Induced metamorphosis in isolated tails of Xenopus larvae

An Inhibitor of Thyroid Hormone Synthesis Protects Tail Skin Grafts Transplanted to Syngenic Adult Frogs

Tail regression in amphibian tadpoles during metamorphosis is one of the most dynamic morphological changes in animal development and is induced by thyroid hormone (TH). It has been proposed that tail resorption is driven by immunological rejection in Xenopus laevis, based on experimental evidence showing that larval skin grafts become atrophic on syngenic recipient adult frogs. This led to the hypothesis that tail regression is induced by an immunological rejection against larval skin-specific antigens called Ouro proteins. However, our group has demonstrated that ouro-knockout tadpoles undergo normal metamorphosis, including tail resorption in Xenopus tropicalis, which indicates that the expression of ouro genes is not necessary for tail regression. In the present study, we showed that an inhibitor of TH synthesis promotes the survival of larval tail skin grafts on syngenic adult Xenopus tropicalis frogs. The levels of endogenous THs in adult frogs were also comparable to those in metamorphosing tadpoles of Xenopus laevis with a regressing tail, and TH induced the regression of tadpole tail tips of Xenopus tropicalis in organ culture. Taken together, these results strongly suggest that endogenous THs in the recipient adult frog induce the degeneration of syngenic tail skin grafts.

Thyroid Hormone Receptor α- and β-Knockout Xenopus tropicalis Tadpoles Reveal Subtype-Specific Roles During Development

Thyroid hormone (TH) binds TH receptor α (TRα) and β (TRβ) to induce amphibian metamorphosis. Whereas TH signaling has been well studied, functional differences between TRα and TRβ during this process have not been characterized. To understand how each TR contributes to metamorphosis, we generated TRα- and TRβ-knockout tadpoles of Xenopus tropicalis and examined developmental abnormalities, histology of the tail and intestine, and messenger RNA expression of genes encoding extracellular matrix-degrading enzymes. In TRβ-knockout tadpoles, tail regression was delayed significantly and a healthy notochord was observed even 5 days after the initiation of tail shortening (stage 62), whereas in the tails of wild-type and TRα-knockout tadpoles, the notochord disappeared after ∼1 day. The messenger RNA expression levels of genes encoding extracellular matrix-degrading enzymes (MMP2, MMP9TH, MMP13, MMP14, and FAPα) were obviously reduced in the tail tip of TRβ-knockout tadpoles, with the shortening tail. The reduction in olfactory nerve length and head narrowing by gill absorption were also affected. Hind limb growth and intestinal shortening were not compromised in TRβ-knockout tadpoles, whereas tail regression and olfactory nerve shortening appeared to proceed normally in TRα-knockout tadpoles, except for the precocious development of hind limbs. Our results demonstrated the distinct roles of TRα and TRβ in hind limb growth and tail regression, respectively.

Mechanisms of tail resorption during anuran metamorphosis

Amphibian metamorphosis has historically attracted a good deal of scientific attention owing to its dramatic nature and easy observability. However, the genetic mechanisms of amphibian metamorphosis have not been thoroughly examined using modern techniques such as gene cloning, DNA sequencing, polymerase chain reaction or genomic editing. Here, we review the current state of knowledge regarding molecular mechanisms underlying tadpole tail resorption.

Ouro proteins are not essential to tail regression during Xenopus tropicalis metamorphosis

Tail regression is one of the most prominent transformations observed during anuran metamorphosis. A tadpole tail that is twice as long as the tadpole trunk nearly disappears within 3 days in Xenopus tropicalis. Several years ago, it was proposed that this phenomenon is driven by an immunological rejection of larval-skin-specific antigens, Ouro proteins. We generated ouro-knockout tadpoles using the TALEN method to reexamine this immunological rejection model. Both the ouro1- and ouro2-knockout tadpoles expressed a very low level of mRNA transcribed from a targeted ouro gene, an undetectable level of Ouro protein encoded by a target gene and a scarcely detectable level of the other Ouro protein from the untargeted ouro gene in tail skin. Furthermore, congenital athymic frogs were produced by Foxn1 gene modification. Flow cytometry analysis showed that mutant frogs lacked splenic CD8(+) T cells, which play a major role in cytotoxic reaction. Furthermore, T-cell-dependent skin allograft rejection was dramatically impaired in mutant frogs. None of the knockout tadpoles showed any significant delay in the process of tail shortening during the climax of metamorphosis, which shows that Ouro proteins are not essential to tail regression at least in Xenopus tropicalis and argues against the immunological rejection model.

Developmental cell death duringXenopus metamorphosis involves BID cleavage and caspase 2 and 8 activation

Elimination of tadpole organs during Xenopus metamorphosis is largely achieved through apoptosis, and recent evidence suggest involvement of the mitochondrial death route and bax-initiated caspase-3 and -9 deployment. However, events upstream of the activation of Bax are unknown. In other models, proteins of the BH3-only group such as BID are known to assure this function. We show that Xenopus bid transcript levels increase at metamorphosis in larval cells destined to disappear. This increase correlates with an abrupt rise in Caspase-2 and -8 mRNA levels and an enhanced activity of Caspase-2 and -8. In BIDGFP transgenic animal's tail regression is accelerated. The cleavage of BIDGFP fusion protein during natural or T(3)-induced metamorphosis was specifically inhibited by caspase-8 inhibitors. Our results show that tail regression at metamorphosis implicates an apoptotic pathway inducible by T(3) hormone in an organ autonomous manner and involving the cell death executioners BID and Caspases-2 and -8.

Programmed cell death during amphibian metamorphosis

The death of different types of cells occurs in regressing or remodeling organs to transform from a tadpole to a frog in both temporally and spatially regulated manners during amphibian metamorphosis. This morphological change is drastic and visible with the naked eye. This review summarizes our current understanding of the basic mechanism of the cell death during the metamorphosis. It focuses in particular on the tail resorption and the remodeling of intestine and skin where programmed cell death is executed by thyroid hormone-signaling through the cell-autonomous response (suicide) and the degradation of the extracellular matrix (murder).

Tissue sensitivity to thyroid hormone in athyroid Xenopus laevis larvae

Tadpoles that spontaneously arrest development and remain as larvae occur occasionally in Xenopus laevis populations. These non-metamorphosing tadpoles continue to grow, and they develop into grossly deformed giant individuals which come as close as any anurans to being truly neotenic. Giant X. laevis tadpoles that fail to metamorphose lack thyroid glands. In this study, the hypothesis that the tissues of these tadpoles nevertheless remain thyroid hormone sensitive was tested, by exposing isolated tadpole tail tips to exogenous thyroid hormone in tissue culture. The tail tips from giant tadpoles significantly shrank in response to the thyroid hormone treatment, showing that their tissue was still capable of metamorphosis. However, the amount of shrinkage was less than that observed in tail tissue from normal tadpoles. It was hypothesized that complete induction of metamorphosis may not be possible in the giant tadpoles due to a disproportionate growth and development of tissues and organs.

Adult-type splenocytes of Xenopus induce apoptosis of histocompatible larval tail cells in vitro

Larval cells of the anuran tadpole are replaced by adult cells in the corresponding tissues of the frog during metamorphosis; tissues of the tail, which have no counterpart in the adult, are completely eliminated during metamorphosis. We have previously demonstrated that young adults of the major histocompatibility complex (MHC) homozygous inbred J strain of Xenopus laevis reject skin grafts from larvae of the same strain, showing that there is histoincompatibility between larval and adult skin tissues [19]. Thus, we postulated that some immunological recognition might be involved in this specific elimination of the tail tissue and set out to test the idea. Using in vitro assays, we detected a significant increase in proliferation of splenocytes derived from adult and metamorphic climax animals co-cultured with larval tail tissue. This response was shown to be thymus-dependent. However, the degeneration of larval tissues was not observed in such co-cultures under our standard culture conditions. To detect the possible cytotoxicity of splenocytes, the culture conditions were modified by supplementing with 10% heat-inactivated adult Xenopus serum instead of 10% fetal calf serum (FCS). After this modification, the degeneration of larval tissues was observable macroscopically and microscopically with co-cultured adult splenocytes, but not tadpole ones. The nuclear fragmentation of the epidermal cells was seen by light and electron microscopy. Apoptosis was evidenced by the demonstration of the "ladder pattern" upon electrophoresis of genomic DNA obtained from the degenerating larval tissues. Surprisingly, this response was thymus independent. Moreover, it was shown that this response was not observed when the larval tissues were cultured with adult thymocytes or adult epidermal cells. In vivo, migration of T cells into the epidermis of tail tissues at the late climax of metamorphosis was demonstrated immunohistochemically using a monoclonal antibody against Xenopus T cells, even in the early thymectomized tadpoles. Considering these results, we propose that populations of adult-type non-T leukocytes might participate in the specific detection and elimination of larval type cells during metamorphosis.

Spatial, temporal and hormonal regulation of programmed muscle cell death during metamorphosis of the frog Xenopus laevis

No examination to date has been made of apoptosis during vertebrate muscle development. The authors recently reported programmed muscle cell death to be important in tail degeneration as well as in the larval-to-adult conversion of the dorsal body muscles of Xenopus laevis during metamorphosis [30]. In the present study, we examined programmed cell death (PCD) of the dorsal body and tail muscle morphologically and biochemically, with special attention to whether apoptotic processes, such as chromatin fragmentation and apoptotic body-formation actually occur, and whether triiodothyronine (T3) induces such processes. Light microscopic observation indicated muscle fibers break down into short fragments (sarcolytes or muscle apoptotic bodies) during the metamorphic climax, not only in tail but also in larval-type fibers of dorsal body muscles. Apoptotic bodies first appeared near the base of the tail in early climax (stage 59) when the T3 level is quite high, and thereafter expanded in an anterior direction in the dorsal body and posteriorly in the tail. The ratio of apoptotic area to total muscle area became maximum (10%-30% in dorsal body muscles and 50% in the tail) at the climax (stages 63-64). During these stages, genomic DNA fragmented into oligonucleosome-sized units (200 bp, 400 bp, 600 bp ...) in both body and tail muscles. To confirm whether this chromatin fragmentation is associated with apoptotic bodies, in situ DNA nick end labeling (TUNEL) was applied to sections of the dorsal body and tail muscles. Labeled muscle nuclei could be found only in muscle apoptotic bodies but not in intact muscle fibers, indicating DNA fragmentation was associated with cell fragmentation during metamorphosis. It thus follows that morphological (apoptotic body formation) and biochemical (fragmentation of chromatin) processes occurring during PCD of dorsal body and tail muscles are identical. To determine whether T3 regulates programmed muscle cell death, the effects of T3 on DNA ladder formation were examined in tails cultured in vitro. The oligonucleosomal DNA ladder was found to form only in tails incubated with T3, thus showing T3 to induce programmed muscle cell death without interaction with other endocrine organs during metamorphosis.

Inhibition of protein kinase C antagonizes in vitro tadpole tail fin regression induced by thyroxine

Tail fin regression can be induced in anuran amphibians with L-thyroxine (T4). This regression can be antagonized with prolactin (PRL). Previous work had suggested that protein kinase C (PKC) was involved in PRL action. To address this issue further, the effect of a potent and selective inhibitor of protein kinase C on in vitro tail fin regression was investigated. T4-induced regression of tail fin pieces from Rana pipiens tadpoles could be antagonized by adding PRL or the PKC inhibitor H-7 to the medium. H-7 inhibited fin regression in a dose-dependent manner, with a half-maximal effective concentration of about 10(-5) M. The H-7 analogue, HA-1004 (which is not a selective inhibitor of PKC), was without effect. These results suggest a possible role for PKC in tail fin regression and may be useful in elucidating the antimetamorphic action of PRL.

The role of cell death genes during development

During development, large numbers of cells die by a process known as programmed cell death. This loss of cells plays a number of important roles, including the sculpting of the body form and the removal of vestigial tissues. Data obtained from a variety of organisms has suggested that a cell's 'decision' to die is a differentiative event, requiring the activation of specific sets of genes. Several putative 'cell death' genes have recently been cloned, and one has been identified as the product of the polyubiquitin gene. Accumulation of ubiquitin has been observed not only during programmed cell death, but also in several neurodegenerative disorders, including Alzheimer's Disease.

An analysis of the influence of thyroid hormone on the synthesis of proteins in the tail fin of bullfrog tadpoles

By incubation of explants of tail fin from tadpoles of Rana catesbeiana in a solution of 35S-methionine for 4 h, newly synthesized proteins were labeled isotopically. After separation by two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis, those proteins were visualized by fluorography. Exposure of explants to culture medium containing thyroxine (T4) (150 nM) increased the incorporation of 35S-methionine into several proteins with 48 h. Effects of T4 on the relative abundance of two of these newly synthesized proteins were detected after 8 h of hormonal treatment. Very similar patterns of newly synthesized proteins were observed when proteins from explants of tail fin removed from tadpoles at metamorphic climax and immediately incubated with 35S-methionine were compared with proteins produced in fin derived from premetamorphic animals. These results are interpreted to indicate that both treatment of explants with T4 and elevation of endogenous levels of thyroid hormones during spontaneous metamorphosis increased the relative rates of synthesis of several identical proteins. The potential involvement of those proteins in early phases of metamorphic action which eventually lead to cell death and resorption is discussed.

Investigations on the role of cAMP in regulating resorption of the tail fin from tadpoles of Rana catesbeiana

Conflicting reports have appeared regarding the role of cAMP in regulating resorption of the tadpole tail during anuran metamorphosis. That cyclic nucleotide has been suggested as a mediator of the effects of both the thyroid hormones and prolactin. We tested the effects of cAMP and its derivatives dibutyryl-cAMP and 8-bromo-cAMP on explants of tail fin from tadpoles of Rana catesbeiana maintained in tissue culture. Unmodified cAMP (0.1, 2 mM) did not influence resorption. Dibutyryl-cAMP (0.1, 1 mM) and 8-bromo-cAMP (1 mM) inhibited resorption of explants induced by thyroxine (T4). The phosphodiesterase inhibitor isobutylmethylxanthine similarly inhibited regression of explants cultured with T4. None of these agents affected the increase in specific activity of hexosaminidase brought about by T4. Although the effects of cAMP in antagonizing tail resorption were similar to those of prolactin, we found no direct effect of prolactin on levels of cAMP in cultured tail fin. Thus, the effects of prolactin appear not to be mediated by increased levels of cAMP. We conclude, however, that the elevation of cellular levels of cAMP does inhibit the resorptive action of T4.

A histological and dynamic study of the gastric region of Discoglossus pictus larvae, cultured with or without thyroxine

The organotypic culture of the gastric region is carried out on premetamorphic Discoglossus pictus larvae. Adding thyroxine to the culture medium provokes various transformations. On the cytological level, the reactions observed, which are variable depending on the cell category concerned, can be divided into two types of phenomena: histolytic and histogenetic. Autophagia linked to lysosome intervention is frequently found among the histolytic processes. Autophagic vacuoles and residual bodies are observed. The gastric lumen is filled with deteriorated cells that probably come from the degeneration of the tadpole epithelium (primary epithelium). The incorporation of tritiated thymidine makes it possible to study the evolution of cell proliferation in the control and in the thyroxinated cultures. After a 1-2 day latency period, possibly due to the adjustment of the tissue to the culture environment, the incorporation of the radioprecursor H3-thymidine into the epithelium and the tunica muscularis of thyroxine-treated gut tissue increased on day 3, reached a maximum on day 5, and then dropped slightly on day 7. In the control cultures H3-thymidine incorporation showed the same pattern but lower levels on the same days. The histolytic phenomena induced by thyroxine in vitro are comparable to those of natural metamorphosis. On the other hand, the histogenetic phenomena are incomplete. Proliferating and transitional phases occur but neoformated (or secondary) epithelium does not replace the degenerated primary epithelium, whatever the culture time.

Death in embryonic systems

The principal conclusion to be drawn from the foregoing discussion is that the death of cells and the destruction of tissues, organs, and organ systems are programmed as normal morphogenetic events in the development of multicellular organisms. Death in embryonic systems may thus be explored within the same conceptual framework as growth and differentiation. The present exploration has revealed that death during embryogenesis serves utilitarian goals in some instances, at least, that its occurrence is subject to control by factors of the immediate cellular and humoral environment, and that aberrations in its normal pattern of expression provide the mechanism for realization of many mutant phenotypes. Hopefully, it has also pointed toward the appropriate formulation of some of the problems that confront us in understanding the control of death at the level of genetic transcription, the biochemical events which determine and accompany its occurrence, and the pathways of disposition and the developmental significance of disassembled cellular building blocks.