Flow cytometric analysis of the chromosomes and stability of a wheat cell-culture line

Flow Cytometry-Based Determination of Ploidy from Dried Leaf Specimens in Genomically Complex Collections of the Tropical Forage Grass Urochloa s. l

Urochloa (including Brachiaria, Megathyrus and some Panicum) tropical grasses are native to Africa and are now, after selection and breeding, planted worldwide, particularly in South America, as important forages with huge potential for further sustainable improvement and conservation of grasslands. We aimed to develop an optimized approach to determine ploidy of germplasm collection of this tropical forage grass group using dried leaf material, including approaches to collect, dry and preserve plant samples for flow cytometry analysis. Our methods enable robust identification of ploidy levels (coefficient of variation of G0/G1 peaks, CV, typically <5%). Ploidy of some 348 forage grass accessions (ploidy range from 2x to 9x), from international genetic resource collections, showing variation in basic chromosome numbers and reproduction modes (apomixis and sexual), were determined using our defined standard protocol. Two major Urochloa agamic complexes are used in the current breeding programs at CIAT and EMBRAPA: the 'brizantha' and 'humidicola' agamic complexes are variable, with multiple ploidy levels. Some U. brizantha accessions have odd level of ploidy (5x), and the relative differences in fluorescence values of the peak positions between adjacent cytotypes is reduced, thus more precise examination of this species is required. Ploidy measurement of U. humidicola revealed aneuploidy.

Chromosome analysis and sorting

Flow cytometric analysis and sorting of plant mitotic chromosomes has been mastered by only a few laboratories worldwide. Yet, it has been contributing significantly to progress in plant genetics, including the production of genome assemblies and the cloning of important genes. The dissection of complex genomes by flow sorting into the individual chromosomes that represent small parts of the genome reduces DNA sample complexity and streamlines projects relying on molecular and genomic techniques. Whereas flow cytometric analysis, that is, chromosome classification according to fluorescence and light scatter properties, is an integral part of any chromosome sorting project, it has rarely been used on its own due to lower resolution and sensitivity as compared to other cytogenetic methods. To perform chromosome analysis and sorting, commercially available electrostatic droplet sorters are suitable. However, in order to resolve and purify chromosomes of interest the instrument must offer high resolution of optical signals as well as stability during long runs. The challenge is thus not the instrumentation, but the adequate sample preparation. The sample must be a suspension of intact mitotic metaphase chromosomes and the protocol, which includes the induction of cell cycle synchrony, accumulation of dividing cells at metaphase, and release of undamaged chromosomes, is time consuming and laborious and needs to be performed very carefully. Moreover, in addition to fluorescent staining chromosomal DNA, the protocol may include specific labelling of DNA repeats to facilitate discrimination of particular chromosomes. This review introduces the applications of chromosome sorting in plants, and discusses in detail sample preparation, chromosome analysis and sorting to achieve the highest purity in flow-sorted fractions, and their suitability for downstream applications.

Flow Analysis and Sorting of Plant Chromosomes

Analysis and sorting of plant chromosomes (plant flow cytogenetics) is a special application of flow cytometry in plant genomics and its success depends critically on sample quality. This unit describes the methodology in a stepwise manner, starting with the induction of cell cycle synchrony and accumulation of dividing cells in mitotic metaphase, and continues with the preparation of suspensions of intact mitotic chromosomes, flow analysis and sorting of chromosomes, and finally processing of the sorted chromosomes. Each step of the protocol is described in detail as some procedures have not been used widely. Supporting histograms are presented as well as hints on dealing with plant material; the utility of sorted chromosomes for plant genomics is also discussed. © 2016 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

Extended Chromatin and DNA Fibers from Active Plant Nuclei for High-resolution FISH

The conventional protocol for isolation of cell wall free nuclei for release of DNA fibers for plants involves mechanical removal of the cell wall and separation of debris by sieve filtration. The mechanical grinding pressure applied during the process leaves only the more tolerant G(1) nuclei intact, and all other states of active nuclei that may be present in the target tissues (e.g., leaf) are simply crushed/disrupted during the isolation process. Here we describe an alternative enzymatic protocol for isolation of nuclei from root tip tissue. Cell wall free nuclei at a given stage of cell cycle, free of any cell debris, could be realized in suspension that are fit for preparation of extended fibers suitable for fiber FISH applications. The protocol utilizes selective harvest of active nuclei from root tip tissue in liquid suspension under the influence of cell wall-degrading enzymes, and provides opportunities to target cell cycle-specific nuclei from interphase through division phase for the release of extended DNA fibers. Availability of cell cycle-specific fibers may have added value in transcriptional analysis, DNA:RNA hybridization, visualization of DNA replication and replication forks, and improved FISH efficiency.

Patterns of nucleotide asymmetries in plant and animal genomes

Symmetry in biology provides many intriguing puzzles to the scientist's mind. Chargaff's second parity rule states a symmetric distribution of oligonucleotides within a single strand of double-stranded DNA. While this rule has been verified in a wide range of microbial genomes, it still awaits explanation. In our study, we inquired into patterns of mono- and trinucleotide intra-strand parity in complex plant genomic sequences that became available during the last few years, and compared these to equally complex animal genomes. The degree and patterns of deviation from Chargaff's second rule were different between plant and animal species. We observed a universal inter-chromosomal homogeneity of mononucleotide skews in coding sequences of plant chromosomes, while the base composition of animal coding sequences differed between chromosomes even within a single species. We also found differences in the base composition of dicot introns in comparison to those of monocots. These genome-wide patterns were limited to genic regions and were not encountered in inter-genic sequences. We discuss the implications of our findings in relation to hypotheses about functional correlations of intra-strand parity which have hitherto been put forward. Furthermore, we propose more recent polyploidization and subsequent homogenization of homoeologues as a possible reason for more homogeneous skew patterns in plants.

Chromosomes in the flow to simplify genome analysis

Nuclear genomes of human, animals, and plants are organized into subunits called chromosomes. When isolated into aqueous suspension, mitotic chromosomes can be classified using flow cytometry according to light scatter and fluorescence parameters. Chromosomes of interest can be purified by flow sorting if they can be resolved from other chromosomes in a karyotype. The analysis and sorting are carried out at rates of 10(2)-10(4) chromosomes per second, and for complex genomes such as wheat the flow sorting technology has been ground-breaking in reducing genome complexity for genome sequencing. The high sample rate provides an attractive approach for karyotype analysis (flow karyotyping) and the purification of chromosomes in large numbers. In characterizing the chromosome complement of an organism, the high number that can be studied using flow cytometry allows for a statistically accurate analysis. Chromosome sorting plays a particularly important role in the analysis of nuclear genome structure and the analysis of particular and aberrant chromosomes. Other attractive but not well-explored features include the analysis of chromosomal proteins, chromosome ultrastructure, and high-resolution mapping using FISH. Recent results demonstrate that chromosome flow sorting can be coupled seamlessly with DNA array and next-generation sequencing technologies for high-throughput analyses. The main advantages are targeting the analysis to a genome region of interest and a significant reduction in sample complexity. As flow sorters can also sort single copies of chromosomes, shotgun sequencing DNA amplified from them enables the production of haplotype-resolved genome sequences. This review explains the principles of flow cytometric chromosome analysis and sorting (flow cytogenetics), discusses the major uses of this technology in genome analysis, and outlines future directions.

Flow analysis and sorting of plant chromosomes

The use of flow cytometry for evaluation of plant chromosomes requires some specialized attention to preparation and instrumentation. This unit deals exclusively with plant cytogenetics and presents an outline of this area as well as methods for accumulation of cells in metaphase, preparation of chromosome suspensions, flow analysis and sorting of chromosomes, and processing of the sorted chromosomes. Each method is described in tremendous detail because in many aspects dealing with plant cells is quite different from dealing with mammalian cells. Supporting histograms are presented as well as a range of special hints on dealing with plant material and a discussion of the utility of sorted chromosomes for plant genome mapping.

Chromosome-based genomics in the cereals

The cereals are of enormous importance to mankind. Many of the major cereal species - specifically, wheat, barley, oat, rye, and maize - have large genomes. Early cytogenetics, genome analysis and genetic mapping in the cereals benefited greatly from their large chromosomes, and the allopolyploidy of wheat and oats that has allowed for the development of many precise cytogenetic stocks. In the genomics era, however, large genomes are disadvantageous. Sequencing large and complex genomes is expensive, and the assembly of genome sequence is hampered by a significant content of repetitive DNA and, in allopolyploids, by the presence of homoeologous genomes. Dissection of the genome into its component chromosomes and chromosome arms provides an elegant solution to these problems. In this review we illustrate how this can be achieved by flow cytometric sorting. We describe the development of methods for the preparation of intact chromosome suspensions from the major cereals, and their analysis and sorting using flow cytometry. We explain how difficulties in the discrimination of specific chromosomes and their arms can be overcome by exploiting extant cytogenetic stocks of polyploid wheat and oats, in particular chromosome deletion and alien addition lines. Finally, we discuss some of the applications of flow-sorted chromosomes, and present some examples demonstrating that a chromosome-based approach is advantageous for the analysis of the complex genomes of cereals, and that it can offer significant potential for the delivery of genome sequencing and gene cloning in these crops.

Determination of cell concentration in a plant cell suspension using a fluorescence microplate reader

Microscopic counting of plant cells is a very tedious and time-consuming process and is therefore seldom used to evaluate plant cell number on a routine basis. This study describes a fast and simple method to evaluate cell concentration in a plant cell suspension using a fluorescence microplate reader. Eschscholtzia californica cells were fixed in a mix of methanol and acetic acid (3:1) and stained with a fluorescent DNA binding dye (Hoechst 33258). Readings were done in a fluorescence microplate reader at 360/465 nm. Specific binding of the dye to double-stranded DNA was significantly favored over unspecific binding when 1.0 M Tris buffer at pH 7.5 containing 1.0 M NaCl and 75 microg ml(-1) of Hoechst 33258 was used. Fluorescence readings must be done between 4 min and 12 min following the addition of the staining solution to the sample. The microplate counting method provides a convenient, rapid and sensitive procedure for determining the cell concentration in plant cell suspensions. The assay has a linear detection range from 0.2 x 10(6) cells to 10.0 x 10(6) cells per milliliter (actual concentration in the tested cell suspension). The time needed to perform the microplate counting was 10% of that needed for the microscopic enumeration. However, this microplate counting method can only be used on genetically stable cell lines and on asynchronous cell suspensions.

Hybrid speciation in plants: new insights from molecular studies

Abrupt speciation through interspecific hybridisation is an important mechanism in angiosperm evolution. Flowering plants therefore offer excellent opportunities for studying genetic processes associated with hybrid speciation. Novel molecular approaches are now available to examine these processes at the level of both genome organization and gene expression - transcriptomics. Here, we present an overview of the molecular technologies currently used to study hybrid speciation and how they are providing new insights into this mode of speciation in flowering plants. We begin with an introduction to hybrid speciation in plants, followed by a review of techniques, such as isozymes and other markers, which have been used to study hybrid species in the past. We then review advances in molecular techniques that have the potential to be applied to studies of hybrid species, followed by an overview of the main genomic and transcriptomic changes suspected, or known, to occur in newly formed hybrids, together with commentary on the application of advanced molecular tools to studying these changes.

Recent progress in chromosome painting of Arabidopsis and related species

This paper reports on state-of-the-art achievements of chromosome painting in Arabidopsis thaliana (2n = 10). Arabidopsis chromosomes 1, 2 and 4 were painted using chromosome-specific BAC contigs. We consider technical aspects of the painting approach and document major applications, such as the tracing of Arabidopsis chromosomes as interphase chromosome territories and during mitotic and meiotic cell cycles as well as comparative chromosome painting in related species. This is the first report of successful interspecific chromosome painting in plants. The evolutionary history of chromosomes homeologous to Arabidopsis chromosome 4 was reconstructed by hybridization of chromosome-4-specific painting probes to karyotypes of Brassicaceae species with x = 8 chromosomes. Future perspectives of chromosome painting in A. thaliana and its wild relatives are outlined.

Chromosome painting in Arabidopsis thaliana

Chromosome painting, that is visualisation of chromosome segments or whole chromosomes based on fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) with chromosome-specific DNA probes is widely used for chromosome studies in mammals, birds, reptiles and insects. Attempts to establish chromosome painting in euploid plants have failed so far. Here, we report on chromosome painting in Arabidopsis thaliana (n = 5, 125 Mb C(-1)). Pools of contiguous 113-139 BAC clones spanning 2.6 and 13.3 Mb of the short and the long arm of chromosome 4 (17.5 Mb) were used to paint this entire chromosome during mitotic and meiotic divisions as well as in interphase nuclei. The possibility of identifying any particular chromosome region on pachytene chromosomes and within interphase nuclei using selected BACs is demonstrated by differential labelling. This approach allows us, for the first time, to paint an entire autosome of an euploid plant to study chromosome rearrangements, homologue association, interphase chromosome territories, as well as to identify homeologous chromosomes of related species.

Trigenomic origin of the hexaploid Psammopyrum athericum (Triticeae: Poaceae) revealed by in-situ hybridization

The genomic constitution of the hexaploid Psammopyrum athericum was studied with in-situ DNA hybridization using both genomic DNA and isolated cloned sequences as probes. A genomic probe from Thinopyrum bessarabicum (E genome) hybridized successfully to 14 chromosomes of Ps. athericum and a probe from Festucopsis serpentinii (L genome) hybridized to another 14 chromosomes. The remaining chromosomes did not hybridize, apart from in the centromeric region, to any of the genomic probes used. It is thus proposed that Ps. athericum contains the genomes E, L and X where X stands for a so-far unknown genome. Psammopyrum athericum has three pairs of pTa71 sites and approximately 30 pSc119:2 sites. The origin of the third genome will be a matter for further research using genomic and genome-specific probes.

Chromosome painting in plants

The current 'state-of-art' as to chromosome painting in plants is reviewed. We define different situations described as painting so far: i) Genomic in situ hybridisation (GISH) with total genomic DNA to distinguish alien chromosomes on the basis of divergent dispersed repeats, ii) 'Chromosomal in situ suppression' (CISS) hybridisation with chromosome-derived DNA probes and blocking of interchromosomally dispersed repeats by total genomic or C0t-1 DNA in excess, iii) exceptional cases of single chromosome painting by probes containing chromosome-specific dispersed repeats, and iv) Fluorescence in situ hybridisation (FISH) with extended contigs of large insert clones for painting of those chromosomes of a euploid complement which harbour the cloned sequences. While GISH was successfully applied in most plant hybrids and/or their derivatives, painting of individual chromosomes by CISS hybridisations of chromosome-specific DNA probes have so far not revealed convincing results in plants. The reason for this failure and the use of possible alternative approaches are discussed. At least for small plant genomes, painting by large insert single sequence clones provides a promising alternative tool to solve cytogenetic questions, which up to now could not be tackled otherwise. An example of such a painting is described in detail for Arabidopsis thaliana.

Flow sorting of mitotic chromosomes in common wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

The aim of this study was to develop an improved procedure for preparation of chromosome suspensions, and to evaluate the potential of flow cytometry for chromosome sorting in wheat. Suspensions of intact chromosomes were prepared by mechanical homogenization of synchronized root tips after mild fixation with formaldehyde. Histograms of relative fluorescence intensity (flow karyotypes) obtained after the analysis of DAPI-stained chromosomes were characterized and the chromosome content of all peaks on wheat flow karyotype was determined for the first time. Only chromosome 3B could be discriminated on flow karyotypes of wheat lines with standard karyotype. Remaining chromosomes formed three composite peaks and could be sorted only as groups. Chromosome 3B could be sorted at purity >95% as determined by microscopic evaluation of sorted fractions that were labeled using C-PRINS with primers for GAA microsatellites and for Afa repeats, respectively. Chromosome 5BL/7BL could be sorted in two wheat cultivars at similar purity, indicating a potential of various wheat stocks for sorting of other chromosome types. PCR with chromosome-specific primers confirmed the identity of sorted fractions and suitability of flow-sorted chromosomes for physical mapping and for construction of small-insert DNA libraries. Sorted chromosomes were also found suitable for the preparation of high-molecular-weight DNA. On the basis of these results, it seems realistic to propose construction of large-insert chromosome-specific DNA libraries in wheat. The availability of such libraries would greatly simplify the analysis of the complex wheat genome.

Flow karyotyping and sorting of mitotic chromosomes of barley (Hordeum vulgare L.)

A high-yield method for isolation of barley chromosomes in suspension, their analysis and sorting using flow cytometry is described. To accumulate meristem root tip cells at metaphase, actively growing roots were subjected to subsequent treatment with 2 mmol/L hydroxyurea for 18 h, 2.5 micromol/L amiprophos methyl for 2 h, and ice water (overnight). This treatment resulted in metaphase indices exceeding 50%. Synchronized root tips were fixed in 2% formaldehyde for 20 min and chromosomes were released into a lysis buffer by mechanical homogenization, producing, on average, 5 x 10(5) chromosomes from 50 root tips. The isolated chromosomes were morphologically intact and suitable for flow cytometric analysis and sorting. While it was possible to discriminate and sort only one chromosome from a barley cultivar with standard karyotype, up to three chromosomes could be sorted in translocation lines with morphologically distinct chromosomes. The purity of chromosome fractions, estimated after PRINS with primers specific for GAA microsatellites, reached 97%. PCR with chromosome-specific primers confirmed the purity and suitability of flow-sorted chromosomes for physical mapping of DNA sequences.

Root tip cell cycle synchronization and metaphase-chromosome isolation suitable for flow sorting in common wheat (Triticum aestivum L.)

An efficient procedure for cell-cycle synchronization in meristematic root tips was achieved in common wheat. Treatment parameters for synchronizing the cell cycle of root tip meristem cells, such as time-course and applied concentrations of various chemicals, were systematically tested and optimized by flow cytometric analysis of isolated nuclei. High mitotic indices (69.5% in the root tip meristematic area) were routinely obtained by treating germinating seeds with 1.25 mM hydroxyurea for 16 h, followed by incubation in a hydroxyurea-free solution for 2 h, and treatment with 1 μM trifluralin for 4 h. Uniform seed germination prior to treatment is very important for achieving consistently high metaphase indices in the root tips. Large numbers of metaphase chromosomes, suitable for flow cytometric analysis and sorting, were isolated from synchronized root tip cells. Flow sorted wheat chromosomes, via univariate and bivariate analysis, showed four major chromosome peaks. Each discrete peak may represent wheat chromosome types with similar DNA content. Bivariate flow karyotyping based on AT and GC content did not improve the separation of wheat chromosomes.Key words: flow cytometry, trifluralin, hydroxyurea, univariate analysis, bivariate analysis.