3-D dosimetric methodology in multiple isocentres radiosurgery: the influence of dose-volume histograms on the choice of the reference isodose

Prediction of AVM obliteration after stereotactic radiotherapy using radiobiological modelling

This study was carried out in order to derive the radiobiological parameters of the dose-response relation for the obliteration of arteriovenous malformation (AVM) following single fraction stereotactic radiotherapy. Furthermore, the accuracy by which the linear Poisson model predicts the probability of obliteration and how the haemorrhage history, location and volume of the AVM influence its radiosensitivity are investigated. The study patient material consists of 85 patients who received radiation for AVM therapy. Radiation-induced AVM obliterations were assessed on the basis of post-irradiation angiographies and other radiological findings. For each patient the dose delivered to the clinical target volume and the clinical treatment outcome were available. These data were used in a maximum likelihood analysis to calculate the best estimates of the parameters of the linear Poisson model. The uncertainties of these parameters were also calculated and their individual influence on the dose-response curve was studied. AVM radiosensitivity was assumed to be the same for all the patients. The radiobiological model used was proved suitable for predicting the treatment outcome pattern of the studied patient material. The radiobiological parameters of the model were calculated for different AVM locations, bleeding histories and AVM sizes. The range of parameter variability had considerable effect on the dose-response curve of AVM. The correlation between the dosimetric data and their corresponding clinical effect could be accurately modelled using the linear Poisson model. The derived response parameters can be introduced into the clinical routine with the calculated accuracy assuming the same methodology in target definition and delineation. The known volume dependence of AVM radiosensitivity was confirmed. Moreover, a trend relating AVM location with its radiosensitivity was observed.

Linac radiosurgery for cerebral arteriovenous malformations: results in 169 patients

PURPOSE

To present the SALT group results using Linac radiosurgery (RS) for AVM in 169 evaluable patients treated from January 1990 thru December 1993.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Median age was 33 years (range 6-68 years). Irradiation was the only treatment in 55% patients. Other treatment modalities had been used prior to RS in 45%: one or more embolizations in 36%, surgery in 6%, and embolization and surgery in 3% patients. Nidus were supratentorial in 94% patients, infratentorial in 6% patients. Circular 15 MV x-ray minibeams (6-20 mm) were delivered in coronal arcs by a GE-CGR Saturne 43 Linac. Patient set-up included a Betti arm-chair, a Talairach frame. Prescribed peripheral dose was 25 Gy on the 60%-70% isodose (max dose 100%). Arteriographic results were reassessed in December 1997 at 48 to 96 months follow-up.

RESULTS

The overall obliteration rate (OR) was 64% (108/169). AVM volumes ranged from 280 to 19,920 mm(3), median 2460 mm(3). OR was 70% for AVM </= 4200 mm(3) 4200 mm(3) (p 25 mm (p = 0.04). OR was 71%, in the absence of embolization, vs. 54% for previously embolized nidus (p = 0.03). OR was 71% for monocentric RS vs. 54% for multi-isocenters (p 28 Gy vs. 55% for values </= 28 Gy (p 79% vs. 57% for lower values (p 17 Gy, vs. 59% for mLd </= 16 Gy (p 40%, vs. 54% for mLi </= 40% (p 85% vs. 60% for CR </= 84% (NS). For patients treated according to our protocol, i.e., 24-26 Gy on the 60%-70% isodoses, OR was higher (68%) than for other patients (47%) (p = 0.02). After multivariate analysis, absence of previous embolization and mono isocentric-irradiation were independent factors predicting obliteration. Complications were: recurrent hemorrhage, 4 patients (1 patient died); brain necrosis on MRI, 2 patients; subsequent epilepsy, 4 patients; other subsequent neurologic deficits, 3 patients.

CONCLUSION

Overall OR was 64% (48-96 months follow-up). After monovariate analysis higher ORs were associated with smaller volumes </= 4200 mm(3), smaller nidus size </= 25 mm, absence of prior embolization, monoisocentric RS, higher values for mean and minimum lesion doses and compliance to our protocol. Higher values for the peripheral dose and isodose tended to give better results. Multivariate analysis showed that the absence of prior embolization and monoisocentric irradiation were independent factors predicting successful irradiation.

[Implementation of receiver operating characteristics for the quantitative evaluation of stereotactic radiotherapy treatment plans]

The definition of criteria and of a methodology dedicated to the quantitative evaluation of conformal stereotactic treatment plans is presented. We implemented the 'Receiver Operating Characteristics' (ROC) analysis, already used in medical imaging, for the quantitative evaluation of irradiation treatment plans. This implementation is based on data provided by dose-volume histograms (DVH). Three techniques, each one using a different dosimetric criterion, were defined for the choice of a reference isodose for a given treatment plan. We used this ROC analysis for the selection of the most conformal treatment plan and its reference isodose among the treatment plans proposed for one patient. This study revealed the interest of ROC analysis based on dose-volume histograms for the quantitative evaluation of treatment plans.

Multimedia educational services in stereotactic radiotherapy

The computer-based learning methods in medicine have been well established as stand-alone learning systems. Recently, these systems were enriched with the use of telematics technology to provide distance learning capabilities. Stereotactic radiotherapy is one of the most representative advanced radiotherapy techniques. Due to the multidisciplinary character of the technique and the rapid evolution of technology implemented, the demands in training have increased. The potential of interactive multimedia and Internet technologies for the achievement of distance learning capabilities in this domain are investigated. The realization of a computer-based educational program in stereotactic radiotherapy in a multimedia format is a new application in the computer-aided distance learning field. The system is built according to a client and server architecture, based on the Internet infrastructure, and composed of server nodes. The impact of the system may be described in terms of: time and transportation costs saving, flexibility in training (scheduling, rate and subject selection), online communication and interaction with experts, cost effective access to material (delivery or access by a large number of users and revision of the material by avoiding high costs of computer-based training systems and database development).

A computerized dosimetric database for conformal stereotactic irradiations

An innovative computerized dosimetric database (DDB) is proposed to enable the analysis of the stereotactic radiosurgical dose distributions; it contains relationships between the irradiation parameters and the dose-volume data. Dose-volume data provide guidance to the physicist-physician team by facilitating the initialization of the irradiation parameters and the treatment planning. The presented DDB contains dose-volume data such as the 70% isodose widths and the 70%-30% isodose penumbra along the right-left, anterior-posterior, and superior-inferior directions as a function of the irradiation parameters defined by the user. In order to demonstrate the usefulness of the DDB, the effects of the collimator diameter, the number of arcs, and their length on the shape of the prescription isodose surface are shown and are related to practical considerations for the treatment plan. However, the presented DDB is one example that can be generated by the DDB system. The planner can define as many different DDBs as he/she wishes, which can then be used for different investigations. This type of DDB enables us to investigate the irradiation technique used, to compare different irradiation techniques, to inspect the feasibility of planning different lesion types, or to define some dosimetric rules. The DDB provides useful interactive guidelines for the treatment planning process and replaces the voluminous dosimetric atlas. It has now been in clinical use for a year in a conformal procedure which automatically proposes collimator diameters, arc positions, and lengths allowing rapid conformal planning.

Single-fraction stereotactic radiotherapy: a dose-response analysis of arteriovenous malformation obliteration

PURPOSE

Stereotactic radiotherapy delivered in a high-dose single fraction is an effective technique to obliterate intracranial arteriovenous malformations (AVM). To attempt to analyze the relationships between dose, volume, and obliteration rates, we studied a group of patients treated using single-isocenter treatment plans.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From May 1986 to December 1989, 100 consecutive patients with angiographically proven AVM had stereotactic radiotherapy delivered as a high-dose single fraction using a single-isocenter technique. Distribution according to Spetzler-Martin grade was as follows: 79 grade 1-3, three grade 4, 0 grade 5, and 18 grade 6. The target volume was spheroid in 74 cases, ellipsoid in 11, and large and irregular in 15. The targeted volume of the nidus was estimated using two-dimensional stereotactic angiographic data and, calculated as an ovoid-shaped lesion, was 1900 +/- 230 mm3 (median 968 mm3; range 62-11, 250 mm3). The mean minimum target dose (Dmin) was 19 +/- 0.6 Gy (median 20 Gy; range: 3-31.5). The mean volume within the isodose which corresponded to the minimum target dose was 2500 +/- 300 mm3 (median 1200 mm3; range 75-14 900 mm3). The mean maximum dose (Dmax) was 34.5 +/- 0.5 Gy (median 35 Gy; range 15-45). The mean angiographic follow-up was 42 +/- 2.3 months (median 37.5; range 7-117).

RESULTS

The absolute obliteration rate was 51%. The 5-year actuarial obliteration rate was 62.5 +/- 7%. After univariate analysis, AVM obliteration was influenced by previous surgery (p = 0.0007), Dmin by steps of 5 Gy (p = 0.005), targeted volume of the nidus (< or = 968 mm3 vs. >968 mm3; p = 0.015), and grade according to Spetzler-Martin (grade 1-3 vs. grade 4-6; p = 0.011). After multivariate analysis, the independent factors influencing AVM obliteration were the Dmin [relative risk (RR) 1.9; 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.4-2.5; p < 0.0001] and grade distribution according to Spetzler-Martin (RR 1.4; 95% CI 1.1-1.7; p = 0.010). Delayed complications were observed in eight patients. The 5-year actuarial rate of delayed complications was 7.4%.

CONCLUSION

After stereotactic radiotherapy delivered in a single high dose using a single-isocenter technique, the success rate for complete obliteration is independently correlated to Dmin but does not seem to be influenced by Dmax and the targeted volume of the nidus.

[Progress in optimizing dosimetry plans in stereotactic radiotherapy in the Salt Group (Saint-Anne-Lariboisière-Tenon]

We began intracranial stereotactic irradiation under the direction of O Betti 11 years ago. At the present time, we believe it is interesting to present the methodologies of the SALT (Saint-Anne-Lariboisière-Tenon) group. Up to the present time we have irradiated 693 patients using a single fraction. Arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) represented the majority (90%) of treated lesions. Irradiation protocol has little changed since 1986, and the localization of the target volume was performed in the neurosurgery department of St Anne Hospital, France. The stereotactic images (computerized tomography [CT], angiography) were sent to the radiotherapy department of Tenon Hospital through the French public digital network NUMERIS. Protocol was realized using the stereotactic ARTEMIS-3D/Dosigray TPS. The lesion volume was filled by one or more spherical or elliptical subvolumes using the "Associated Target Methodology". The interactive adjustment of subvolumes was based on the 3D graphical representations of the lesion. The direct optimization of the irradiation space was performed by managing parameters provided by the DDB (Dosimetric Data Base) such as the number of arcs, their angular position, as well as the starting and the ending point of each arc. The evaluation of the calculated dose distribution was made using quantitative parameters. The second method of optimization was based on the minibeam intensity modulation using a mathematical theory of inverse problems and singular value decomposition (SVD) analysis. At the present time, due to technical reasons, linear accelerators do not permit the modulation of intensity of arctherapy. Thus we transformed the profiles of irregular forms into rectangular profiles of modulated ponderation, with each optimized plan being evaluated before its implementation. The criteria of evaluation were derived from the differential and cumulative dose volume histograms (DVH). The DVHs permitted the evaluation of the volumes of underdosage and overdosage inside the lesion and in the healthy tissue, respectively. Using DVHs, we have defined parameters such as the conform factor and the homogeneity index. We stress that the methodology of protocol optimization is valid for single or multiple fractions as well as for intra- and extra-cranial irradiation.

Treatment of brain arteriovenous malformations by embolization and radiosurgery

Embolization was used to reduce the size of brain arteriovenous malformations (AVMs) prior to radiosurgical treatment in 125 patients who were poor surgical candidates or had refused surgery. Of these patients, 81% had suffered hemorrhage, and 22.4% had undergone treatment at another institution. According to the Spetzler-Martin scale, the AVMs were Grade II in 9.6%, Grade III in 31.2%, Grade IV in 30.4%, and Grades V to VI in 28.8% of the cases. Most embolizations were performed using cyanoacrylate delivered by flow-guided microcatheters. Radiosurgery was performed using a linear accelerator in 62 patients treated by the authors, and 34 patients were treated at other institutions using various methods. Embolization produced total occlusion in 11.2% of AVMs and reduced 76% of AVMs enough to allow radiosurgery. Radiosurgery produced total occlusion in 65% of the partially embolized AVMs (79% when the residual nidus was < 2 cm in diameter). Embolizations resulted in a mortality rate of 1.6% and a morbidity rate of 12.8%. No complications were associated with radiosurgery. The hemorrhage rate for partially embolized AVMs was 3% per year. No patient with a completely occluded AVM experienced rehemorrhage. Angiographic follow-up review of AVMs embolized with cyanoacrylate demonstrated a 11.8% revascularization rate, occurring within 1 year. It is concluded that after partial embolization with cyanoacrylate, the risk of hemorrhage from the residual nidus is comparable to the natural history of AVMs and that the residual nidus can be irradiated with results almost as good as for a native AVM of the same size.