The cleft sign may be an independent factor of magnetic resonance imaging findings associated with a delayed return-to-play time in athletes with groin pain

Cleft Sign in MRI May Represent the Disruption of Cartilage Structure within Pubic Symphysis and Pubic Plate: A Cadaver Case Report

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVES

Long-standing groin pain is a severe issue for athletes, often associated with the cleft sign on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) scans, yet its underlying causes are poorly understood. The purpose of this study is to histologically examine the pubic plate structure in cadavers with and without the cleft sign on MRI, shedding light on the pathology behind the cleft sign.

METHODS

Three fresh human pelvic cadavers underwent 3.0T MRI to detect the cleft sign before histological dissection of pubic plates. Pubic plate tissues were fixed in formalin, decalcified, and processed. Of the two cleft sign-negative specimens, one was cut into sagittal sections, and the other was cut into coronal sections for histology. For the cleft sign positive specimen, a sagittal section was cut. Moreover, 5 µm thick sections were cut at different axial levels for each orientation. Sections were subjected to Safranin O, Alcian blue, and Herovici's staining or hematoxylin and eosin staining.

RESULTS

MRI confirmed that one specimen had a cleft sign in the inferior region on both sides of the pubis and that two specimens had no cleft sign. Both sagittal and coronal sections showed the presence of a cartilage structure continuing from the pubic symphysis to 3 mm laterally within the pubic plate. In the specimen with a positive cleft sign, cartilage damage within the pubic symphysis and pubic plate was identified as revealed by Safranin O staining, Herovici's staining, and H&E staining.

CONCLUSIONS

This study elucidated the existence of a cartilage component extending from the pubic symphysis to the pubic plate. The cleft sign in MRI correlated with a disruption in the cartilage component in histology within this specific area.

Groin pain in soccer players: anatomy, clinical presentation, biomechanics, pathology and imaging findings

Groin pain is extremely common in soccer players, especially male soccer players, with nearly a third experiencing groin pain over the course of their careers. Despite its high prevalence, there continues to be some confusion and controversy regarding the detailed anatomy and recommended terminology related to groin pain in athletes. This article will review the anatomy, clinical presentation, biomechanics, pathology and imaging findings most commonly associated with groin pain in soccer players.

Significant relationship between musculoaponeurotic attachment of the abdominal and thigh adductor muscles to the pubis: implications for the diagnosis of groin pain

Groin pain is prevalent in orthopedic and sports medicine, causing reduced mobility and limiting sports activity. To effectively manage groin pain, understanding the detailed anatomy of supporting muscles is crucial. This study aimed to investigate the musculoaponeurotic attachments on the pubis and the relationship among intramuscular aponeuroses of abdominal and thigh adductor musculatures. Macroscopic analyses were performed in 10 pelvic halves. The bone morphology of the pubis was assessed in two pelvic halves using microcomputed tomography. Histological investigations were conducted in two pelvic halves. The external oblique aponeurosis extended to the adductor longus aponeurosis, forming conjoined aponeurosis, which attached to a small impression distal to the pubic crest. The gracilis aponeurosis merges with the adductor brevis aponeurosis and is attached to the proximal part of the inferior pubic ramus. The rectus abdominis and pyramidalis aponeuroses were attached to the pubic crest and intermingled with the gracilis-adductor brevis aponeurosis, forming bilateral conjoined aponeurosis, which attached to a broad area covering the anteroinferior surface of the pubis. Histologically, these two areas of conjoined aponeuroses were attached to the pubis via the fibrocartilage enthesis. Microcomputed tomography revealed two distinctive bone morphologies, a small impression and an elongated osseous prominence on pubis, corresponded to the two areas of conjoined aponeuroses. This study demonstrated close relationships between the aponeurotic attachment of the external oblique and adductor longus, and between the rectus abdominis, pyramidalis, gracilis, and adductor brevis. The findings of aponeurotic complexes would aid in diagnostic and surgical approaches for athletic groin pain.

MRI findings in athletic groin pain: correlation of imaging with history and examination in symptomatic and asymptomatic athletes

OBJECTIVE

To determine differences in prevalence and diagnostic accuracy of MRI findings between asymptomatic athletes and athletes with longstanding groin pain.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred twenty-three adult male athletes were approached with 85 consecutive athletes recruited. Group 1 (symptomatic, n = 34) athletes referred for longstanding groin pain (insidious onset, > 3 weeks duration). Group 2 (control, n = 51) athletes referred for injuries remote from the pelvis and no groin pain in the last 12 weeks. All referrers completed a clinical examination proforma documenting absence or presence of pelvis and hip abnormality. All patients completed the Copenhagen Hip and Groin Outcome Score (HAGOS) questionnaire and underwent a 3T MRI groin and hip protocol. MRIs were scored independently by two musculoskeletal radiologists blinded to clinical details. Statistical analysis was performed to evaluate associations between MRI findings, inter-reader reliability, clinical examination and HAGOS scores.

RESULTS

Pubic body subchondral bone oedema, capsule/aponeurosis junction tear and soft tissue oedema were more prevalent in the symptomatic group (p = 0.0003, 0.0273 and 0.0005, respectively) and in athletes with clinical abnormality at symphysis pubis, adductor insertion, rectus abdominis, psoas and inguinal canal (p = 0.0002, 0.0459 and 0.00002, respectively). Pubic body and subchondral oedema and capsule/aponeurosis tear and oedema significantly correlated with lower (worse) HAGOS scores (p = 0.004, 0.00009, 0.0004 and 0.002, respectively). Inter-reader reliability was excellent, 0.87 (range 0.58-1). Symphyseal bone spurring, disc protrusion and labral tears were highly prevalent in both groups.

CONCLUSION

Clinical assessment and MRI findings of pubic subchondral bone oedema and capsule/aponeurosis abnormality appear to be the strongest correlators with longstanding groin pain.

Comparison between dedicated MRI and symphyseal fluoroscopic guided contrast agent injection in the diagnosis of cleft sign in athletic groin pain and association with pelvic ring instability

OBJECTIVE

To compare dedicated MRI with targeted fluoroscopic guided symphyseal contrast agent injection regarding the assessment of symphyseal cleft signs in men with athletic groin pain and assessment of radiographic pelvic ring instability.

METHODS

Sixty-six athletic men were prospectively included after an initial clinical examination by an experienced surgeon using a standardized procedure. Diagnostic fluoroscopic symphyseal injection of a contrast agent was performed. Additionally, standing single-leg stance radiography and dedicated 3-Tesla MRI protocol were employed. The presence of cleft injuries (superior, secondary, combined, atypical) and osteitis pubis was recorded.

RESULTS

Symphyseal bone marrow edema (BME) was present in 50 patients, bilaterally in 41 patients and in 28 with an asymmetrical distribution. Comparison of MRI and symphysography was as followed: no clefts: 14 cases (MRI) vs. 24 cases (symphysography), isolated superior cleft sign: 13 vs. 10, isolated secondary cleft sign: 15 vs. 21 cases and combined injuries: 18 vs. 11 cases. In 7 cases a combined cleft sign was observed in MRI but only an isolated secondary cleft sign was visible in symphysography. Anterior pelvic ring instability was observed in 25 patients and was linked to a cleft sign in 23 cases (7 superior cleft sign, 8 secondary cleft signs, 6 combined clefts, 2 atypical cleft injuries). Additional BME could be diagnosed in 18 of those 23.

CONCLUSION

Dedicated 3-Tesla MRI outmatches symphysography for purely diagnostic purposes of cleft injuries. Microtearing at the prepubic aponeurotic complex and the presence of BME is a prerequisite for the development of anterior pelvic ring instability.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT

For diagnostic of symphyseal cleft injuries dedicated 3-T MRI protocols outmatch fluoroscopic symphysography. Prior specific clinical examination is highly beneficial and additional flamingo view x-rays are recommended for assessment of pelvic ring instability in these patients.

KEY POINTS

• Assessment of symphyseal cleft injuries is more accurate by use of dedicated MRI as compared to fluoroscopic symphysography. • Additional fluoroscopy may be important for therapeutic injections. • The presence of cleft injury might be a prerequisite for the development of pelvic ring instability.

Pain provocation tests and clinical entities in male football players with longstanding groin pain are associated with pain intensity and disability

BACKGROUND

Clinical examination of male football players with longstanding groin pain can be considered difficult. Pain provocation tests are used to examine and classify longstanding groin pain into clinical entities as adductor-, iliopsoas-, inguinal-, and pubic-related. It is unknown if pain provocation tests and clinical entities are associated with pain intensity and disability.

OBJECTIVES

To investigate if the number of positive pain provocation tests and clinical entities are associated with pain intensity and disability, measured by the Copenhagen 5-Second Squeeze Test (5SST) and the Copenhagen Hip and Groin Outcome Score (HAGOS), respectively.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional.

METHOD

Forty male football players (age: mean 24 years [SD: 3.2]; height: mean 182 cm [SD: 5.7]; weight: mean 78 Kg [SD: 6.6]) with longstanding groin pain for a median of 8.5 months (IQR: 4-36) were included. The players underwent a bilateral groin examination with 33 pain provocation tests and were classified with clinical entities (0-7) based on the test findings.

RESULTS

The number of positive pain provocation tests (median 10, range 2-23) correlated with pain intensity (5SST: rs = 0.70 [95% CI: 0.50, 0.83]) and disability (HAGOS subscales Sport: rs =-0.62 [95% CI: -0.81, -0.36], Pain: rs = -0.38 [95% CI: -0.69, -0.06], Symptoms: rs = 0.52 [95% CI: -0.73, -0.24], ADL: rs = -0.48 [95% CI: -0.71, -0.18]). The number of clinical entities (median 3, range: 1-7) showed similar but weaker correlations to pain intensity and disability.

CONCLUSIONS

In male football players with longstanding groin pain, the number of positive pain provocation tests and clinical entities shows weak to strong correlations with pain intensity and disability. Consequently, when pain intensity and disability are severe, a higher number of pain provocation tests may be positive, and more clinical entities may be present.

Soccer players show the highest seasonal groin pain prevalence and the longest time loss from sport among 500 athletes from major team sports

PURPOSE

Groin pain is a widely recognized medical issue among athletes. Groin pain can affect both player and team performance and sometimes can be a career-ending injury. The aim of this study was to assess seasonal groin pain prevalence and the average seasonal time loss from sport for each injury in different team sport athletes. The hip and groin functionality at the beginning of the following season was also investigated.

METHODS

A cross-sectional study was undertaken on 600 team sport athletes (soccer, futsal, basketball, volleyball, and water polo players). The seasonal prevalence of groin pain, level of competition (professional and non-professional), time loss, and concomitant injuries in addition to groin pain were reported and analyzed. The Copenhagen Hip and Groin Outcome Score (HAGOS) was used to assess hip and groin pain and function related to sport and activity.

RESULTS

Among the 506 (84%) players included, 123 players (24.3%) reported groin pain. Overall, soccer players reported the highest groin pain prevalence (32.5%) followed by futsal (25.5%), basketball (25.2%), water polo (17.6%) and volleyball players (13.6%). Professional soccer, futsal and basketball athletes showed higher groin pain prevalence in comparison with non-professional athletes (p = 0.02, p = 0.005 and p = 0.004, respectively). The mean time loss from sport due to groin pain was 60.3 ± 66 days in soccer, 41.1 ± 16.6 days in futsal, 31.5 ± 18 days in water polo, 37.2 ± 14.2 days in basketball and 50.8 ± 24.6 days in volleyball. Significantly lower HAGOS values were found in athletes with groin pain for all sports evaluated compared to athletes with no groin pain history (p =  0.0001). Longer time loss from sport was correlated with lower HAGOS values in soccer (p = 0.002) and futsal (p = 0.002) players with groin pain. Concomitant injuries were correlated with lower HAGOS values in water polo players (p = 0.03).

CONCLUSIONS

Seasonal groin pain occurs in as many as one in four team sport athletes. Soccer players show the highest groin pain prevalence and the longest time loss from sport. Professional athletes report higher prevalence of groin pain in comparison with non-professional athletes. HAGOS appears to be a valid outcome instrument to measure groin pain, correlating with both time loss from sport and concomitant injuries in athletes.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV.

Cleft Sign and Bone Marrow Edema of the Pubic Symphysis Are Associated With Sports and Bony Morphology in Patients With Femoroacetabular Impingement and Labral Tears

Background:

The cleft sign (CS) and bone marrow edema (BME) are considered magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings signifying a pubic pathology, which is associated with groin pain; however, their relationship with bony morphology related to femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) has not been established.

Purpose:

To investigate the prevalence of CS and BME in symptomatic patients with acetabular labral tears and assess their possible association with bone morphology and sport-specific activities.

Study Design:

Cross-sectional study; Level of evidence, 3.

Methods:

This study enrolled 418 patients (469 hips) undergoing hip arthroscopic surgery for labral tears. Also included were patients with labral tears in the setting of either hip dysplasia or borderline hip dysplasia who were undergoing endoscopic shelf acetabuloplasty combined with hip arthroscopic labral repair, cam osteoplasty, and capsular plication. All patients were screened for superior CS (SCS), inferior CS (ICS), and BME of the ipsilateral side of the pubis using 3-T MRI. We measured the following angles: lateral center edge (LCE), Sharp, Tönnis, vertical-central-anterior, and alpha. Then, we evaluated the relationship between patient characteristics and abnormal findings on MRI scans (preoperatively vs 1 year postoperatively).

Results:

An overall 397 hips were included: 200 in men and 197 in women (mean ± SD age, 35.3 ± 16.0 years). There were hips in 214 athletes (53.9%) and hips in 183 nonathletes (46.1%). MRI findings revealed SCS, ICS, and BME in 18 (4.5%), 13 (3.3%), and 34 hips (8.6%), respectively. Abnormal MRI findings at the pubis were seen more often in athletes than nonathletes (23.8% vs 3.3%), and contact sports athletes had the most frequent abnormalities. There was no SCS in patients with an LCE angle <22°. SCS was more frequently seen in those who had an alpha angle ≥71°. More than 60% of abnormal findings at the pubis diminished after arthroscopic surgery that included FAI correction and labral repair.

Conclusion:

In patients with labral tears, CS and BME were seen more frequently in athletes versus nonathletes, especially contact athletes with FAI-related bony abnormalities. More than 60% of abnormal MRI pubis findings resolved after arthroscopic treatment of FAI.