Comparison of enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay with coagglutination and latex agglutination for rapid diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia by detecting antigen in sputa

Diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia: current pitfalls and the way forward

Streptococcus pneumoniae is the most common cause of community-acquired pneumonia. However, it can also asymptomatically colonize the upper respiratory tract. Because of the need to distinguish between S. pneumoniae that is simply colonizing the upper respiratory tract and S. pneumoniae that is causing pneumonia, accurate diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia is a challenging issue that still needs to be solved. Sputum Gram stains and culture are the first diagnostic step for identifying pneumococcal pneumonia and provide information on antibiotic susceptibility. However, these conventional methods are relatively slow and insensitive and show limited specificity. In the past decade, new diagnostic tools have been developed, particularly antigen (teichoic acid and capsular polysaccharides) and nucleic acid (ply, lytA, and Spn9802) detection assays. Use of the pneumococcal antigen detection methods along with biomarkers (C-reactive protein and procalcitonin) may enhance the specificity of diagnosis for pneumococcal pneumonia. This article provides an overview of current methods of diagnosing pneumococcal pneumonia and discusses new and future test methods that may provide the way forward for improving its diagnosis.

Antigen detection for the diagnosis of pneumonia

Streptococcus pneumoniae and Haemophilus influenzae type b are the main agents of bacterial community-acquired pneumonia in developing countries, although a definite etiologic diagnosis cannot be established in most cases. This study was carried out to assess the performance of a latex particle agglutination test (LPAT) from a commercial kit (Slidex Méningite Kit trade mark, BioMérieux, France) in diagnosing pneumococcal and H. influenzae type b pneumonia. One hundred and seven children (45 ill subjects and 62 healthy controls) were enrolled. All 45 cases had a presumptive diagnosis of bacterial pneumonia based on clinical (WHO criteria), laboratory (white blood cell count > or = 15.000/mm3, polymorphonuclear leukocytes > or = 70%, bands > or = 500/mm3, and C-reactive protein > or = 40 mg/l), and radiological findings, i.e., two or more positive points in the scoring system described by Khamapirad and Glezen (Semin Respir Infect 1987;2:130-144). Clinical, laboratory, and radiological assessments were performed in a blinded manner. LPAT was performed in urine samples after concentration through an ethanol-acetone solution. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were 77.3% (95% CI, 61.8-88.0%), 90.3% (95% CI, 79.5-96.0%), 85.0% (95% CI, 69.5-93.8%), and 84.8% (95% CI, 73.4-92.1%), respectively. Results suggest that LPAT is a useful diagnostic tool for the etiologic diagnosis of S. pneumoniae and H. influenzae type b pneumonia, especially in the developing world.

Type-specific enzyme immunoassay for detection of pneumococcal capsular polysaccharide antigens in nasopharyngeal specimens

We developed a new competitive EIA method for the demonstration of pneumococcal capsular polysaccharides from respiratory samples. The pediatric types 4, 6B, 9V, 14, 18C, 19F and 23F were selected for this study, because these capsular polysaccharides were included in the first heptavalent pneumococcal conjugate vaccines, which were used in the Finnish Otitis Media Vaccine Trial. Sensitivity of the EIA tests for purified polysaccharide antigens varied between 5 and 100 ng/ml, depending on the type. The assays performed well in 100 nasopharyngeal samples (NPS) samples processed through an enrichment culture, with an almost 100% sensitivity compared with routine culture. The method appeared type-specific, except that EIA for 6B capsule also detected 6A. The method is applicable for type-specific identification of pneumococcus in carriage studies.

Detection of Streptococcus pneumoniae antigen by a rapid immunochromatographic assay in urine samples

STUDY OBJECTIVES

Evaluation of a newly available rapid (15 min) immunochromatographic membrane test (ICT) to detect Streptococcus pneumoniae in urine samples, in order to assess its utility in the diagnosis of bacteremic and nonbacteremic pneumococcal pneumonia.

DESIGN

Retrospective study.

SETTING

We studied urine samples from 51 patients with bacteremic and nonbacteremic pneumonia due to S pneumoniae diagnosed by blood culture and pneumococcal polysaccharide capsular antigen detection by counterimmunoelectrophoresis in urine samples, 16 patients with probable pneumococcal pneumonia, 71 patients with nonpneumococcal pneumonia, and 16 patients with pneumonia but no pathogen identified. Urine samples were collected and frozen at - 20 degrees C until used. The ICT test was performed following the instructions of the manufacturer.

MEASUREMENTS AND RESULTS

S. pneumoniae antigen was detected in 41 of 51 patients with pneumococcal pneumonia (80.4%); results were positive in 23 of 28 bacteremic cases (82.1%) and in 18 of 23 nonbacteremic cases (78.3%). From patients with a diagnosis of presumptive pneumococcal pneumonia, antigen was detected in seven urine samples (43.7%) and also in one case of the 16 patients with pneumonia but no pathogen identified. The specificity of the ICT test was 97.2%.

CONCLUSION

The ICT assay is a valuable tool for the diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia, especially for the nonbacteremic cases.

Diagnosis of Streptococcus pneumoniae pneumonia by quantitative enzyme linked immunosorbent assay of C-polysaccharide antigen

AIMS

To evaluate the use of a quantitative enzyme linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) detecting C-polysaccharide (PnC) antigen in sputum for the diagnosis of Streptococcus pneumoniae infection.

METHODS

Specimens of sputum from 60 patients with acute community and hospital acquired pneumonia and infective exacerbations of obstructive airways disease were examined by semiquantitative culture and antigen ELISA.

RESULTS

Using a cutoff value of 1 microgram/ml PnC antigen for a positive result, the sensitivity of this assay was 90.3%, specificity 93.1%, predictive value of a positive result was 93.5%, and the predictive value of a negative result 89.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

Quantitation of C-polysaccharide antigen in sputum by ELISA distinguishes between carriage of oral bacteria which express PnC-like antigen and infection with S pneumoniae and compares favourably with other diagnostic methods.

Significance of isolation of Moraxella catarrhalis in routine cultures from the respiratory tract in adults: antibody response studied in a whole cell EIA

The significance of the isolation of Moraxella catarrhalis from sputum or nasopharynx was studied in patients treated at an infectious disease clinic. A whole-cell enzyme immunoassay was used to detect a specific antibody response to M. catarrhalis during infection. In all, 27 patients with respiratory tract infections and 4 with other infections were studied. Titre rises were recorded in 11/23 patients with lower respiratory tract infections, whereas patients with common cold or infections elsewhere all had negative serology. In patients with acute bronchitis, 7/10 patients responded with a significant titre rise. Patients with a low titre in their acute serum sample were those who responded with a titre increase during infection. The findings indicate that isolation of M. catarrhalis from sputa and nasopharyngeal samples in adults is of value for the etiological diagnosis of acute bronchitis and other lower respiratory tract infections, and is therefore important for the choice of drug for treatment, as many isolates are resistant to beta-lactam antibiotics.

Demonstration of circulating pneumococcal immunoglobulin G immune complexes in patients with community-acquired pneumonia by means of an enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay

An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay was developed for quantitation of circulating immune complexes (CICs) containing specific antipneumococcal immunoglobulin G (IgG). These CICs were detected in 17 (85%) of 20 patients with bacteremic pneumococcal pneumonia, 4 (36.4%) of 11 patients with probable pneumococcal pneumonia, 3 (16.7%) of 18 patients with pneumonia of other (nonpneumococcal) etiology, and 13 (41.9%) of 31 patients with pneumonia of unknown etiology. There was no correlation between CICs and serum IgG antibody levels. Pneumococcal capsular antigen was demonstrated in dissociated CICs by latex agglutination.

Antigen detection in oropharyngeal secretions for rapid diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia

To determine the value of detection of antigen in the oropharynx in the diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia, oropharyngeal secretions were cultured for the presence of Streptococcus pneumoniae and tested for the presence of pneumococcal antigen. Sputum (if available) collected on the same day was also investigated for the presence of antigen. Detection of pneumococcal antigen was found to be directly related to the severity of pneumococcal carriership or infection (p < 0.0001) and was not related to culture results. Patients with pneumococcal pneumonia had the highest antigen detection rate (38%), followed by patients with pneumonia of unknown etiology (32%) and patients with an acute lower respiratory tract infection due to Streptococcus pneumoniae (20%). Pneumococcal carriers had a detection rate of only 9%. Antigen could be detected in only one patient of the control groups. Although antigen detection in sputum was superior to that in oropharyngeal secretions, concordant results were obtained in 8 (40%) and 6 (36%) patients with pneumococcal pneumonia and pneumonia of unknown etiology respectively. The results strongly suggest that pneumococcal carriage seldom leads to a detectable level of antigen, and that antigen detection in the oropharynx appears to be of additive value in the diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia.

Rapid detection of pneumococcal antigen in pleural fluid of patients with community acquired pneumonia

BACKGROUND

Detection of pneumococcal antigen may help to increase the rate of diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia. This study was designed to determine the value of rapid detection of pneumococcal antigen in pleural fluid from patients with community acquired pneumonia.

METHODS

Thoracentesis was performed in patients suspected of having empyema and in patients with pneumonia of unknown aetiology. Pneumococcal capsular antigen was detected by latex agglutination and this method was compared with Gram staining and culture, specimens of pleural fluid being examined in parallel by the three methods.

RESULTS

Pleural fluid was radiographically identified in 63 of 135 patients with community acquired pneumonia. In nine of 45 patients with pneumococcal pneumonia and pleural fluid pneumococci were identified by Gram stain in two and by culture in one specimen of pleural fluid, whereas antigen was detected in eight of these specimens. In 12 of 33 patients with pneumonia of other known aetiology only one pleural fluid specimen was antigen positive, providing a specificity of 92% for this test. Pleural fluid obtained from 12 of 58 patients with pneumonia of unknown aetiology yielded detectable antigen in seven cases.

CONCLUSIONS

Detection of pneumococcal antigen by latex agglutination in pleural fluid may yield important and rapid information in patients with community acquired pneumonia.

Detection of pneumococcal capsular antigen in the presence of penicillin in vitro

Eight strains of Streptococcus pneumoniae were tested in vitro for their ability to produce capsular antigen in the presence of penicillin. It was found that, provided 10(6) to 10(7) pneumococci/ml were present, capsular antigen could be detected during the 72 h in which the experiment was conducted, irrespective of whether penicillin was added at 0 h or 8 h, and even when no viable pneumococci remained. When fewer pneumococci were present, capsular antigen could not be detected at any time in the presence of penicillin. Control cultures, without penicillin, yielded detectable capsular antigen only when the threshold value of 10(6)-10(7) pneumococci/ml was reached. It is concluded that the presence of penicillin does not influence the detection of pneumococcal capsular antigen, but demonstration of this antigen is totally dependent on the number of pneumococci present.

Pneumococcal antigen persistence in sputum from patients with community-acquired pneumonia

The purpose of this study was to establish the diagnostic value of pneumococcal capsular antigen by comparing this with the results of Gram stain and culture in representative and nonrepresentative sputa during follow-up in patients with community-acquired pneumonia. Antigen was detected by a latex particle agglutination test. At the time of hospital admission, antigen was detected in 17 representative sputum specimens from 30 patients with pneumococcal pneumonia, which was comparable to the results of Gram stain and culture. In five additional patients, antigen was demonstrated in nonrepresentative specimens. During follow-up under antibiotic treatment, this number increased by six: three patients with representative and three patients with nonrepresentative sputum, respectively. Two of the 22 patients with pneumonia of other known cause had an antigen-positive sputum on admission and in another two patients, sputum antigen was detected during follow-up. Ten of 34 patients with pneumonia of unknown cause had detectable antigen in representative or nonrepresentative sputum on admission. During follow-up, antigen was detected in sputa of an additional seven patients. There was no difference in duration of antigen persistence between patients with pneumococcal pneumonia and pneumonia of unknown cause. It was observed that the first antigen-positive sputum specimen was always detected within the first five days of the hospital stay. We conclude that antigen detection in both representative and nonrepresentative sputum specimens at the time of hospital admission and during follow-up is of additional value for the diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia. It markedly increases the number of patients with pneumococcal pneumonia detected, who would otherwise be considered to have pneumonia of unknown cause. However, antigen-positive results should be interpreted carefully, especially in those pneumonia patients with chronic bronchitis, because detectable antigen may be caused by pneumococcal carriership of the lower respiratory tract.

Comparison of three methods for detection of pneumococcal antigen in sputum of patients with community-acquired pneumonia

In a prospective study of 249 patients with community-acquired pneumonia, three tests for the detection of pneumococcal antigen in sputum were compared: a coagglutination test for detecting capsular antigens (Cap-CoA), a sandwich enzyme immunoassay (PnC-EIA) and a coagglutination test (PnC-CoA), both the latter detecting the pneumococcal C-polysaccharide common to all pneumococcal types. Sixty-three patients had culture-positive pneumococcal pneumonia, 45 pneumonia caused by other bacteria and 141 pneumonia of viral or unknown etiology. The sensitivity of Cap-CoA (63%) and PnC-CoA (65%) was somewhat higher than that of PnC-EIA (49%), but not significantly so. The specificity was 96-98% for all three methods. Using PnC-CoA 66 patients with possible pneumococcal infection were detected, the diagnosis being verified by culture in 41. Using Cap-CoA 59 such patients were detected, the diagnosis being verified in 40, and using the PnC-EIA 47 such patients were detected, the diagnosis being verified in 31. Antigen was found almost as often in non-purulent as in purulent samples, and as often in washed as in non-washed purulent samples. However, antibiotic treatment before the sputum sample was obtained resulted in significantly lower sensitivity of both PnC-CoA and Cap-CoA. This study confirms the high sensitivity and specificity of methods for pneumococcal antigen detection in sputum. Since CoA is easier and quicker to perform, and cheaper than the EIA, either PnC-CoA or Cap-CoA would seem to be the technique of choice for detection of pneumococcal antigen, whereby all sputum samples, including non-purulent samples, can be used.

Rapid streptococcal antigen detection in experimental keratitis

We assessed the role of commercially available immunodiagnostic procedures in comparison to Gram stain and culture in experimental bacterial keratitis. Rabbit corneas were inoculated with Streptococcus pneumoniae, S. pyogenes, S. faecalis, or Haemophilus influenzae. Corneal scrapings were processed before and during antibacterial therapy using a coagglutination assay to detect pneumococcal capsular antigen (Phadebact Pneumococcus test) and an enzyme immunoassay to detect group A streptococcal cell-wall antigen (TestPack Strep A test). In untreated infected eyes, both immunoassays were highly specific and as sensitive as Gram stain for detection of the respective microorganisms. For S. pneumoniae keratitis, the sensitivity of coagglutination was 82% and Gram stain, 73%. For S. pyogenes keratitis, the sensitivity of enzyme immunoassay was 100% and Gram stain, 62%. Immunoassays and Gram stain were less sensitive than culture during antibacterial therapy. Successful clinical application of the coagglutination assay in a patient with pneumococcal keratitis permitted early use of specific cephalosporin treatment.

Highly sensitive biotin-avidin sandwich ELISA for the rapid detection of pneumococcal capsular polysaccharide antigens

The immunological detection of soluble pneumococcal polysaccharide antigens in pathological products is of importance in the direct diagnosis of meningitis or pulmonary infections. We have developed a double antibody sandwich ELISA method using a biotin-avidin system using antibodies constituted with a mixture of IgGs from pooled and/or monospecific antipneumococcal sera provided by the Danish Statens Seruminstitut. The sensitivity of this rapid ELISA method was optimized with purified capsular polysaccharides of the 24 main pneumococcal serotypes. With incubation steps of 30 min at 37 degrees C for the antigens and the conjugates, the detection limit was close to 1 ng/ml for 75% of the purified polysaccharides. A retrospective study of 46 CSF samples established the validity of the assay. This type of modified ELISA system represents a specific, sensitive and rapid procedure for the potential detection of capsular soluble antigens of all pneumococcal serotypes.

Comparison of immunological methods for diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia in biological fluids

Five immunological tests were evaluated for their ability to detect Streptococcus pneumoniae antigen in serum and urine simultaneously as a means of rapid diagnosis in 40 patients with bacteremic or non-bacteremic pneumococcal pneumonia or pneumonia with other etiologies. Serum and urine were screened in parallel with counterimmunoelectrophoresis (CIE), two commercial latex agglutination kits - the Slidex pneumokit (LA-SPK) and the Bactigen Streptococcus pneumoniae kit (LA-Bac) - the coagglutination Phadebact Pneumococcus test (CoA) and a newly developed enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) containing the immunoglobulin G fraction from rabbit pneumococcal antiserum. The detection rate for accumulated serum in bacteremic patients was 18% for LA-Bac, 24% for CIE, 47% for LA-SPK and CoA and 76% for ELISA, whereas antigenuria was present in only 29% for LA-SPK, 24% for CIE, 19% for CoA, 14% for LA-Bac and 5% for ELISA. Detection by ELISA of pneumococcal antigen in severely ill patients can predict bacteremia and rapidly confirm the diagnosis of pneumococcal pneumonia if sputum and results of blood cultures are not available.