusions can be drawn about the evolution of this molecule.

Clustering of transfer RNAs by cell type and amino acid specificity

Procaryotic and eucaryotic transfer RNA sequences are distinct at the 0.5% probability level as demonstrated by permutation testing. Moreover, within each cell type, transfer RNA sequences of different amino acid acceptor classes are distinct at the 0.1% level. We propose that the latter finding reflects sets of nucleotides, other than the anticodons themselves, that specifically relate the transfer RNAs to their respective amino acids. The utility of permutation testing is emphasized by the additional information this study provides compared to that of Holmquist et al. (1973), using the same data set.

The nucleotide sequence of blue-green algae phenylalanine-tRNA and the evolutionary origin of chloroplasts

Phenylalanine tRNA from the blue-green alga, Agmenellum quadruplicatum, has been purified to homogeneity. The nucleotide sequence of this tRNA was determined to be: (see tests) Comparisons of the sequence and the modified nucleosides of this tRNA with those of other tRNAPhes thus far sequenced, indicate that this blue green algal tRNAPhe is typically prokaryotic and closely resembles the chloroplast tRNAPhes of higher plants and Euglena. The significance of this observation to the evolutionary origin of chloroplasts is discussed.

A strategy for sequence phylogeny research

Minimal mutation trees, and almost minimal trees, are constructed from two data sets, one of phenylalanine tRNA sequences, and the other of 5S RNA sequences, from a diverse range of organisms. The two sets of results are mutually consistent. Trees representing previous evolutionary hypotheses are compared using a total weighted mutational distance criterion. The importance of sequence data from relatively little-studed phylogenetic lines is stressed. A procedure is illustrated which circumvents the computational difficulty of evaluating the astronomically large number of possible trees, without resorting to suboptimal methods.

An evaluation of the phylogenetic position of the dinoflagellate Crypthecodinium cohnii based on 5S rRNA characterization

Partial nucleotide sequences for the 5S and 5.8S rRNAs from the dinoflagellate Crypthecodinium cohnii have been determined, using a rapid chemical sequencing method, for the purpose of studying dinoflagellate phylogeny. The 5S RNA sequence shows the most homology (75%) with the 5S sequences of higher animals and the least homology (less than 60%) with prokaryotic sequences. In addition, it lacks certain residues which are highly conserved in prokaryotic molecules but are generally missing in eukaryotes. These findings suggest a distant relationship between dinoflagellates and the prokaryotes. Using two different sequence alignments and several different methods for selecting an optimum phylogenetic tree for selecting an optimum phylogenetic tree for a collection of 5S sequences including higher plants and animals, fungi, and bacteria in addition to the C. cohnii sequence, the dinoflagellate lineage was joined to the tree at the point of the plant-animal divergence well above the branching point of the fungi. This result is of interest because it implies that the well-documented absence in dinoflagellates of histones and the typical nucleosomal subunit structure of eukaryotic chromatin is the result of secondary loss, and not an indication of an extremely primitive state, as was previously suggested. Computer simulations of 5S RNA evolution have been carried out in order to demonstrate that the above-mentioned phylogenetic placement is not likely to be the result of random sequence convergence. We have also constructed a phylogeny for 5.8S RNA sequences in which plants, animals, fungi and the dinoflagellates are again represented. While the order of branching on this tree is the same as in the 5S tree for the organisms represented, because it lacks prokaryotes, the 5.8S tree cannot be considered a strong independent confirmation of the 5S result. Moreover, 5.8S RNA appears to have experienced very different rates of evolution in different lineages indicating that it may not be the best indicator of evolutionary relationships. We have also considered the existing biological data regarding dinoflagellate evolution in relation to our molecular phylogenetic evidence.

Transfer-RNA: the early adaptor

Evolutionary history of tRNA is studied by comparative sequence analysis of two specified tRNA's at various phylogenetic levels and of tRNA families within four different species. Criteria are developed that allow 1) to distinguish between convergent and divergent evolution, 2) to determine the mechanism of divergence and 3) to estimate the degree of randomization of the variable parts of the sequences. The conclusion of these investigations is that tRNA's represent ancient molecules that existed in the form of a mutant distribution prior to their integration into genomes.

The evolving tRNA molecule

The study of tRNA molecular evolution is crucial to understanding the origin and establishment of the genetic code as well as the differentiation and refinement of the machinery of protein synthesis in prokaryotes, eukaryotes, organelles, and phage systems. The small size of the molecule and its critical involvement in a multiplicity of roles distinguish its study from classical protein molecular evolution with respect to goals and methods. Here, the authors assess available and missing data, existing and needed methodology, and the impact of tRNA studies on current theories both of genetic code evolution and of the evolution of species. They analyze mutational "hot spots", the role of base modification, synthetase recognition, codon-anticodon interactions and the status of organelle tRNA.

Distinctive sequence of human mitochondrial ribosomal RNA genes

The nucleotide sequence spanning the ribosomal RNA (rRNA) genes of cloned human mitochondrial DNA reveals an extremely compact genome organization wherein the putative tRNA genes are probably 'butt-jointed' around the two rRNA genes. The sequences of the rRNA genes are significantly homologous in some regions to eukaryotic and prokaryotic sequences, but distinctive; the tRNA genes also have unusual nucleotide sequences. It seems that human mitochondria did not originate from recognizable relatives of present day organisms.