[Injuries of the thoracic vertebrae in head-first dive into water]

Demographics and functional outcome of shallow water diving spinal injuries in northern Germany - A retrospective analysis of 160 consecutive cases

AIM

To describe demographic findings, typical injuries and functional neurological outcomes in patients with cervical trauma and tetraplegia sustained after diving into shallow water.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A retrospective study was performed including all patients treated in BG Klinikum Hamburg suffering from tetraplegia after jumping into shallow water between 1st June 1980 and 31st July 2018.

RESULTS

One hundred and sixty patients with cervical spinal injuries and tetraplegia following a dive into shallow water were evaluated. Of these, 156 patients (97.5%) were male. The mean age was 24.3 years ± 8.1 and the accidents occurred most often in inland waters (56.2%) and mostly between May and August (90.6%). In all cases there was one vertebra fractured, whereas in 48.1% of cases, two vertebrae were severed. In the majority of cases (n = 146), a surgical procedure was performed. Overall, the mean hospital stay was 202 days (±72, range: 31-403) and one patient died. On admission, 106 patients (66.2%) showed a complete lesion according to AIS A, with incomplete lesions in the remaining 54 patients (AIS B: n = 25 [15.6%], AIS C: n = 26 [16.3%], AIS D: n = 3 [1.9%]). In two thirds of the patients, the level of paralysis on admission was at the level of segments C4 (31.9%) or C5 (33.7%). Seventeen patients (10.6%) needed prehospital resuscitation. In 55 patients (34.4%), the neurological findings improved during the course of inpatient treatment and rehabilitation. Sixty-eight patients (42.5%) developed pneumonia, of which 52 patients (76.5%) were ventilated. In addition, 56.5% of patients with paralysis levels C0-C3 required ventilation, whereas only 6.3% of patients with paralysis levels C6-C7 were affected. Three patients (1.9%) were discharged from hospital with continuous ventilation. Overall, 27.4% of all AIS A patients, 56% of all AIS B patients and 46.2% of all AIS C patients improved neurologically, with 17% of all patients being able to walk.

CONCLUSIONS

The consequences of a cervical spine injury after diving into shallow water are severe and lifelong. Functionally, patients may benefit from care in a specialised centre, both in the acute phase and during rehabilitation. The more incomplete the primary paralysis, the greater the possibility of neurological recovery.

Spinal Cord Injury With Tetraplegia in Young Persons After Diving Into Shallow Water: What Has Changed in the Past 10 to 15 Years?

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective, monocentric, observational study in a tertiary health care center.

OBJECTIVES

To analyze prehospital and clinical findings, complications, neurological improvement and follow-up in a young person cohort with spinal cord injury (SCI) and tetraplegia according to the American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) Impairment Scale (AIS) A to D after diving into shallow water.

METHODS

Included were all persons younger than 50 years with SCI after head-first diving into shallow water between June 2001 and June 2019. All persons with SCI were divided into complete tetraplegia (AIS A) and incomplete tetraplegia (AIS B, C, and D) to test differences.

RESULTS

A total of 59 males (98.7%) and 1 female with a mean age of 27.7 years suffered an SCI. Alcohol use was documented in 25 cases (41.7%). At the time of admission, 33 people (55%) showed a complete tetraplegia (AIS A) and 27 showed an incomplete tetraplegia with 8 AIS B (13.3%), 15 AIS C (25%), and 4 AIS D (6.7%). At the time of discharge, people with initially complete tetraplegia showed a significant improvement from admission to discharge (P ≤ .004). Persons with incomplete tetraplegia were more likely to improve their neurological status compared with complete tetraplegia patients (P ≤ .001). Especially persons with complete tetraplegia suffered from typical SCI-related problems and complications.

CONCLUSIONS

People with SCI and tetraplegia at the time admission show neurological improvement in 50% of the cases with an overall better outcome in persons with incomplete tetraplegia. The surgical treatment of SCI within 24 hours seems to be associated with a better neurological outcome and a lower level of tetraplegia. The incidence of SCI caused by diving into shallow water remains stable without a significant change, especially in high-risk groups. More education and prevention programs are necessary to avoid these injuries.

Prevention of diving-induced spinal cord injuries-preliminary results of the first Romanian mass media prophylactic educational intervention

STUDY DESIGN

The study was an observational study of the seasonal incidence of diving accidents, according to the summer weather pattern and the influence of an educative prophylactic intervention.

OBJECTIVES

The study analyzed the preliminary results of a national project, disseminated on social networking (Facebook) and broadcasted on main national and international Romanian TV channels.

SETTING

The study was conducted at the Neurorehabilitation, Teaching Emergency Hospital 'Bagdasar-Arseni.'

METHODS

The study had a dichotomous design (a retrospective review and a prospective component), and it analyzed the evolution trends of diving accidents, before and after the prophylactic intervention. The retrospective review analyzed 41 diving accidents, registered during 2011-2015. The prospective component focused on cases registered in 2016. Spearman's Rho non-parametric test was used to evaluate the association between two variables (the air temperature and the number of diving accidents).

RESULTS

The study involved 46 males and 1 female, with a mean age (at the time of injury) 26.4±7.02 (median 25, mode 23), admitted to rehabilitation in an early post-acute status after surgical intervention. Male youths and young adults <35 years old represented 83% of all cases. During 2011-2015, a monotonic association between the summer climate and the incidence of diving-induced tetraplegia (R=0.97468; P=0.00482) was noticed. Analyzing the evolutionary trends of similar cases registered in 2016, variables did not increase in value together (R=0.73561; P=0.09561). In 2016, the number of diving-induced quadriplegics was reduced on average by 26.8%.

CONCLUSIONS

One year is not enough for a successful, durable educative intervention. It is compulsory to continue, extend and intensively promote this program.

Risk factors and prevention for spinal cord injury from diving in swimming pools and natural sites in Quebec, Canada: a 44-year study

BACKGROUND

Diving is the most frequent cause of spinal cord injury (SCI) from recreation and sport in Canada. This study was done to identify risk factors for SCI from diving in the province of Quebec.

METHODS

An interview survey was done for a target population of 203 subjects with a SCI from diving treated in the two specialized rehabilitation centers in Quebec during 1961-2004. Telephone interviews of consenting individuals were used to collect pertinent personal, equipment, and environmental factors for each incident.

RESULTS

Response was 44% (89/203); 92% were male and 85% <35 years old. Only 37% were aware prior to injury of the risk of SCI from diving, and only 33% had received water safety training. Swimming pools were the site of 51% (n=45) and natural bodies of water for 49% (n=44). 87% (n=39) of pools were single-unit home pools and 57% (n=26) above-ground. Depth indicators were absent for 100% of above-ground and 74% of in-ground pools. For SCI in in-ground pools, 63% resulted from striking the up-slope between deep and shallow ends. For dives at natural sites, a dock or wharf was the most frequent location, 36% (n=16). In 52% of pools and 79% of natural sites, depth was <1.4m (4.6ft). Signs prohibiting diving were absent in 96% of above-ground and 89% of in-ground pools. Alcohol was reported in 47% of SCIs.

INTERPRETATION

The target for prevention of diving SCI is male youths and young adults. Above-ground pools are too shallow and small for diving. Deep ends of many in-ground pools are excessively shallow and short since many SCIs resulted from striking the up-slope. Prevention of SCI from diving needs to focus on education of potential victims, pool vendors and manufacturers, and regulations for safety norms in private pools. Water safety should highlight diving as a high-risk activity, and emphasize that most home pools and natural sites are unsafe. Safer evidence-based pool designs and more effective warnings need to be implemented.

[Water rescue. A unique area of emergency medicine with many facets]

Emergencies on or in water are relatively rare in the rescue service. For this reason, water accident treatment and management does not receive much attention in the training of emergency medicine physicians. Consequently doctors working in emergency medicine often have minimal knowledge in this area. On the other hand, the number of fatal accidents on and in water has increased in recent years. In Germany the number of non-swimmers is also increasing, so it can be assumed that the number of water-related accidents will continue to rise. Drowning accidents and near drowning are important in this context and will be discussed in detail in this review as well as hypothermia (a frequent problem), accompanying injuries and diving accidents.

Diving injuries of the cervical spine in amateur divers

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Diving injuries are the cause of potentially devastating trauma, primarily affecting the cervical spine.

PURPOSE

Our purpose was to describe our experience with diving injuries treatment.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review.

PATIENT SAMPLE

Twenty patients with diving injuries.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Using the American Spinal Injury Association (ASIA) impairment scales as the primary outcome measure, the patients' neurological status before and after treatment was assessed. In this way we were able to draw conclusions about neurological improvement or deterioration in response to conservative or operative treatment.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed 20 patients with diving injuries of the cervical spine who were admitted to our institute over a 34-year period from 1970 until 2004.

RESULTS

The typical patient profile was of a young, healthy, athletic male who suffered an injury to the cervical spine after diving into shallow water. The number of cases corresponds to 2.6% of all admitted cervical spine injuries. All injures occurred between May and September. The most commonly fractured vertebrae were C5 and C6. Four patients were treated operatively and 16 conservatively. The indications for surgical treatment were posttraumatic instability and persistent neurological deficit. The mean follow-up of the patients was 17 years. Five patients died within the first month of their hospitalization and 1 patient died 1 year after his injury. Of the 14 patients who were available for follow-up 5 years past injury time, 6 improved neurologically and 8 remained unchanged in relation to their neurology upon admission. Of the 11 patients who were available for follow-up 10 years past injury time, 9 remained neurologically unchanged, 1 deteriorated, and 1 improved in relation to their neurology in the 5-year follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Diving injuries of the cervical spine demonstrate high mortality and morbidity rates. Recovery depends on the severity of the initial neurological damage. Conservative treatment is justified in specific patients and can lead to improvement of the initial neurological deficit.