Long-term survival of and plasmid stability inPseudomonas andKlebsiella species and appearance of nonculturable cells in agricultural drainage water

Persistence in Phytopathogenic Bacteria: Do We Know Enough?

Phytopathogenic bacteria affect a wide range of crops worldwide and have a negative impact in agriculture due to their associated economic losses and environmental impacts. Together with other biotic and abiotic stress factors, they pose a threat to global food production. Therefore, understanding bacterial survival strategies is an essential step toward the development of new strategies to control plant diseases. One mechanism used by bacteria to survive under stress conditions is the formation of persister cells. Persisters are a small fraction of phenotypic variants within an isogenic population that exhibits multidrug tolerance without undergoing genetic changes. They are dormant cells that survive treatment with antimicrobials by inactivating the metabolic functions that are disrupted by these compounds. They are thus responsible for the recalcitrance of many human diseases, and in the same way, they are thought to contribute to the survival of bacterial phytopathogens under a range of stresses they face in the environment. It is believed that persister cells of bacterial phytopathogens may lead to the reoccurrence of disease by recovering growth and recolonizing the host plant after the end of stress. However, compared to human pathogens, little is known about persister cells in phytopathogens, especially about their genetic regulation. In this review, we describe the overall knowledge on persister cells and their regulation in bacterial phytopathogens, focusing on their ability to survive stress conditions, to recover from dormancy and to maintain virulence.

Viable but non-culturable (VBNC) bacteria: Gene expression in planktonic and biofilm cells

Viable but non-culturable (VBNC) bacteria are common in nutrient poor and/or stressed environments as planktonic cells and biofilms. This article discusses approaches to researching VBNC bacteria to obtain knowledge that is lacking on their gene expression while in the VBNC state, and when they enter into and then recover from this state, when provided with the necessary nutrients and environmental conditions to support growth and cell division. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of proteins, global gene expression, reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis and sequencing by synthesis coupled with data on cell numbers, viability and species present are central to understanding the VBNC state.

Comparison of Three Methods for Monitoring Populations of Different Genotypes of 2,4-Diacetylphloroglucinol-Producing Pseudomonas fluorescens in the Rhizosphere

ABSTRACT Pseudomonas fluorescens strains producing the antibiotic 2,4-diacetylphloroglucinol (DAPG) have biocontrol activity against a broad spectrum of root and seedling diseases. In this study, we determined the effect of genotype on the ability to isolate and quantify introduced 2,4-DAPG producers from the rhizosphere of wheat using three different methods: traditional dilution plating on selective media, colony hybridization followed by polymerase chain reaction (PCR), and phlD-specific PCR-based dilution endpoint assay. Regression analysis of the population densities of 10 2,4-DAPG-producing P. fluorescens, representing five genotypes, determined by the three different methods demonstrated that the relationship was linear (P < 0.001) and the techniques were very similar (i.e., slopes equal to 1.0). The phlD-specific PCR-based assay had a slightly lower limit of detection than the other two methods (log 3.3 versus log 4.0 CFU/g of fresh root weight). With the colony hybridization procedure, we observed that the phlD probe, derived from strain P. fluorescens Q8r1-96, hybridized more strongly to colonies of BOX-PCR genotypes D (strains W2-6, L5.1-96, Q8r1-96, and Q8r2-96) and K (strain F113) compared with strains of genotypes A (Pf-5 and CHA0), B (Q2-87), and L (1M1-96 and W4-4). Colony hybridization alone overestimated the actual densities of some strains, thus requiring an additional PCR step to obtain accurate estimates. In contrast, population densities estimated for three of the bacterial treatments (strains CHA0, W2-6, and Q8r2-96) with the PCR-based assay were significantly (P < 0.041) smaller by 7.6 to 9.2% and 6.4 to 9.4% than population densities detected by the dilution plating and colony hybridization techniques, respectively. In this paper, we discuss the relative advantages of the different methods for detecting 2,4-DAPG producers.

Effect of inoculation of a TOL plasmid containing mycorrhizosphere bacterium on development of Scots pine seedlings, their mycorrhizosphere and the microbial flora in m-toluate-amended soil

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the influence of introduced bacteria containing a contaminant degrading plasmid on the growth and survival of pine seedlings and mycorrhizosphere microbial flora in contaminated soil. The Pseudomonas fluorescens strain OS81, originally isolated from fungal hyphae in contaminated soil, was supplied with the TOL plasmid pWW0::Km (to generate OS81(pWW0::Km)) and inoculated in humus-soil microcosms with and without pine seedlings mycorrhized with Suillus bovinus. After 3 months of regular treatment with m-toluate (mTA) solutions, the introduced catabolic plasmid was found to be disseminated in the indigenous bacterial population of both mycorrhizosphere and soil uncolonized by the fungus. Transconjugants were represented by bacteria of the genera Pseudomonas and Burkholderia and their number correlated positively with the concentration of mTA applied. Indigenous mTA degrading bacteria with low similarity to Burkholderia species were also enriched in microcosms. They were mostly associated with mycorrhizal soil or fungal structures and virtually absent in microcosms without pines. The total number of Tol(+) bacteria was higher in mycorrhizospheric soil compared with bulk soil. Inoculation with P. fluorescens OS81(pWW0::Km) had a positive effect on the development of roots and fungus in contaminated soil. Both inoculation with the P. fluorescens OS81(pWW0::Km) and mTA contamination as well as the presence of mycorrhized pine roots and fungal hyphae had an effect on the microbial community structure of soil as measured by carbon source oxidation patterns. However, the impact of mTA on the microbial community was more prominent. The study indicates that an effect on plant and fungal development can be obtained by manipulating the mycorrhizosphere. Both introduction of the bacterium carrying the degradative plasmid and the plasmid itself are likely to have a positive effect not only on the organisms involved, but also on bioremediation of contaminated soil, a factor that was not directly monitored here.

Comparative analysis of antibiotic resistance, immunofluorescent colony staining, and a transgenic marker (bioluminescence) for monitoring the environmental fate of rhizobacterium

Field releases of the wild-type plant growth-promoting rhizobacterium Pseudomonas fluorescens 89B-27, its bioluminescent derivative GEM-8 (89B-27::Tn4431), and a spontaneous rifampin-resistant variant estimating the wild-type population. Seed and root samples were taken 0, 7, 14, 21, or 28, 35 or 42, and 70 days after planting in each year and processed for enumeration by spiral plating or immunofluorescent colony staining (IFC). In both years, the populations of 89B-27, R34, and GEM-8, as measured by IFC, were not significantly different (P > 0.05) from each other at each sampling time. However, the populations of R34 and GEM-8, as measured by spiral plating and differentiation based on their respective phenotypes, were significantly lower (P < 0.05) than the wild-type populations and their IFC-determined populations. These data indicate that traditional marker systems may underestimate populations and hence the survival and colonization of genetically marked bacteria.

Activity and three-dimensional distribution of toluene-degrading Pseudomonas putida in a multispecies biofilm assessed by quantitative in situ hybridization and scanning confocal laser microscopy

As a representative member of the toluene-degrading population in a biofilter for waste gas treatment, Pseudomonas putida was investigated with a 16S rRNA targeting probe. The three-dimensional distribution of P. putida was visualized in the biofilm matrix by scanning confocal laser microscopy, demonstrating that P. putida was present throughout the biofilm. Acridine orange staining revealed a very heterogeneous structure of the fully hydrated biofilm, with cell-free channels extending from the surface into the biofilm. This indicated that toluene may penetrate to deeper layers of the biofilm, and consequently P. putida may be actively degrading toluene in all regions of the biofilm. Furthermore, measurements of growth rate-related parameters for P. putida showed reduced rRNA content and cell size (relative to that in a batch culture), indicating that the P. putida population was not degrading toluene at a maximal rate in the biofilm environment. Assuming that the rRNA content reflected the cellular activity, a lower toluene degradation rate for P. putida present in the biofilm could be estimated. This calculation indicated that P. putida was responsible for a significant part (65%) of the toluene degraded by the entire community.

Impact of Growth in Benzoate and m-Toluate Liquid Media on Culturability of Pseudomonas putida on Benzoate and m-Toluate Plates

Pseudomonas putida grown in continuous culture on benzoate or m-toluate lost the ability to grow on benzoate or m-toluate plates. A similar effect was not seen with a glucose continuous culture. Cells carrying and expressing a TOL plasmid rapidly lost their ability to grow on benzoate solid medium.

Root Exudate-Induced Promoter Activity in Pseudomonas fluorescens Mutants in the Wheat Rhizosphere

Tn5-B20 (lacZ as reporter gene) transcriptional fusion mutants of Pseudomonas fluorescens R2f were screened for their response to wheat root exudate. Several mutants showed (beta)-galactosidase activity under the influence of wheat root exudate. In one such mutant, RIWE8, gene expression was specifically induced by proline but not by 125 other substrates. This mutant also showed reporter gene induction, albeit to a lesser extent, by exudate of maize and grass roots but not by that of clover roots. In situ promoter activity of RIWE8 was found in Flevo silt loam soil amended with proline but not in water-, arginine-, glutamic acid-, or malic acid-amended soils. Reporter gene expression in RIWE8 was triggered in a model rhizosphere-soil system in the presence of wheat, maize, and grass roots but not in the presence of clover roots or in root-free (bulk) soil. The induction of expression of the reporter gene in soil, using this approach, is suggestive that promoter activity in RIWE8 may be useful for the construction of organisms with rhizosphere-controlled beneficial genes.

Efficacy in aquatic microcosms of a genetically engineered pseudomonad applicable for bioremediation

A genetically engineered microorganism (GEM), Pseudomonas sp. B13 FRI (pFRC20P) (abbreviated FR120), has previously been engineered to simultaneously mineralize mixtures of methylated and chlorinated benzoic acids and phenols through a modified ortho cleavage pathway. In this study, its performance was investigated both in different types of aquatic microcosms and in pure culture to determine (1) if under simulated in situ conditions the genetically engineered pathway effectively removes mixtures of model pollutants simultaneously, quickly, and completely; (2) where the optimum pollutant concentration range for this activity lies; and (3) how physical, chemical, and biological factors in the microcosms influence degradation rates. Growth and degradation parameters of FR 120 in pure culture were determined with 3-chlorobenzoate (3CB), 4-methylbenzoate (4MB), and equimolar mixtures of both as carbon sources. These substrates were degraded simultaneously, albeit with different degradation velocities, by FR120. The optimum growth concentrations for 3CB and 4MB were 3.0 mm and 2.1 mM, respectively, and the inhibition constants (Ki) were 11 mm (3CB) and 6 mm (4MB). The pathway was induced at low concentrations of substrate (> 1 [μM). The first order degradation constants (kl) were determined with respect to substrate concentration, cell density, and temperature. In aquatic microcosms inoculated with FR120, first order degradation constants and half lives of target chemicals were calculated based on the total amount of aromatics recovered. Half lives ranged from 1.3 days to 3.0 days, depending on the target chemical and the type of microcosm. Degradation constants determined in pure culture were extrapolated to the densities of FR120, substrate concentrations, and temperature occurring in the microcosm experiments, and used to calculate theoretical half lives. In water microcosms, theoretical and observed half lives corresponded well, indicating that FR120 functioned optimally in this environment. In whole core sediment microcosms, and especially at low cell densities, the observed degradation activity was in some cases considerably higher than expected from pure culture degradation rates. This suggests that environmental conditions in the sediment were more favorable to the degradation of substituted aromatics than those in pure culture. The physiological characteristics of FR120 and its performance in aquatic microcosms make it a good candidate for bioremediation at sites contamninated with mixtures of chlorinated and methylated aromatics.

Survival of allochthonous bacteria in still mineral water bottled in polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and glass

The mortality of Escherichia coli, Enterobacter cloacae, Klebsiella pneumoniae and Pseudomonas aeruginosa, based on the culturability of these bacteria, was assessed in non-carbonated mineral water, bottled in polyvinyl chloride (PVC) containing the indigenous flora, sterile mineral water bottled in PVC, sterile mineral water in glass containers, and sterile tap water in glass containers. There was a general decrease in the culturability of these organisms in the four test waters, except that Ps. aeruginosa grew in sterile tap water. Escherichia coli and Kl. pneumoniae had the highest mortality rates under the conditions tested, while Ent. cloacae had a very low and constant mortality rate that would have resulted in the persistence of this organism in mineral water for a long period of time. After a sharp initial decrease in culturability, Ps. aeruginosa also had a very low mortality rate in mineral water bottled in PVC.

Use of a novel plasmid to monitor the fate of a genetically engineered Pseudomonas putida strain

Plasmid pSI30 was constructed to increase the sensitivity of detection of a genetically engineered micro-organism (GEM) and its recombinant DNA in environmental samples. This broad host-range, mobilizable plasmid contained chlorocatechol (clc) degradative genes, antibiotic resistance genes (ampicillin and kanamycin) and a fragment of eukaryotic DNA. The clc genes encode enzymes that convert 3-chlorocatechol to maleylacetic acid permitting the host, Pseudomonas putida RC-4, to grow on 3-chlorobenzoate. This catabolic phenotype was exploited using enrichment procedures to detect RC-4(pSI30) cells, free-living in the water column or when irreversibly bound to surfaces. The eukaryotic DNA sequence provided a unique target allowing positive identification by DNA:DNA hybridization. Using the eukaryotic DNA sequence as a probe, no transfer of the plasmid to indigenous bacteria was detected. Persistence of RC-4(pSI30) and its ability to multiply upon addition of 3-chlorobenzoate were demonstrated 78 days after its addition to natural freshwater. In flow-through microcosms RC-4(pSI30), undetectable as free-living cells, was found by enrichment as irreversibly bound sessile forms. These experiments revealed the stability of pSI30 and its utility in a 'combination' detection system for tracking the survival of a GEM and its DNA in environmental samples.

Survival of lux-lac-marked biosurfactant-producing Pseudomonas aeruginosa UG2L in soil monitored by nonselective plating and PCR

Two reporter systems, lacZY and luxAB, were stably integrated into the chromosome of Pseudomonas aeruginosa UG2, a biosurfactant-producing strain. Growth and rhamnolipid production of the UG2 wild-type and reporter gene-bearing UG2L strains were similar in liquid culture. A spontaneous rifampin-resistant detecting UG2Lr, allowed antibiotic selection. Phenotypic characteristics were compared for usefulness in detecting UG2Lr colonies: morphology, fluorescent pigment production, light emission (lux), X-Gal (5-bromo-4-chloro-3-indolyl-beta-D-galactopyranoside) cleavage (lac), and rifampin resistance. Survival patterns of UG2, UG2L, and UG2Lr strains were similar in sandy loam soil microcosms over 12 12 weeks. The lac marker was not suitable for monitoring P. aeruginosa UG2Lr in soil since 20 to 42% of cultured, aerobic, heterotrophic soil microorganisms formed blue, lactose-positive colonies. The lux genes provided a stable and unequivocal reporter system, as effective as conventional antibiotic plating, for tracking microorganisms nonselectively at 10(3) CFU/g of soil. Three months after inoculation into oil-contaminated and uncontaminated soil microcosms, UG2Lr cells were recovered at 10(7) and 10(4) cells per g (dry weight) of soil, respectively. Detection by PCR amplification of part of the luxA gene confirmed a decrease in UG2Lr cell numbers in uncontaminated soil. In combination, antibiotic resistance, bioluminescence, and PCR analyses provided sensitive detection and quantitative enumeration of P. aeruginosa UG2Lr in soil.

Fate of Pseudomonas putida after release into lake water mesocosms: Different survival mechanisms in response to environmental conditions

To study the fate of Pseudomonas putida DSM 3931 in an aquatic environment, cultures of the strain were released into lake water mesocosms. P. putida, bearing the TOL-plasmid, was released as a representative xenobiotic-degrading microorganism. The release was carried out in mesocosms with unamended lake water and in lake water with added culture medium to compare the survival of the strain due to the influence of different organic load. As a comparison, the survival of P. putida was followed in microcosms with sterile lake water. Survival and fate of the strain were determined by means of immunofluorescence with highly specific monoclonal antibodies and growth on selective agar medium for up to ten weeks after release. Addition of medium had a pronounced influence on survival in mesocosms. In mesocosms without added medium, the number of P. putida cells decreased within ten days by over 2 orders of magnitude. In mesocosms with medium, cell numbers increased in the first two days by an order of magnitude and were, after ten days, in the same range as at the time of introduction. Over time, cell numbers decreased but remained detectable in both types of mesocosms for up to ten weeks after release. In mesocosms with unamended lake water, the major fraction of the cells was attached to particles after two days. In mesocosms with medium, large aggregates of P. putida cells formed which included algae. The observed decrease in cell numbers in mesocosms was attributed mainly to grazing. Sedimentation was an additional factor contributing to loss of cells out of the water column, which especially affected aggregate-forming cells in mesocosms with medium in the long run (beyond two weeks). These studies demonstrate that experimental tools on a mesoscale are crucial in order to understand the complex processes microorganisms are subjected to after release into a natural environment, and that single cell detection, such as immunofluorescence, is essential to understand mechanisms of survival and elimination.

Plasmid stability and ecological competence in recombinant cultures

The instability of cell cultures containing plasmid vectors is a major problem in the commercial exploitation of molecular cloning techniques. Plasmid stability is influenced by the nature of the host cell, the type of plasmid and/or environmental conditions. Plasmid encoded properties may confer a selective advantage on the host cell but can be an energy drain due to replication and expression. Stability of recombinant cultures ultimately may be determined by the cost to benefit ratio of plasmid carriage. The relative competition between plasmid containing and plasmid-free or indigenous populations can determine the degree of dominance of recombinant cultures. The use of inocula in biotechnological processes in which dynamic environmental conditions dominate may also result in instabilities resulting from the characteristics of the ecosystem. In such dynamic conditions plasmid stability is just one contribution to culture stability. Strategies to enhance plasmid stability, within such environments, based on manipulation of physiological state of host cells, must consider the responsiveness or plasticity of both cells and populations. The robustness of cells or the responses to stresses or transient environmental conditions can influence the levels of instability detected; for example, instability or mutation in the host genome may lead to enhanced plasmid stability. Competition among subpopulations arising from unstable copy number control may determine the levels of recombinant cells in open versus closed fermenter systems. Thus the ecological competence (ability to survive and compete) of recombinant cells in dynamic or transient environments is fundamental to the understanding of the ultimate dominance or survival of such recombinant cultures and may form the basis of a strategy to enhance or control stability either in fermenter systems or dynamic process environments. The creation of microniches in time and/or space can enhance plasmid stability. Transient operation based on defined environmental stresses or perturbations in fermenter systems or in heterogeneous or dynamic environments found in gel immobilized cultures have resulted in enhanced stability. Spatial organization resulting from immobilization has the additional advantage of regulated cell protection within defined microenvironments and controlled release, depending on the nature of the gel, from these microenvironments or microcosms. This regulation of ecological competence allied to the advantages of microbial cell growth in gel microenvironments combined with the spatial organization (or juxtapositioning of cells, selective agents, nutrients, protectants, etc.) possible through immobilization technology offers new strategies to enhance plasmid and culture stability.

Influence of ecosystematic factors on survival of Escherichia coli after large-scale release into lake water mesocosms

Mass cultures of an Escherichia coli K-12 strain were released into exposed mesocosms in a eutrophic lake. The release was performed with and without additional input of the E. coli culture medium to stimulate the scenario of leakage of a production fermenter on one hand and to compare the influence of the added organic nutrients with that of the added strain on the other hand. The survival of the introduced strain and the influence on ecological processes in the mesocosms were monitored for 10 weeks after release. For comparison, survival of the strain in microcosms with sterile lake water was also monitored. Survival of the strain was determined by means of immunofluorescence and growth on selective agar medium. In lake mesocosms, E. coli showed a rapid and constant dieback during the first week. After 4 days, cells were mostly restricted to particles, which seemed to provide niches for survival. From the second week onward, survival was improved in mesocosms with culture medium added. In microcosms with sterile lake water, plate counts of E. coli showed a strong decrease within 2 weeks, while total cell numbers remained approximately the same. The rapid elimination of E. coli from the free-water phase of the mesocosms was probably due to the combined effect of the inability to grow in lake water and grazing. The better survival of E. coli (mainly on particles) in mesocosms with added medium was attributed to the medium-induced enhancement of primary production, which was the source of a large quantity of particles. These particles, in turn, may have functioned as niches for prolonged survival as well as transport vehicles for sedimentation of the E. coli cells.

Survival of Aeromonas salmonicida in lake water

The survival of Aeromonas salmonicida subsp. salmonicida in lake water was investigated by using a variety of techniques. They included acridine orange epifluorescence, respiration, cell culture, cell revival, flow cytometry, plasmid maintenance, and membrane fatty acid analysis. During a 21-day study, A. salmonicida became nonculturable in sterile lake water samples. Flow cytometry and direct microscopy indicated that cells were present. Although the nonculturable cells could not be revived, the recovery method did indicate that the presence of low numbers of culturable cells within samples could produce misleading results. Plasmid DNA, genomic DNA, and RNA were maintained in the nonculturable cells; in addition, changes in the fatty acid profiles were also detected. Although viability could not be proven, it was shown that the morphological integrity of nonculturable cells was maintained.