Classic metaphyseal lesion of distal tibia following footling breech delivery

Iatrogenic Flexion-Related Classic Metaphyseal Lesion of the Distal Tibia: Three Cases

BACKGROUND

Classic metaphyseal lesions (CMLs) should raise concern for nonaccidental trauma. However, iatrogenic causes for CMLs have increasingly been described and warrant close consideration. Increasing the clinical understanding of CML mechanics and their relation to often routine medical procedures will enhance provider awareness and expand the differential diagnosis when these otherwise highly concerning injuries are identified.

CASE REPORTS

We describe three clinical cases where suspected iatrogenic dorsiflexion or plantar flexion resulted in an isolated distal tibia CML. Respectively, we present heel-stick testing and i.v. line placement as clinical correlates of these two mechanisms. Although prior reports have aimed to describe iatrogenic CML etiologies, they have not focused on dorsiflexion or plantar flexion as predominant mechanisms of injury. WHY SHOULD AN EMERGENCY PHYSICIAN BE AWARE OF THIS?: Emergency physicians are critical to the surveillance and identification of nonaccidental trauma. Given that children oftentimes present to the emergency department with subtle yet concerning signs of maltreatment, an emergency physician must be aware of the potential causes of injury as well as the recommended response. Although avoiding missed cases of abuse and improving the detection of injuries is crucial for child health and well-being, failing to consider or recognize alternative explanations could also have serious implications for a child and their caregivers.

Difficult birth is the main contributor to birth-related fracture and accidents to other neonatal fractures

AIM

Specific birth-related fractures have been studied; underestimates might be a problem. We aimed to assess all fractures diagnosed as birth-related as well as other neonatal fractures.

METHODS

A population-based study on all infants born in Sweden 1997-2014; data were retrieved from the Swedish Health Registers (10th version of International Classification of Diseases. Outcome measures were birth-related fractures (ICD-10 P-codes) and other neonatal fractures (ICD-10 S-codes).

RESULTS

The overall fracture incidence was 2.9 per 1000 live birth (N = 5336); 92.6% had P-codes and 7.4% (S-codes). Some birth-related fractures were diagnosed beyond the neonatal period. Other neonatal fractures could have been birth-related. Clavicle fracture (88.8%) was associated with adverse maternal and infant anthropometrics and birth complications. The few neonates with rib fractures all had concomitant clavicle fracture. For skull fractures, a minor part was birth-related and most were associated with accidents. Half of the long bone fractures were associated with accidents. Birth-related femur fractures were associated with bone fragility risk factors. Five infants with abuse diagnoses had fractures: skull (4), long bone (2) and rib (1).

CONCLUSION

Birth-related and other neonatal fractures are rarely diagnosed. Difficult birth is the main contributor to birth-related fracture and accidents to other neonatal fractures.

Are classic metaphyseal lesions pathognomonic for child abuse? Two cases of motor vehicle collision-related extremity CML and a review of the literature

Long bone fractures at the infant growth plate, known as classic metaphyseal lesions (CMLs), raise a strong suspicion for abusive injury. CMLs persist as a hallmark for inflicted injury although a handful of documented cases of CMLs created by other, non-abusive mechanisms within various healthcare settings are scattered throughout the past few decades of medical literature. The forces required to sustain a CML are typically defined as a combination of tensile, compressive, or rotational energy applied to the metaphyseal regions of an infant's long bones. Recently, two separate child protection teams each encountered a case of CML discovered after reported motor vehicle collisions (MVC). This provoked a critical appraisal of the medical literature to inform clinical practice regarding MVCs as a potential mechanism for this fracture type and to remind clinicians that there is no single injury pathognomonic for abuse.