Three missense mutations in the galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase gene of three families with mild galactosaemia

Mutation spectrum in the French cohort of galactosemic patients and structural simulation of 27 novel missense variations

BACKGROUND

Classic galactosemia refers to galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) deficiency and is characterized by long-term complications of unknown mechanism and high allelic heterogeneity of GALT gene.

AIM

To report molecular characterization of GALT variations in 210 French families, to analyze the structural effects of novel missense variations and to assess informativity of structural data in predicting outcome.

METHODS

Sequencing of exons and intron-exon junctions of GALT gene was completed in unsolved cases by analysis of a long range PCR product. Structural consequences of novel missense variations were predicted using a homology model of GALT protein and a semi-automated analysis which integrates simulation of variations, structural analyses and two web servers dedicated to identify mutation-induced change of protein stability.

RESULTS

Forty four novel variations were identified, among them 27 nucleotide substitutions. In silico modeling of these missense variations showed that 12 variations are predicted to impair subunit interactions and/or active site conformation and that 23 variations modify H-bond or salt-bridge networks. Twenty variations decrease the global stability of the protein. Five variations had apparently no structural effect.

CONCLUSION

Our results expand the mutation spectrum in GALT gene and the list of GALT variations analyzed at the structural level, providing new data to assess the pathophysiology of galactosemia.

Simultaneous amplification, detection, and analysis of common mutations in the galactose-1-phosphate uridyl transferase gene

Classic galactosemia is an autosomal recessive inherited error of galactose metabolism. It is caused by lack of galactose-1-phosphate uridyl transferase, an enzyme that is required to metabolize galactose-1-phosphate to uridine diphosphate galactose. The build up of galactose-1-phosphate is toxic at high levels and can damage the liver, brain, eyes, and other vital organs. Over 200 mutations have been identified in affected individuals. We describe an assay to identify nine target mutations or variants in the galactose-1-phosphate uridyl transferase gene, namely p.Q188R, p.S135L, p.K285N, p.L195P, p.T138M, p.Y209C, IVS2-2 A>G, p.L218L, and p.N314D. A single long-range PCR is followed by a multiplexed nucleotide extension assay (single nucleotide extension) and capillary electrophoresis to detect simultaneously all nine target mutations/variants. Fifty-four previously characterized samples (47 clinical samples and seven controls) gave a 100% concordance. We also report a nontarget novel mutation, p.L192X, and its profile using single nucleotide extension. This assay can complement the enzyme activity assay and identify familial mutations for testing additional family members.

Structure-function analyses of a common mutation in blacks with transferase-deficiency galactosemia

We previously identified a missense mutation at amino acid 135 of human galactose 1-phosphate uridyltransferase (hGALT) in which a leucine (TTG) was substituted for a serine (TCG), S135L. This mutation was common in black patients with galactosemia and homozygotes (S135L/S135L) had no GALT activity or protein in their erythrocytes or lymphoblasts. However, there was residual GALT activity and protein in their leukocytes, and they had near normal total body [13C]galactose oxidation to 13CO2 in breath. To evaluate the biochemical mechanism(s) producing these effects, we overexpressed hGALT proteins with site-directed mutations in this nonconserved amino acid in a GALT-minus Escherichia coli. Enzyme activities detected in bacterial lysates overexpressing either S135 (wild type), A135, C135, H135, L135, S132-H135, T135, or Y135 were 100, 4.7, 3.0, 4.0, 2.7, 0.7, 35.4, and 1.4%, respectively. Only the threonine substitution (S135T) had significant enzyme activity in these lysates. There was also decreased abundance of all mutant proteins in the lysates exposed to bacterial proteolysis during preparation and analysis. This added the variable of bio-instability to analysis of enzyme activities in lysates. To further characterize the catalytic role of serine at amino acid 135 and to differentiate bio-instability from impaired catalysis by the leucine substitution, we purified wild-type and L135-hGALT proteins to homogeneity and analyzed identical amounts of enzyme protein. We found that the apparent Vmax of the purified L135-hGALT protein was significantly reduced from 80 +/- 5.9 to 5.8 +/- 1.8 micromol glucose 1-phosphate released/min/mg hGALT protein with no increase in KM for galactose 1-phosphate for the second displacement. The first displacement reaction, although three orders of magnitude slower, was similar between the wild type and L135-hGALT. We conclude that a hydroxyl group on amino acid 135 is required for the catalysis of uridyl transfer from UDP-glucose to UDP-galactose in the presence of galactose 1-phosphate, and plays a role in the bio-stability of hGALT.

Relationship between genotype, activity, and galactose sensitivity in yeast expressing patient alleles of human galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase

Impairment of the human enzyme galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT) results in the potentially lethal disorder galactosemia; the biochemical basis of pathophysiology in galactosemia remains unknown. We have applied a yeast expression system for human GALT to test the hypothesis that genotype will correlate with GALT activity measured in vitro and with metabolite levels and galactose sensitivity measured in vivo. In particular, we have determined the relative degree of functional impairment associated with each of 16 patient-derived hGALT alleles; activities ranged from null to essentially normal. Next, we utilized strains expressing these alleles to demonstrate a clear inverse relationship between GALT activity and galactose sensitivity. Finally, we monitored accumulation of galactose-1-P, UDP-gal, and UDP-glc in yeast expressing a subset of these alleles. As reported for humans, yeast deficient in GALT, but not their wild type counterparts, demonstrated elevated levels of galactose 1-phosphate and diminished UDP-gal upon exposure to galactose. These results present the first clear evidence in a genetically and biochemically amenable model system of a relationship between GALT genotype, enzyme activity, sensitivity to galactose, and aberrant metabolite accumulation. As such, these data lay a foundation for future studies into the underlying mechanism(s) of galactose sensitivity in yeast and perhaps other eukaryotes, including humans.

Classical galactosemia and mutations at the galactose-1-phosphate uridyl transferase (GALT) gene

Classical galactosemia is caused by a deficiency in activity of the enzyme galactose-1-phosphate uridyl transferase (GALT), which, in turn, is caused by mutations at the GALT gene. The disorder exhibits considerable allelic heterogeneity and, at the end of 1998, more than 150 different base changes were recorded in 24 different populations and ethnic groups in 15 countries worldwide. The mutations most frequently cited are Q188R, K285N, S135L, and N314D. Q188R is the most common mutation in European populations or in those predominantly of European descent. Overall, it accounts for 60-70% of mutant chromosomes, but there are significant differences in its relative frequency in individual populations. Individuals homoallelic for Q188R tend to have a severe phenotype and this is in keeping with the virtually complete loss of enzyme activity observed in in vitro expression systems. Globally, K285N is rarer, but in many European populations it can be found on 25-40% of mutant chromosomes. It is invariably associated with a severe phenotype. S135L is found almost exclusively in African Americans. In vitro expression results are discrepant, but some individuals carrying S135L appear to exhibit GALT activity in some tissues. Duarte 1 (or Los Angeles) and Duarte 2 (or Duarte) variants carry the same amino acid substitution, N314D, even though D1 is associated with increased erythrocyte GALT activity and D2 with reduced activity. N314D is in linkage disequilibrium with other base changes that differ on the D1 and D2 alleles. N314D does not impair GALT activity in in vitro expression systems. However, there are differences in the abundance of GALT protein in lymphoblastoid cells lines from D2 and D1 individuals. It is unclear whether the specific molecular changes that distinguish the D1 and D2 alleles account for the different activities. The considerable genetic heterogeneity documented to date undoubtedly contributes to the phenotypic heterogeneity that is observed in galactosemia. The additional effects of nonallelic variation and other constitutional factors on phenotypic variability remain to be elucidated.

The molecular biology of galactosemia

Classic galactosemia is an autosomal recessive disorder caused by the deficiency of galactose 1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT). Although the potentially lethal, neonatal hepatotoxic syndrome is prevented by newborn screening and galactose restriction, long-term outcome for older patients with galactosemia remains problematic. After the cloning and sequencing of the GALT gene, more than 130 mutations in the GALT gene have been associated with GALT deficiency; this review relates them to function and clinical outcome. Two common mutations, Q188R and K285N, account for more than 70% of G alleles in the white population and are associated with classic galactosemia and impaired GALT function. In the black population, S135L accounts for 62% of the alleles causing galactosemia and is associated with good outcomes. A large 5 kb deletion in the GALT gene is found in Ashkenazim Jews. The Duarte galactosemia variant is caused by N314D. Homozygosity for N314D reduces GALT activity to 50%. When either E203K or a 1721C-->T transition (Los Angeles variant) are present in cis with N314D, GALT activity reverts to normal. In this review, we discuss the structural biology of these mutations as they affect both the GALT enzyme and patient outcome.

Newborn screening for galactosemia: ultramicro assay for galactose-1-phosphate-uridyltransferase activity

An enzymatically optimized, miniaturized (20 microl) fluorimetric assay of galactose-1-phosphate-uridyltransferase using dried blood spots for newborn screening is presented. The Beutler reaction principle has been adapted to the microtiter plate technology and acetone/methanol was used for complete deproteinization. A special ultramicro multiwell screening plate resistant to organic solvents has been developed and employed. The assay is simple, sensitive and inexpensive, due to small reagent volumes and the low prices of ultramicro screening plates. The reaction is linear with galactose-1-phosphate-uridyltransferase activity up to 120 min of incubation time. It shows low imprecision and good correlation to a quantitative validation test. For standardization the use of plate means or medians of activity or fluorescence values is proposed. Individual blank measurement prevents false negative assessments.

Biochemical characterization of the S135L allele of galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase associated with galactosaemia

Impairment of the human enzyme galactose-1-phosphate uridylyltransferase (GALT) results in the potentially lethal disorder galactosaemia. The S135L mutation, which accounts for almost 50% of the GALT alleles in galactosaemia patients of African-American descent, has been associated with activities ranging from null to wild-type by different investigators examining cell lysates representing different tissues or model systems. Because of the crude nature of the lysates examined, however, and the absence of quantitative measures concerning GALT abundance in most of those lysates, the available data do not distinguish between differences in GALT enzyme expression/abundance, specific activity, or kinetic constants in these different tissues or systems. In an effort to overcome this uncertainty and investigate the biochemical impact of the S135L substitution on human GALT function under defined conditions, we have overexpressed both wild-type and S135L-mutant GALT sequences in a null-background yeast expression system, and purified both proteins to near homogeneity. Abundance of the wild-type and mutant proteins in crude yeast lysates differed by approximately 2-fold. Kinetic studies of the purified proteins, however, demonstrated that although K(m) values differed by < 2-fold, specific activities differed by 10-fold. Temperature-activity profiles revealed no significant differences, and coprecipitation studies demonstrated that S135L-hGALT subunits remained competent to self-associate in vivo. We conclude that the S135L substitution causes either steric or electrochemical changes sufficiently close to the active site in human GALT to result in partial impairment of the transferase reaction.

Molecular characterization of Duarte-1 and Duarte-2 variants of galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase

The N314D polymorphism was found in two different alleles of the galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) gene, Duarte-1 (D1) and Duarte-2 (D2). Although both variants have identical electrophoretic mobility and isoelectro-focusing points, the galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT) activity varies: D1 alleles showed 110-130% of the normal RBC activity, but D2 alleles only 40-50%. We found that D1 alleles also carried a silent mutation in exon 7 (L218L) in addition to N314D. In contrast, besides N314D, D2 alleles carried two regulatory mutations, G1105C and G1391A, in introns D and E, respectively. In normal and Q188R alleles none of the above four mutations coexisted. However, some galactosaemia alleles with mutations other than Q188R, such as W316X and E340X of exon 10, also carried the N314D mutation. The W316X alleles existed in cis with the intron mutations (G1105C and G1391A), whereas those with E340X are in cis with L218L. In all cases examined, the intron mutations were not found in D1 alleles and no D2 alleles had the silent mutation of L218L. These results suggest that the decrease in the GALT activity in D2 may be due to regulation of the GALT gene expression. The G1105C site may be critical to the function of erythroid transcription factor NF-E1, since it flanks the core consensus sequence for one of its binding sites. The G1391A mutation may affect another cis-acting regulatory sequence. Alternatively, both mutations may be involved in an aberrant splice processing, which possibly results in a low level of correctly spliced mRNA.

Characterization of two stop codon mutations in the galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase gene of three male galactosemic patients with severe clinical manifestation

Classical galactosemia, which is caused by deficiency of galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase, is characterized by acute problems of hepatocellular dysfunction, sepsis, cataracts and failure to thrive. Galactose limitation reverses these symptoms immediately; however, the long-term complications, such as mental retardation and ovarian failures are major problems in most of these patients. In order to investigate the molecular basis for phenotype variation in galactosemia, we have screened the most common mutation in the GALT gene, Q188R. We have further examined those patients who are heterozygous for Q188R or negative for this mutation by SSCP analysis and direct sequencing. In three male patients, we have identified, for the first time, two stop-codon mutations in the GALT gene, G212X (exon 7) and E340X (exon 10). Two patients of 8 and 28 years of age, respectively, who are compound heterozygotes for Q188R and G212X, have severe mental retardation and their general clinical condition is more severe than that of patients with missense mutations. The third patient, who is 8 years of age and who is homozygous for E340X, the N314D polymorphism and a silent substitution L218L, presents with a relatively normal physical and mental condition to date.

Mutations in the galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase gene of two families with mild galactosaemia variants

Classical galactosaemia, deficiency of galactose-1-phosphate uridyltransferase (GALT), is characterized by acute symptoms of hepatomegaly, jaundice, sepsis, cataracts and growth retardation. Treatment with dietary galactose restriction corrects these complications immediately; however, most of these children develop long-term complications of verbal dyspraxia, mental retardation and ovarian failure. Our previous molecular study showed that the most common mutation of the GALT gene is a missense mutation of Q188R (replacement of glutamine-188 by arginine) in approximately 60-65% of the German galactosaemic population. The coding region of GALT was amplified by the polymerase chain reaction from genomic DNA of classical galactosaemic individuals, who are negative or heterozygous for Q188R, and was further characterized by direct sequencing. Three new disease-causing mutations, two missense and a stop codon mutation, were identified in three patients from two families with mild galactosaemic variants: firstly R67C, replacement of arginine-67 by cysteine and W316X, the stop codon at tryptophan-316 in one male; secondly A330V, replacement of alanine-330 by valine in two female siblings. In the first family the patient was also heterozygous for the polymorphism N314D and in the second family both girls were compound heterozygotes for Q188R and A330V. All three galactosaemic individuals have a considerable amount of the residual GALT activity in RBC and the galactose-1-phosphate (GALP) level decreased much faster on treatment than that of other galactosaemic patients with missense mutations such as Q188R. The clinical and biochemical data of these patients were much more favourable in comparison with those of two female galactosaemic individuals, one homozygous for L195P and the other compound heterozygous for Q188R and L195P. These three missense mutations (R67C, L195P and A330V) also occur in highly conserved regions. These observations suggest that the phenotypic variation in galactosaemic individuals may be due to different molecular aetiologies.