Development of an assay for label-free high-throughput screening of thrombin inhibitors by use of reflectometric interference spectroscopy

Label-Free Immunoassay Using Droplet-Based Brewster's Angle Straddle Interferometry

We report the detection of antigen capture by immobilized antibodies using a simple, label-free version of monochromatic reflective interferometry. The technique is implemented on silicon with its native oxide and relies on choosing an incident angle between the Brewster angles for the air/oxide and oxide/silicon interfaces. We demonstrate sensitivity to anti-human and anti-rabbit immunoglobulin (anti-IgG) concentrations less than 100 nM using only 10 nL droplets of the analyte. We have introduced a protocol using a model sugar to reduce nonspecific binding and have been able to detect anti-IgG even in the presence of 100-fold larger concentrations of bovine serum albumin. The limit of detection is not yet associated with the optical method but is imposed by nonspecific binding. Evaluated in terms of pg/mm², our sensors are comparable in sensitivity to surface plasmon resonance (SPR) but are advantaged with respect to SPR in the tolerance of the optical components and alignment, the low material usage, and the ability to exploit multiplex detection without modification. The simplicity and convenience of the method are promising for eventual application to portable diagnostic applications.

Critical assessment of relevant methods in the field of biosensors with direct optical detection based on fibers and waveguides using plasmonic, resonance, and interference effects

Direct optical detection has proven to be a highly interesting tool in biomolecular interaction analysis to be used in drug discovery, ligand/receptor interactions, environmental analysis, clinical diagnostics, screening of large data volumes in immunology, cancer therapy, or personalized medicine. In this review, the fundamental optical principles and applications are reviewed. Devices are based on concepts such as refractometry, evanescent field, waveguides modes, reflectometry, resonance and/or interference. They are realized in ring resonators; prism couplers; surface plasmon resonance; resonant mirror; Bragg grating; grating couplers; photonic crystals, Mach-Zehnder, Young, Hartman interferometers; backscattering; ellipsometry; or reflectance interferometry. The physical theories of various optical principles have already been reviewed in detail elsewhere and are therefore only cited. This review provides an overall survey on the application of these methods in direct optical biosensing. The "historical" development of the main principles is given to understand the various, and sometimes only slightly modified variations published as "new" methods or the use of a new acronym and commercialization by different companies. Improvement of optics is only one way to increase the quality of biosensors. Additional essential aspects are the surface modification of transducers, immobilization strategies, selection of recognition elements, the influence of non-specific interaction, selectivity, and sensitivity. Furthermore, papers use for reporting minimal amounts of detectable analyte terms such as value of mass, moles, grams, or mol/L which are difficult to compare. Both these essential aspects (i.e., biochemistry and the presentation of LOD values) can be discussed only in brief (but references are provided) in order to prevent the paper from becoming too long. The review will concentrate on a comparison of the optical methods, their application, and the resulting bioanalytical quality.

Reflectometric interference spectroscopy-based sensing for evaluating biodegradability of polymeric thin films

Enzymatic degradation of poly(ε-caprolactone) (PCL) thin films was analyzed by reflectometric interference spectroscopy (RIfS)-based sensing system, and validated by attenuated total reflection infrared spectroscopy (ATR-IR) imaging. The degradation of the PCL thin film spin-coated on the silicon substrate on which 65-nm silicon nitride layer was deposited as an interference layer was easily monitored by shifting the peak bottom of reflectance spectra (Δλ) that is known to be proportional to the thickness of thin films. The Δλ values decreased with increasing the concentration of lipase from Pseudomonas cepacia, and the obtained sensorgrams were applied for kinetic analysis using a curve fitting software. ATR-IR spectra and imaging analysis on the surface of the PCL film revealed that carbonyl groups on the surface decreased with time, resulting from proceeding with the enzymatic hydrolysis, and importantly, extinction of the carbonyl group was declined with proportional to the decrease in the film thickness measured by the RIfS system. Consequently, the present RIfS-based label-free monitoring system can provide a simple and reliable way for evaluating biodegradability on synthetic materials.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

A RIfS-based sensing system in combination with ATR-IR measurements can be an analytical method for evaluation of biodegradability of polymeric thin films. This study demonstrates the utility of the RIfS-based sensing approach for analyzing the lipase-catalyzed degradation of PCL. Despite the RIfS is known as an inexpensive label-free detection method for biological interaction, the RIfS applications as monitoring methods for enzymatic degradation of biodegradable polymers had not been systematically explored. This study additionally demonstrated the capability of combined analysis of the biodegradation with ATR-IR spectra/imaging and RIfS measurements, which could be broadly applied towards evaluating biodegradability of various biodegradable polymers in environmental protection research.

Combined microslit electrokinetic measurements and reflectometric interference spectroscopy to study protein adsorption processes

Streaming potential/current measurements for the characterization of charge formation processes at solid/liquid interfaces were combined with reflectometric interference spectroscopy. The simultaneous determination of electrosurface characteristics and the optical thickness of interfacial layers provides information on structural variations of adsorbed or covalently bound polymers and on charge dependent adsorption and desorption phenomena at solid/liquid interfaces. To demonstrate the potentialities of this extended approach for biointerfacial studies the authors report a series of experiments on the adsorption of the plasma protein fibrinogen at poly(octadecene-alt-maleic acid) thin films.

A sensitive multilayered structure suitable for biosensing on the BioDVD platform

Several technologies are currently available for the analysis of biomolecular interactions with high sensitivity and efficiency. However, these instruments are invariably expensive and, thus, are not suitable for bedside analyses. To circumvent this issue, we have previously reported a BioDVD platform that allowed us to use a DVD mechanism to monitor various biomolecular interactions [Gopinath et al., 2008, ACS Nano 2, 1885-1895]. In the present study, to improve the sensitivity of the BioDVD platform for various analyses, we have performed computer simulations to optimize the ZnS-SiO(2) layer thicknesses and determined an optimized optical interferometric response after adjusting the ZnS-SiO(2) layer thickness to 65 and 60 nm for the inner and outer layer thicknesses, respectively. Biomolecular interaction analyses performed with the optimized BioDVD disks revealed a 3-fold improvement in the sensitivity, compared to our previously reported multilayered structure. In this study, we have also shown that the BioDVD platform is suitable not only for analyzing nucleic acid hybridization and interactions between RNA-small ligands and RNA-proteins, but also for antigen-antibody interactions. Furthermore, our evaluations revealed that each sample required no more than 10 tracks of data to analyze the biomolecular interactions on the BioDVD platform, which permits a greater number of spots per BioDVD disk and also reduces the time needed to measure the biomolecular interactions.

Label-free technologies for quantitative multiparameter biological analysis

In the postgenomic era, information is king and information-rich technologies are critically important drivers in both fundamental biology and medicine. It is now known that single-parameter measurements provide only limited detail and that quantitation of multiple biomolecular signatures can more fully illuminate complex biological function. Label-free technologies have recently attracted significant interest for sensitive and quantitative multiparameter analysis of biological systems. There are several different classes of label-free sensors that are currently being developed both in academia and in industry. In this critical review, we highlight, compare, and contrast some of the more promising approaches. We describe the fundamental principles of these different methods and discuss advantages and disadvantages that might potentially help one in selecting the appropriate technology for a given bioanalytical application.

Phase sensitive interferometry for biosensing applications

A simple yet highly sensitive implementation of an interferometric technique for a label-free molecular biosensing application is described. The intereferometric detection method is based on the phase-sensitive detection of spectral interference fringes. The change in optical path length due to binding of biomolecules on functionalized optically clear substrates can be quantified by detecting the change in the phase of the spectral fringes. The common path interferometeric design permits measurement of sub-monolayer binding of biomolecules to the sensor surfaces.

Monitoring biomolecular interactions on a digital versatile disk: a BioDVD platform technology

A spinning-disk biosensor utilizing optical interference of reflected light from a multilayered structure, consisting of dielectric, metal, and optical phase-change thin films, is shown to have the potential to monitor various interactions on its surface. We refer to this platform as a BioDVD, since it utilizes the optical system of a digital versatile disk (DVD) to measure changes in reflected light intensity. Here, we demonstrated that nucleic acid hybridization and RNA-protein interactions can be analyzed efficiently, in a label-free environment, by measuring the reflected light intensity using a DVD-like mechanism. Moreover, our studies revealed that the detection sensitivity for the interactions on the BioDVD can be altered by shifting the state of the phase-change materials, where the amorphous state can be used for analysis and another state (crystalline) can be used both for recording information and selectively masking areas of the disk.

Strategies for label-free optical detection

A large number of methods using direct detection with label-free systems are known. They compete with the well-introduced fluorescence-based methods. However, recent applications take advantage of label-free detection in protein-protein interactions, high-throughput screening, and high-content screening. These new applications require new strategies for biosensors. It becomes more and more obvious that neither the transduction principle nor the recognition elements for the biomolecular interaction process alone determine the quality of the biosensor. Accordingly, the biosensor system has to be considered as a whole. This chapter focuses on strategies to optimize the detection platform and the biomolecular recognition layer. It concentrates on direct detection methods, with special focus on optical transduction. Since even this restriction still leaves a large number of methods, only microrefractometric and microreflectometric methods using planar transducers have been selected for a detailed description and a listing of applications. However, since many review articles on the physical principles exist, the description is kept short. Other methods are just mentioned in brief and for comparison. The outlook and the applications demonstrate the future perspectives of direct optical detection in bioanalytics.

Potential of label-free detection in high-content-screening applications

The classical approach of high-content screening (HCS) is based on multiplexed, functional cell-based screening and combines several analytical technologies that have been used before separately to achieve a better level of automation (scale-up) and higher throughput. New HCS methods will help to overcome the bottlenecks, e.g. in the present development chain for lead structures for the pharmaceutical industry or during the identification and validation process of new biomarkers. In addition, there is a strong need in analytical and bioanalytical chemistry for functional high-content assays which can be provided by different hyphenated techniques. This review discusses the potential of a label-free optical biosensor based on reflectometric interference spectroscopy (RIfS) as a bridging technology for different HCS approaches. Technical requirements of RIfS are critically assessed by means of selected applications and compared to the performance characteristics of surface plasmon resonance (SPR) which is currently the leading technology in the area of label-free optical biosensors.

Biomolecular interaction analysis under electrophoretic flow conditions

Combining the advantages of electrophoresis with the advantages of biomolecular interaction analysis (BIA) enables the biospecific detection of separated molecules; for example it permits differentiation between a complementary single-stranded DNA and a single nucleotide polymorphism. In order to integrate these two techniques, it is necessary to investigate whether it is possible to detect a biomolecular interaction under electrophoretic flow conditions. To this end a novel detection system was developed for electrophoresis that utilizes a label-free and time-resolved detection technique: reflectometric interference spectroscopy (RIfS). The biological functions of important analytes were investigated using this system. Although RIfS can be used as a postcolumn detector, it is also possible to use it to detect relevant substances under electrophoretic flow conditions. DNA-LNA, biotin-streptavidin and protein-protein interactions were detected using this coupled electrophoresis-RIfS set-up.

Emerging tools for real-time label-free detection of interactions on functional protein microarrays

The availability of extensive genomic information and content has spawned an era of high-throughput screening that is generating large sets of functional genomic data. In particular, the need to understand the biochemical wiring within a cell has introduced novel approaches to map the intricate networks of biological interactions arising from the interactions of proteins. The current technologies for assaying protein interactions--yeast two-hybrid and immunoprecipitation with mass spectrometric detection--have met with considerable success. However, the parallel use of these approaches has identified only a small fraction of physiologically relevant interactions among proteins, neglecting all nonprotein interactions, such as with metabolites, lipids, DNA and small molecules. This highlights the need for further development of proteome scale technologies that enable the study of protein function. Here we discuss recent advances in high-throughput technologies for displaying proteins on functional protein microarrays and the real-time label-free detection of interactions using probes of the local index of refraction, carbon nanotubes and nanowires, or microelectromechanical systems cantilevers. The combination of these technologies will facilitate the large-scale study of protein interactions with proteins as well as with other biomolecules.

Label-free characterisation of oligonucleotide hybridisation using reflectometric interference spectroscopy

The potential of a label-free detection method, reflectometric interference spectroscopy (RIfS), for temperature-dependent DNA hybridisation experiments (for example in single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) analysis) is investigated. Hybridisations of DNA, peptide nucleic acid (PNA), and locked nucleic acid (LNA) to a single stranded DNA were measured for several temperatures, and the melting curves and temperatures were calculated from the changes in optical thickness obtained. These measurements were performed by hybridising surface-immobilised single stranded oligomers with their complementary ssDNA or with ssDNA containing SNPs at different temperatures. DNA was compared to its analogue oligomers PNA and LNA due to their stability against nuclease. A comparison of melting temperatures demonstrated the higher binding affinities of the DNA analogues. Moreover, a continuous melting curve was obtained by first hybridising the functionalised surface with its complementary DNA at room temperature and then heating up in-flow. Measurement of the continuous melting curve was only possible due to the insensitivity of the RIfS method towards temperature changes. This is an advantage over other label-free detection methods, which are based on determining the refractive index.

Exploring biology with small organic molecules

Small organic molecules have proven to be invaluable tools for investigating biological systems, but there is still much to learn from their use. To discover and to use more effectively new chemical tools to understand biology, strategies are needed that allow us to systematically explore 'biological-activity space'. Such strategies involve analysing both protein binding of, and phenotypic responses to, small organic molecules. The mapping of biological-activity space using small molecules is akin to mapping the stars--uncharted territory is explored using a system of coordinates that describes where each new feature lies.

Direct optical detection of protein-ligand interactions

Direct optical detection provides an excellent means to investigate interactions of molecules in biological systems. The dynamic equilibria inherent to these systems can be described in greater detail by recording the kinetics of a biomolecular interaction. Optical biosensors allow direct detection of interaction patterns without the need for labeling. An overview covering several commercially available biosensors is given, with a focus on instruments based on surface plasmon resonance (SPR) and reflectometric interference spectroscopy (RIFS). Potential assay formats and experimental design, appropriate controls, and calibration procedures, especially when handling low molecular weight substances, are discussed. The single steps of an interaction analysis combined with practical tips for evaluation, data processing, and interpretation of kinetic data are described in detail. In a practical example, a step-by-step procedure for the analysis of a low molecular weight compound interaction with serum protein, determined on a commercial SPR sensor, is presented.

Direct optical sensors: principles and selected applications

In the field of bio and chemosensors a large number of detection principles has been published within the last decade. These detection principles are based either on the observation of fluorescence-labelled systems or on direct optical detection in the heterogeneous phase. Direct optical detection can be measured by remission (absorption of reflected radiation, opt(r)odes), by measuring micro-refractivity, or measuring interference. In the last case either Mach-Zehnder interferometers or measurement of changes in the physical thickness of the layer (measuring micro-reflectivity) caused, e.g., by swelling effects in polymers (due to interaction with analytes) or in bioassays (due to affinity reactions) also play an important role. Here, an overview of methods of microrefractometric and microreflectometric principles is given and benefits and drawbacks of the various approaches are demonstrated using samples from the chemo and biosensor field. The quality of sensors does not just depend on transduction principles but on the total sensor system defined by this transduction, the sensitive layer, data acquisition electronics, and evaluation software. The intention of this article is, therefore, to demonstrate the essentials of the interaction of these parts within the system, and the focus is on optical sensing using planar transducers, because fibre optical sensors have been reviewed in this journal only recently. Lack of selectivity of chemosensors can be compensated either by the use of sensor arrays or by evaluating time-resolved measurements of analyte/sensitive layer interaction. In both cases chemometrics enables the quantification of analyte mixtures. These data-processing methods have also been successfully applied to antibody/antigen interactions even using cross-reactive antibodies. Because miniaturisation and parallelisation are essential approaches in recent years, some aspects and current trends, especially for bio-applications, will be discussed. Miniaturisation is especially well covered in the literature.

Epitope-mapping of transglutaminase with parallel label-free optical detection

The gastrointestinal disorder coeliac disease (CD) is induced by the ingestion of wheat gluten and is characterized by damage of the typical structure of the intestinal mucosa. The enzyme tissue transglutaminase (tTGase) was identified as the major target of disease-specific antibodies in-patients. We performed an epitope fine-mapping with a series of pentadecapeptides synthesized using parallel multiple peptide synthesis. For the detection of biomolecular interactions a label-free parallel method, reflectometric interference spectroscopy (RIfS), was used. This is the first optical label-free method adapted to a high throughput screening (HTS) format and the experimental results demonstrate its applicability as a biological screening device. A high titer of anti-tTGase antibodies is found in the serum of coeliac patients. We have taken the first step towards a fast non-surgical test for the detection of these antibodies. In order to identify and characterize a continuous epitope with high affinity against the anti-tTGase antibody a screening of 21 pentadecapeptides has been accomplished with the parallel RIfS system. A single channel RIfS-system with high resolution was used to determine binding constants of identified peptides with high affinity.