Selection of ovarian stimulation protocol is related to IVF treatment outcome in women 35 years of age and older

LH improves early follicular recruitment in women over 38 years old

Although the capacity of recombinant FSH alone to induce folliculogenesis is undisputed, many believe that follicular recruitment in women over 38 years old could be improved by supplementing rFSH with human menopausal gonadotrophin (HMG). The present study sought to determine whether recombinant LH could reproduce the effect of HMG in women over 38 years during ovulation induction. Fifty-eight patients received rFSH (225 IU/day) supplemented with one ampoule of HMG (75 IU of FSH/75 IU of LH/HCG per day) for 5 days. Another 36 patients received rFSH (300 IU/day) supplemented with one ampoule of rLH (75 IU/day), also for 5 days. Both groups of patients received similar amounts of rFSH (1500 IU), LH/HCG (375 IU) and rLH (375 IU) and recruited a similar number of follicles as counted on day 6 (4.07 +/- 3.1 in the HMG group versus 3.7 +/- 3.2 in the LH group respectively) or on the day that human chorionic gonadotrophin (HCG) was indicated (6.5 +/- 2.7 versus 5.8 +/- 2.5 respectively). Ovarian stimulation was shorter, but not significantly so, in the group of patients receiving rFSH + HMG (10.5 +/- 1.7 days) than in the group of patients treated with rFSH +/- rLH (12 +/- 1.8 days). Significantly more MII oocytes were seen in the group treated with rFSH + rLH than in the group treated with rFSH + HMG (93.1 versus 75.3%, P < 0.05). With respect to pregnancy rates, 14/54 (26%) patients receiving rFSH + HMG and 16/34 (47%) patients receiving rFSH + rLH had a positive serum HCG. No significant difference in the number of miscarriages was observed between the two groups. In conclusion, the present results seem to indicate that rLH could be the HMG component that aids early follicular recruitment.

Endometrial evaluation is not predictive for in vitro fertilization treatment

PURPOSE

The main purpose of this study was to evaluate ovarian function by clomiphene citrate (CC) challenge test in a group of tubal infertile women and to study endometrial morphological maturation in the early luteal phase of CC-stimulated cycles as compared to in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment outcome.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Four women presented with strongly retarded, proliferative endometrium in the luteal phase. Of these, three presented with impaired ovarian function, high basal follicle-stimulating hormone, and high follicle-stimulating hormone levels after clomiphene stimulation on cycle day 10. In the remaining 30 women, showing an in-phase endometrium after CC stimulation, a comparison of six morphological characteristics did not reveal any significant differences between the 14 women who did become pregnant and the 16 who did not. No significant differences in endometrial thickness were observed between the groups. Significant differences were found when comparing estradiol and progesterone area under the curve during the luteal phase (P < 0.001 and P < 0.01, respectively) between those who did and those who did not become pregnant.

CONCLUSIONS

Luteal endometrium morphology was not a sharp instrument to detect differences between women who did and women who did not become pregnant following IVF treatment, while ovarian function, as measured by hormonal markers, seemed to be a more reliable prognostic factor for IVF treatment outcome.

Importance of endometrial quality in women with tubal infertility during a natural menstrual cycle for the outcome of IVF treatment

PURPOSE

The importance of endometrial maturation at estimated time of implantation for the outcome of IVF treatment in regularly menstruating women with tubal infertility was evaluated.

METHODS

FSH was measured on cycle day 3, on days 10-15 urine and blood were collected to estimate the day of the LH peak, and E2 and P4 were measured during the luteal phase, on cycle days 19-26. An endometrial biopsy was obtained on days LH + 3 to LH + 6.

RESULTS

The number of subjects with delayed endometrial maturation was larger in the group of infertile women who did not become pregnant compared to pregnant women and controls. Those infertile women who did not become pregnant after IVF treatment also presented with a higher basal FSH on cycle day 3 and lower E2 and P4 AUC in the luteal phase. Six infertile women and two controls presented with mid- and late-proliferative endometrium in the luteal phase on cycle days LH + 3 to LH + 6, in the presence of adequate E2 and P4 secretion. Six morphological characteristics were compared in the three groups: (1) 17 infertile women who became pregnant, (2) 18 who did not become pregnant, and (3) 28 controls. The pregnant infertile women did not differ from the controls. The numbers of glandular and stromal mitoses were significantly higher in those women who did not become pregnant (P < 0.01) compared with those who became pregnant. Endometrial biopsies obtained on cycle days LH + 5 and LH + 6 showed significant differences in glandular epithelial height (P < 0.05) and number of vacuolated cells among the nonpregnant women (P < 0.01), the pregnant women (P < 0.05), and controls.

CONCLUSIONS

A higher frequency of retarded endometrial development in women who did not become pregnant following IVF treatment was found. In some cases, endometrial insensitivity could most likely cause retarded endometrial development and failure of implantation after IVF treatment, which could not be overcome by routine luteal-phase support. However, our results do not allow conclusions concerning its relative importance compared to preembryo quality; this has to be investigated further.

Zona pellucida thickness variation and occurrence of visible mononucleated blastomers in preembryos are associated with a high pregnancy rate in IVF treatment

PURPOSE

The ability of six morphological criteria (embryo development rate, fragmentation, regularity of blastomere shape, equality of blastomere size, zona pellucida thickness variation [ZPTV], and visible mononucleated blastomeres [VMBs]) to predict pregnancy in IVF treatment cycles was evaluated.

METHODS

In order to select a homogeneous study group, 85 consecutive nulliparous couples with single tubal infertility undergoing their first IVF treatment and receiving three preembryos at embryo replacement 2 days after ovum pickup were included.

RESULTS

A total of 255 preembryos was replaced two days after ovum pickup and resulted in 34 clinical pregnancies (40%). By logistic regression analysis, ZPTV and VMBs showed highly significant and strong predictive values, whereas none of the other parameters was a significant predictor of pregnancy. In the treatments in which all replaced preembryos had a ZPTV of less than 15%, the pregnancy rate was extremely low (1/22). If the maximum ZPTV of any of the replaced preembryos was in the interval between 15 and 20%, the pregnancy rate was 24.1% (7129). In the treatments in which at least one preembryo had a ZPTV of more than 20%, the pregnancy rate was 76.5% (26/34). When VMBs were added to the results of the ZPTV analysis, the pregnancy rate was as high as 92.3% (24/26).

CONCLUSIONS

ZPTV and VMBs seem to be strong predictors of pregnancy in IVF treatment and thus important indicators of good embryo quality.

Ovarian function in relation to the outcome of in vitro fertilization (IVF) treatment in regularly menstruating women with tubal infertility

STUDY DESIGN

Ovarian endocrine function was evaluated in 53 regularly menstruating women, 27 to 38 years of age, who failed to conceive at least 2 years following reconstructive surgery for tubal infertility. Thirty apparently healthy women, 24 to 40 years of age with proven fertility, served as controls. Blood samples were obtained daily on cycle days 2-4 and 22-26 to assess FSH, E2, and P4 results.

RESULTS

There was a tendency for women with more advanced tubal damage to be subjected to more extensive surgery. Based on extent of reconstructive surgery, the patients were divided into three groups. Group A (n = 29) had less extensive surgery, limited to the fallopian tubes, group B (n = 14) included patients with extended adhesiolysis, and group C (n = 10) comprised patients that had the most extensive reconstructive procedures involving ovarian surgery. Significantly highest FSH levels were found in group C (P < 0.001) compared to groups A and B in the early follicular phase. During the luteal phase, E2 levels were lower in groups B (P < 0.01) and C (P < 0.001) compared to group A. P4 levels were lower in group C compared to groups A and B.

CONCLUSION

When the patients underwent IVF treatment higher grades of tubal damage, more extensive surgery and hormonal signs of ovarian insufficiency were highly related to treatment failure.