Bone metabolism is a key factor for clinical outcome of tibial plateau fractures

Functional assessment and outcome following surgical treatment of displaced tibial plateau fractures: a retrospective analysis

PURPOSE

Patients with tibial plateau fractures (TPF) are at risk of long-term hampered bipedal locomotion. A retrospective single-center study using patient-related outcome measures and a sophisticated assessment of walking abilities was conducted.

METHODS

Adults receiving surgical treatment of an isolated TPF between January 2012 and December 2016 received the KOOS questionnaire together with the invitation for an extensive follow-up examination on the clinical outcome including standardized assessment of the walking abilities (loadsol® system). Outcome was assessed relative to the severity of the injury or time to follow-up. Fractures were classified according to AO/OTA and Luo, respectively.

RESULTS

58 out of 132 eligible patients filled in the questionnaire and participated at a median follow-up of 3.05 years after injury. For the categories "pain", "mobility", and "daily life activities", all patients were rather satisfied and this was virtually not related to the time between fracture and assessment. Relevant limitations were reported for "sports and recreational activities" and "quality of life". Loading of the previously fractured leg was most evidently changed on stairs and outdoor walking. Outcome was not related to either fracture type severity or time from injury.

CONCLUSION

Outcome after an isolated TPF is neither related to fracture type, severity of the fracture nor time from injury. Simple gait analysis techniques relying on different tasks appear to yield a more sophisticated image on functional deficits after TPF than classical exam of ground-level walking and correlate quite well with validated patient-related outcome measures as the KOOS.

S2k Guideline for Tibial Plateau Fractures - Classification, Diagnosis, and Treatment

Tibial plateau fractures are mostly complex and surgically demanding joint fractures, which require a comprehensive understanding of the fracture morphology, ligamentous and neurovascular injuries, as well as the diagnostic and therapeutic options for an optimal clinical outcome. Therefore, a standardised and structured approach is required. The success of the treatment of tibial plateau fractures relies on the interdisciplinary cooperation between surgical and conservative physicians in an outpatient and inpatient setting, physical therapists, patients and service providers (health insurance companies, statutory accident insurance, pension providers). On behalf of the German Society for Orthopaedics and Trauma Surgery (DGOU), the German Trauma Society (DGU) and the Society for Arthroscopy and Joint Surgery (AGA), under the leadership of the Fracture Committee of the German Knee Society (DKG), a guideline for tibial plateau fractures was created, which was developed in several voting rounds as part of a Delphi process. Based on the current literature, this guideline is intended to make clear recommendations and outline the most important treatment steps in diagnostics, therapy and follow-up treatment. Additionally, 25 statements were revised by the authors in several survey rounds using the Likert scale in order to reach a final consensus.

[Intra-articular proximal tibia fractures]

The incidence of proximal intra-articular tibial fractures is continuously increasing. In addition to high-energy trauma in young patients, osteoporotic fractures occur more frequently in geriatric patients. After a thorough clinical examination including X‑ray and computed tomography (CT) imaging, consolidation of the soft tissue is followed by surgical treatment to achieve the best possible anatomic reconstruction of the articular surface. Nonanatomic reduction with articular gaps >2.5 mm leads to a significantly increased risk of osteoarthritis. Selection of the surgical approach and planning of the osteosynthesis are based on the fracture morphology and the existing soft tissue damage. In addition to arthroscopically assisted percutaneous procedures, sophisticated osteosynthesis is often necessary, which requires several surgical approaches. In this context, posterior surgical approaches are becoming increasingly more important. Primary knee arthroplasty can also play a role, particularly in older patients.

Mismatch between Clinical-Functional and Radiological Outcome in Tibial Plateau Fractures: A Retrospective Study

BACKGROUND

The evaluation of tibial plateau fractures (TPF) encompasses the assessment of clinical-functional and radiological parameters. In this study, the authors aimed to investigate the potential correlation between these parameters by utilizing both the clinical-functional and the modified radiological Rasmussen score.

METHODS

In this retrospective monocentric study conducted at a level-I trauma center, patients who underwent surgery between January 2014 and December 2019 due to a TPF were included. The clinical-functional Rasmussen score prior to the injury, at 1-year postoperatively, and during the last follow-up (minimum 18 months) was assessed using a standardized questionnaire. Additionally, the modified radiological Rasmussen score was determined at the 1-year postoperative mark using conventional radiographs in two planes.

RESULTS

A total of 50 patients were included in this study, comprising 40% (n = 20) men, and 60% (n = 30) women, with an average age of 47 ± 11.8 years (range 26-73 years old). Among them, 52% (n = 26) had simple fractures (classified according to Schatzker I-III), while 48% (n = 24; according to Schatzker IV-VI) had complex fractures. The mean follow-up was 3.9 ± 1.6 years (range 1.6-7.5 years). The functional Rasmussen score assessed before the injury and at follow-up showed an "excellent" average result. However, there was a significant difference in the values of complex fractures compared to before the injury. One year postoperatively, both the clinical-functional score and the modified radiological score demonstrated a "good" average result. The "excellent" category was more frequently observed in the functional score, while the "fair" category was more common in the radiological score. There was no agreement between the categories in both scores in 66% of the cases.

CONCLUSIONS

The data from this retrospective study demonstrated that patients with TPF are able to achieve a nearly equivalent functional level in the medium-term after a prolonged recovery period, comparable to their pre-injury state. However, it is important to note that the correlation between clinical-functional and radiological parameters is limited. Consequently, in order to create prospective outcome scores, it becomes crucial to objectively assess the multifaceted nature of TPF injuries in more detail, both clinically and radiologically.

Extension of the Medial Approach to the Tibial Plateau via an Osteotomy of the Tibial Insertion of the Superficial Medial Collateral Ligament

The treatment of medial tibial plateau fractures can be challenging due to poor exposure of the articular surface. Therefore, a medial epicondyle osteotomy may be needed. Current methods describe osteotomy of the medial femoral epicondyle. However, this method requires additional detachment of the medial meniscus in order to ensure proper visualization. The aim of this study is to present a new technique using distal osteotomy of the superficial medial collateral ligament and to analyze the area of the exposed articular surface area. On each of eight fresh-frozen human cadaveric knees (mean age: 79.4 ± 9.4 years), an osteotomy and proximal reflection of the distal insertion of the superficial medial collateral ligament combined with a submeniscal arthrotomy was performed, followed by a medial epicondyle osteotomy. Using a three-dimensional measurement arm (Absolute Arm 8320-7, Hexagon Metrology GmbH), the exposed area was analyzed and compared to the entire medial articular surface using ANOVA (p < 0.05). Through the medial epicondyle osteotomy, 39.9 ± 9.7% of the anteromedial articular surface was seen. This area was significantly smaller compared to the osteotomy of the distal insertion of the superficial collateral ligament with an exposed articular surface of 77.2 ± 16.9% (p = 0.004). Thus, the distal osteotomy exposed 37.3% more of the articular surface compared to the medial epicondyle osteotomy. None of these techniques were able to adequately expose the posteromedial- and medial-most aspects of the tibial plateau. A distal superficial collateral ligament osteotomy may be superior to a medial epicondyle osteotomy when an extension of the anteromedial approach to the tibial plateau is required. A distal superficial medial collateral ligament osteotomy combines the advantages of better exposure of the medial articular surface with preservation of the blood supply to the medial meniscus. However, surgeons should carefully consider whether such an extended approach is necessary, as it significantly increases invasiveness.

The influence of 3D printing on inter- and intrarater reliability on the classification of tibial plateau fractures

PURPOSE

Tibial plateau fractures continue to be a challenging task in clinical practice and current outcomes seem to provide the potential for further improvement. Especially presurgical understanding of the orientation of fracture lines and fracture severity is an essential key to sufficient surgical treatment. The object of this study was to evaluate the reliability of modern axial CT-based classification systems for tibial plateau fractures. In addition, the diagnostic-added value of 3D printing on the classification systems was investigated.

METHODS

22 raters were asked to classify 22 tibial plateau fractures (11 AO B- and 11 AO C-fractures) with the AO, the 10-Segment and the Revisited Schatzker classification in a three-step evaluation: first only using CT scans, second with 3D volumetric reconstructions and last with 3D-printed fracture models. Inter- and intraobserver agreement and the subjective certainty were analyzed. Statistics were done using kappa values, percentage match and a univariant one-way analysis of variance.

RESULTS

The AO classifications interobserver percentage match and kappa values improved for all raters and recorded an overall value of 0.34, respectively, 43% for the 3D print. The 10-Segment classification interobserver agreement also improved with the 3D-printed models and scored an overall kappa value of 0.18 and a percentage match of 79%. Equally the Revisited Schatzker classification increased its values to 0.31 and 35%. The intraobserver agreement showed a moderate agreement for the AO (0.44) and Revisited Schatzker classification (0.42) whereas the 10-Segment classification showed a fair agreement (0.27). Additionally, the raters changed their classification in 36% of the cases after evaluating the fracture with the 3D-printed models and the subjective certainty regarding the decisions improved as categories of self-reliant diagnostic choices were selected 18% (p < 0.05) more often after using the 3D-printed models.

CONCLUSION

Based on the measured outcomes it was concluded that the new classification systems show an overall slight to fair reliability and the use of 3D printing proved to be beneficial for the preoperative diagnostics of tibial plateau fractures. The 10-Segment classification system showed the highest percentage match evaluation of all classification systems demonstrating its high clinical value across all levels of user experience.

[Ligament injuries in tibial plateau fractures]

Fracture dislocations of the proximal tibia are associated with a markedly high incidence of ligament ruptures. Despite knowledge on the frequency of accompanying ligament injuries, even now neither adequate diagnostics nor targeted treatment of associated ligament injuries are the gold standard in the treatment algorithm for tibial plateau fractures. To be able to assess the risk and the type of accompanying ligament injuries in tibial plateau fractures, it is recommended to decidedly analyze the fracture morphology. For example, flexion varus fractures are very frequently associated with injuries to the anterior cruciate ligament, whereas valgus fractures are prone to ruptures of the medial collateral ligament and (hyper)extension fractures facilitate ruptures of the posterior cruciate ligament and the posterolateral corner. In order not to overlook high-grade instability, magnetic resonance imaging or intraoperative dynamic fluoroscopy can be carried out after completing osteosynthesis. Bony avulsions should either be addressed directly during osteosynthesis or indirectly retained via interfragmentary compression. In cases of direct visualization or relevant instability, intraligamentous tears should at least be intraoperatively reduced. If patients suffer from persistent instability a secondary ligament reconstruction with autologous tendons can be carried out following bony consolidation of the tibial plateau fracture.

[Change in the treatment of tibial plateau fractures]

BACKGROUND

The treatment of tibial plateau fractures has experienced a number of very different conceptual developments in recent years, not only with respect to technical innovations but also against the background of changing fracture patterns and the growing requirements of patients.

OBJECTIVE

What developments in recent years have had a significant impact on current treatment strategies for tibial plateau fractures?

METHODS

Narrative review of publications listed in PubMed on the topic of treatment of complex tibial plateau fractures.

RESULTS

While the two-dimensional classifications are becoming less important, computed tomography (CT)-based three-dimensional assessment of fracture progression and an access strategy based on it are coming to the fore. Direct dorsal approaches have been shown to be superior, particularly in the case of relevant posteromedial and/or posterolateral fracture involvement. The step-by-step approach extension via specific osteotomies of ligamentous attachments also enables a needs-dependent and fracture-dependent complete joint visualization and reduction control. In the treatment of geriatric tibial plateau fractures, primary treatment with endoprostheses is becoming increasingly more important to enable early mobilization under full load bearing with significantly shorter rehabilitation times.

CONCLUSION

Modern developments in the context of fracture treatment around the tibial plateau have led to a relevant reduction of infections and improved surgical outcomes; however, the high demands and the improved understanding of fractures still underline the great challenge in the treatment of complex fracture patterns.

Does Time to Theatre Affect the Ability to Achieve Fracture Reduction in Tibial Plateau Fractures?

Surgical management of displaced tibial plateau fracture (TPF) is often delayed due to accompanying soft tissue injuries sustained at the time of injury. The primary aim of this study was to assess the effect of time to surgery on fracture reduction in cases of TPF. The secondary aim was to assess the effect of preoperative demographics and residual articular step on Lysholm Scores and Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Scores (KOOS) following fixation. Patients between 2006 and 2017, managed by a single surgeon, were prospectively enrolled in the study. Reduction of articular step, defined as <2 mm, was assessed by a single blinded examiner. A total of 117 patients were enrolled, 52 with Schatzker II, 4 with Schatzker IV, and 61 with Schatzker VI fractures. Patients were followed up to a mean of 3.9 years. Analysis showed that the ability to achieve fracture reduction was negatively influenced by time to theatre, with the odds of achieving reduction decreasing 17% with each subsequent day post injury (p = 0.002). Furthermore, an increased time to theatre was associated with a reduced Lysholm score at one year (p = 0.01). The ability to achieve fracture reduction did not influence PROMs within the study period. We conclude that delay in surgical fixation negatively affects fracture reduction in TPF and may delay recovery. However, residual articular step does not necessarily influence PROMs over the mid-term.