Clonality Analysis of Benign Parathyroid Lesions by Human Androgen Receptor (HUMARA) Gene Assay

Intratumor heterogeneity in human parathyroid tumors

Parathyroid tumors are the second most common endocrine neoplasia after thyroid neoplasia. They are mostly associated with impaired parathormone (PTH) synthesis and release determining the metabolic and clinical condition of primary hyperparathyroidism (PHPT). PHPT is the third most prevalent endocrine disorder, mainly affecting postmenopausal women. Parathyroid benign tumors, both adenomas of a single gland or hyperplasia involving all the glands, are the main histotypes, occurring in more than 95% of PHPT cases. The differential diagnosis between benign and malignant parathyroid lesions is a challenge for clinicians. It relies on histologic features, which display significant overlap between the histotypes with different clinical outcomes. Parathyroid adenomas and hyperplasia have been considered so far as a unique monoclonal/polyclonal entity, while accumulating evidence suggest great heterogeneity. Intratumor parathyroid heterogeneity involves tumor cell type, as well as tumor cell function, in terms of PTH synthesis and secretion, and of expression patterns of membrane and nuclear receptors (calcium sensing receptor, vitamin D receptor, α-klotho receptor and others). Intratumor heterogeneity can also interfere with cell molecular biology, in regard to clonality, oncosuppressor gene expression (such as MEN1 and HRPT2/CDC73), transcription factors (GCM2, TBX1) and microRNA expression. Such heterogeneity is likely involved in the phenotypic variability of the parathyroid tumors, and it should be considered in the clinical management, though at present target therapies are not available, with the exception of the calcium sensing receptor agonists.

Polyclonal origin of parathyroid tumors is common and is associated with multiple gland disease in primary hyperparathyroidism

BACKGROUND

Parathyroid tumors are mostly considered monoclonal neoplasms, the rationale for focused parathyroidectomy in primary hyperparathyroidism. We reported that flow sorting parathyroid tumor cells and methylation-sensitive polymerase chain reaction (me-PCR) of polymorphic human androgen receptor gene and phosphoglycerate kinase gene alleles in deoxyribonucleic acid reveals that ≤35% of parathyroid tumors are polyclonal. We sought to confirm these findings and assess for clinical relevance.

METHODS

Parathyroid tumors from 286 female primary hyperparathyroidism patients were analyzed for clonal status. Tumor clonal status was compared with clinical variables and operative findings. Statistical analysis was performed and significance was established at P < .05.

RESULTS

In the study, 176 (62%) patients were informative for human androgen receptor gene and/or phosphoglycerate kinase gene. Assignment of clonal status was made in 119 (68%) tumors, of which 64 (54%) were monoclonal and 55 (46%) were polyclonal. Comparison of tumor clonal status to clinical variables in patients with complete operative data (N = 82) showed that while clinical features were the same between tumor types, patients with polyclonal tumors more often had multiple gland disease (risk ratio 4.066, confidence interval, 1.016-16.26; P = .039) potentially missed at unilateral neck exploration.

CONCLUSION

This work confirms that primary hyperparathyroidism is often the result of polyclonal tumors and that parathyroid tumor clonal status may be associated with multiple gland disease.

Parathyroid: The Pathology of Hyperparathyroidism

This review focuses on the pathologic entities associated with hyperparathyroidism in humans. A discussion of the lesions, their embryology, and pathologic features is included. Immunohistology, cytopathology, and a brief overview of molecular aspects of the lesion are included.

Functional and genetic studies of isolated cells from parathyroid tumors reveal the complex pathogenesis of parathyroid neoplasia

Parathyroid adenomas (PAs) causing primary hyperparathyroidism (PHPT) are histologically heterogeneous yet have been historically viewed as largely monotypic entities arising from clonal expansion of a single transformed progenitor. Using flow cytometric analysis of resected adenomatous parathyroid glands, we have isolated and characterized chief cells, oxyphil cells, and tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes. The parathyroid chief and oxyphil cells produce parathyroid hormone (PTH), express the calcium-sensing receptor (CASR), and mobilize intracellular calcium in response to CASR activation. Parathyroid tumor infiltrating lymphocytes are T cells by immunophenotyping. Under normocalcemic conditions, oxyphil cells produce ∼50% more PTH than do chief cells, yet display significantly greater PTH suppression and calcium flux response to elevated calcium. In contrast, CASR expression and localization are equivalent in the respective parathyroid cell populations. Analysis of tumor clonality using X-linked inactivation assays in a patient-matched series of intact tumors, preparatively isolated oxyphil and chief cells, and laser-captured microdissected PA specimens demonstrate polyclonality in 5 of 14 cases. These data demonstrate the presence of functionally distinct oxyphil and chief cells within parathyroid primary adenomas and provide evidence that primary PA can arise by both clonal and polyclonal mechanisms. The clonal differences, biochemical activity, and relative abundance of these parathyroid adenoma subpopulations likely reflect distinct mechanisms of disease in PHPT.

Different clonal origin of bilateral papillary thyroid carcinoma, with a review of the literature

Papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) often presents with two or more anatomically separate foci. A long-standing argument is whether this multifocality is the result of multiple independent tumors ("multicentricity") or of intrathyroidal spread originating from a single tumor mass, presumably through permeation of intrathyroidal lymph vessels. We reexamined this issue with a clonality assay and compared our results with those in the literature. A total of 27 nodules from 11 female patients with bilateral PTC treated with total thyroidectomy were investigated for clonality using the HUMARA assay. Eight of 11 cases were informative (72.7 %). All but one of tumor foci showed a monoclonal population. The outlier sample gave a value indicative of balanced X-inactivation in one nodule. The monoclonality was concordant in three patients, discordant in three, and mixed in two (with both concordant and discordant results). Interestingly, in both of the latter cases (composed of over two samples per case), the contralateral nodules were discordant. Moreover, all four ipsilateral nodules were concordant. The results of our study suggest that some cases of multifocal PTC are the result of true multicentricity, whereas others are the consequence of intrathyroid spread by an originally single tumor mass. These conclusions support those made in the past years on the basis of morphologic considerations. Specifically, the incidental finding of two or more microscopic foci of PTC widely separate from each other was felt to favor multicentricity, whereas the finding of multiple ipsilateral foci of PTC within vascular spaces, often accompanied by multiple lymph node metastases, suggested intrathyroid spread; the most striking manifestation of this phenomenon being seen in the diffuse sclerosing variant of PTC.

Molecular alterations in hereditary and sporadic thyroid and parathyroid diseases

Thyroid and parathyroid diseases are fairly common and can be either hereditary or sporadic in nature. Tumors and tumor-like processes account for the majority of surgical pathology specimens in both of these endocrine organs. Molecular alterations are well known to occur in both the hereditary and the sporadic settings, and include alterations in tumor suppressor genes and oncogenes. The genetic pathways of tumors of parathyroid and thyroid are beginning to be well understood and are proving to be useful diagnostic, prognostic, and potential therapeutic targets. The molecular alterations in parathyroid and thyroid tumors and tumor-like processes are reviewed, with a focus on the potentially clinically useful diagnostic markers.

Primary hyperparathyroidism: role of the preoperative oral calcium loading test in the differential diagnosis between adenoma and hyperplasia

Whereas the sensitivity of the membrane calcium receptors is decreased in parathyroid adenoma, extracellular calcium may reduce parathyroid hormone (PTH) secretion through the protein kinase C pathway in parathyroid hyperplasia. The aim of this study was to determine the role of a preoperative oral calcium loading test in the differential diagnosis between adenoma and hyperplasia. Twenty-two subjects with adenoma (group A, age +/- standard error 56 +/-2 years, female/male 15/7), 10 individuals with hyperplasia (group H, age 54 +/-3, female/male 8/2), and 32 age and gender pair-matched controls (group C) underwent the test. Calcium and PTH were measured before and 60, 120, and 180 min after oral administration of 1 g of calcium (as gluconolactate). Product P was defined as minimal PTH concentration (pg/mL) x maximal calcium concentration (mg/dL) during the test. Ratio R was defined as relative PTH decline/relative calcium increase. The PTH decline during the test in group H was comparable to that of the controls. PTH decline <30%, Product P > 1,100, and Ratio R < 4 diagnosed adenoma with specificity of 100%, 90%, and 100%, respectively. PTH decline >60% diagnosed hyperplasia with specificity of 100%. The total accuracy of the test (65%) was comparable to that of technetium-99 m sestamibi scintigraphy (66%) and better than that of ultrasonography (58%). The test may discriminate patients with sporadic diffuse hyperplasia from individuals with solitary adenoma in cases of primary hyperparathyroidism with an indication for surgery.

Potential applications of molecular biology in neuroendocrine tumors

The impact of molecular biology procedures on neuroendocrine (NE) tumor biology is gradually evolving from purely academic and research studies to clinical applications. This review deals with applications of molecular techniques in neuroendocrine tumors, with special reference to their potential for diagnostic, prognostic, or therapeutic impact. Since the cloning of the genes involved in inherited endocrine tumor syndromes, molecular analysis of the responsible genetic alterations has become a routine diagnostic tool to select affected patients and their relatives, and also an interesting approach to investigate the pathogenesis of neuroendocrine tumors. Assessment of the clonal composition of endocrine tumors could be useful to differentiate hyperplastic versus either adenomatous or carcinomatous conditions, as well as to better understand the clonal relationship between different neoplastic populations in mixed tumors. In addition, molecular approaches allow high sensitivity both in defining the neuroendocrine phenotype in poorly differentiated tumors and in searching for micrometastasis during the follow up of patients with endocrine tumors. Finally, the detection of peptide hormone receptors (e.g., oxytocin and somatostatin receptors) and the development of potent synthetic analogs of such peptides, are opening promising applications in the diagnosis and therapy of endocrine tumors.

Synchronous water-clear cell double parathyroid adenomas a hitherto uncharacterized entity?

Water-clear cell hyperplasia is a rare but well-documented cause of primary hyperparathyroidism. Parathyroid adenomas of the water-clear cell type are exceptionally rare, and only 2 cases have been reported. We describe a patient with synchronous water-clear cell double parathyroid adenomas, an entity that has not previously been reported. In our case, the enlarged superior parathyroid glands were completely replaced by water-clear cells, with only a minute rim of extracapsular, histologically unremarkable parathyroid tissue. The inferior parathyroid glands were grossly unremarkable, and incisional biopsy specimens were histologically normal (no foci of water-clear cells were identified). The findings in this case are most consistent with the diagnosis of double adenomas of the water-clear cell type. We acknowledge that despite molecular proof of monoclonality of the 2 lesions, it is not possible to entirely exclude the possibility that this unusual case could be due to asymmetric hyperplasia.