Endoscopic anatomic ligament reconstruction is a reliable option to treat chronic lateral ankle instability

Accuracy of Cutaneous Landmarks Compared to Ultrasound to Locate the Calcaneal Footprint of the CFL

The purpose was to determine the accuracy of the techniques of Lopes et al. and Michels et al., compared to ultrasound, to locate the center of the calcaneal footprint of the CFL in healthy volunteers. The authors recruited 17 healthy adult volunteers at 1 center with no current ankle pathologies and no previous surgical antecedents on either ankle. The authors recorded the age, sex, height, BMI, and ankle side for each volunteer. Measurements were made on both ankles of the 17 volunteers to increase the sample size and ensure less dispersion of data, independently by 2 surgeons: 1 senior surgeon with 15 years' experience and 1 junior with 3 years' experience. The location of the center of the calcaneal footprint of the CFL was determined by each surgeon using 3 methods: (1) the cutaneous technique of Lopes et al., (2) the cutaneous technique of Michels et al., and (3) ultrasound imaging. The 17 volunteers (34 feet) had a mean age of 26.3 ± 8.7 and a BMI of 21.7 ± 2.9. The Michels point was significantly closer (4.6 ± 3.7 mm) than the Lopes point (11.1 ± 5.4 mm) to the true center of the calcaneal footprint of the CFL determined by ultrasound, notably in the vertical direction. The Michels point was located significantly closer to the true center of the calcaneal footprint of the CFL and demonstrated less dispersion than the Lopes point, indicated by significantly lower absolute mean deviation from the true center of the calcaneal footprint of the CFL, and that ultrasound is therefore preferred to locate the footprint the CFL.

MRI Assessment of Tendon Graft After Lateral Ankle Ligament Reconstruction: Does Ligamentization Exist?

BACKGROUND

No description exists in the literature about the normal evolution of tendon graft after a lateral ankle ligament (LAL) reconstruction.

PURPOSE

To assess the magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) characteristics and the evolution of the tendon graft during different moments in the follow-up after an endoscopic reconstruction of the LAL.

STUDY DESIGN

Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3.

METHODS

This prospective study included 37 consecutive patients who underwent an endoscopic reconstruction of the LAL with an autograft using the gracilis tendon to treat chronic ankle instability (CAI) resistant to nonoperative treatment (CAI group) and 16 patients without ankle instability (control group). All patients in the CAI group underwent a postoperative assessment at 6, 12, and 24 months using the Karlsson score and MRI examination. Only patients with good and excellent results were included in the study. Graft assessment consisted of qualitative measurements and quantitative evaluations of the reconstructed anterior talofibular ligament (RATFL) and reconstructed calcaneofibular ligament (RCFL), including signal-to-noise quotient (SNQ) and contrast-to-noise quotient (CNQ) measurements in proton density-fat suppressed (PD-FS) and T1-weighted sequences. The analysis of variance test was used to compare the SNQ and the CNQ at different time points for each sequence.

RESULTS

The MRI signal at 6 months was increased compared with that of the control group. Next, a significant signal decrease from 6 to 24 months was noted on PD-FS and T1-weighted images. SNQ measurements on PD-FS weighted images for both the RATFL and the RCFL demonstrated a significantly higher signal (P < .01 and P = .01, respectively) at 6 months compared with that of the control group. Subsequently, the signal decreased from 6 to 24 months. Similarly, CNQ measurements on PD-FS weighted images for both the RATFL and the RCFL demonstrated a significantly higher signal (P < .01 and P < .01, respectively) at 6 months compared with that of the control group. Subsequently, the signal decreased from 6 to 24 months.

CONCLUSION

The present study demonstrated an evolution of the MRI characteristics, suggesting a process of graft maturation toward ligamentization. This is important for clinical practice, as it suggests an evolution in graft properties and supports the possibility of creating a viable ligament.

Return to sports after ankle reconstruction with tendon grafts in chronic lateral ankle instability: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Purpose

Anatomic reconstruction using grafts is being performed more frequently in athletes experiencing recurrent chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI). The purpose of the study was to systematically review the current literature to determine the rates of return to sports (RTS) along with timing in patients with CLAI undergoing ligament reconstruction.

Methods

The databases PubMed, Scopus, Cochrane, and Embase were searched based on the PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines. Articles quoting on the return to sports rate after lateral ankle reconstruction were included. The rates of return to any sports, return to pre-injury sports, and return to competitive sports along with the timing of return were evaluated and a proportion meta-analysis was performed.

Results

A total of 720 patients in 20 studies met our inclusion criteria. The RTS rates for any sports were 95.3%, and 84.3% for pre-injury sports The average time taken for return to sports was 17 weeks. Postoperative functional outcomes, ankle stability, and ROM were significantly improved in comparison to preoperative status.

Conclusion

The RTS rates following lateral ankle reconstruction in CLAI showed a high return to any sports, but moderate to high rates for the pre-injury or competitive level of sports.

Level of evidence

Level of evidence II.

Advantages of ultrasound identification of the distal insertion of the calcaneofibular ligament during ligament reconstructions

INTRODUCTION

In lateral ankle instability, anatomical ligament reconstructions are generally performed using arthroscopy. The ligament graft is passed through the talar, fibular and calcaneal tunnels, reconstructing the anterior talofibular and calcaneofibular (CFL) bundles. However, the calcaneal insertion of the CFL needs to be performed in an extra-articular fashion, and cannot be carried out under arthroscopy, thus requiring specific anatomical landmarks. For obtaining these landmarks, methods based on radiography or surface anatomy have already been described but can only offer an approximate identification of the actual CFL anatomical insertion point. In contrast, an ultrasound technique allows direct visualization of the insertion point and of the sural nerve that may be injured during surgery. Our study aimed to assess the reliability and accuracy of ultrasound visualization when performing calcaneal insertion of the CFL with specific monitoring of the sural nerve.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Our anatomical study was carried out on 15 ankles available from a body donation program. Ultrasound identification of the sural nerve was obtained first with injection of dye. A needle was positioned at the level of the calcaneal insertion of the CFL. After dissection, in all the ankles, the dye was in contact with the sural nerve and the needle was located in the calcaneal insertion area of the CFL. The mean distance between the sural nerve and the needle was 4.8 mm (range 3-7 mm).

DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION

A pre- or intra-operative ultrasound technique is a simple and reliable means for obtaining anatomical landmarks when drilling the calcaneal tunnel for ligament reconstruction of the lateral plane of the ankle. This tunnel should preferably be drilled obliquely from the heel towards the subtalar joint (1 h-3 h direction on an ultrasound cross section), which preserves a maximum distance from the sural nerve for safety purposes, while allowing an accurate anatomical positioning of the osseous tunnel.

Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability: Can We Get Even Better with Surgical Treatment?

Lateral ligament attenuation may occur after repetitive ankle sprains, creating instability. Management of chronic ankle instability requires a comprehensive approach to mechanical and functional instability. Surgical treatment, however, is indicated when conservative treatment is not effective. Ankle ligament reconstruction is the most common surgical procedure to resolve mechanical instability. Anatomic open Broström-Gould reconstruction is the gold standard for repairing affected lateral ligaments and returning athletes to sports. Arthroscopy may also be beneficial for identifying associated injuries. In severe and long-standing instability, reconstruction with tendon augmentation could be necessary.

Both Open and Arthroscopic All-Inside Anatomic Reconstruction With Autologous Gracilis Tendon Restore Ankle Stability in Patients With Chronic Lateral Ankle Instability

PURPOSE

To compare the return to sports and short-term clinical outcomes between the arthroscopic all-inside and the open anatomic reconstruction with gracilis tendon autograft for chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) patients.

METHODS

From March 2018 to January 2020, 57 CLAI patients were prospectively included with arthroscopic all-inside anatomic reconstruction (n = 31) or open anatomic reconstruction (n = 26) with gracilis tendon autograft. The patients were evaluated before operation and at 3 months, 6 months, 12 months, and 24 months after surgery. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society score (AOFAS), visual analog scale (VAS), and Karlsson-Peterson score were evaluated at each time point, and stress radiography with a Telos device was performed before surgery and at final follow-up. The time to return to full weightbearing walking, jogging, sports, and work, Tegner activity score, and complications were recorded and compared.

RESULTS

All the subjective scores significantly improved after surgery from the preoperative level. Compared with the open group, the arthroscopic group demonstrated significantly earlier return to full weightbearing walking (8.9 vs 11.7 weeks, P < .001), jogging (17.9 vs 20.9 weeks, P = .012), and recreational sports (22.4 vs 26.5 weeks, P = .001) with significantly better AOFAS score and Karlsson score at 3 to 6 months, and better VAS score at 6 months after surgery. The 2 groups demonstrated no significant difference in the surgical duration or surgical complications. No significant difference was found in the clinical scores or stress radiographic measurements at 24 months after surgery (P > .05).

CONCLUSION

Compared with the open procedure, the arthroscopic all-inside anatomic lateral ankle ligament reconstruction with autologous gracilis tendon could achieve earlier return to full weightbearing, jogging, and recreational sports with less pain and better ankle functional scores at 3 to 6 months after surgery. Similar favorable short-term clinical outcomes were achieved for both techniques at 2 years after surgery.

STUDY DESIGN

Level I, randomized controlled trial.

Current Definitions of Failure in Lateral Ankle Instability Surgery: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

"Failure" is a term that is frequently used to describe an unfavorable outcome for patients who undergo surgical treatment for lateral ankle instability (LAI). A standard definition of failure for the surgical treatment of ankle instability has not been established by clinicians and researchers.

PURPOSE

To identify the definitions of ankle instability treatment failure that are currently in the literature and to work toward the standardization of the definition.

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review; Level of evidence, 4.

METHODS

A systematic search of MEDLINE, SPORTDiscus, CINAHL, Embase, and Web of Science was conducted to identify clinical studies that included patients who underwent surgical treatment for LAI and included information about surgical failure. Studies with level of evidence 1 to 4 were included in this review. Animal studies, biomechanical studies, cadaveric studies, review articles, and expert opinions were excluded. The included studies were then reviewed for definitions of failure of any surgical procedure that was performed to correct LAI.

RESULTS

Of the 1200 studies found, 3.5% (42/1200) published between 1984 and 2021 met the inclusion criteria and were analyzed. After reviewing the data, we found numerous definitions were reported in the literature for LAI surgical failure. The most common was recurrent instability (40% [17/42]), followed by rerupture (19% [8/42]). For the original surgical procedure, the anatomic Broström-Gould technique was used most frequently (57% [24/42]). The failure rate of the Broström-Gould technique ranged from 1.1% to 45.2% depending on the definition of failure.

CONCLUSION

There were multiple definitions of failure for the surgical treatment of LAI, which is one of the reasons why the rate of failure can vary greatly. The literature would benefit greatly from the standardization of the definition of ankle instability treatment failure. This definition should include specific, objective physical examination findings that eliminate the ambiguity surrounding failure.

Role of the intrinsic subtalar ligaments in subtalar instability and consequences for clinical practice

Subtalar instability (STI) is a disabling complication after an acute lateral ankle sprain and remains a challenging problem. The pathophysiology is difficult to understand. Especially the relative contribution of the intrinsic subtalar ligaments in the stability of the subtalar joint is still controversial. Diagnosis is difficult because of the overlapping clinical signs with talocrural instability and the absence of a reliable diagnostic reference test. This often results in misdiagnosis and inappropriate treatment. Recent research offers new insights in the pathophysiology of subtalar instability and the importance of the intrinsic subtalar ligaments. Recent publications clarify the local anatomical and biomechanical characteristics of the subtalar ligaments. The cervical ligament and interosseous talocalcaneal ligament seem to play an important function in the normal kinematics and stability of the subtalar joint. In addition to the calcaneofibular ligament (CFL), these ligaments seem to have an important role in the pathomechanics of subtalar instability (STI). These new insights have an impact on the approach to STI in clinical practice. Diagnosis of STI can be performed be performed by a step-by-step approach to raise the suspicion to STI. This approach consists of clinical signs, abnormalities of the subtalar ligaments on MRI and intraoperative evaluation. Surgical treatment should address all the aspects of the instability and focus on a restoration of the normal anatomical and biomechanical properties. Besides a low threshold to reconstruct the CFL, a reconstruction of the subtalar ligaments should be considered in complex cases of instability. The purpose of this review is to provide a comprehensive update of the current literature focused on the contribution of the different ligaments in the stability of the subtalar joint. This review aims to introduce the more recent findings in the earlier hypotheses on normal kinesiology, pathophysiology and relation with talocrural instability. The consequences of this improved understanding of pathophysiology on patient identification, treatment and future research are described.

Reconstruction of the cervical ligament in patients with chronic subtalar instability

PURPOSE

Diagnosis and treatment of subtalar instability (STI) remains complicated and challenging. The purpose of this study was to investigate the outcome of an anatomical reconstruction of the cervical ligament in patients with suspected chronic STI.

METHODS

This prospective study assessed the results of a surgical reconstruction of the cervical ligament using a gracilis tendon graft in a group of 14 patients (16 feet). Diagnosis of STI was performed using a predefined algorithm including clinical signs, MRI and peroperative evaluation. All patients had symptoms of chronic hindfoot instability despite prolonged non-surgical treatment. At final follow-up the outcome was assessed using the Karlsson score, the Foot and Ankle Outcome Score and the American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society score.

RESULTS

After an average follow up of 22.6 months (range, 15-36), all patients reported significant improvement compared to their preoperative symptoms. The mean preoperative Karlsson score improved from 36.4 ± 13.5 (median 37, range 10-55) to a mean postoperative Karlsson score was 89.6 ± 8.5 (median 90, range 72-100) (P < 0.0001). The cervical ligament reconstruction was combined with other procedures in 13 cases: calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) reconstruction (3), CFL and anterior talofibular ligament reconstruction (7), bifurcate ligament reconstruction (3).

CONCLUSION

Anatomical reconstruction of the cervical ligament is a valid technique to treat patients with STI. It is a safe procedure and produces good clinical results with minimal complications. This technique can be considered in more complex cases and can be combined with other procedures according to the specific location of the instability.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Anatomic reconstruction using the autologous gracilis tendon achieved less sprain recurrence than the Broström-Gould procedure but delayed recovery in chronic lateral ankle instability

PURPOSE

To compare the return-to-activity and long-term clinical outcomes between anatomic lateral ligament reconstruction using the autologous gracilis tendon and modified Broström-Gould (MBG) procedure in chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI). It was hypothesised that there was no difference between the two techniques.

METHODS

From 2013 to 2018, 30 CLAI patients with grade III joint instability confirmed by anterior drawer test underwent anatomic reconstruction of lateral ankle ligament with the autologous gracilis tendon (reconstruction group) in our institute. Another 30 patients undergoing MBG procedure (MBG group) were matched in a 1:1 ratio based on demographic parameters. The post-operative American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, visual analogue scale (VAS) pain score, Tegner activity score, Karlsson-Peterson score, surgical complications, return-to-activities and work were retrospectively evaluated and compared between the two groups.

RESULTS

All subjective scores significantly improved after the operation (all with p < 0.001) without difference between the two groups (all n.s.). The MBG group showed a significantly higher proportion of postoperative sprain recurrence than the reconstruction group (26.7% vs. 0, p = 0.002). The reconstruction group showed a significantly longer period to start walking with full weight-bearing (10.5 ± 6.9 vs. 7.0 ± 3.1 weeks, p = 0.015), jogging (17.1 ± 8.9 vs. 12.7 ± 6.9 weeks, p = 0.043) and return-to-work (13.5 ± 12.6 vs. 8.0 ± 4.7 weeks, p = 0.039) than the MBG group.

CONCLUSIONS

Both anatomic reconstruction using the autologous gracilis tendon and MBG procedure could equally achieved reliable long-term clinical outcomes and the tendon reconstruction showed a relatively lower incidence of postoperative sprain recurrence but delayed recovery to walking, jogging and return-to-work. The MBG procedure was still the first choice with rapid recovery but the tendon reconstruction was recommended for patients with higher strength demand.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Return to sports: Rate and time after arthroscopic surgery for chronic lateral ankle instability

BACKGROUND

Arthroscopic surgery for treating ankle instability is increasingly popular. Several studies showed similar functional outcomes to those seen after open surgery, with no increase in complications. The objective of this study was to evaluate the return-to-sports (RTS) rate and time after arthroscopic surgery to treat chronic lateral ankle instability.

HYPOTHESIS

The rate and time of RTS are satisfactory after arthroscopic surgery to treat chronic lateral ankle instability.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This single-centre retrospective study included patients managed arthroscopically for chronic lateral ankle instability, with no other procedures, between February 2014 and May 2017. We evaluated the time and rate of RTS, as well as factors associated with RTS such as motivation, athletic level before surgery and whether the injury was work-related. Follow-up was at least 1 year.

RESULTS

Of the 40 included patients, 30 (75%) returned to their main sport, after a median of 6 months. Moreover, 22 (55%) patients resumed their main sport at the same or a higher level within 12 months after surgery, their median postoperative follow-up being 29 months (range, 13-61). The AOFAS score improved significantly, from 67 (30-90) before surgery to 88.5 (39-100) at last follow-up (p<0.001). The numerical pain score decreased significantly between these two timepoints, from 6 (0-10) to 1 (0-10) (p<0.001). By multivariate analysis, a high level of motivation before surgery was the main factor significantly associated with RTS at the same or a higher level within 12 months after surgery (odds ratio, 16.47; 95%CI, 3.33-81.20; p=0.007). Persistent pain was more common in patients with work-related injuries (p=0.016).

CONCLUSION

At 12 months, the RTS rate was 75% overall, with 55% of patients returning to the same or a higher level. Median time to RTS was 6 months (4-8). Both the rate of and the time to RTS were independently associated with greater preoperative motivation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV, retrospective observational cohort study.

Arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction of lateral collateral ligaments with ligament advanced reinforcement system artificial ligament for chronic ankle instability

BACKGROUND

Recently, the use of ligament advanced reinforcement system (LARS) artificial ligament, a new graft which has several unique advantages such as no donor-site morbidity, early recovery and no risk of disease transmission which has been a significant breakthrough for anatomical ligament reconstruction. Growing studies suggested that the special design of the LARS ligament with open fibers in its intra-articular part was believed to be more resistant to torsional fatigue and wearing. However, the safety and efficacy of LARS artificial ligament for ankle joint lateral collateral ankle ligament reconstruction has not been defined to date.

AIM

To evaluate the clinical results of all-arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction of ankle joint lateral collateral ligaments with the LARS artificial ligament for chronic ankle instability.

METHODS

Twenty-two patients with chronic lateral instability underwent anatomical reconstruction of the lateral collateral ligaments of ankle with LARS artificial ligament. The visual analogue score (VAS), American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society score (AOFAS score) and Karlsson score were used to evaluate the clinical results before and after surgery.

RESULTS

A total of 22 patients (22 ankles) were followed up for a mean of 12 mo. All patients reported significant improvement compared to their preoperative status. The mean AOFAS score improved from 42.3 ± 4.9 preoperatively to 90.4 ± 6.7 postoperatively. The mean Karlsson score improved from 38.5 ± 3.2 preoperatively to 90.1 ± 7.8 postoperatively. The mean VAS score improved from 1.9 ± 2.5 preoperatively to 0.8 ± 1.7 postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

All-arthroscopic anatomical reconstruction of the lateral collateral ligaments with LARS artificial ligament achieved a satisfactory surgical outcome for chronic ankle instability.

The L-shaped tunnel technique showed favourable outcomes similar to those of the Y-graft technique in anatomic lateral ankle ligament reconstruction

PURPOSE

To compare the mid- to long-term clinical and radiological outcomes of the confluent L-shaped tunnel technique with the Y-graft technique for anatomic lateral ankle ligament reconstruction.

METHODS

This retrospective study involved 41 patients who underwent lateral ankle ligament reconstruction between 2013 and 2018. Based on the tunnel direction and tendon fixation method at the fibula side, patients were divided into two groups, with 17 patients in the L-shaped tunnel group and 24 patients in the Y-graft group. The American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, visual analogue scale (VAS) pain score, Tegner score, and Karlsson score were evaluated and compared preoperatively and at follow-up. Anterior talar translation and talar tilt at stress radiographs, postoperative sprain recurrence, range of motion (ROM) restriction, sensory disturbance, etc., were also collected and compared.

RESULTS

The mean follow-up times were 72 and 42 months for the L-shaped group and Y-graft group, respectively. The median VAS pain score, Tegner score, AOFAS score, Karlsson score significantly improved from a preoperative level in both groups (all with p < 0.01). No significant difference was found between the two groups regarding the changes from preoperatively to postoperatively except for the VAS pain score reduction (1.58 ± 1.58 in the L-shaped group vs. 2.53 ± 1.29 in the Y-graft group, p = 0.035). The incidence of flexion-extension ROM restriction (≥ 5°) was significantly higher in the Y-graft group (41.2%) than in the L-shaped group (12.5%) (p = 0.035).

CONCLUSIONS

Both the confluent L-shaped tunnel technique and the Y-graft technique significantly improved symptoms, ankle function, and radiographic outcomes in patients with chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI) at mid- to long-term follow-up. The confluent L-shaped tunnel technique resulted in lower rates of flexion-extension ROM restriction, while the Y-graft technique showed better VAS pain reduction. This result could provide further evidence for the surgical treatment of CLAI.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

The French Ankle Ligament Reconstruction - Return to Sport after Injury (ALR-RSI-Fr) is a valid scale for the French population

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to translate, adapt and validate in French the Ankle Ligament Reconstruction - Return to Sport after Injury (ALR-RSI), a 12-item English language scale assessing the psychological impact of returning to sports after ACL reconstruction. Our hypothesis was that the French version of the ALR-RSI scale would be valid and adaptable to the French population.

METHODS

The procedure followed the guidelines for the intercultural adaptation of the self-administered questionnaires. A version of the ALR-RSI-Fr questionnaire was validated according to the international guidelines of COSMIN (COnsensus-based Standards for the selection of health status Measurement INstruments). A prospective study was conducted between March 2020 and June 2021. The study included two population groups, the first one being that of adult athletes of all levels who underwent arthroscopic ankle ligament reconstruction and the second being that of adult athletes who did not suffer from any ankle problems. After consent, patients completed three questionnaires, the ALR-RSI-Fr, the AOFAS and the Karlsson score.

RESULTS

The study included 30 patients and 30 controls who were all athletes. The mean age of the patients was 34.6 with 60% male and 40% female. The average time for patients to return to sport was 5.6 months. Twenty-nine patients (96.6%) underwent arthroscopic ankle reconstruction while only one was eligible for ligament reinsertion. The control group with demographic data matched to the patient group was included in this study. Correlations between ALRSI, the total Karlsson score and its different sub items and the AOFAS were estimated using Spearman coefficients. Discriminant validity was tested between the "patient" and "control" groups and sub-groups using the Wilcoxon tests. Reliability was evaluated on the ρ intraclass correlation coefficient (ICCC). A strong correlation was noted between the ALR-RSI-Fr , Karlsson and AOFAS with a Spearman score of 0.90 [0.76-0.96].A highly significant difference was found between the "patient" and "control" groups. The internal consistency of the questionnaire was excellent with a Cronbach's alfa of 0.94. Reproducibility was "excellent" with an interclass correlation coefficient of q = 0.97 [0.94-0.99].

CONCLUSION

This study showed that the cross-cultural adaptation of the English version of the ALR-RSI was successful and validated for the French-speaking population. The discriminant capacity of the scale between patients who underwent reconstruction and healthy subjects was also confirmed. This questionnaire will allow surgeons to better evaluate the psychological impact of returning to sports after ankle ligament reconstruction in French speaking patients LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: LEVEL II: Prospective cohort study (patients enrolled at different points in their disease) Control arm of randomized trial.

Anatomic reconstruction of lateral ankle ligaments: is there an optimal graft option?

PURPOSE

Different graft options are available for the reconstruction of lateral ankle ligaments to treat chronic ankle instability (CAI), which fall in two categories: allografts and autografts. This study aims to provide an updated comparison of the clinical outcomes after stabilisation procedures using allografts and autografts, to correctly advise the clinician during the choice of the best material to be used for the reconstruction of the lateral ligamentous complex of the ankle.

METHODS

A systematic review was performed to analyse the use of autografts and allografts for anatomic reconstruction of the lateral ligamentous complex of the ankle in CAI patients. The presence of a postoperative assessment through outcome measures with proofs of validation in the CAI population or patient's subjective evaluation on the treatment were necessary for inclusion. The quality of the included studies was assessed through the modified Coleman Methodology Score (mCMS). Relevant clinical outcome data were pooled to provide a synthetic description of the results in different groups or after different procedures.

RESULTS

Twenty-nine studies (autograft: 19; allograft: 9; both procedures: 1) accounting for 930 procedures (autograft: 616; allograft: 314) were included. The average mCMS was 55.9 ± 10.5 points. The Karlsson-Peterson scale was the most frequently reported outcome scale, showing a cumulative average post- to preoperative difference of 31.9 points in the autograft group (n = 379, 33.8 months follow-up) and of 35.7 points in the allograft group (n = 227, 25.8 months follow-up). Patient satisfaction was good or excellent in 92.8% of autograft (n = 333, 65.2 months follow-up) and in 92.3% of allograft procedures (n = 153, 25.0 months follow-up). Return to activity after surgery and recurrence of instability were variably reported across the studies with no clear differences between allograft and autograft highlighted by these outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

The systematic analysis of validated CAI outcome measures and the patient's subjective satisfaction does not support a specific choice between autograft and allograft for the reconstruction of the ankle lateral ligamentous complex in CAI patients. Both types of grafts were associated to a postoperative Karlsson-Peterson score superior to 80 points and to a similar rate of patient's subjective satisfaction.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

Connecting fibers between ATFL's inferior fascicle and CFL transmit tension between both ligaments

PURPOSE

The lateral ligament complex of the ankle has been extensively studied. Recently an anatomical study described a connection between anterior talofibular ligament inferior fascicle (ATFLif) and calcaneofibular ligament (CFL). The applicability and the mechanical role of these connections have not yet been studied and need to be clarified. The purpose of this study is to evaluate the connection between ATFLif and CFL through a dynamic measurement analysis.

METHODS

An anatomical study was performed in 13 fresh-frozen below-the-knee ankle specimens. Each specimen was dissected in a protocolized manner until the lateral ligaments were exposed. A complete injury to both ATFL's fascicles was created in the proximal third of the ligament. A displacement transducer specifically design was inserted in the CFL and in the lateral part of the calcaneus to test its lengthening. A traction of 1 kg weight (9.8 N) was applied to ATFLif while the transducer measured the lengthening that this force created in the CFL.

RESULTS

A total of 13 ankle specimens were carefully dissected. One specimen with signals of a prior traumatic injury of the ATFLif was excluded. A total of 12 specimens were included, 7 females and 5 males with an average age of 74 years (52-88 years). The right ankle was dissected in 6 specimens. ATFL was identified as a two-fascicled ligament in all cases. The fibers connecting the ATFLif and CFL were observed in all specimens. The displacement transducer showed lengthening in the CFL in all measurements with a median of 0.59 mm (SD ± 0.34).

CONCLUSION

Connecting fibers between ATFLif and CFL are robust enough to transmit tension from one structure to the other. In the case of associated proximal lesions of the ATFLif and CFL, ligaments repair with a single suture may be considered. This can be applied in surgical procedures in patients with lateral ankle instability.

A calcaneal tunnel for CFL reconstruction should be directed to the posterior inferior medial edge of the calcaneal tuberosity

PURPOSE

Anatomical reconstruction of the calcaneofibular ligament (CFL) is a common technique to treat chronic lateral ankle instability. A bone tunnel is used to fix the graft in the calcaneus. The purpose of this study is to provide some recommendations about tunnel entrance and tunnel direction based on anatomical landmarks.

METHODS

The study consisted of two parts. The first part assessed the lateral tunnel entrance for location and safety. The second part addressed the tunnel direction and safety upon exiting the calcaneum on the medial side. In the first part, 29 specimens were used to locate the anatomical insertion of the CFL based on the intersection of two lines related to the fibular axis and specific landmarks on the lateral malleolus. In the second part, 22 specimens were dissected to determine the position of the neurovascular structures at risk during tunnel drilling. Therefore, a method based on four imaginary squares using external anatomical landmarks was developed.

RESULTS

For the tunnel entrance on the lateral side, the mean distance to the centre of the CFL footprint was 2.8 ± 3.0 mm (0-10.4 mm). The mean distance between both observers was 4.2 ± 3.2 mm (0-10.3 mm). The mean distance to the sural nerve was 1.4 ± 2 mm (0-5.8 mm). The mean distance to the peroneal tendons was 7.3 ± 3.1 mm (1.2-12.4 mm). For the tunnel exit on the medial side, the two anterior squares always contained the neurovascular bundle. A safe zone without important neurovascular structures was found and corresponded to the two posterior squares.

CONCLUSION

Lateral landmarks enabled to locate the CFL footprint. Precautions should be taken to protect the nearby sural nerve. A safe zone on the medial side could be determined to guide safe tunnel direction. A calcaneal tunnel should be directed to the posterior inferior medial edge of the calcaneal tuberosity.

Modified Broström repair with suture tape augmentation for lateral ankle instability: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

There is increasing interest in augmentation of modified Broström repairs for lateral ankle instability with a prosthetic reconstruction using suture tape internal bracing. The aim of this study was to investigate if suture tape augmentation resulted in improved clinical and radiological outcomes compared to a standard modified Broström repair alone.

METHODS

A systematic review following PRISMA guidelines was undertaken. All clinical studies published in Medline, Embase, Pubmed and the Cochrane Library Database from inception until January 2020 reporting on the use of suture tape augmentation to a modified Broström repair for lateral ankle instability.

RESULTS

78 studies were identified of which 10 (assessing 333 patients) met the criteria for inclusion. Mean follow up was 24.8 months (range 6-52 months). All studies showed a statistically significant improvement across multiple clinical outcome measures post-surgery in both suture tape augmentation and modified Broström groups, however there were no statistically significant inter-group differences. Pooled results suggested there may be a reduction in recurrence of instability with suture tape augmentation when compared to modified Broström repair alone (p < 0.05). Overall quality of evidence was moderate to poor with limited data to support use of suture tape augmentation.

CONCLUSION

Clinical and radiographic outcomes using a suture tape internal bracing for lateral ankle instability are excellent, and are equivalent to standard treatment across multiple clinical and radiographic assessment measures. There is minimal evidence to suggest functional outcomes are better, or recurrence rates are lower than modified Broström repair alone.

PROSPERO REGISTRY

CRD42020169876.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

II.

All-inside endoscopic anatomic reconstruction leads to satisfactory functional outcomes in patients with chronic ankle instability

PURPOSE

Ankle sprain is a common injury that can be treated conservatively, though many injured patients do not seek treatment or are not adequately managed, both of which can lead to subsequent chronic ankle instability (CAI). The purpose of this study was to evaluate the functional scores and complication rates of an all-inside anatomic reconstruction technique to treat CAI at a minimum follow-up of 24 months.

METHODS

The authors retrospectively collected the records of 41 patients that underwent all-inside endoscopic anatomic reconstruction of the ATFL and CFL including demographics, complications, satisfaction, American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Karlsson score, and ankle activity score (AAS), at a minimum follow-up of 24 months.

RESULTS

The study cohort, comprised 34 patients aged 35.6 ± 10.8 years, were assessed at 48.7 ± 19.0 months. AOFAS scores improved from 60.3 ± 11.9 to 94.3 ± 6.2 postoperatively. Karlsson scores improved from 49.0 ± 10.9 to 87.2 ± 10.1 postoperatively. Thirty-three (97%) patients returned to the same AAS (5.6 ± 3.1) and rated their overall satisfaction ≥ 7. One patient (3%) was reoperated to treat a hematoma, while five patients (15%) were reoperated to remove the cortical fixation device that caused discomfort.

CONCLUSION

The novel all-inside endoscopic technique for anatomic reconstruction of the ATFL and CFL grants satisfactory functional outcomes at a minimum of 24 months, and the improvements in AOFAS and Karlsson scores compared favourably to those reported for other techniques in the literature.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Effectiveness of Hospital-Based Systemic Rehabilitation in Improving Ankle Function after Surgery in Chronic Ankle Instability Patients

We investigated the therapeutic effect of a postoperative hospital-based systemic rehabilitation protocol on ankle function in chronic ankle instability (CAI) patients. Thirty-five patients who underwent a modified Broström procedure for CAI were recruited in this prospective randomized controlled trial. Fifty-minute sessions of hospital-based rehabilitation were performed three times weekly for 12 weeks in the intervention group. Education-based rehabilitation was conducted at home in the control group. The outcomes were evaluated at baseline (T0), 12 weeks (T1), and 16 weeks (T2). The primary outcome was the foot and ankle outcome score (FAOS). Ankle motor strength and spatiotemporal gait metrics were assessed as secondary outcomes. There were significant time and group interaction effects on the pain, symptoms, activities of daily living, sports activities, and quality of life (QOL) domains of the FAOS (P < 0.05, all). The patients in the intervention group showed larger improvements in all domains of the FAOS than did the control group at both T1 and T2 (P < 0.05, all). The time and group interaction effects on invertor and evertor strength were also significant (P = 0.047 and P = 0.044). Invertor and evertor strength improved significantly more in the intervention group than in the control group at T1 and T2 (P < 0.05, all). The preferred walking velocity, cadence, step length on the affected side, and double stance phase duration tended to improve over time. Postoperative hospital-based rehabilitation helped improve CAI pain, symptoms, independence in activities of daily living, sports activity levels, and QOL more effectively than did conventional rehabilitation at home.

Arthroscopic Remnant-Preserving Anterior Talofibular Ligament Reconstruction does not Improve Mid-term Function in Chronic Ankle Instability

BACKGROUND

Anterior talofibular ligament (ATFL) reconstruction is routinely undertaken to manage chronic lateral ankle instability (CLAI). This study evaluated the effects on clinical outcome of preserving or not preserving the ATFL remnant when reconstructing the ATFL.

METHODS

From January 2015 to July 2017, 53 CLAI patients with ATFL injury were randomized to undergo either a remnant-preserving (preservation of ATFL) or a non-preserving (no preservation of ATFL) anatomic reconstruction of the ATFL using an ipsilateral free semitendinosus tendon autograft. The Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) score, the American Orthopedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) score, Karlsson Ankle Functional Score (KAFS), Anterior Talar Translation (ATT), and ankle proprioceptive recovery in both groups were compared.

RESULTS

All patients were followed up for at least 2 years, VAS, AOFAS, KAFS, ATT and ankle proprioception between two the groups were not statistically significant different.

CONCLUSION

There are no differences at 2.5 years in postoperative ankle function, stability and proprioceptive recovery when an ipsilateral free semitendinosus tendon autograft is used to manage CLAI regardless of preservation of the remnant ATFL.