B-Cell Epitopes of Intracellular Autoantigens: Myth and Reality

HHV-5 epitope: A potential vaccine candidate with high antigenicity and large coverage

Outbreak of Human Herpes virus-5 (HHV-5) infection in emerging countries has raised worldwide health concern owing to prevalence of congenital impairments and life threatening consequences in immunocompromised individuals. Thus, there lies an impending need to develop vaccine against HHV-5. HHV-5 enters into host cells with the help of necessary components glycoprotein B (gB) and H/L. In this study, the conformational linear B-cell and T-cell epitopes for gB of HHV-5 have been predicted using conformational approaches, for their possible collective use as vaccine candidates. We examined epitope's interactions with major histocompatibility complexes using molecular docking and also investigated their stable binding with specific toll like receptor-2 (TLR2), present on host cells during HHV-5 infection. Predicted MHC-I epitope 'LVAIAVVII' with high antigenicity and large coverage of HLA alleles was found to superimpose on MHC-II epitope (Rank 1) and was also identified to be the core sequence of putative B cell epitope 'ILVAIAVVIITYLI'. Resulting epitope was found to have consistent interaction with TLR2 during long term (100 ns) MD run. We also validated this nonamer epitope for its dissimilarity with human genome and high population coverage, suggesting it to be a potential vaccine candidate with higher coverage for both the MHC alleles of Indian population. Communicated by Ramaswamy H. Sarma.

Anti-SLA/LP alone or in combination with anti-Ro52 and fine specificity of anti-Ro52 antibodies in patients with autoimmune hepatitis

BACKGROUND & AIMS

Antibodies (Abs) to soluble liver antigen/liver pancreas (anti-SLA/LP) are considered markers of worse prognosis and outcome in patients with autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) although this assumption has recently been attributed to their frequent co-expression with Abs against Ro52 (anti-Ro52). To assess the clinical significance of anti-SLA/LP Abs alone or in combination with anti-Ro52 in AIH patients and determine the immunodominant Ro52 epitopes according to the anti-SLA/LP status.

METHODS

Twenty-three anti-SLA/LP-positive and 106 anti-SLA/LP-negative AIH patients were included. Anti-SLA/LP were determined by ELISA using recombinant antigen, and confirmed by immunoblot using cytosolic rat liver fraction or HuH-7 extract. Anti-Ro52 Abs were determined by ELISA using recombinant antigen. Epitope mapping was assessed by ELISA using overlapping peptides covering the whole Ro52 protein in 26 AIH patients and 12 patients with Sjögren's syndrome.

RESULTS

Anti-SLA/LP positivity was not associated with the clinical, laboratory or histological characteristics of AIH patients. Treatment response, corticosteroid withdrawal, relapse after stopping treatment and outcome, were not associated with the presence of anti-SLA/LP, anti-Ro52 or double reactivity. Moreover, Ro52 epitope mapping revealed new epitopes unique for AIH and independent from anti-SLA/LP positivity.

CONCLUSIONS

Neither anti-SLA/LP nor anti-Ro52 Abs or their combination could specify a distinct group of AIH patients in terms of clinical characteristics, treatment response and outcome. Further studies are needed to clarify whether the newly discovered immunodominant epitopes of Ro52 antigen which were associated specifically with AIH have any clinical or pathogenetic significance in AIH.

Immunogenicity of autoantigens

Background

Autoantibodies against self-antigens have been associated not only with autoimmune diseases, but also with cancer and are even found in healthy individuals. The mechanism causing the autoantibody response remains elusive for the majority of the immunogenic antigens. To deepen the understanding of autoantibody responses, we ask whether natural-occurring, autoimmunity-associated and tumor-associated antigens have structural or biological features related to the immune response. To this end, we have carried out the most comprehensive in-silicio study of different groups of autoantigens including large antigen sets identified by our groups combined with publicly available antigen sets.

Results

We found evidence for an enrichment of genes with a larger exon length increasing the probability of the occurrence of potential immunogenic features such as mutations, SNPs, immunogenic sequence patterns and structural epitopes, or alternative splicing events. While SNPs seem to play a more central role in autoimmunity, somatic mutations seem to be stronger enriched in tumor-associated antigens. In addition, antigens of autoimmune diseases are different from other antigen sets in that they appear preferentially secreted, have frequently an extracellular location, and they are enriched in pathways associated with the immune system. Furthermore, for autoantibodies in general, we found enrichment of sequence-based properties including coiled-coils motifs, ELR motifs, and Zinc finger DNA-binding motifs. Moreover, we found enrichment of proteins binding to proteins or nucleic acids including RNA and enrichment of proteins that are part of ribosome or spliceosome. Both, homologies to proteins of other species and an enrichment of ancient protein domains indicate that immunogenic proteins are evolutionary conserved and that mimicry might play a central role.

Conclusions

Our results provide evidence that proteins which i) are evolutionary conserved, ii) show specific sequence motifs, and iii) are part of cellular structures show an increased likelihood to become autoimmunogenic.

RNA recognition motif (RRM) of La/SSB: the bridge for interparticle spreading of autoimmune response to U1-RNP

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is characterized by the production of grouped sets of autoantibodies targeting mainly the U1 ribonucleoprotein (RNP) and/or Ro/La RNP particles. Intraparticle diversification of the autoimmune response is believed to occur via epitope spreading. So far, it is not known how the autoimmune response "jumps" from one particle to another. To the extent that the majority of nuclear autoantigens in SLE are RNA binding proteins and major epitopes were previously mapped within their RRM (RNA recognition motifs), conserved sequences within RRM could be involved in the intermolecular and inter-particle diversification process of the autoimmune response. We investigated the potential of RRM of the La/SSB autoantigen to induce antibodies that cross-recognize components of the U1-RNP particle and therefore its capacity to produce interparticle epitope spreading. We immunized New Zealand white rabbits with a peptide corresponding to the epitope 145-164 of La/SSB (belonging to the RRM of La/SSB), attached in four copies on a scaffold carrier. Sera were drawn from 20 sera of patients with SLE and anti-U1-RNP antibodies and 26 sera of primary Sjögren syndrome patients with anti-La/SSB antibodies. All sera were evaluated for reactivity against the major epitope of La/SSB (pep349-364), the RNP antigen and the RRM-related epitope of La/SSB (pep145-164). Specific antibodies against pep145-164 were purified with immunoaffinity columns from selected sera. After the immunization of the animals with pep145-164, a specific IgG antibody response was detected, directed against the La/SSB autoantigen (wks 3-7), the immunizing peptide (wks 3-27), and the RNP autoantigen (wks 7-20). This response gradually decreased to low levels between postimmunization wks 27-42. Purified antibodies against pep145-164 recognized La/SSB and a 70-kD autoantigen in Western blot and exhibited significant reactivity in anti-U1-RNP ELISA. Depletion of anti-pep145-164 antibodies eliminated anti-U1-RNP reactivity from immunized rabbit sera but not from human sera. In addition, pep145-164 was recognized to a greater extent by autoimmune sera with anti-RNP reactivity compared with anti-La/SSB-positive sera, in contrast to pep349-364 of La/SSB, which was recognized almost exclusively by sera with anti-La/SSB reactivity. These data suggest that the RRM region of La/SSB can trigger interparticle B-cell diversification to U1-RNP-70 autoantigen via molecular mimicry. Identification of key sequences that trigger and perpetuate the autoimmune process is particularly important for understanding pathogenetic mechanisms in autoimmunity.

Autoantibodies to intracellular autoantigens and their B-cell epitopes: molecular probes to study the autoimmune response

A common laboratory finding in systemic autoimmune diseases is the presence of autoantibodies against intracellular autoantigens. Although their pathogenesis is not fully understood, autoantibodies are important tools for establishing diagnosis, classification, and prognosis of autoimmune diseases. Autoantibodies mainly target multicomponent complexes containing both protein antigens and (ribo)-nucleic acid(s), such as the spliceosome or Ro/La RNPs. In this review, we address the main characteristics and the clinical value of the main autoantibody types with respect to their disease association, and we describe the corresponding autoantigens, their biologic function, and their B-cell antigenic determinants (epitopes). The structural characteristics and clinical associations of these epitopes, and their utility as tools to investigate the autoimmune response, are discussed in detail. New insights into the pathogenetic role of epitopes in systemic autoimmunity are also examined. In this regard, using the defined structures of the B-cell antigenic epitopes, complementary epitopes can be designed according to the "molecular recognition" theory. These complementary epitopes can be used as probes to study pathogenetic and immunoregulatory aspects of the anti-idiotypic response. The origin of humoral autoimmunity and the spreading of the epitopes in systemic lupus erythematosus are also discussed. Finally, the ability of post-translational modifications to induce autoreactive immune attack via the generation of neo-epitopes is summarized.

Zinc Ion Dependent B-Cell Epitope, Associated with Primary Sjogren's Syndrome, Resides within the Putative Zinc Finger Domain of Ro60kD Autoantigen: Physical and Immunologic Properties

The Ro/La ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complex is composed of the proteins Ro60kD, Ro52kD, and La48kD that are in association with one small cytoplasmic RNA (YRNA). Specific protein-RNA and protein-protein interactions are thought to occur through the RNP and zinc-finger secondary structure elements of the Ro60kD protein. The aim of our study was to investigate the antigenic properties of the zinc finger domain of the Ro60KD autoantigen and its contribution to the formation of Ro/La RNP complex. It was found that the peptide VSLVCEKLCNEKLLKKARIHPFHILIA (Zif-1), which corresponds to the natural sequence of the zinc finger domain (301-327), and the peptide C(Acm)NEKLLKKARIC(Acm), analogous to the intermediate loop 310-319 (Zif-3) of the same domain of Ro60KD, are recognized by the majority of anti-Ro/SSA and anti-La/SSB positive sera (82.6% and 77.1%, respectively) in the absence of zinc ions. The same sera failed to react with Zif-1 peptide in the presence of Zn2+. In contrast, the addition of zinc ions was necessary for the binding of Zif-1 to recombinant Ro52KD as shown by direct binding experiments of the recombinant protein with synthetic peptides. Our data suggest the zinc finger domain of Ro60kD contains a B-cell epitope with high specificity for primary Sjogren's syndrome. Furthermore, depending on the presence of zinc ions, the zinc finger domain of the Ro60KD protein can exist in two different conformational states favoring either an interaction with the Ro52KD protein or binding with autoantibodies.

The clinical value of intracellular autoantigens B-cell epitopes in systemic rheumatic diseases

A hallmark of autoimmune diseases is the production of autoantibodies against intracellular autoantigens. Although their pathogenetic and their etiologic relationship are not fully understood, these autoantibodies are important tools for establishing the diagnosis, classification and prognosis of autoimmune diseases. Systemic rheumatic diseases are among the most complex disorders because their clinical presentation and constellation of findings are in part reflected by the wide spectrum of autoantibodies found in the sera of patients suffering from these disorders. These autoantibodies usually target large complexes consisting of protein antigens noncovalently associated with (ribo)-nucleic acid(s), like the spliceosome or Ro/La-RNPs. In this review, we first address the main characteristics and the clinical value of several autoantibodies, with respect to their diagnostic sensitivity and specificity. Subsequently, we provide a brief overview of the antigenic determinant types that have been identified on the corresponding autoantigens. The antibody targets of autontigens include primary, secondary, tertiary and quarternary structure epitopes, as well as cryptotopes, neoepitopes and mimotopes. We next focus on antigenic structures corresponding to B-cell epitopes with high disease specificity and sensitivity for all the major autoantigens in systemic autoimmunity including the Ro/La and U1 ribonucleoprotein complexes and the Ku70/80, ribosomal P, DNA topoisomerase I, filaggrin, Jo-1 and PM/SCl-100 autoantigens. These epitopes, defined at the peptide level, can be chemically synthesized and engineered for the development of new inexpensive and easier to perform assays and the improvement of the methods for autoantibody detection. Specific examples of newly developed assays that incorporate (i) epitopes with high disease specificity and sensitivity, (ii) modified epitopes, (iii) conformational epitopes and (iv) complementary epitopes are discussed in detail. Finally, we examine the potential of combining these synthetic epitopes for future development of multiplex diagnostic tests based on miniaturized autoantigen arrays.

Key sequences involved in the spreading of the systemic autoimmune response to spliceosomal proteins

Immune spreading to multiple intracellular antigens is likely to be of primary importance in organ-specific and systemic autoimmune diseases. A number of mechanisms by which immune spreading may occur from only a single autoreactive epitope have been proposed. Search for an initiator or early epitope thus represents an important area of investigation. For example, many studies have focused on the identification of epitopes recognized by the antibodies from both patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and lupus-prone mice. Recently, an autoepitope present in the 70K U1 ribonucleo protein (RNP) and recognized by CD4+ T cells from lupus mice has also been identified. Here, we analyze the results of B- and T-cell-epitope mapping studies of several RNPs present in the spliceosome and propose a model of epitope spreading. In this model, a consensus sequence (the RNP motif) conserved in many nuclear, nucleolar and cytoplasmic antigens, might play a role as 'driver' epitope. This hypothesis is based on the observation that this sequence is recognized by CD4+ T cells from lupus mice and is often targeted by autoantibodies, very early during the course of the disease. Targeting this region that is repeated in different self-antigens, might represent an interesting strategy to interfere with the continuous T-cell stimulation and exposure to specific antigens.