Comparative studies on the usefulness of phosphate versus glycerin enema in preparation for colon examinations

Malone Antegrade Continence Enemas vs. Cecostomy vs. Transanal Irrigation-What Is New and How Do We Counsel Our Patients?

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

No gold standard exists for managing neurogenic bowel dysfunction, specifically in individuals with spina bifida. Since the International Children's Continence Society published its consensus document on neurogenic bowel treatment in 2012, an increased focus on why we must manage bowels and how to improve our management has occurred. This review provides updated information for clinicians.

RECENT FINDINGS

A surge in research, mostly retrospective, has been conducted on the success and satisfaction of three types of management for neurogenic bowel. All three management techniques have relatively high success rates for fecal continence and satisfaction rates. Selection of which treatment to carry out still is debated among clinicians. Transanal irrigation is a safe and effective management option for neurogenic bowel that does not require surgery. Antegrade enemas can be carried out via cecostomy tube or Malone antegrade continence enema with similar fecal continence outcomes.

Experience with glycerin for antegrade continence enema in patients with neurogenic bowel

PURPOSE

Malone antegrade continence enemas are used in the management of neurogenic bowel to attain fecal continence. Several different irrigation solutions have been described but glycerin, an osmotic laxative that promotes peristalsis, has rarely been mentioned or studied. We assessed clinical outcomes in our patients with a Malone antegrade continence enema using glycerin based irrigation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed patients with neurogenic bowel who underwent a Malone antegrade continence enema procedure between 1997 and 2011. Glycerin diluted with tap water followed by a tap water flush is our preferred irrigation protocol. Bowel regimen outcomes examined included fecal continence, emptying time, leakage from stoma, enema volume, frequency and independence.

RESULTS

Of the 23 patients with followup greater than 6 months 19 used glycerin based irrigation. Average age at surgery was 8.8 years. Patients using glycerin instilled a median of 30 ml (mean 29) glycerin and 50 ml (131) tap water. Fecal continence rate was 95% and stoma leakage rate was 16%, and only 16% of patients required daily irrigation.

CONCLUSIONS

Glycerin is a viable and effective alternative irrigant for antegrade enemas of neurogenic bowel, with an excellent fecal continence rate. The volume of irrigant needed is typically less than 90 ml, which is much less than in published reports using tap water alone.

Systematic review: the adverse effects of sodium phosphate enema

BACKGROUND

Sodium-phosphate enemas are widely used to treat constipation, and are rarely associated with side effects.

AIM

A systematic review of the literature was conducted to identify the most common adverse effects of sodium-phosphate enemas and associated risk factors.

METHODS

A systematic search was conducted in Internet (MEDLINE), and the Cochrane Library, from January 1957 to March 2007.

RESULTS

A total of 761 references were identified initially, and 39 relevant papers were finally selected. The most common therapeutic indications included constipation (63%). Sixty-eight per cent of the patients having adverse effects had associated conditions, the most common being gastrointestinal motility disorders, cardiological diseases and renal failure. Virtually, all side effects were due to water and electrolyte disturbances. Most patients were under 18 years of age (66%) or older than 65 years (25%). A total of 12 deaths were found.

CONCLUSION

The main side effects caused by sodium phosphate enemas are water and electrolyte disturbances. The main risk factors are extreme age and associated comorbidity.

The effects of sodium phosphate and polyethylene glycol-electrolyte bowel preparation solutions on 2,4,6-trinitrobenzenesulfonic acid-induced colitis in the rat

The aim of the present study is to evaluate the effects of sodium phosphate (NaP) and polyethylene glycol-electrolyte (PEG-EL) colon cleansing solutions on histopathology of 2,4,6-trinitrobenzene sulfonic acid (TNBS) and ethanol (E)-induced colitis in the rat and normal rat colon. The presence of hyperemia, inflammation and ulcer was evaluated to score of macroscopic morphologic damage. The microscopic criteria including ulceration, mucus cell depletion, crypt abscesses, inflammatory cysts, mucosal atrophy, edema, inflammatory cell infiltration, and vascular dilatation were evaluated to determine the extent of inflammatory reaction. Colitis findings were determined on the rats which were administered TNBS-E. Aphthoid lesions were seen 30% and 20 % of rats, respectively, by NaP and PEG-EL solutions in healthy group. Microscopic examination of aphthoid lesions revealed edema within the lamina propria and lymphoid hyperplasia in the mucosa and submucosa without erosion, ulceration and inflammatory cell infiltration. No significant difference was statistically found either macroscopically or microscopically in terms of the effects of saline, NaP and PEG-EL solutions in healthy rats and rats with colitis (p > .05). Under the present conditions, we concluded administration of NaP and PEG-EL solutions did not cause evident morphological changes on the rectal mucosa macroscopically and microscopically, although in a proportion of rats aphthoid lesions seem as a marker of mucosal damage macroscopically.

A novel method for the preclinical assessment of rectal irritation

The purpose of this study concerns a novel method for preclinical assessment of rectal irritation caused by suppositories introduced into the rectum. Rectal irritation was assessed by the balloon method in fasting conscious rats. This method is based on measuring rectal contractions due to possible irritation caused by the presence of drugs and adjuvants in the suppository. In control experiments (vehicle only), significant rectal contractions were not observed in a range of pH 1.5-11.0 and osmotic pressure 70-2000 mOsm kg-1 H2O, respectively. On the other hand, strong contractions were observed after rectal administration of an aqueous solution of 50% glycerin, 100 mM sodium caprate or 25 mM sodium cholate. The intensity of contraction after rectal administration of sodium caprate or sodium cholate was dependent on the concentration in the dosing solution. In addition, the effect of sodium caprate and sodium cholate on rat rectal mucosa was investigated by optical light microscopy. Although slight or moderate alteration such as the presence of mucinous substance in lumen and congestion, oedema and haemorrhage of the rectal membrane 20 min after rectal administration, there was no major damage to the rectal mucosa. There was a correlation between the median score for mucinous substance in lumen and mean intensity of rectal contraction. For comparative purposes, defecating sensations, pain, itch, burning sensations, and awareness of the presence of a foreign body after administration of suppositories containing 0, 1, 2 and 4% sodium caprate were examined in eight healthy volunteers. The defecating sensation in the human subjects correlated with the intensity of rectal contraction in rats. The results suggest that rectal contraction in conscious rats could be a useful index for prediction of a defecating sensation in man.