The use of computers in the safety evaluation of drugs and other chemicals

Further evaluation of COMPACT, the molecular orbital approach for the prospective safety evaluation of chemicals

The molecular dimensions and electronic structures of the first group of 100 US NCI/NTP miscellaneous chemicals, evaluated for potential carcinogenicity by computer-optimized molecular parametric analysis for chemical toxicity (COMPACT) have been re-determined. Using improved criteria for cytochrome P450 (CYP) substrate specificity, re-defined for CYP1 as having a COMPACT radius [square root of (deltaE - 9.5)2 + (a/d(2) - 7.8)2] of < 6.5, and for CYP2E as having a collision diameter of 6.5 angstroms or less and deltaE < 15.5, the likely substrates of CYP1 and CYP2E, which are regarded as potential carcinogens, have been identified. In addition, log P values have been taken into account; those chemicals with log P < 0 are non-lipophilic substrates unlikely to reach the activating cytochrome enzymes, and have been regarded as non-carcinogens. The second group of 100 US NCI/NTP chemicals have also now been categorized by COMPACT into CYP1 and CYP2E substrates, and their potential carcinogenicities evaluated. Of the 203 chemicals in the 2 groups, those positive in the rodent two-species life-span carcinogenicity study (rodent assay) were 53%, those positive in the Ames test (mutagenicity) were 48%, and those positive in the COMPACT programme (carcinogenicity, mutagenicity, cytotoxicity) were 54%. Concordance between the COMPACT prediction of carcinogenicity/cytotoxicity and rodent two species life-span carcinogenicity data for the 203 chemicals is 69%, and correlation of COMPACT with Ames test data is 61%. The sensitivity of COMPACT for predicting rodent carcinogenicity is 72%, whereas the sensitivity of the Ames test for predicting carcinogenicity for the 203 chemicals was only 57%. The degree (severity) of rodent carcinogenicity also showed correlation with the COMPACT predictive evaluations of the chemicals.