Sequential Molecular Events of Functional Trade-Offs in 5-Hydroxyisourate Hydrolase Before and After Gene Duplication Led to the Evolution of Transthyretin During Chordate Diversification

Conservation of kinetic stability, but not the unfolding mechanism, between human transthyretin and a transthyretin-related enzyme

Kinetic stability is thought to be an attribute of proteins that require a long lifetime, such as the transporter of thyroxine and holo retinol-binding protein or transthyretin (TTR) functioning in the bloodstream, cerebrospinal fluid, and vitreous humor. TTR evolved from ancestral enzymes known as TTR-related proteins (TRPs). Here, we develop a rate-expansion approach that allows unfolding rates to be measured directly at low denaturant concentration, revealing that kinetic stability exists in the Escherichia coli TRP (EcTRP), even though the enzyme structure is more energetically frustrated and has a more mutation-sensitive folding mechanism than human TTR. Thus, the ancient tetrameric enzyme may already have been poised to mutate into a kinetically stable human transporter. An extensive mutational study that exchanges residues at key sites within the TTR and EcTRP dimer-dimer interface shows that tyrosine 111, replaced by a threonine in TTR, is the gatekeeper of frustration in EcTRP because it is critical for function. Frustration, virtually absent in TTR, occurs at multiple sites in EcTRP and even cooperatively for certain pairs of mutations. We present evidence that evolution at the C terminus of TTR was a compensatory event to maintain the preexisting kinetic stability while reducing frustration and sensitivity to mutation. We propose an "overcompensation" pathway from EcTRPs to functional hybrids to modern TTRs that is consistent with the biophysics discussed here. An alternative plausible pathway is also presented.

Reenacting the Birth of a Function: Functional Divergence of HIUases and Transthyretins as Inferred by Evolutionary and Biophysical Studies

Transthyretin was discovered in the 1940s, named after its ability to bind thyroid hormones and retinol. In the genomic era, transthyretins were found to be part of a larger family with homologs of no obvious function, then called transthyretin-related proteins. Thus, it was proposed that the transthyretin gene could be the result of gene duplication of an ancestral of this newly identified homolog, later found out to be an enzyme involved in uric acid degradation, then named HIUase (5-hydroxy-isourate hydrolase). Here, we sought to re-enact the evolutionary history of this protein family by reconstructing, from a phylogeny inferred from 123 vertebrate sequences, three ancestors corresponding to key moments in their evolution-before duplication; the common transthyretin ancestor after gene duplication and the common ancestor of Eutheria transthyretins. Experimental and computational characterization showed the reconstructed ancestor before duplication was unable to bind thyroxine and likely presented the modern HIUase reaction mechanism, while the substitutions after duplication prevented that activity and were enough to provide stable thyroxine binding, as confirmed by calorimetry and x-ray diffraction. The Eutheria transthyretin ancestor was less prone to characterization, but limited data suggested thyroxine binding as expected. Sequence/structure analysis suggests an early ability to bind the Retinol Binding Protein. We solved the X-ray structures from the two first ancestors, the first at 1.46 resolution, the second at 1.55 resolution with well-defined electron density for thyroxine, providing a useful tool for the understanding of structural adaptation from enzyme to hormone distributor.

Evolution of thyroid hormone distributor proteins in fish

In plasma, thyroid hormone (TH) is bound to several TH distributor proteins (THDPs), constituting a TH delivery/distribution network. Extensive studies of THDPs from tetrapods has proposed an evolutionary scenario concerning structural and functional changes in THDPs, especially for transthyretin (TTR). When assessing, in an evolutionary context, the roles of THDPs as a component constituting part of the vertebrate thyroid system, the data from fish THDPs are critical. In this review the phylogenetic distributions, spatiotemporal expression patterns and binding properties of THDPs in fish are described, and the question of whether the evolutionary hypotheses proposed in tetrapod THDPs can be applied to fish THDPs is assessed. The phylogenetic distributions of THDPs are highly variable among fish groups. Analysis in this review reveals that the evolutionary hypotheses proposed in tetrapod THDPs cannot be applied to fish THDPs, and that the role of plasma lipoproteins as THDPs grows in importance in fish groups. In primitive fish, zinc is an import factor in TH binding to TTR, and high zinc content may facilitate the acquisition of high TH binding activity during the early evolution of TTR. Finally, the possible roles of THDPs in the vertebrate thyroid system are discussed.

The interaction of zinc with the multi-functional plasma thyroid hormone distributor protein, transthyretin: evolutionary and cross-species comparative aspects

A considerable body of evidence has been accumulated showing the interrelationship between zinc and the plasma thyroid hormone (TH) distributor protein, transthyretin (TTR). TTR is a multi-functional protein, which emerged from 5-hydroxyisourate hydrolase (HIUHase) by neo-functionalization after gene duplication during early chordate evolution. HIUHase is also a zinc-binding protein. Most biochemical and molecular biological findings have been obtained from mammalian studies. However, in the past two decades, it has become clear that fish TTR displays zinc-dependent TH binding. After a brief introduction on plasma zinc, THs and their binding proteins, this review will focus on the role of zinc in TTR functions of various vertebrates. In particular primitive fish TTR has an extremely high zinc content, with an increased number of histidine residues which are involved in TH binding. However, zinc-dependent TH binding may have been gradually lost from TTRs during higher vertebrate evolution. Although human TTR has a low zinc content, zinc plays an essential role in TTR functions other than TH binding: the stability of TTR-holo retinol binding protein 4 (holoRBP4) complex, TTR amyloidogenesis, the sequestration of amyloid β (Aβ) fibrils and cryptic proteolytic activity. The interaction of TTR with metallothioneins may be a critical step in the exertion of some of these functions. Evolutionary and physiological insights on zinc-dependent functions of TTRs are also discussed.