"Benign" acute subdural haematomas. Analysis of 12 cases

Acute posttraumatic subdural hematomas: "intradural" computed tomographic appearance as a favorable prognostic factor

OBJECTIVE

Posttraumatic acute subdural hematoma carries a high postoperative mortality rate. Preservation of subarachnoid spaces in preoperative computed tomographic (CT) scans may be interpreted as a favorable prognostic factor.

METHODS

Thirty-one cases of posttraumatic acute subdural hematoma operated on consecutively, with an interval from trauma to surgery of less than 4 hours and a Glasgow Coma Scale score of less than 8, were reviewed. The immediate and long-term results were evaluated with reference to preoperative CT images, distinguishing cases with preserved subarachnoid spaces from the others.

RESULTS

In 5 of the 31 cases, preoperative CT scans showed intact subarachnoid spaces and the absence of blood in the cerebrospinal fluid. These cases presented a much better postoperative course than did the others.

CONCLUSION

The presence of intact subarachnoid spaces in CT scans for patients with acute subdural hematomas may be interpreted as an extremely favorable prognostic factor; this may be attributed to the protective effect of the integral visceral membrane of the hematoma, which prevents the diffusion of neurotoxic and vasoactive substances into the subarachnoid spaces. This group of hematomas was classified as "intradural," with reference to the concept of the "subdural compartment" described in studies conducted using an electron microscope.

Prognostic factors in severely head injured adult patients with acute subdural haematoma's

A medline search back to 1975 was undertaken to identify relevant papers published on subdural haematomas. The search was restricted, whenever possible, to adult age and comatose patients. Forty relevant reports were identified. Only 3 papers reported results on multivariate analysis. In terms of prognosis, the following parameters were found to be significant: age, time from injury to treatment, presence of pupillary abnormalities, GCS/motor score on admission, immediate coma or lucid interval, CT findings (haematoma volume, degree of midline shift, associated intradural lesion, compression of basal cisterns), post-operative ICP and the type of surgery. Improving the outcome of patients with acute subdural haematoma's is a difficult task. A small subpopulation of patients may have a benign course without surgical haematoma evacuation, but all comatose patients with an acute subdural haematoma should be treated in Centers where neurosurgical facilities and appropriate monitoring are available.

Prognostic factors after acute subdural hematoma

Factors that have been shown to affect outcome after acute subdural hematoma (ASDH) include age, Injury Severity Score (ISS), intracranial pressure (ICP), direct admission to a trauma center, presence of subarachnoid hemorrhage, score on the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS), and timing of operation. However, these data come from selected patient populations (e.g., operated, comatose, or minimally symptomatic patients, etc.). In an effort to evaluate factors that predict outcome for the entire spectrum of ASDH patients, we evaluated 211 patients with ASDH and GCS scores of 3 to 15. One hundred twenty-eight patients (61%) were managed nonoperatively (Nonop), whereas 83 (39%) were managed with craniotomy [operatively (Op)]. Op patients had more severe brain injuries, as evidenced by their lower GCS scores (Op 7.8 vs. Nonop 10.7, p = 0.0001), higher incidence of large ASDH with midline shift (Op 61% large ASDH, 83% midline shift vs. Nonop 16% large ASDH, 30% midline shift, p = 0.001 for each comparison), and higher incidence of basilar cistern effacement (Op 61% vs. Nonop 21%, p = 0.001). Thirty-five percent of the Op patients had their hematoma evacuated within 4 hours (early), whereas 65% did not (delayed). Early Op patients had a significantly lower incidence of functional survival (early = 24% vs. delayed = 51%, p = 0.02). The early patients seem to have had more significant head injuries, as evidenced by their lower GCS scores (early = 7.0 vs. delayed = 8.4), higher incidence of associated intracranial injuries (early = 1.14 vs. delayed = 0.85), and higher incidence of cistern effacement (early = 76% vs. delayed = 53%, p = 0.002).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Head injuries in the elderly

Two hundred and sixty-three consecutive head-injured patients aged over 65 years, admitted to a neurosurgical service, are reported. In contrast to younger age group the main cause was falls concomitant with a high rate of cardiovascular pre-existing disorders. The distribution of causes and grim results justify, in our opinion, regarding head injury in the elderly as a distinct entity requiring special surgical, medical, organizational and ethical considerations.

Acute subdural haematoma in adults: an analysis of outcome in comatose patients

The authors analysed a series of 200 adult patients admitted to the Department of Neurosurgery, Medical University of Lódź with a diagnosis of acute subdural haematoma (ASDH). 63% of them were surgically treated within the first 4 hours after head injury, the others were operated on 4 to 16 hours after trauma. All patients had GCS below 10 for the whole time period from trauma to surgery. Younger patients 18-30 year old had lower mortality-25%, while patients above 50 revealed 75% mortality. Analysis of operative timing and outcome, no benefit revealed when surgery was performed within first 4 hours. However, the patients operated on later than 4 hours after trauma had smaller midline shift and less pronounced brain contusion. It must be taken into account that some patients who could benefit from early surgery-those with quickly developing haematomas and intracranial hypertension-had no chance to arrive and died in peripheral hospitals. Despite our results we advocate an urgent evacuation of haematoma, as early as possible after trauma. Significant correlation was found between midline shift, cerebral contusion on CT scans and results of surgery. Patients with bigger midline shift or presence of focal cerebral contusion revealed higher mortality and worse outcome than patients with smaller shift and no cerebral contusion visible on CT pictures.