The saltation illusion demonstrates integrative processing of spatiotemporal information in thermoceptive and nociceptive networks

Retracing the rabbit's path: Effects of altering the second flash position in the visual saltation illusion

Two dots shown in quick succession at one point and a third at a distance on the same linear path creates an illusion of intervening flashes on a visual field, a phenomenon known as the reduced visual rabbit illusion or visual saltation illusion. This study presents this illusion in a novel way by altering the position of the second flash, which has been typically presented only in the same position as the first flash. A series of experiments were conducted to observe whether saltation would occur if the second flash was presented in the same position as the third flash, out of sequential order relative to the first and last flash, or out of linear alignment at the midpoint between the first and the last flash. When all three flashes were presented in quick succession, participants misperceived the second flash to occur close to the midpoint between the first and last flash. Saltation was achieved in all three novel conditions, hinting a particular neurological process may be responsible for shared outcomes.

Investigation of directional discrimination in the nociceptive system using temperature-controlled laser stimuli

BACKGROUND

Cutaneous laser stimulation has commonly been employed to investigate the thermal properties of the nociceptive system. The aim of this study was to investigate how a temperature-controlled laser system improves the assessment of directional discrimination in the nociceptive system.

METHODS

In total, twenty healthy volunteers participated in this study. To determine the directional discrimination threshold (stimulation length 50% correct, expressed in mm), thermal stimuli were delivered using a diode laser and the laser beam was perpendicularly displaced across the skin to give a linear stimulation in four different directions (distal, proximal, lateral and medial) and displacement lengths (3 for lateral-medial and 5 for distal-proximal). Two temperature control modes were used in the stimulation system, open-loop and closed-loop control. The subjects had to report the perceived stimulus direction, the degree of certainty regarding the perceived direction and the intensity of the perceived stimulus (0-10 numerical rating scale, 3: pain threshold).

RESULTS

During closed-loop control, the orientation of stimuli was discriminated significantly more accurately than during open-loop control. During closed-loop control, the directional discrimination threshold was 31.9 and 26.1 mm for distal-proximal and lateral-medial directed stimuli, respectively. A numerical rating scale was significantly higher for the lateral/medial directions. Moreover, the variability of the discrimination threshold is reduced in the closed-loop control system.

CONCLUSIONS

The findings show that discrimination ability is better in the lateral-medial directions compared to the distal-proximal directions. This study indicates that using a system enabling closed-loop temperature control, allows more robust probing of the temporo-spatial mechanisms in the nociceptive system.

SIGNIFICANCE

This study shows that a newly developed temperature-controlled laser stimulation system enhances the possibilities to investigate the nociceptive temporo-spatial integration, as shown by a less variable directional discrimination threshold. The results also show that different orthogonal directions are discriminated differently. This new method allows a better investigation of the combined temporal and spatial mechanisms in the nociceptive system.

The perceptual timescape: Perceptual history on the sub-second scale

There is a high-capacity store of brief time span (∼1000 ms) which information enters from perceptual processing, often called iconic memory or sensory memory. It is proposed that a main function of this store is to hold recent perceptual information in a temporally segregated representation, named the perceptual timescape. The perceptual timescape is a continually active representation of change and continuity over time that endows the perceived present with a perceived history. This is accomplished primarily by two kinds of time marking information: time distance information, which marks all items of information in the perceptual timescape according to how far in the past they occurred, and ordinal temporal information, which organises items of information in terms of their temporal order. Added to that is information about connectivity of perceptual objects over time. These kinds of information connect individual items over a brief span of time so as to represent change, persistence, and continuity over time. It is argued that there is a one-way street of information flow from perceptual processing either to the perceived present or directly into the perceptual timescape, and thence to working memory. Consistent with that, the information structure of the perceptual timescape supports postdictive reinterpretations of recent perceptual information. Temporal integration on a time scale of hundreds of milliseconds takes place in perceptual processing and does not draw on information in the perceptual timescape, which is concerned with temporal segregation, not integration.

Thermal illusions for thermal displays: a review

Thermal illusions, a subset of haptic illusions, have historically faced technical challenges and limited exploration. They have been underutilized in prior studies related to thermal displays. This review paper primarily aims to comprehensively categorize thermal illusions, offering insights for diverse applications in thermal display design. Recent advancements in the field have spurred a fresh perspective on thermal and pain perception, specifically through the lens of thermal illusions.

I am the metre: The representation of one's body size affects the perception of tactile distances on the body

Humans must ground the perception of one's body in a mental representation to move in space and interact with objects. This representation can be temporarily altered artificially. In the full-body illusion (FBI), participants see a virtual (or filmed) body receiving a tactile stimulation. When participants receive touches on their body similarly to the seen one (i.e., homologous location and synchronous timing), they embody the seen alien body. While the subjective embodiment of alien bodies of different sizes has been already manipulated with the FBI, it remains unexplored whether the body-metric perception is impacted too. We first developed a new setup for the FBI using 360° videos to favour the embodiment. The FBI was induced for bodies of three sizes adopting anatomical and non-anatomical viewpoints, and we measured the subjective embodiment. The results suggest that humans can embody normal size or bigger bodies seen from anatomical viewpoints, but not smaller ones. We then investigated if the FBI modulates the body-metric representation. We found that the resized bodies' vision affects the perception of one's body-metric representation, but this was independent of the embodiment, suggesting that the FBI alters the body representation at different levels with a specific impact.

The intensity order illusion: temporal order of different vibrotactile intensity causes systematic localization errors

Haptic illusions serve as important tools for studying neurocognitive processing of touch and can be utilized in practical contexts. We report a new spatiotemporal haptic illusion that involves mislocalization when the order of vibrotactile intensity is manipulated. We tested two types of motors mounted in a 4 × 4 array in the lower thoracic region. We created apparent movement with two successive vibrotactile stimulations of varying distance (40, 20, or 0 mm) and direction (up, down, or same) while changing the temporal order of stimulation intensity (strong-weak vs. weak-strong). Participants judged the perceived direction of movement in a 2-alternative forced-choice task. The results suggest that varying the temporal order of vibrotactile stimuli with different intensity leads to systematic localization errors: when a strong-intensity stimulus was followed by a weak-intensity stimulus, the probability that participants perceived a downward movement increased, and vice versa. The illusion is so strong that the order of the strength of stimulation determined perception even when the actual presentation movement was the opposite. We then verified this "intensity order illusion" using an open response format where observers judged the orientation of an imaginary line drawn between two sequential tactor activations. The intensity order illusion reveals a strong bias in vibrotactile perception that has strong implications for the design of haptic information systems.NEW & NOTEWORTHY We report a new illusion involving mislocalization of stimulation when the order of vibrotactile intensity is manipulated. When a strong-intensity stimulus follows a weak-intensity stimulus, the probability that participants perceive an upward movement increases, and vice versa. The illusion is so strong that the order of the strength of stimulation determined perception even when the actual presentation movement was the opposite. This illusion is important for the design of vibrotactile stimulation displays.

Distinct temporal filtering mechanisms are engaged during dynamic increases and decreases of noxious stimulus intensity

Offset analgesia could be activated with a feedback-controlled near-infrared laser system. Larger and delayed response to temperature decrease than to temperature increase was observed.

Physical stimuli are subject to pronounced temporal filtering during afferent processing such that changes occurring at certain rates are amplified and others are diminished. Temporal filtering of nociceptive information remains poorly understood. However, the phenomenon of offset analgesia, where a disproportional drop in perceived pain intensity is caused by a slight drop in noxious heat stimulation, indicates potent temporal filtering in the pain pathways. To develop a better understanding of how dynamic changes in a physical stimulus are constructed into an experience of pain, a transfer function between the skin temperature and the perceived pain intensity was modeled. Ten seconds of temperature-controlled near-infrared (970 nm) laser stimulations above the pain threshold with a 1°C increment, decrement, or constant temperature were applied to the dorsum of the hand of healthy human volunteers. The skin temperature was assessed by an infrared camera. Offset analgesia was evoked by laser heat stimulation. The estimated transfer functions showed shorter latencies when the temperature was increased by 1°C (0.53 seconds [0.52-0.54 seconds]) than when decreased by 1°C (1.15 seconds [1.12-1.18 seconds]) and smaller gains (increase: 0.89 [0.82-0.97]; decrease: 2.61 [1.91-3.31]). The maximal gain was observed at rates around 0.06 Hz. These results show that temperature changes occurring around 0.06 Hz are best perceived and that a temperature decrease is associated with a larger but slower change in pain perception than a comparable temperature increase. These psychophysical findings confirm the existence of differential mechanisms involved in temporal filtering of dynamic increases and decreases in noxious stimulus intensity.

A system for inducing concurrent tactile and nociceptive sensations at the same site using electrocutaneous stimulation

Studies of the interaction between mechanoception and nociception would benefit from a method for stimulation of both modalities at the same location. For this purpose, we developed an electrical stimulation device. Using two different electrode geometries, discs and needles, the device is capable of inducing two distinct stimulus qualities, dull and sharp, at the same site on hairy skin. The perceived strength of the stimuli can be varied by applying stimulus pulse trains of different lengths. We assessed the perceived stimulus qualities and intensities of the two electrode geometries at two levels of physical stimulus intensity. In a first series of experiments, ten subjects participated in two experimental sessions. The subjects reported the perceived quality and intensity of four different stimulus classes on visual analogue scales (VASs). In a second series, we added a procedure in which subjects assigned descriptive labels to the stimuli. We assessed the reproducibility of the VAS scores by calculating intraclass correlation coefficients. The results showed that subjects perceived stimuli delivered through the disc electrodes as dull and those delivered through the needles as sharp. Increasing the pulse train length increased the perceived stimulus intensities without decreasing the difference in quality between the electrode types. The intraclass correlation coefficients for the VAS scores ranged from .75 to .95. The labels that were assigned for the two electrode geometries corresponded to the descriptors for nociception and touch reported by other researchers. We concluded that our device is capable of reliably inducing tactile and nociceptive sensations of controllable intensity at the same skin site.

Tactile and Haptic Illusions

This paper surveys the research literature on robust tactile and haptic illusions. The illusions are organized into two categories. The first category relates to objects and their properties, and is further differentiated in terms of haptic processing of material versus geometric object properties. The second category relates to haptic space, and is further differentiated in terms of the observer's own body versus external space. The illusions are initially described and where possible addressed in terms of their functional properties and/or underlying neural processes. The significance of these illusions for the design of tactile and haptic displays is also discussed. We conclude by briefly considering a number of important general themes that have emerged in the materials surveyed.

Spatiotemporal integration in somatosensory perception: effects of sensory saltation on pointing at perceived positions on the body surface

In the past, sensory saltation phenomena (Geldard and Sherrick, 1972) have been used repeatedly to analyze the spatiotemporal integration capacity of somatosensory and other sensory mechanisms by means of their psychophysical characteristic. The core phenomenon consists in a systematic mislocalization of one tactile stimulus (the attractee) toward another successive tactile stimulus (the attractant) presented at another location, increasing with shorter intervals. In a series of four experiments, sensory saltation characteristics were studied at the forearm and the abdomen. Participants reported the perceived positions of attractees, attractants, and reference stimuli by pointing. In general, saltation characteristics compared well to those reported in previous studies, but we were able to gain several new insights regarding this phenomenon: (a) the attractee–attractant interval did not exclusively affect the perceived attractee position, but also the perceived attractant position; (b) saltation characteristics were very similar at different body sites and orientations, but did show differences suggesting anisotropy (direction-dependency) in the underlying integration processes; (c) sensory saltation could be elicited with stimulation patterns crossing the body midline on the abdomen. In addition to the saltation-specific results, our experiments demonstrate that pointing reports of perceived positions on the body surface generally show pronounced systematic biases compared to veridical positions, moderate intraindividual consistency, and a high degree of inter-individual variability. Finally, we address methodological and terminological controversies concerning the sensory saltation paradigm and discuss its possible neurophysiological basis.

Exteroceptive aspects of nociception: insights from graphesthesia and two-point discrimination

The exteroceptive capabilities of the nociceptive system have long been thought to be considerably more limited than those of the tactile system. However, most investigations of spatio-temporal aspects of the nociceptive system have largely focused on intensity coding as consequence of spatial or temporal summation. Graphesthesia, the identification of numbers "written" on the skin, and assessment of the two-point discrimination thresholds were used to compare the exteroceptive capabilities of the tactile and nociceptive systems. Numbers were "written" on the forearm and the abdomen by tactile stimulation and by painful non-contact infrared laser heat stimulation. Subjects performed both graphesthesia tasks better than chance. The tactile graphesthesia tasks were performed with 89% (82-97%) correct responses on the forearm and 86% (79-94%) correct responses on the abdomen. Tactile graphesthesia tasks were significantly better than painful heat graphesthesia tasks that were performed with 31% (23-40%) and 44% (37-51%) correct responses on the forearm and abdomen, respectively. These findings demonstrate that the central nervous system is capable of assembling complex spatio-temporal patterns of nociceptive information from the body surface into unified mental objects with sufficient accuracy to enable behavioral discrimination.

Tactile-auditory saltation: spatiotemporal integration across sensory modalities

The perceptual phenomena of sensory saltation involve the systematic displacement of a target stimulus (the attractee) towards a subsequent stimulus (the attractant), which occurs closely in time and space. Here, we demonstrate the existence of cross-modal tactile-auditory saltation. Tactile stimuli were delivered to the forehead and spatially congruent stereoscopic auditory stimuli were presented via headphones to a total of 20 participants. After a reference stimulus at one of five spatial positions, the attractee was presented at a fixed position, followed by the attractant at a different fixed position with a delay of 81, 121, or 181 ms. Participants rated whether the attractee was perceived left or right of the reference in 2 uni-modal and 2 cross-modal (different reference/attractee vs. attractant mode) configurations. Saltation was present in all uni- and cross-modal configurations at an attractee-attractant delay of 81 ms. At delays of 81 ms the overall displacements were stronger than at delays of 121 ms, and tactile attractants generally induced stronger displacements than auditory attractants. The results indicated the existence of cross-modal tactile-auditory saltation, suggesting the application of the saltation phenomenon as a powerful approach for examining multi-modal sensory representations in future studies.

Saltation in pitch perception

Sensory saltation is a spatiotemporal illusion in which the location of a brief stimulus is displaced towards a subsequent one following closely in time and space. This study investigated in three experiments whether or not saltation is present in spectral pitch, a non-spatial dimension. Employing the "symmetrical-rabbit" paradigm, listeners judged the continuity of sequences of six short tones, differing in pitch (Exp. 1). Furthermore, the "reduced-rabbit" paradigm consisting of only three short tones was used in combination with an objective two-alternative forced-choice task (Exp. 2) and a subjective judgment task (Exp. 3). All findings indicated displacements in pitch towards subsequent tones when the interstimulus interval between the tones was short, and the frequency separation was small. This suggests a saltation-like illusion for non-spatial stimulus parameters. Possible explanations are discussed in view of the supramodal characteristic of the phenomenon.

Psychophysical ‘perceptual maps’ of heat and pain sensations by direct localization of CO2 laser stimuli on the skin

Brain activation patterns derived from neurofunctional methods are often implicitly regarded as being directly related to subjective perceptual experience in an iso- or at least homomorph manner, neglecting the operational differences between these two dimensions. This paper (a) introduces a method for assessing 'perceptual maps' of stimulation patterns presented to the body surface, providing a means to parametrically relate neural representation and subjective percept, and (b) applies this method to demonstrate the existence of 'somatotopic maps' of hot and painful stimulus patterns independent from mechanoceptive co-activation. Brief (90 ms) CO2 laser pulses were presented in an array of multiple stimulation sites on the dorsal forearms (N. radialis area, C7 dermatome) of healthy subjects. Perceived locations were indicated with a 3D tracker without touching the skin, and (mis-)localizations in distal-proximal direction were analyzed. Stimuli were localized with overall mean errors of 22 mm (SD: 16 mm) toward the wrist and 24 mm (SD: 18 mm) toward the elbow. Somatotopic representation of thermal-nociceptive stimuli could be demonstrated in all subjects, independent from mechanoceptive co-activation. The perceptual maps revealed striking individual (mis-)localization patterns, many subjects exhibiting 'stretched', some 'condensed' somatotopic representations. In estimating the mapping parameters from physical to perceptual space linear regressions generally provided a good fit (adj. R2>0.80 in 10 out of 12 subjects). Nonlinear models were advantageous in some subjects only. Our method can be useful in assessing inter-individual differences or experimentally induced shifts in somatotopic processing.