Common variable immunodeficiency and malignancy: a report of two cases and possible explanation for the association

Cancer Trends in Inborn Errors of Immunity: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

BACKGROUND

Patients with inborn errors of immunity (IEI) are susceptible to developing cancer due to defects in the immune system. The prevalence of cancer is higher in IEI patients compared to the immunocompetent population and cancers are considered as an important and common cause of death in IEI patients.

OBJECTIVES

To systematically review demographic, genetic and cancer-related data of IEI patients with a history of malignancy. Moreover, we performed a meta-analysis aiming to determine the frequency of cancer in patients with different types of IEI.

METHODS

We conducted electronic searches on Embase, Web of Science, PubMed, and Scopus (until September 2023) introducing terms related to IEI and cancer. Studies with human subjects with confirmed IEI who had developed at least one malignancy during their lifetime were included.

RESULTS

A total number of 4607 IEI patients with a cancer history were included in the present study. Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) had the highest number of reported cases (1284 cases), mainly due to a higher relative proportion of patients with predominantly antibody deficiencies (PAD) and their increased life expectancy contributing to the higher detection and reporting of cancers among these patients. The most common malignancy was hematologic/blood cancers (3026 cases, mainly diffuse large B cell lymphoma). A total number of 1173 cases (55.6%) succumbed to cancer, with the highest rate of bone marrow failure (64.9%). Among the patients with monogenic defects in IEI-associated genes, the majority of cases had ATM deficiency (926 cases), but the highest cancer frequency rate belonged to NBS1 deficiency (50.5%). 1928 cases out of total 4607 eligible cases had detailed data to allow further statistical analysis that revealed BRCA2 deficiency had the earliest cancer development (~ 38 months), lowest cure frequency, and highest fatality rate (85%), while ATM deficiency had the lowest cure frequency and highest fatality rate (72%) among total cases reviewed with exclusion of Fanconi anemia.

CONCLUSION

The overall reported cancer frequency in the cases reviewed with and without exclusion of Fanconi anemia was 11.1% (95% confidence interval: 9.8-12.5%) and 12.0% (95% confidence interval: 10.6-13.5%), respectively. Our study revealed that the incidence of cancer is significantly dependent on the molecular and pathway defects in IEI patients, and individualized early screening and appropriate treatment, might improve the prognosis of these patients.

The impact of immune dysregulation on the risk of malignancy in common variable immunodeficiency: insights from a multicenter study

Background

Common Variable Immunodeficiency (CVID) represents a heterogenic group of primary immunodeficiencies (PID) characterized by impaired antibody production and susceptibility to infections. Non-infectious complications, such as autoimmune diseases, lymphoproliferative disorders, and malignancies, now significantly impact prognosis. Moreover, both hematologic and solid organ malignancies are more frequently observed in CVID patients compared to other PIDs. The risk factors for carcinogenesis in CVID remain largely unknown.

Objective

This multicenter study aims to characterize the clinical profile of cancer in CVID patients in Spain and to identify independent risk factors associated with malignancy development, focusing on the role of immune dysregulation.

Methods

A nationwide, cross-sectional study was conducted from November 2019 to May 2022, involving 17 hospitals treating PID patients in Spain. Data were collected systematically on demographics, infectious and non-infectious comorbidities, immunological parameters, and treatment. Statistical analysis, including multivariate logistic regression, was performed to identify risk factors associated to malignancy.

Results

Of 250 CVID patients, 38 (15.26%) were diagnosed with cancer, predominantly non-Hodgkin lymphoma, gastric cancer, and lung adenocarcinoma. Cancer patients were significantly older (mean age 60.70 vs. 49.36 years, p<0.001) and had higher rates of immune dysregulation (81.58% vs. 59.7%, p=0.01). Immune dysregulation was an independent risk factor for cancer (OR 2.19, p=0.04), alongside previous immunosuppressant therapy (OR 2, p=0.031), higher IgM levels (OR 1.008 per SD, p=0.012), older age (OR 1.04, p<0.001), and lower CD4 cell counts at diagnosis (OR 0.997, p<0.001).

Conclusions

This study highlights the increased cancer risk in CVID patients, with immune dysregulation, prior immunosuppressant use, elevated IgM levels, and lower CD4 cell counts as conjointly associated. These findings underscore the need for vigilant cancer screening and tailored management strategies in CVID patients to improve outcomes. Future research should focus on elucidating the molecular mechanisms linking immune dysregulation and malignancy in CVID.

Immunogenetics of gastrointestinal cancers: A systematic review and retrospective survey of inborn errors of immunity in humans

BACKGROUND AND AIM

Humans with inborn errors of immunity (IEI), or primary immunodeficiencies, may be associated with a potential risk factor for early-onset gastrointestinal (GI) cancer.

METHODS

We systematically reviewed all cases with clinical diagnoses of both an IEI and a GI cancer in three databases (MEDLINE, SCOPUS, and EMBASE). In total, 76 publications satisfying our inclusion criteria were identified, and data for 149 cases were analyzed. We also searched our institutional cancer registry for such cases.

RESULTS

We identified 149 patients with both an IEI and a GI cancer, 95 presented gastric cancer, 13 small bowel cancer, 35 colorectal cancer, and 6 had an unspecified cancer or cancer at another site. Gastric and colon adenocarcinomas were the most common. For both gastric and colorectal cancers, age at onset was significantly earlier in patients with IEIs than in the general population, based on the SEER database. Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) was the most common IEI associated with gastrointestinal cancer. About 12% of patients had molecular genetic diagnoses, the three most frequently implicated genes being ATM, CARMIL2, and CTLA4. Impaired humoral immunity and Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) infection were frequently reported as factors potentially underlying early-onset GI cancers in patients with IEIs. We identified one patient with CVID and early-onset gastric adenocarcinoma, recurrent diarrhea, and gastrointestinal CMV infection from a retrospective survey.

CONCLUSION

Patients with IEIs should be considered at risk of early-onset GI cancers and should therefore undergo cancer screening at an earlier age.

Altered Spectrum of Lymphoid Neoplasms in a Single-Center Cohort of Common Variable Immunodeficiency with Immune Dysregulation

Purpose

Common variable immune deficiency (CVID) confers an increased risk of lymphoid neoplasms, but reports describing the precise WHO specification of the lymphoma subtypes and their immunological environment are lacking. We therefore classified lymphomas—occurring in a cohort of 21 adult CVID patients during a 17-year period at our center—according to the 2016 WHO classification and characterized the local and systemic immunological context

Results

The median time between the onset of CVID and lymphoma was 14 years. Patients showed a high prevalence of preceding immune dysregulation: lymphadenopathy (n = 13, 62%), splenomegaly (n = 18, 86%), autoimmune cytopenia (n = 14, 67%), and gastrointestinal involvement (n = 15, 71%). The entities comprised extranodal marginal zone lymphoma (n = 6), diffuse large B cell lymphoma (n = 7), plasmablastic lymphoma (n = 1), classic Hodgkin lymphoma (n = 4, including three cases with germline CTLA4 mutations), T cell large granular lymphocytic leukemia (n = 2), and peripheral T cell lymphoma, not otherwise specified (n = 1), but no follicular lymphoma. An Epstein-Barr virus association was documented in eight of 16 investigated lymphomas. High expression of PDL1 by tumor cells in five and of PDL1 and PD1 by tumor-infiltrating macrophages and T cells in 12 of 12 investigated lymphomas suggested a tolerogenic immunological tumor environment.

Conclusion

In summary, a diverse combination of specific factors like genetic background, chronic immune activation, viral trigger, and impaired immune surveillance contributes to the observed spectrum of lymphomas in CVID. In the future, targeted therapies, e.g., PD1/PDL1 inhibitors in CVID associated lymphomas with a tolerogenic environment may improve therapy outcome.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10875-021-01016-4.

Evaluation of Radiation Sensitivity in Patients with Hyper IgM Syndrome

BACKGROUND

HIGM syndrome is a rare form of primary immunodeficiencies characterized by normal/increased amounts of serum IgM and decreased serum levels of other switched immunoglobulin classes. Since the affected patients are continuously infected with various types of pathogens and are susceptible for cancers, diagnostic and therapeutic tests including imaging techniques are recommended for the diagnosis and treatment of these patients, which predispose them to higher accumulated doses of radiation. Given the evidence of class switching recombination machinery defect and its association with an increased rate of DNA repair, we aimed to evaluate radiation sensitivity among a group of patients diagnosed with HIGM syndrome.

METHODS

19 HIGM patients (14 CD40 L and 3 AID deficiencies and 2 unsolved cases without known genetic defects) and 17 control subjects (10 healthy subjects as negative control group, 7 ataxia-telangiectasia patients as positive control group) were enrolled. G2 assay was carried out for the determination of radiosensitivity.

RESULTS

Based on radiation-induced chromosomal changes among the studied HIGM patients and their comparison with the controls, almost all (95%) the patients had degrees of radiosensitivity: 6 patients with low to moderate, 1 patient with moderate, 11 patients with severe and 1 patient without radiation sensitivity.

CONCLUSION

Today, X-ray radiation plays a very important role in diagnostic and therapeutic procedures; while increased exposure has devastating effects especially in radiosensitive patients. Considering higher sensitivity in HIGM patients, utilizing radiation-free techniques could partly avoid unnecessary and high-level exposure to radiation, thus preventing or reducing its harmful effects on the affected patients.

In vitro chromosomal radiosensitivity in patients with common variable immunodeficiency

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is one of the predominant antibody deficiency disorders, some evidence of which indicates that chromosome instability is present in these patients. An increased risk of cancer in patients with CVID has been documented. This study was undertaken to highlight radiation sensitivity in CVID patients and to clarify the genetic basis of this defect in these cases. Stimulated lymphocytes of the studied subjects were exposed to low-dose gamma-rays in the G2 phase or the G0 phase of the cell cycle and chromosomal aberrations were scored. Lymphocytes of healthy individuals, ataxia telangiectasia (AT) cases and a group of acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL) patients were investigated in the same way as controls. By two methods of analysis (one-way ANOVA and unpaired t-test), the CVID cases were significantly more radiosensitive than healthy controls based on the results of the G2 and the G0 assays. First-degree relatives of CVID patients were radiosensitive by the micronucleus assay which showed a significant difference as compared with normal controls (p = 0.001). In conclusion, this study may support that chromosomal radiosensitivity in CVID patients is a marker of genetic predisposition to the disease. The results might be a clue to describe the increased risk of cancer in CVID patients.

Epidemiology and pathophysiology of malignancy in common variable immunodeficiency?

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is a diagnostic category of primary immunodeficiency (PID) which may present with heterogeneous disorders including recurrent infections, autoimmunity, granulomatous diseases, lymphoid and other types of malignancies. Generally, the incidence of malignancy in CVID patients is around 1.5-20.7% and usually occurs during the 4th-6th decade of life. Non-Hodgkin lymphoma is the most frequent malignancy, followed by epithelial tumours of stomach, breast, bladder and cervix. The exact pathological mechanisms for cancer development in CVID are not fully determined; however, several mechanisms including impaired genetic stability, genetic predisposition, immune dysregulation, impaired clearance of oncogenic viruses and bacterial infections, and iatrogenic causes have been proposed to contribute to the high susceptibility of these patients to malignancies.

Approach to the Management of Autoimmunity in Primary Immunodeficiency

Primary immunodeficiency diseases (PIDs) consist of a genetically heterogeneous group of immune disorders that affect distinct elements of the immune system. PID patients are more prone to infections and non-infectious complications, particularly autoimmunity. The concomitance of immunodeficiency and autoimmunity appears to be paradoxical and leads to difficulty in the management of autoimmune complications in PID patients. Therefore, management of autoimmunity in patients with PID requires special considerations because dysregulations and dysfunctions of the immune system along with persistent inflammation impair the process of diagnosis and treatment.

Immunodeficiency, radiosensitivity, and the XCIND syndrome

Through the analysis of a rare disorder called ataxia-telangiectasia (A-T), many important biological lessons have been gleaned. Today, it is clear that the underlying defect of A-T lies in the nucleus, as an inability to repair or process double strand breaks. More important, by the A-T phenotype now allows us to appreciate a much more general distinction between immunodeficiencies that are radiosensitive and those that are not.

Hypogammaglobulinémies primitives découvertes à l’âge adulte

Hypogammaglobulinemia during adulthood can lead to recurrent infectious diseases, particularly pneumonia, otitis, and sinusitis, mainly due to Streptococcus pneumoniae and Haemophilus influenzae. Physicians must discriminate between primary and secondary hypogammaglobulinemia to provide appropriate treatment. Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is the most common cause of primary hypogammaglobulinemia diagnosed in adulthood. Clinical features include various combinations of infectious diseases, autoimmune diseases, lymphoproliferative disorders, and gastrointestinal diseases. Mutations in genes responsible for primary hypogammaglobulinemia in children are occasionally described in adults with CVID. ICOS and TACI deficiencies have recently been reported in a few CVID patients, although most cases have no proven genetic defects. The DefI cohort is recruiting adults with CVID throughout France. It will make it possible to describe the clinical, immunological, and genetic features of French patients with hypogammaglobulinemia and will help us to understand this immune deficiency better.

In vitro chromosomal radiosensitivity in common variable immune deficiency

Common variable immune deficiency (CVID) is characterized by low immunoglobulin levels and recurrent infections in patients with a period of normal immune function several years after birth. It is associated with diarrhea, malabsorption, bronchiectasis, and lymphoreticular malignancies. Radiation-induced chromosome instability may contribute to the high degree of susceptibility to neoplasia. Peripheral blood lymphocyte cultures were obtained from six patients with CVID and the healthy control group matched by age and sex. The groups did not differ in the frequency of spontaneous chromosome aberrations. After exposure to X-ray radiation, mitotic indices were found to be significantly low and incidence of chromosomal alterations were high in the CVID group. We conclude that chromosomes of cells from patients with CVID are significantly more radiosensitive than those of controls. Thus these patients must be protected from unnecessary X-ray examinations and in case of radiosensitive tumour, the dose of irradiation should be carefully monitored.

Severe aplastic anemia in a patient with primary immunodeficiency

This paper reports the case of a 6 year old boy with primary immunodeficiency disease, whose marrow cells showed dyshematopoietic features, that was subsequently transformed to severe aplastic anemia. He was first diagnosed as having congenital immunodeficiency comprising deficiency of immunoglobulin A (IgA), IgG2 and IgG4, depressed mitogen responses, lymphopenia with inverted CD4/CD8 ratio and an increased proportion of T-cell receptor gamma/delta-bearing cells. Cytogenetic study of the peripheral blood showed a normal karyotype of 46,XY, but that of the marked hypoplastic marrow demonstrated one cell with monosomy 7 and another with trisomy 8 in the 20 cells examined.

Chromosomal radiosensitivity in common variable immune deficiency

From more than 500 tumours reported in human primary immune deficiencies a majority has been observed in two disorders: ataxia telangiectasia (A-T) and common variable immune deficiency (CVID). Since both diseases have an increased risk of lymphomas/leukaemias and gastrointestinal tumours, suggesting a common risk factor, and the cells derived from A-T patients exhibit an increased chromosomal radiosensitivity we analysed chromosome damage in the G2 lymphocytes of 24 CVID patients and 21 controls after X-irradiation in vitro. There was a significant difference in mean aberration yields between patients and controls. Three CVID patients had yields higher than the mean + 3SD of the controls. Six patients but only one control had yields higher than the mean + 2SD of controls. The patient with the highest chromosomal radiosensitivity subsequently developed a lymphoma. Repeat assays on the same blood sample, with a 24-h delay in setting up the second culture, showed as much variability for control donors as the variation between control donors although for CVID patients inter-individual variation was greater than the difference between results of repeat samples. There was a weak positive correlation between radiosensitivity and age of donor. Chromosomal radiosensitivity of five patients with X-linked hypogammaglobulinaemia was not different from healthy donors. The mean mitotic index (MI) for unirradiated samples from CVID patients was significantly lower than for controls and there was an inverse relationship between MI and aberration yields in the patients, but not in controls. We suggest that the defect in CVID patients that reduces response to mitogenic stimuli may have mechanism(s) in common with those involved in cellular repair processes.

Preferential damage to IgM production by ultraviolet B in the cells of patients with Bloom's syndrome

In most patients with Bloom's syndrome (BS), selective IgM deficiency is commonly found. We examined proliferative responses by incorporation of [3H]-thymidine and the production of immunoglobulin after ultraviolet B (UVB) irradiation in the cells of two patients with BS. With regard to the proliferative responses in peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) cultured with pokeweed mitogen (PWM), the patients' PBMC were more sensitive to UVB irradiation than controls. Although the effect of UVB irradiation in lymphoblastoid cell lines (LCL) after 0 days of culture showed no difference between one patient and controls, the patient's LCL were more sensitive to UVB than the controls after 3 and 7 days of culture. These results suggest that the proliferative responses of the patient's LCL recovered later than those of controls. IgM production was the most sensitive to UVB in the patients' PBMC and LCL. IgG and IgA production in the patients' PBMC and LCL showed the same sensitivity as controls. From our results, it is suspected that the preferential damage to IgM production by UVB is connected with the selective IgM deficiency of BS.