Flavor stability assessment of lager beer: what we can learn by comparing established methods

Characterization of Key Odor-Active Compounds in Draft Beers for the Chinese Market Using Molecular Sensory Science Approaches

Beer is a popular alcoholic beverage worldwide. However, limited research has been conducted on identifying key odor-active components in lager-type draft beers for the Chinese market. Therefore, this study aims to elucidate the odor characteristics of the four most popular draft beer brands through a sensory evaluation and an electronic nose. Subsequently, the four draft beers were analyzed through solid-phase microextraction and liquid-liquid extraction using a two-dimensional comprehensive gas chromatography-olfactometry-mass spectrometry analysis (GC×GC-O-MS). Fifty-five volatile odor compounds were detected through GC×GC-O-MS. Through an Aroma Extract Dilution Analysis, 22 key odor-active compounds with flavor dilution factors ≥ 16 were identified, with 11 compounds having odor activity values > one. An electronic nose analysis revealed significant disparities in the odor characteristics of the four samples, enabling their distinct identification. These findings help us to better understand the flavor characteristics of draft beer and the stylistic differences between different brands of products and provide a theoretical basis for objectively evaluating the quality differences between different brands of draft beer.

Identification of key aroma compounds of faba beans (Vicia faba) and their development during germination - a SENSOMICS approach

Faba beans are a promising source of valuable plant protein. However, their aroma impression is often a hindrance for the use in a broad range of food products. To develop mitigation strategies, a deeper insight into the faba bean aroma is required. Therefore, for the first time, the SENSOMICS concept was applied. First, 52 aroma active compounds in raw and malted faba beans were identified and semi-quantitatively preselected by aroma extract dilution analysis. Afterwards, the aroma compounds were quantified, odor activity values were calculated, and the 17 prominent odors were selected and used in the reconstitution of the faba bean aroma. Seven statistically significant key aroma compounds 3-methylbutanoic acid, (E)-non-2-enal, hexanal, methional, 3-methylbutanal, sotolon, and 2-methylbutan-1-ol were identified in omission experiments. Finally, their development upon malting was studied. To conclude, by knowing the key aroma compounds, specific mitigation strategies can be developed, which facilitates the broader use of faba beans.

Monitoring the Evolution of the Aroma Profile of Lager Beer in Aluminium Cans and Glass Bottles during the Natural Ageing Process by Means of HS-SPME/GC-MS and Multivariate Analysis

Headspace solid-phase microextraction coupled to gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (HS-SPME/GC-MS), sensory evaluation, and multivariate analysis were applied to monitor and compare the evolution of the aromatic profile of a lager beer in different types of containers (aluminum cans and glass bottles) during the natural ageing process. Samples were aged naturally for a year in the absence of light with a controlled temperature of around 14 °C +/- 0.5 °C. The sensory evaluation applied was a blind olfactometric triangle test between canned and bottled samples at different periods of aging: fresh, 6 months, and 11 months. The sensory evaluation showed that the panelists were able to differentiate between samples, except for the fresh samples from the brewery. A total of 34 volatile compounds were identified using the HS-SPME/GC-MS technique for both packaging types in this experiment. The application of multivariate analysis to the GC-MS data showed that the samples could not be differentiated according to the type of packaging but could be differentiated by the ageing time. The results showed that the combination of sensory, HS-SPME-GC-MS, and multivariate analysis seemed to be a valuable tool for monitoring and identifying possible changes in the aroma profile of a beer during its shelf life. Furthermore, the results showed that storing beer under optimal conditions helped preserve its quality during its shelf life, regardless of the type of packaging (aluminum can and glass bottle).

A Comprehensive Evaluation of Flavor Instability of Beer (Part 1): Influence of Release of Bound State Aldehydes

Flavor instability of pale lager beer depends decisively on aroma-active aldehydes from the Maillard reaction, Strecker degradation, and lipid oxidation, which are formed in various oxidative and non-oxidative reactions. Therein, aldehydes can be formed de novo and be released from bound states to a free, aroma-active form during aging. During malting and brewing, proteolysis affects the amount of soluble nitrogen and thus flavor instability in different ways (e.g., precursors for de novo formation and binding agents for bound states). To isolate nitrogen-related aging processes, beers from malts (two barley varieties, three proteolytic malt modifications) were produced on a 50 L scale in part 1 of this study. Sensory analysis revealed increased flavor instability for beers with higher amounts of soluble nitrogen. Especially Strecker aldehydes significantly increased with malt modification. The release of bound state aldehydes revealed most free aldehydes in fresh beers and with higher malt modification. During aging, the equilibrium between free and bound state aldehydes shifted toward the free form. These results reveal a nitrogen-dependent bound pool of aldehydes that is depleted during aging and is responsible for aged aroma, especially in the early and medium stages of aging. Therefore, bound state aldehydes are indicators of the early-stage prediction of flavor instability already in a fresh condition.

Untargeted flavor profiling of lager beers by stir bar sorptive extraction -capillary gas chromatography - time-of-flight mass spectrometry: High analytical performance with a green touch

Beer is one of the most popular beverages in the world and its complex flavor is widely appreciated. Beer flavor profiling is important for brewers to optimize beer production and to guarantee odor quality and taste stability of the final products. This is especially the case for pale lager beers that represent the beer type with the largest worldwide production volume. In this study, the combination of stir bar sorptive extraction (SBSE) with capillary gas chromatography (GC) hyphenated to time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOFMS) was used to perform a detailed aroma profiling of lager beer samples originating from Belgium, The Netherlands, and France. A generic SBSE method was applied resulting in a very broad extraction coverage of odor solutes, while the extraction process is miniaturized, unattended and solventless, meeting green analytical chemistry requirements. Using GC-TOFMS analysis operated in untargeted mode, MS deconvolution and statistical data analysis, with principal component and hierarchical clustering analysis, it was possible to clearly differentiate brands and origins of the beer samples and to identify marker compounds for flavor profiling of these closely related beer samples. An extended database of beer aroma compounds was created. The developed method can be applied in beer quality optimization and quality control in routine laboratories.

Influence of 3-DG as a Key Precursor Compound on Aging of Lager Beers

3-Deoxyglucosone (3-DG) is a Maillard reaction intermediate, which forms known beer aging compounds such as Strecker aldehydes. However, the role of 3-DG in beer aging stability has not been described yet. To investigate the influence of 3-DG toward beer aging stability, different concentrations of 3-DG were added to the freshly brewed beer at the beginning of storage. Analysis of well-known degradation products of 3-DG such as 3-deoxygalactosone (HPLC-UV), 5-hydroxymethylfurfural (HPLC-UV), Strecker aldehydes (GC-MS), and free glycated amino acids (HPLC-MS/MS) during beer aging revealed that a higher initial 3-DG concentration increases the formation of the products. In this study, the significant importance of 3-DG as a key precursor compound in beer aging has been shown, especially the increase of Strecker aldehydes.