Total anorectal reconstruction with a double dynamic graciloplasty after abdominoperineal reconstruction for low rectal cancer

Current aspects and future prospects of total anorectal reconstruction--a critical and comprehensive review of the literature

PURPOSE

Many rectal cancer patients undergo abdominoperineal excision worldwide every year. Various procedures to restore perineal (pseudo-) continence, referred to as total anorectal reconstruction, have been proposed. The best technique, however, has not yet been defined. In this study, the different reconstruction techniques with regard to morbidity, functional outcome and quality of life were analysed. Technical and timing issues (i.e. whether the definitive procedure should be performed synchronously or be delayed), oncological safety, economical aspects as well as possible future improvements are further discussed.

METHODS

A MEDLINE and EMBASE search was conducted to identify the pertinent multilingual literature between 1989 and 2013. All publications meeting the defined inclusion/exclusion criteria were eligible for analysis.

RESULTS

Dynamic graciloplasty, artificial bowel sphincter, circular smooth muscle cuff or gluteoplasty result in median resting and squeezing neo-anal pressures that equate to the measurements found in incontinent patients. However, quality of life was generally stated to be good by patients who had undergone the procedures, despite imperfect continence, faecal evacuation problems and a considerable associated morbidity. Many patients developed an alternative perception for the urge to defecate that decisively improved functional outcome. Theoretical calculations suggested cost-effectiveness of total anorectal reconstruction compared well to life with a permanent colostomy.

CONCLUSIONS

Many patients would be highly motivated to have their abdominal replaced by a functional perineal colostomy. Given the considerable morbidity and questionable functional outcome of current reconstruction technique improvements are required. Tissue engineering might be an option to design an anatomically and physiologically matured, and customised continence organ.

The antegrade continence enema procedure and total anorectal reconstruction

Patients may present with anal incontinence (AI) following repair of a congenital anorectal anomaly years previously, or require total anorectal reconstruction (TAR) following radical rectal extirpation, most commonly for rectal cancer. Others may require removal of their colostomy following sphincter excision for Fournier's gangrene, or in cases of severe perineal trauma. Most of the data pertaining to antegrade continence enema (the ACE or Malone procedure) comes from the pediatric literature in the management of children with AI, but also with supervening chronic constipation, where the quality of life and compliance with this technique appears superior to retrograde colonic washouts. Total anorectal reconstruction requires an anatomical or physical supplement to the performance of a perineal colostomy, which may include an extrinsic muscle interposition (which may or may not be 'dynamized'), construction of a neorectal reservoir, implantation of an incremental artificial bowel sphincter or creation of a terminal, smooth-muscle neosphincter. The advantages and disadvantages of these techniques and their outcome are presented here.

Total perineal reconstruction after abdominoperineal excision for rectal cancer: long-term results of dynamic graciloplasty with Malone appendicostomy

AIM

This study aimed to assess long-term function after total perineal reconstruction (TPR) with dynamic graciloplasty (DG) and systematic Malone appendicostomy (MA) adjunction after abdominoperineal excision (APR) for rectal cancer.

METHOD

From 1999 to 2004, TPR using DG and MA was performed in 10 patients [seven women; median age 40 (range 28-55) years] after APR for rectal cancer (cT2 in one patient, cT3 in six patients and cT4 in three patients). We prospectively recorded early and late morbidity, mortality, oncological outcome, functional results (using the modified Working Party on Anal Sphincter Replacement 'WPASR' scoring system) and quality of life (QoL; using the European Organisation for Research and Treatment of Cancer 'EORTC' QLQ-C30 and QLQ-CR38 questionnaires).

RESULTS

There was no procedure-related mortality. One patient required intra-abdominal re-operation. Nine patients required local and multiple revisions [there was one coloperineal anastomosis (CPA) stenosis, five CPA mucosal prolapse, three stenosis related to graciloplasty, two MA stenosis and one MA reflux]. After a median follow up of 78 months, there was no local recurrence and six patients were alive and disease-free. Regarding the functional results, the median modified WPASR score, of 8, after a follow up of 78 months, was good. The overall QoL scores remained stable over time.

CONCLUSION

In carefully selected patients who want to avoid definitive abdominal colostomy after APR for rectal cancer, reconstruction involving MA and DG after APR for low rectal cancer is followed by good long-term function and QoL.

Evolving therapy for fecal incontinence

BACKGROUND

Fecal incontinence is common and can be socially debilitating. Nonoperative management of fecal incontinence includes dietary modification, antidiarrheal medication, and biofeedback. The traditional surgical approach is sphincteroplasty if there is a defect of the external sphincter. Innovative treatment modalities have included sacral nerve stimulation, injectable implants, dynamic graciloplasty, and artificial bowel sphincter.

DISCUSSION

This review was designed to assess the various surgical options available for fecal incontinence and critically evaluate the evidence behind these procedures. The algorithm in the surgical treatment of fecal incontinence is shifting. Injectable therapy and sacral nerve stimulation are likely to be the mainstay in future treatment of moderate and severe fecal incontinence, respectively. Sphincteroplasty is limited to a small group of patients with isolated defect of the external sphincter. A stoma, although effective, can be avoided in most cases.

[Dynamic graciloplasty vs artificial bowel sphincter in the management of severe fecal incontinence]

Dynamic graciloplasty (DGP) and the Acticon Neosphincter (artificial bowel sphincter, ABS) are well-established therapeutic instruments in patients with severe fecal incontinence. However, the success rates in the literature must be interpreted with caution. The report presented here presents firstly a critical analysis of 1510 patients in 52 studies (29 DGP vs 23 ABS). The evidence of these studies was assessed using the Oxford EBM criteria. All data were statistically analysed. Up to 94% of the studies analysed show EBM levels of only >3b. Both procedures show significant improvements in postoperative continence scores (p<0.001) and a significant advantage of ABS over DGP. Nevertheless, they are associated with a high incidence of morbidity in the long term (infection rate ABS vs DGP 21.74% vs 35.1%, revision rate ABS vs DGP 37.53% vs 40.64%, and ABS explantation rates of 30%). Presently no therapeutic recommendation can be expressed based on the few data available. Furthermore, therapy should be performed in specialized centers and patients should be given a realistic picture of the critical outcome of both surgical techniques.

Neosphincter surgery for fecal incontinence: a critical and unbiased review of the relevant literature

Up until about 15 years ago the only realistic option for end-stage fecal incontinence was the creation of a permanent stoma. There have since been several developments. Dynamic graciloplasty (DGP) and artificial bowel sphincter (ABS) are well-established surgical techniques, which offer the patient a chance for continence restoration and improved quality of life; however, they are unfortunately associated with high morbidity and low success rates. Several trials have been done in an attempt to clarify the advantages and disadvantages of these methods and define their place in the second-line treatment of severe, refractory fecal incontinence. This review presents a critical and unbiased overview of the current status of neosphincter surgery according to the available data in the world literature.

Electrodynamic smooth muscle sphincter: development and biomechanical evaluation of a novel porcine artificial smooth muscle sphincter in a new in vitro stoma simulator

AIM

Many authors have suggested that the activity of the enteric inhibitory nerves is important in regulating normal gastrointestinal motility and inducing smooth muscle relaxation. Hitherto, no experimental or clinical models exist that transfer these physiological aspects to creating an autologous artificial sphincter for the treatment of major incontinence. Therefore, this study was performed to determine the contractile and relaxant capacity of gastrointestinal muscle types and to investigate the efficiency of a novel smooth muscle sphincter, based on the non-adrenergic, non-cholinergic (NANC) receptive relaxation under electrical field stimulation (EFS).

METHODS

For the first step, the isometric tension from isolated circular porcine fundus and colon muscle strips was recorded during pharmacological stimulation (TTX, L-NNA and atropine) and EFS. As a result, a continent electrodynamic smooth muscle sphincter (ESMS) was created by wrapping a fundus muscle flap around an isolated segment of porcine distal colon. The EFS of the free nerve fibers of the flap was realized using a circular platinum wire electrode. Parameters such as threshold of continence, intra/preluminal pressure and fluid passage were analyzed in a newly designed in vitro stoma simulator.

RESULTS

Electrical field stimulation produced a maximal and voltage-dependent fundus relaxation to --12.4 mN/mm(2) (frequency of 40 Hz, pulse duration, train duration and voltage of 5 ms, 1 s and 60 mA respectively), which were abolished by N-nitro-L -arginine (L-NNA; 10(-4) M) in a dose-dependent manner, confirming that relaxant responses were mediated by NANC nerves. The results of eight ESMS showed that circular electrical stimulation of the muscle flap caused muscle relaxation with a concomitant and effective reduction in the occlusion pressure.

CONCLUSION

The NANC-induced relaxation mechanism of porcine fundus preparations could be transferred to an efficient smooth muscle sphincter with a high threshold of continence and electrically controlled defecation.

Anorectal reconstruction by electrostimulated graciloplasty as part of abdominoperineal resection

AIMS

To report the outcomes of anorectal reconstruction by electrostimulated graciloplasty as part of abdominoperineal resection, on data prospectively collected over 10 years.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Twenty-three abdominoperineal resections were associated to coloperineal pull through, double graciloplasty and loop abdominal stoma. Fifteen patients also received an implantable pulse generator, either for unsatisfactory result after external-source intermittent electrostimulation and biofeedback (five cases) or during graciloplasty (10 cases). Follow-up was to a maximum of 10 years. Functional outcome was followed up in sixteen patients who underwent stoma takedown.

RESULTS

Mean actuarial survival at 5 years was 72.3%. Satisfactory results (score < or =8) occurred in 75% of patients (three without and 13 with stimulator) in the early stages, decreasing to 57% at 1 year and gradually increasing up to 100% at 5 years and over.

CONCLUSIONS

Total anorectal reconstruction yields a good functional outcome over time. Thus, despite, and because of, a high complication rate and a great drain on resources, it should be considered a suitable procedure only for selected, strongly motivated patients.

Long-term outcomes of a neo-anus with a pudendal nerve anastomosis contemporaneously reconstructed with an abdominoperineal excision of the rectum

BACKGROUND

Pudendal nerve innervation can transform a neo-sphincter into an original anal sphincter-like muscle in animal studies. The results led us to clinical trials of a neo-anus with a pudendal nerve anastomosis (NAPNA). No long-term results in a series have been reported.

METHODS

From 1995 to 2003, a neo-anus was reconstructed by using an inferior portion of the gluteus maximum muscle with a pudendal nerve anastomosis contemporaneously with an abdominoperineal excision of the rectum (APER) in 19 patients (17 men, 2 women; median age, 62.0 years; range, 46-73) with low-lying malignancy. The long-term (<2 years) clinical results were evaluated.

RESULTS

The neo-sphincter began contracting (n = 15) at 6.6 +/- 1.8 months after surgery; then the ileostomy was closed (n = 14) at 9.1 +/- 2.6 months. The long-term results were studied in 10 patients (40.9 +/- 14.1 months after ileostomy closure). All patients (100%) defecated at 4.8 +/- 2.6 times/day without irrigation. Pads were used every day in 9 patients (90%). The Cleveland Clinic Florida incontinence score was 12.2 +/- 3.3 points. No patients lost their occupation. Eight patients (80%) answered that their life with a NAPNA was better than with an ileostomy. The average World Health Organization Quality of Life-BREF in patients with NAPNAs was significantly better than that in those patients who underwent conventional APERs in our hospital (n = 27, 66.4 +/- 0.8 years old) ( P = .0402). Four patients (40%) experiencing the need to defecate got significantly better continence score (mean +/- SD).

CONCLUSIONS

The sensitivity to recognize the need to defecate may be a key to success in NAPNAs. A NAPNA can be a practical option for selected patients wishing to avoid a stoma after an APER.

Dynamic graciloplasty for total anorectal reconstruction after abdominoperineal resection for rectal tumour

AIM

To review the results of dynamic graciloplasty for total anorectal reconstruction after abdominoperineal resection (APR) for rectal cancer.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Chart reviews were done on 17 patients who had dynamic graciloplasty following abdominoperineal resection and details of post-operative complications, bowel functions and recurrences were obtained.

RESULTS

Seventeen patients (12 males) had dynamic graciloplasty after APR for low rectal tumours. The median age was 58.5 years (range 33-78). Three patients from overseas were lost to follow-up, and three still have not had the defunctioning stoma closed. Only 11 patients were available for evaluation of function. The median time from graciloplasty to continence to solids and liquids is 15.7 months (range 0.4-21.9 months). Six patients had defecatory problems, requiring daily irrigation to evacuate. Nine patients were continent without need for gracilis stimulation. Only two patients needed gracilis stimulation to maintain continence. Fifty percent of rectal carcinoma patients had developed a recurrence.

CONCLUSION

Dynamic graciloplasty had a high morbidity and did not always bring about normal defecatory function. Gracilis stimulation was not needed to achieve continence in all cases. Conversely, dynamic graciloplasty may lead to defecatory difficulties in a large number of patients. Graciloplasty should only be considered three years after the initial APR to avoid performing the procedure in a patient who may develop recurrence as well as to select patients who are psychologically prepared for the surgery and its complications.

A review of contemporary surgical alternatives to permanent colostomy

OBJECTIVES

To review the options available to patients with faecal incontinence with failed conservative treatment and/or failed anal sphincter repair and assessing the current indications and results of these options.

METHODS

A literature search of MEDLINE, EMBASE and Cochrane databases was performed using the relevant search terms.

RESULTS

Continent options for patients with severe or end stage faecal incontinence include the creation of a form of an anal neosphincter and more recently sacral nerve stimulation. Over half the patients, who are candidates, may benefit from these procedures, although long term results of sacral nerve stimulation are unknown. Dynamic graciloplasty improves the continence in 44-79% of the patients. The complications include frequent reoperations, high incidence of infection and obstructive defaecation. The success rates of artificial bowel sphincter vary between 24% and 79%. Once functional, the artificial bowel sphincter seems to improve the continence in the majority of the patients. Device removal due to infection, obstructive defaecation and pain is a frequent problem. Sacral nerve stimulation is claimed to result in improvement in continence in 35-100% of patients. The main risks in this procedure are infection, electrode displacement and pain.

CONCLUSIONS

All these procedures have high complication rates and have moderate success rates only. A major proportion of patients will need reoperations and hence high motivation is necessary for patients who undergo these procedures. A uniform standard for measurement of success is also necessary so that these procedures can be compared with each other.

Plastic and reconstructive surgery approaches in the management of anal cancer

Various reliable reconstructive options are available for treatment of perineal and perianal skin and soft tissue defects resulting from tumor ablation. Indications for TAR include the following: very low rectal cancers, in which low anterior resection or resection with coloanal anastomosis is not possible: persistent or recurrent anal cancer that has failed to respond to chemoradiation therapy; and previous rectal excision with either recurring colostomy complications or an unacceptable quality of life with a stoma. Of course, adequate surgical oncologic principles must not be compromised to enhance sphincter reconstruction. Either primary reconstruction at the time of cancer excision or secondary reconstruction at a later date is an acceptable alternative. Most investigators believe that primary reconstruction is technically easier and associated with fewer complications. Secondary reconstruction provides the advantage of oncologic certainty. Double dynamic graciloplasty after APR has proved to be anoncologically sound procedure with a good chance of continence and a life without a stoma in most patients. Finally, the preliminary experience with new techniques of electrode implants encourages further application. In most patients who have rectal cancer, a sphincter-saving resection can avoid the need for a permanent stoma. Very low rectal tumors, however, still require an APR as the treatment of choice when a safe coloanal anastomosisis not possible. In recent years, several authors have reported their experience on sphincteric reconstruction after APR. Most of these authors used gracilis muscles transposed from the thigh to the perineum (graciloplasty) to surround a coloperineal anastomosis after pull-through of the distal colon. The best way to achieve fecal continence is to obtain a mechanically sufficient contraction of the sphincter. Electrostimulation of the transposed gracilis muscles creates an essential framework for their postoperative muscular growth and contractility. In particular, adoption of continuous low-frequency stimulation has proved to be effective in increasing fatigue resistance of the transposed muscles, allowing their continuous "pseudotonic" contraction. Despite the general acceptance of the efficacy of this scheme, there are significant variations in various authors' experiences pertaining to graciloplasty configuration, surgical timing of resection and transposition, and electrostimulation device use and implantation.

Surgical results and functional outcome after total anorectal reconstruction by double graciloplasty supported by external-source electrostimulation and/or implantable pulse generators: an 8-year experience

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Surgical and functional results after abdominoperineal resection and total anorectal reconstruction by electrostimulated gracilis muscle transposition are still poorly documented. This study prospectively evaluated surgical and functional outcome over time in our patients.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Twenty-three patients underwent abdominoperineal resection, coloperineal pullthrough, double graciloplasty, and loop abdominal stoma. Temporary external-source intermittent electrostimulation, biofeedback training, and selective delayed stimulator implantation to improve unsatisfactory results were carried out in the first 13 patients (1st series); thereafter (2nd series) the stimulator was implanted during graciloplasty. Surgical and oncological results were followed up in all patients. Functional results were evaluated in 16 patients who underwent abdominal stoma takedown, eight in each of the two series, by anomanometry (up to 1 year) and our own 0-20 scoring system (up to 8 years from initial surgery).

RESULTS

The rate of major and minor postoperative complications was 21.7% and 65%, respectively. Continuous electrostimulation proved effective on resting anal pressure. Early clinical assessments showed satisfactory functional results (considered as having a score < or =8) in all first-group patients, including five who had stimulator support, and in one-half of second-group patients. After impairment (at least 2 points) at 1 year in five patients, four of whom were from the first group, all functional results improved and became satisfactory from 5 years on (1st series) and from 4 years on (2nd series).

CONCLUSION

Despite marked morbidity the high rate of good results, which improved over time, suggests that total anorectal reconstruction is worth being performed as part of abdominoperineal resection in well-selected patients with a strong motivation to avoid a permanent colostomy.

Attainment of continence with J-pouch and artificial bowel sphincter for concomitant imperforate anus and familial adenomatous polyposis: report of a case

Numerous proven surgical therapies now exist to compensate for loss of anal sphincter function or loss of rectal reservoir capacity. Fecal incontinence that results from the combined loss of rectal reservoir and anal sphincter tone remains a surgical challenge. This case describes what may be the first successful treatment of a patient with imperforate anus and familial adenomatous polyposis using an ileal J-pouch and artificial bowel sphincter.

The effects of high field strength MRI on electrodes and pulse generator in dynamic graciloplasty

OBJECTIVE

Dynamic graciloplasty is a treatment for intractable faecal incontinence. A gracilis muscle is transposed around the anus and stimulated with an implanted pulse generator (IPG). This in vitro study was designed to determine the safety of MRI in patients with implanted electrodes and pulse generators for dynamic graciloplasty.

METHODS

Temperatures were measured with fiberoptic probes around the devices in a cadaver model. Current was measured with an oscilloscope connected to electrodes and IPG. Movement and IPG parameter setting were observed before, during and after testing.

RESULTS

Minor temperature increase under 1 degrees C were observed around the electrodes. Amplitudes measured were within the range of -1 and +1 Volt. No movement or changing of IPG parameters was noted.

CONCLUSION

Changes noted are well within physiological ranges. Dynamic graciloplasty is not a contraindication for high field strength MRI.

[Anal sphincter replacement]

Presently, deep rectal carcinoma is usually treated by deep anterior rectal resection and colonal anastomosis. Abdominoperineal resection is needed only for the very few patients whose tumors infiltrate the pelvic base or sphincter musculature. This means the loss of normal anal function and thus of normal defecation. Many patients find the idea of a stoma unacceptable. In our experience, the construction of a functional neoanus after abdominoperineal rectal resection is a suitable option for patients in good general health and who are highly motivated.

Systematic review of dynamic graciloplasty in the treatment of faecal incontinence

Background

The aim of this systematic review was to compare the safety and efficacy of dynamic graciloplasty with colostomy for the treatment of faecal incontinence.

Methods

Two search strategies were devised to retrieve literature from the Medline, Current Contents, Embase and Cochrane Library databases up until November 1999. Inclusion of papers depended on a predetermined protocol, independent assessments by two reviewers and a final consensus decision. English language papers were selected. Acceptable study designs included randomized controlled trials, controlled clinical trials and case series. Forty papers met the inclusion criteria. They were tabulated and critically appraised in terms of methodology and design, outcomes, and the possible influence of bias, confounding and chance.

Results

No high-level evidence was available and there were no comparative studies. Mortality rates were around 2 per cent for both graciloplasty and colostomy. Morbidity rates reported for graciloplasty appear to be higher than those for colostomy. Dynamic graciloplasty was clearly effective at restoring continence in between 42 and 85 per cent of patients, whereas colostomy is, by its design, incapable of restoring continence. However, dynamic graciloplasty is associated with a significant risk of reoperation.

Conclusion

While dynamic graciloplasty appears to be associated with a higher rate of complications than colostomy, it is clearly a superior intervention for restoring continence in some patients. It is recommended that a comparative, but non-randomized, study be undertaken to evaluate the safety of dynamic graciloplasty in comparison to colostomy, and that the procedure should be performed only in centres where it is carried out routinely.

Total anorectal reconstruction with an artificial bowel sphincter: Report of five cases with a minimum follow-up of 6 months

BACKGROUND: The artificial bowel sphincter (Acticon ABS - American Medical Systems, Minneapolis, MN, USA) has been proposed as a treatment for patients with faecal incontinence. The good results achieved with this procedure encouraged us to utilize this device for reconstruction of patients who previously underwent an abdominoperineal resection (APR). METHOD: Between 1999 and 2000 we implanted the ABS in five patients undergoing an APR. One patient was male and four female, the mean age was 51.3 years. Three patients had been operated on for rectal cancer, one for rectal agenesia and one for a giant benign tumour of the pelvis. RESULTS: The length of follow up ranged from 6 to 22 months. Manometry assessed a basal pressure with the ABS cuff inflated between 58 and 62.2 mmHg. All but one achieved a good grade of continence with a Wexner score range between 3 and 9. A certain degree of impaired evacuation occurred in two patients but, with adequate training, this improved and did not affect patient satisfaction. CONCLUSION: The ABS is a good option for reconstruction of patients previously treated with an APR. As compared to electrostimulated graciloplasty the ABS technique seems to be easier to perform and more acceptable for the patients, although the cost of the device is still high.

Electrical impedance, a sensory system for detection of rectal filling after anorectal reconstruction: experimental study of rectal impedance measurements and defecation in dogs

BACKGROUND

Total anorectal reconstruction with dynamic graciloplasty is an alternative to a permanent colostomy; however, perfect continence cannot be achieved because of loss of sensitivity. This study was designed in dogs to determine whether monitoring of rectal electric impedance can give information about fullness or motility of the rectum.

METHODS

Four adult female beagle dogs underwent rectal electric impedance measurements using a bipolar electrode implanted on the rectal wall. An alternating current of 1 microA at a frequency of 4 kHz was applied between the two wires. Variations of impedance (called impedance waves), defecations, and weight of stools were recorded and analyzed.

RESULTS

The basal rectal impedance was 682+/-19 omega. During the period of observation (n = 4), 84 impedance waves (amplitude, 72+/-2 omega; duration, 58+/-11 minutes) were observed and 33 defecations (weight of stools, 74+/-6 g) occurred. Four types of impedance waves were identified and classified into two groups: low-amplitude or short-duration waves (Types I, II, and III), and high-amplitude and long-duration waves (Type IV). Frequency of defecation was associated with the amplitude of the waves. The weight of stools was correlated with the duration of the waves (r = 0.574, n = 27, P = 0.002). Types I, II, and III waves were correlated with eventual partial defecations, whereas Type IV waves were correlated with complete defecations. After defecation, no spontaneous new defecation occurred before recovering at least 80 percent of the basal impedance.

CONCLUSIONS

Rectal impedance variations are correlated with defecation in a canine model, and single bipolar measurements provide a suitable evaluation of rectum fullness. This suggests the possible use of impedance signals to control electrostimulated graciloplasty after anorectal reconstruction.

Neosphincters in the management of faecal incontinence

BACKGROUND

Surgical treatment of end-stage faecal incontinence has its origin in the early 1950s. Interest has been revived as a result of technical advances achieved in the recent past. The purpose of this article is to review the principles that underlie the use of skeletal muscle transposition around the anal canal and of electrical stimulation in the treatment of incontinence, and to explore new methods of treatment of this condition.

METHODS

A literature search was performed using Pubmed and Medline, employing keywords related to treatment of faecal incontinence by neosphincter reconstruction. Basic science and clinical aspects of neosphincter reconstruction were gathered from relevant texts, original articles and recently published abstracts.

RESULTS

The electrically stimulated gracilis neoanal sphincter seems to be the popular choice of biological neosphincter. It is more likely to produce higher resting anal canal pressures than the unstimulated neosphincter, and hence improved continence. However, electrostimulator failure may result in explantation in a proportion of patients. Impairment of evacuation is a functional setback in approximately one-third of patients with the gracilis neosphincter. Overall, improvement of continence may be expected in up to 90 per cent of patients according to some reports. By contrast, experience with the artificial neosphincter, which is less expensive, has been limited to a few tertiary centres across the world. Reported continence of stool is 100 per cent, and that of gas and stool 50 per cent, following implantation of the artificial sphincter. Both of the above operations have been associated with implant-related infection and impaired evacuation.

CONCLUSION

Neoanal sphincter operations are technically demanding, require a considerable learning experience and should be confined to specialist colorectal centres. Patients are likely to benefit from a plan that incorporates preoperative counselling and a selective approach.

Experimental model of anorectal transplantation

BACKGROUND

Anorectal transplantation with pudendal nerve anastomosis after rectal excision is a possible strategy that would avoid a colostomy and recreate potentially normal anorectal function. This study investigates the technical feasibility of anorectal transplantation with pudendal nerve and inferior mesenteric artery and vein anastomosis in a porcine model.

METHODS

Four female pigs (22-42 kg) provided donor anorectum for four male recipients (29-39 kg) under standard general anaesthesia. The donor operation involved abdominoperineal excision of rectum (APR) taking the anal sphincter, pudendal neurovascular bundle and inferior mesenteric vessels. The recipient underwent APR, transperineal introduction of the donor graft, anastomoses of the rectum, inferior mesenteric vessels and pudendal neurovascular bundle, and perineal closure. Recorded variables were duration of each step of transplantation, ischaemic time, dimensions of anastomosed structures and postoperative graft viability. Animals were killed at 24 h, the state of the graft was noted and tissue was taken for confirmatory histology.

RESULTS

Mean operation time was 372 (range 303-435)min. Mean ischaemic time was 118 (100-130)min. Before death, observation at laparotomy revealed two pink grafts, one slightly dusky but healthy graft and one outright failure, reflecting the state of the mesenteric vessels, which were patent in three and thrombosed in one. Histological examination showed no difference between control biopsies and the three cases with satisfactory mesenteric flow. Gross ischaemia was present histologically in the failed case.

CONCLUSION

Anorectal transplantation is technically feasible in a pig model. Longer-term studies are now needed to assess return of function and overcome rejection issues.

Morbidity and functional outcome after double dynamic graciloplasty for anorectal reconstruction

BACKGROUND

After abdominoperineal resection (APR), anorectal reconstruction with dynamic graciloplasty has been proposed to avoid abdominal colostomy and improve quality of life. Graciloplasties involving one or two gracilis muscles with various configurations have been described. The aim of this study was to evaluate morbidity and functional results in a homogeneous series of patients undergoing double dynamic graciloplasty following APR for rectal cancer.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

: From May 1995 to May 1998, 15 patients (ten men and five women; mean age 54 (range 39-77) years) underwent anorectal reconstruction with double dynamic graciloplasty after APR for low rectal carcinoma. All patients had preoperative radiotherapy (45 Gy), 11 with concomitant chemotherapy, eight had intraoperative radiotherapy (15 Gy) and ten received adjuvant chemotherapy for 6 months. The surgical procedure was performed in three stages: APR with coloperineal anastomosis and double graciloplasty (double muscle wrap); implantation of the stimulator 2 months later; and ileostomy closure after a training period.

RESULTS

There was no operative death. At a mean of 28 (range 3-48) months of follow-up, there was no local recurrence; two patients had lung metastases. Early and late morbidity occurred in 11 patients, mainly related to the neosphincter (12 of 16 complications). The main complication was stenosis of the neosphincter (n = 6), which developed with electrical stimulation. Of 12 patients available for functional outcome, seven were continent, two were incontinent and three had an abdominal colostomy (two for incontinence, one for sepsis). Compared with patients without stenosis, patients with neosphincter stenosis required major reoperations (four versus zero) and had a poor outcome (two of six versus five of six with a good result).

CONCLUSION

The double dynamic graciloplasty is associated with a high risk of neosphincter stenosis, which may entail morbidity, reintervention and poor functional results. The stenosis is a heterogeneous feature of the neosphincter induced by asymmetrical traction of both gracilis muscles. It is suggested that single dynamic graciloplasty should be used for anorectal reconstruction after APR. Presented to the 101st congress of the Association Française de Chirurgie in Paris, France, October 1999, and to the European Council of Coloproctology in Munich, Germany, October-November 1999

Total anorectal and partial vaginal reconstruction with dynamic graciloplasty and colonic vaginoplasty after extended abdominoperineal resection: report of a case

PURPOSE

Quality of life is altered after abdominoperineal resection, because of permanent iliac colostomy. Psychological rehabilitation is even more difficult after extended abdominoperineal resection to the vagina, because of the loss of both continence and sexual functions. We report the first case of total anorectal and vaginal reconstruction using dynamic graciloplasty and colonic vaginoplasty after extended abdominoperineal resection.

METHODS

A 46-year-old female underwent extended abdominoperineal resection with posterior colpectomy for a low rectal adenocarcinoma infiltrating the anal sphincter and vagina. Anorectal reconstruction was performed with coloperineal anastomosis and double dynamic graciloplasty. Vaginal reconstruction was performed using a 10-cm, isolated, rotated sigmoid loop. The procedure was performed in three stages, including abdominoperineal resection with reconstruction, implantation of the stimulator, and closure of the temporary ileostomy.

RESULTS

Resting and electrostimulated pressures of the neosphincter were 40 and 110 cm H2O respectively. Continence was achieved for formed stools two months after closure of the stoma, with spontaneous defecations (30-90 minutes). The patient experienced regular sexual activity six months after closure of the stoma.

CONCLUSION

This new original technique can be proposed in selected young females after extended abdominoperineal resection, to preserve continence, sexual activity, and body image.

Secondary coloperineal pull-through and double dynamic graciloplasty after Miles resection--feasible, but with a high morbidity

PURPOSE

Until recently, patients who underwent abdominoperineal resections had to cope with a colostomy for the rest of their lives. For some of these patients this colostomy was a terrible burden, physically and mentally. Publications about abdominoperineal pull-through and double dynamic graciloplasty immediately after a Miles resection showed good results. The purpose of this study was to investigate the procedure as a secondary approach after abdominoperineal resections.

METHODS

In this study seven patients were evaluated. All had had an abdominoperineal resection and proved to have unbearable problems with their stoma. All had a secondary pull-through and double dynamic graciloplasty, a mean of 8.5 (range, 1.1-34.8) years after the Miles resection.

RESULTS

In five patients continence was regained; two were reversed to colostomy because of several complications. Patients who had a successful outcome also suffered from numerous complications, with a total mean hospital stay of 73.8 (range, 27-167) days, a mean of 3.1 (range, 1-6) additional operations, and 1.8 (range, 0-4) readmissions.

CONCLUSION

Secondary anorectal reconstruction after abdominoperineal resection is a feasible option, but with a high morbidity. Because of this the procedure was stopped at the beginning of 1997.

Anal sphincter reconstruction by dynamic graciloplasty after abdominoperineal resection for cancer

PURPOSE

Chronic low-frequency electrical stimulation can safely transform fatiguing muscle into fatigue-resistant muscle. This fundamental discovery was used to reconstruct the anal sphincter. Dynamic graciloplasty was found to be effective in the treatment of fecal incontinence. Our study was undertaken to investigate the oncologic, functional, and quality of life results of dynamic graciloplasty anal reconstruction after an abdominoperineal resection for carcinoma.

METHODS

Between April 1993 and April 1996, nine patients (4 males) with a median age of 51.2 (range, 29-69) years underwent an abdominoperineal resection for carcinoma (4 had a rectal adenocarcinoma and 5 had an epidermoidal anal tumor) and an anal sphincter reconstruction with electrically stimulated graciloplasty. Oncologic and functional results were evaluated after a mean follow-up of 32 (range, 14-50) months. A quality of life questionnaire was filled out by seven patients.

RESULTS

Sphincter reconstruction required the same hospitalization period as abdominoperineal resection. Two patients died from evolutive disease. Three patients were operated on twice, one for immediate colonic necrosis, two for colonic perforation after enema. One of them refused the graciloplasty and had an abdominoperineal resection. Six patients were dysfunctioned. The mean resting pressure was 24 +/- 10 mmHg, and the mean pressure during stimulation was 95 +/- 25 mmHg. Five patients were continent for solids and liquid; four wore less than three pads per day, and one wore more than three. Four patients used enemas twice a week; one patient had spontaneous evacuation. The quality of life questionnaire showed that the mean scores for social interaction, symptoms, and psychological and physical states were 2.1, 2.2, 2.4, and 2.7, respectively. The mean value was 1.5.

CONCLUSIONS

Total anorectal reconstruction with dynamic graciloplasty is an oncologically safe procedure. Functional results improve with time, but careful patient selection guarantees a successful functional outcome. Technical progress is necessary to improve the quality of life.

Anorectal reconstruction after abdominoperineal resection. Experience with double-wrap graciloplasty supported by low-frequency electrostimulation

PURPOSE

The aims of the study contained herein were to analyze the efficacy and safety of a chronically electrostimulated double-wrap graciloplasty for restoration of continence after a curative abdominoperineal resection for rectal carcinoma and to evaluate late results of a stimulation protocol that was begun early.

METHODS

During the last six years, 31 consecutive patients underwent this procedure: in 24 patients, electrostimulated double-wrap graciloplasty was performed simultaneously with abdominoperineal resection for lower rectal cancer, 7 strictly selected patients underwent conversion to an abdominal stoma following previous abdominoperineal resection (mean length of time from stoma creation, 71.4 months) Anorectal reconstruction was performed following a surgical scheme already standarized since 1985 in 102 patients: after abdominoperineal resection, the distal colon was pulled through to the perineum and surrounded by both gracilis muscles following an "alfa and new-sling" configuration; using platinumiridium electrodes, both muscles were then connected to pulse generator, which was implanted subcutaneously in the abdomen. All surgical steps were performed during the same surgical session to allow early postoperative stimulation of the transposed muscles. A contemporary covering stoma was abandoned as a standard procedure; the distal colon was left closed for a few postoperative days, then it was resected and sutured to the perineum under local anesthesia. Eighteen patients underwent preoperative or postoperative radiotherapy or both, without any significant adverse outcome. To increase gracilis resistance to prolonged "tonic" contraction, patients underwent a chronic, low-frequency stimulation protocol. In the last 11 patients, a new "over-the-nerve and intramuscular" implant was adopted to optimize fiber recruitment and to reduce electrostimulation thresholds. At regular intervals, all patients were evaluated using continence scores and questionnaires, electromanometry, endoluminal ultrasound study, and defecography.

RESULTS

Twenty-six of 31 patients were evaluated for continence, with a mean length of follow-up of 37.8 (range, 4-68) months; 3 patients died because of cancer recurrence, 1 underwent conversion to an abdominal stoma, and 1 is waiting for stoma closure. Continence to liquid and solid stools was achieved in 22 patients (85 percent), and electromanometry findings confirmed a good muscular contraction postoperatively and during follow-up intervals. No postoperative mortality (40 days) was observed; the postoperative complication rate was high 22-percent), but early treatment (drainage and temporary diversion in 7 patients) led to favorable outcomes (4 resolutions, 3 partial muscular impairments). Four stimulators had to be temporarily explanted because of late complications, and two stimulators had to be replaced because of battery exhaustion after three years of use with high stimulation parameters. A significant difference was observed comparing full-contracting threshold after intramuscular (14 patients) and the new over-the-nerve and intramuscular implant technique.

CONCLUSIONS

The study contained herein confirms the efficacy of the surgical scheme we have adopted since 1985 to reconstruct sphincteric apparatus after abdominoperineal resection of the rectum. The "one-step" timing of surgical and electrostimulation-related procedures and the early start of stimulation did not show a significant increase in the complication rate and did not produce noticeable muscular or nerve damage. Adoption of chronic electrostimulation protocols using implantable devices increased the rate of fully continent patients; nevertheless, the overall cost for devices and medical staff duties was high, and a small increase of late morbidity was observed. Finally, the preliminary experience with our new technique of electrode implants encourages further application.

Modern surgical treatment of anal incontinence

New surgical treatment modalities have been developed for patients with anal incontinence resulting from extensive sphincter destruction and in whom standard sphincter repair has failed. These new modalities include the transposition of striated skeletal muscles combined with implantation of neurostimulators, artificial sphincters based on the same principle as artificial urinary sphincters, and direct sacral nerve stimulation. In a few reported series muscle transposition in combination with neurostimulation has given a satisfactory continence in 50-70% of the patients. The same is true for the smaller series published on artificial anal sphincters, whereas the results of sacral nerve stimulation have thus far been reported in only a few patients. The selection of patients and the performance of these procedures should be limited to few specialist centres.