Thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy: pilot evaluation of a simple alternative for chronic pancreatic pain control

Geographical variance in reporting of elective surgery for chronic pancreatitis

The selection of optimum surgical procedure from the range of reported operations for chronic pancreatitis (CP) can be difficult. The aim of this study is to explore geographical variation in reporting of elective surgery for CP. A systematic search of the literature was performed using the Scopus database for reports of five selected procedures for CP: duodenum-preserving pancreatic head resection, total pancreatectomy with islet autotransplantation (TPIAT), Frey pancreaticojejunostomy, thoracoscopic splanchnotomy and the Izbicki V-shaped resection. The keyword and MESH heading 'chronic pancreatitis' was used. Overall, 144 papers met inclusion criteria and were utilized for data extraction. There were 33 reports of duodenum-preserving pancreatic head resection. Twenty-one (64%) were from Germany. There were 60 reports of TPIAT, 53 (88%) from the USA. There are only two reports of TPIAT from outwith the USA and UK. The 34 reports of the Frey pancreaticojejunostomy originate from 12 countries. There were 20 reports of thoracoscopic splanchnotomy originating from nine countries. All three reports of the Izbicki 'V' procedure are from Germany. There is geographical variation in reporting of surgery for CP. There is a need for greater standardization in the selection and reporting of surgery for patients with painful CP.

[Vascular relationships of the right great splanchnic nerve in the thorax]

AIM

The surgical assumption of responsibility of the pancreatic pain requires either a truncular coelioscopic or radicular neurectomy of greater splanchnic nerves (gsn). The goal of our work is to describe the way and relations of the right gsn which are variable and rarely described. This constitutes an undeniable peroperational hemorrhagic risk during splanchnicectomy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

After a double side thoracotomy and a bilateral sterno-clavicular desarticulation on 15 adult cadaveric subjects preserved by method of Winckler we removed the sterno-costal drill plate as well as the ventral rib arch and proceeded to a mediastinal evisceration of the thorax. Then we respected only the thoracic aorta and the oesophagus, the azygos venous system, the thoracic duct and the thoracic sympathetic chain. In some of the subjects, the azygos vein was injected (after catheterization of its stick) using gelatine coloured with blue paint. We studied the way and vascular relations of the right gsn. We measured the transverse distances between the origin of the gsn on one hand and the longitudinal axes of the azygos vein and the thoracic duct on the other hand.

RESULTS

The relations of the right gsn trunk during its way related to the azygos vein in particular its constitutive origin and its affluents: ascending lumbar vein and twelfth intercostal vein. Sometimes the thoracic duct even a lymphatic node was near the gsn in the posterior infra-mediastinal space. A classification of the way and vascular relations of the right gsn in the thorax identified 3 anatomical types. The average distances separating the right gsn on one hand from the azygos vein and the thoracic duct on the other hand were respectively 5.7 mm and 11.2 mm.

CONCLUSION

The vascular relations of the right gsn are very variable from one subject to another but primarily venous, sometimes lymphatic. They concerned the great thoracic vessels whose respect is essential in particular at the time of mini-invasive access procedure for a cœlioscopic splanchnicectomy.

Preoperative opioid use and the outcome of thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy in chronic pancreatitis: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

Thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy (TS) is a minimally invasive intervention to relieve pain in patients with chronic pancreatitis (CP) with equivocal results. Preoperative opioid use seems to impair TS outcome but this has not been investigated in a systematic matter.

METHODS

We searched PubMed, EMBASE, and The Cochrane Library for studies on the outcome of TS in CP patients. Studies with ≥5 patients and a follow-up of ≥12 months were included. Success was defined as the proportion of patients free of opioids or who had a reduction of ≥4 points on a pain scale. The effect of opioid use on the success rate of TS was analyzed by uni- and multivariate regression.

RESULTS

Sixteen studies with 484 patients were included in our review. The mean (±SD) age of the patients was 44 ± 4.3 years and 66 % were male. Median follow-up period was 21 months (IQR 14-35). Median preoperative opioid use was 85 % (IQR 54-100 %). After TS, a median of 49 % (IQR 22-75 %) of patients were free of opioids at end of follow-up. The median success rate was 62 % (IQR 48-86 %). Mean success rate in studies in which ≤50 % of the patients used opioids preoperatively was 81 % (SD ± 21) compared to 60 % (SD ± 15) for other studies (p = 0.049). Higher age, male gender, and lower rates of preoperative opioid use were associated with a higher success rate (p = 0.003, 0.047, and 0.017, respectively). Multivariate regression, including age, gender, preoperative opioid use, and duration of follow-up, identified age and preoperative opioid use as independent predictors of success after TS (both p = 0.002).

CONCLUSION

Preoperative opioid use is associated with a worse outcome after TS in CP patients. To optimize outcome, use of TS may be considered at an earlier stage in the treatment of patients with CP before prolonged opioid therapy.

Prospective evaluation of pain control and quality of life in patients with chronic pancreatitis following bilateral thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy

Background

Abdominal pain in chronic pancreatitis (CP) is the most common symptom with a highly unfavorable impact on the quality of life. It has been shown that bilateral thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy (BTS) may produce marked pain relief for the majority of patients. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of BTS in pain control and quality-of-life improvement in patients with a severe form of CP.

Methods

Between April 2000 and April 2009, a total of 30 patients qualified for BTS due to CP-related pain. Their age ranged from 28 to 60 years. A 12-month follow-up period was planned for all the patients enrolled. To evaluate effectiveness of BTS, an 11-point Numeric Rating Scale (NRS) and the Quality of Life Questionnaire C-30 (QLQ-C30) in its basic form, developed by European Organization for Research and Treatment of Cancer, were used. An NRS value between 0 and 3 was considered a positive postoperative pain control result.

Results

The bilateral splanchnicectomy procedure was performed successfully in 27 of 30 qualified patients. A positive effect based on decreased pain (p < 0.05) at 12 months was achieved in 24 patients (80 %). The initial change in quality of life was not significant but it gradually improved with time (preop vs. 12 months QLQ-C30 score, p < 0.001).

Conclusions

This study showed that BTS is safe and efficacious for pain alleviation in patients with severe CP. It may significantly increase the chances of a long-lasting, life-changing improvement in the quality of life.

Guidelines on surgery of the thoracic sympathetic nervous system

Thoracic sympathetic nervous system (TSNS) surgery has increased in importance in the last few years, generating great expectations among the general population and the scientific community. This has been due to the excellent results obtained by videothoracoscopy-assisted thoracic sympathectomy in the treatment of essential hyperhidrosis and other TSNS disorders. This minimally invasive surgical technique has been shown to be effective, and with a low morbidity it is accepted as one of the best therapeutic options for the treatment of palmar and bilateral axillary hyperhidrosis and the number of patients consulting with the intention of having the operation has increased considerably. Although compensatory sweating, which is occasionally intense, often occurs after the surgery, this and other secondary effects of the technique are well tolerated by patients. The current evidence on TSNS and the treatment of essential hyperhidrosis is based on observational studies, making it difficult to compare series and draw conclusions. There has been much discussion on standardising the technique, defining the most favourable levels for clipping, and choosing the type of denervation with least secondary effects. This has led to the need to draw up these guidelines which should clarify and standardise the criteria for managing patients with disorders of TSNS.

A review of the thoracic splanchnic nerves and celiac ganglia

Anatomical variation of the thoracic splanchnic nerves is as diverse as any structure in the body. Thoracic splanchnic nerves are derived from medial branches of the lower seven thoracic sympathetic ganglia, with the greater splanchnic nerve comprising the more cranial contributions, the lesser the middle branches, and the least splanchnic nerve usually T11 and/or T12. Much of the early anatomical research of the thoracic splanchnic nerves revolved around elucidating the nerve root level contributing to each of these nerves. The celiac plexus is a major interchange for autonomic fibers, receiving many of the thoracic splanchnic nerve fibers as they course toward the organs of the abdomen. The location of the celiac ganglia are usually described in relation to surrounding structures, and also show variation in size and general morphology. Clinically, the thoracic splanchnic nerves and celiac ganglia play a major role in pain management for upper abdominal disorders, particularly chronic pancreatitis and pancreatic cancer. Splanchnicectomy has been a treatment option since Mallet-Guy became a major proponent of the procedure in the 1940s. Splanchnic nerve dissection and thermocoagulation are two common derivatives of splanchnicectomy that are commonly used today. Celiac plexus block is also a treatment option to compliment splanchnicectomy in pain management. Endoscopic ultrasonography (EUS)-guided celiac injection and percutaneous methods of celiac plexus block have been heavily studied and are two important methods used today. For both splanchnicectomies and celiac plexus block, the innovation of ultrasonographic imaging technology has improved efficacy and accuracy of these procedures and continues to make pain management for these diseases more successful.

An Objective Study of Pain Relief in Chronic Pancreatitis from Bilateral Thoracoscopic Splanchnicectomy

Pain from chronic pancreatitis leads to disability, malnutrition, and narcotic dependence. This study demonstrates the efficacy of bilateral thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy in reducing pain associated with chronic pancreatitis. This study reviews results from this procedure between 1998 and 2006. Data included pain levels, hospital admissions, nutritional status, and the duration between splanchnicectomy and pancreatic resection. Narcotic use was determined from the Kentucky All Schedule Prescription Electronic Reporting system. Fifty-four patients underwent splanchnicectomy with technical success in 98 per cent and immediate symptom relief in 43 per cent. Additional surgery occurred in 44 per cent (average time to surgery was 26 months). Failure of pain relief occurred in 17 per cent, early recurrence (6–12 months) occurred in 15 per cent, and 68 per cent had over a year of relief. Admissions decreased from 5.8 to 2.9 post surgery. Average pain levels decreased from 8.7 to 6.1 post surgery ( P < 0.001). Kentucky All Schedule Prescription Electronic Reporting demonstrated decreased or stable narcotic use in half of the patients. Over half (55%) maintained or gained weight, whereas 39 per cent experienced weight loss. Discharge occurred 24-hours after surgery. Bilateral thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy demonstrates a positive impact on pain control, hospital admissions, nutritional status, and narcotic use. Thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy is an effective and safe option in the treatment of pain from chronic pancreatitis.

Bilateral thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy with sympathectomy for managing abdominal pain in cancer patients

BACKGROUND

Simple interruption of splanchnic nerve can lead to incomplete transection of nerve fibers responsible for cancer-derived abdominal visceral because lots of neural communications exist.

METHODS

From December 1999 to June 2005, a total of 21 cancer patients underwent bilateral thoracoscopic segmental resection of splanchnic nerve with sympathectomy for intractable abdominal pain based on the anatomic observation of 26 embalmed Korean cadaveric specimens in Yonsei University Medical Center, Seoul, Korea. All patients were preoperatively asked to rate the extent of their current pain by using the numeric rating scale (NRS), where 0 indicated no pain and 10 indicated intractable pain. The effectiveness of this thoracoscopic procedure was assessed based on the NRS reevaluated after surgery.

RESULTS

NRS score was significantly reduced after thoracoscopic surgery (1.71 +/- 1.10 versus 8.52 +/- 1.08, paired t test, P < .0001). Sixteen patients (76.2%) could tolerate pain without or with reduced dose of analgesics. No mortality and morbidity were found in this study.

CONCLUSION

This bilateral thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy with sympathectomy is safe, easy, and effective method in managing cancer-derived visceral abdominal pain.

Bilateral Thoracoscopic Splanchnicectomy for Pain Control in Chronic Pancreatitis

The purpose of this study was to evaluate prospectively the efficacy of bilateral thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy (TS) for pain due to chronic pancreatitis. Pain is invariably a major debilitating factor in the course of chronic pancreatitis. This study was performed to evaluate the effect of bilateral TS on pain intensity, hospital admissions, and daily functions in patients with debilitating pain due to chronic pancreatitis. Twenty bilateral TS were performed in 20 patients. Follow-up was obtained in all patients and averaged 15 months (6 months to 3 years). To evaluate efficacy of the procedure, all 20 patients were personally interviewed after TS regarding impact of pain and change in lifestyle. Using the 0–10 numeric rating scale, patients ranked pre- and postoperative pain level and overall mood. A KASPER report was obtained for 17 of 20 patients from the Kentucky Drug Control and Professional Practices to obtain accurate information on all narcotic prescriptions filled for 1 year prior to surgery until today. Information from the KASPER report provided very objective information on pain medication use before and after TS. Thirteen patients (65%) had a decreased pain level, and 12 patients (55%) also developed an improved overall mood. The number of hospital admissions for chronic pancreatitis pain decreased in 19 patients (95%), and the days spent in the hospital decreased for 15 patients (75%). Overall, 12 patients (60%) indicated pain symptom relief during a mean duration of 14.8 months after the procedure. KASPER reports indicated a decrease in pain medication prescriptions filled for 9 patients (53%), 3 of which were able to discontinue completely use of opioids for pain associated with chronic pancreatitis. TS is a minimally invasive procedure that appears to offer pain relief, improve quality of life, and reduce narcotic dependence in patients with pain from chronic pancreatitis. The decrease in hospital admissions represents further quality of life improvement in this difficult to treat group of patients.

Neurolytic Approaches for the Treatment of Pain in Patients with Chronic Pancreatitis

In large part, treatment options for patients with painful chronic pancreatitis remain empirical because of our limited understanding of the pathobiology of pancreatic pain. The procedures of neural block/ablation exemplify these limitations, which include the lack of a clear biologic rationale for various approaches, as well as unequivocal data on long-term outcomes and efficacy. Although the techniques themselves appear to be well established, controlled trials of various medical, endoscopic, radiologic, and surgical options to define the best treatment are clearly needed. In addition, the lack of uniform improvement with any technique underscores the need for applying a multidisciplinary approach to these patients, as should be the case for any chronic pain disorder.

Quality of life improvement after videothoracoscopic splanchnicectomy in chronic pancreatitis patients: case control study

The authors report on the effectiveness of videothoracoscopic splanchnicectomy (VSPL) as a method of pain treatment in patients with chronic pancreatitis (CP). A minimally invasive technique, VSPL is used in CP as an alternative method of pain treatment. The aim of the investigation was to evaluate by a prospective, semirandomized case-control study the influence of VSPL on the quality of life and the level of pain suffered by patients with CP. The study groups consisted of 32 patients who underwent VSPL between March 2000 and January 2001 and a control group of 32 CP patients who received conservative treatment. The effect of the therapy on subjective pain measures and multiparametric quality of life was measured before VSPL and throughout the first year thereafter. In the follow-up period there was a significant decrease in intensity of pain and an improvement in the quality of life of the patients-most significantly concerning emotional well-being and functioning in everyday life. We conclude that the VSPL is a safe, effective, and minimally invasive procedure and recommend that it be used in such cases.

Thoracoscopic sympathectomy for palmaris hyperhidrosis

INTRODUCTION

Palmaris hyperhidrosis is a disorder mediated by the sympathetic nervous system. It causes excessive sweating. This study evaluated the safety, efficacy, and outcome after thoracoscopic sympathectomy in patients with palmaris hyperhidrosis.

METHODS

We reviewed the medical records of 18 patients (10 male) who underwent bilateral thoracoscopic sympathectomy between July 1998 and June 2001.

RESULTS

The patients' mean age was 34 years. No conversions to thoracotomy occurred. Three 2- to 5 mm trocars were used. The thoracic sympathetic chain was resected from ganglia T2-T4, except in one patient with axillary hyperhidrosis requiring resection to T5. The mean operating time was 112 minutes, the mean blood loss was 50 ml, and the mean postoperative hospital stay was 1.2 days. Two patients had a unilateral pneumothorax requiring tube thoracostomy; one patient developed a chest wall hematoma at a trocar site that resolved without treatment, and one patient developed a transient unilateral Horner's syndrome. There have been no hospital readmissions. After a mean follow-up period of 14 months, 11 patients (56%) reported compensatory sweating. Sixteen patients (89%) were satisfied with their outcomes. One patient was dissatisfied because of excessive compensatory sweating, and another continues to have mild unilateral sweating on one hand and compensatory sweating of the face.

CONCLUSION

Thoracoscopic sympathectomy is a safe and effective alternative treatment for palmaris hyperhidrosis. Compensatory sweating occurs in more than 50% of patients but is tolerable in most. The majority of patients are satisfied with their short-term outcomes.

Thoracic splanchnic nerves: implications for splanchnic denervation

Splanchnic neurectomy is of value in the management of chronic abdominal pain. It is postulated that the inconsistent results of splanchnicectomies may be due to anatomical variations in the pattern of splanchnic nerves. The advent of minimally invasive and video-assisted surgery has rekindled interest in the frequency of variations of the splanchnic nerves. The aims of this study were to investigate the incidence, origin and pattern of the splanchnic nerves in order to establish a predictable pattern of splanchnic neural anatomy that may be of surgical relevance. Six adult and 14 fetal cadavers were dissected (n = 38). The origin of the splanchnic nerve was bilaterally asymmetrical in all cases. The greater splanchnic nerve (GSN) was always present, whereas the lesser splanchnic nerve (LSN) and least splanchnic nerve (ISN) were inconsistent (LSN, 35 of 38 sides (92%); LSN, 21 of 38 sides (55%). The splanchnic nerves were observed most frequently over the following ranges: GSN, T6-9: 28 of 38 sides (73%); LSN, when present, T10-11: (10 of 35 sides (29%); and ISN, T11-12: 3 of 21 sides (14%). The number of ganglionic roots of the GSN varied between 3 and 10 (widest T4-11; narrowest, T5-7). Intermediate splanchnic ganglia, when present, were observed only on the GSN main trunk with an incidence of 6 of 10 sides (60%) in the adult and 11 of 28 sides (39%) in the fetus. The higher incidence of the origin of GSN above T5 has clinical implications, given the widely discussed technique of undertaking splanchnicectomy from the T5 ganglion distally. This approach overlooks important nerve contributions and thereby may compromise clinical outcome. In the light of these variations, a reappraisal of current surgical techniques used in thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy is warranted.

Surgical management of chronic pancreatitis at the Mayo Clinic

The authors' approach to the overall surgical management of chronic pancreatitis is to treat complications, that is, pain and, less commonly, obstruction and bleeding. The authors' practice is to exhaust nearly all forms of nonsurgical intervention before suggesting a surgical approach. Nonresponders are then evaluated for severity of pain, interference of quality of life, and presence of chemical dependency. Appropriate candidates undergo imaging examinations to determine the primary site of disease, presence of pancreatic ductal dilatation, and associated peripancreatic complications. The surgical treatment approach involves classic lines of proximal resection (pylorus-preserving pancreaticoduodenectomy) for small duct disease and lateral pancreaticojejunal drainage for a dilated pancreatic duct. The authors have not yet routinely adopted the duodenum-preserving head resections of Beger and Frey, or thoracoscopic transthoracic splanchnicectomy, but they remain open-minded and avidly await good confirmatory, independent trials of these promising surgical interventions.

Thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy for control of intractable pain due to advanced pancreatic cancer

BACKGROUND

Severe upper abdominal pain is a dominant and distressing feature of advanced pancreatic cancer. This study was performed to evaluate pain intensity and to determine the ways in which pain may interfere with the common daily activities of patients with intractable pain before and after thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy.

METHODS

Twenty-six left-sided thoracoscopic splanchnicectomies were performed. To assess pain severity and the impact of pain, all patients completed a short questionnaire using the 0-10 Numeric Rating Scale. The Pain Management Index was used to describe and compare the adequacy of analgesic management. Patients were evaluated 1 day prior to operation and for 6 months after the procedure.

RESULTS

Pain was reduced significantly after the operation (p < 0.001), and all patients enjoyed consistent pain relief during the postoperative follow-up. The degree to which pain interfered with their daily function decreased significantly (p < 0.001) after surgery. The adequacy of the analgesic management improved, and none of the patients required opioids.

CONCLUSIONS

Unilateral left thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy is a simple, minimally invasive, effective, and safe procedure that can be recommended as the method of choice for the management of intractable upper abdominal pain due to advanced pancreatic cancer.

Surgical options in the patient with chronic pancreatitis

There are a number of indications for surgical intervention in chronic pancreatitis, but the most common is intractable pain. Many surgical procedures can be applied in the patient with chronic pain, and the variety of procedures reflects the fact that no single procedure is ideal for all patients. Duct drainage procedures are safe and have a significant response rate, but only about one third of patients experience long-lasting complete relief of pain. Procedures that combine resection and duct drainage are generally more effective, with long-term success rates in the 80% range. The development of the Frey and Beger procedures, two methods for pancreatic head resection that preserve the anatomy of the stomach, duodenum, and bile duct, represents an advance in surgical therapy of chronic pancreatitis. Total pancreatectomy with islet autotransplantation is a procedure that may be appropriate in certain subsets of patients. Thoracoscopic splanchnicectomy is a new, minimally invasive procedure, still in evaluation, which may become a very valuable method when the sole indication for surgery is intractable pain.