Formation of Se(0), Te(0), and Se(0)-Te(0) nanostructures during simultaneous bioreduction of selenite and tellurite in a UASB reactor

Riboflavin secreted by Shewanella sp. FDL-2 facilitates its reduction of Se(iv) and Te(iv) by promoting electron transfer

The biological reduction of selenite (Se(iv)) or tellurite (Te(iv)) to Se0 or Te0 has received increasing attention, as related studies have favored the development of Se/Te pollution control methods. In the presence of the electron donor, the microbes acquired energy and transferred electrons to Se(iv) or Te(iv) to achieve their detoxication. However, the microbial electron transfer pathways involved in this process are still not fully understood. In this study, we reported that marine Shewanella sp. FDL-2 (FDL-2) was capable of reducing Se(iv) and Te(iv) through a novel riboflavin-involved pathway. The results showed that FDL-2 can effectively reduce 10 mM Se(iv) and 5 mM Te(iv) to Se0 and Te0, which was further confirmed by XPS and XRD analyses. RT-qPCR results indicate the upregulation of genes coding flavin-related proteins, and the production of flavin-related substances by strain FDL-2 during Se(iv)/Te(iv) bioreduction was proven by fluorescence chromatography analysis. In addition, the presence of riboflavin enhanced the electron transfer efficiency, indicating its promoting effect on the bioreduction of Se(iv)/Te(iv). Overall, our results highlight a riboflavin-involved electron transfer pathway during Se(iv)/Te(iv) bioreduction and thus deepen our understanding of the corresponding mechanism.

Simultaneous bioreduction of tellurite and selenite by Yarrowia lipolytica, Trichosporon cutaneum, and their co-culture along with characterization of biosynthesized Te-Se nanoparticles

BACKGROUND

Natural and anthropogenic activities, such as weathering of rocks and industrial processes, result in the release of toxic oxyanions such as selenium (Se) and tellurium (Te) into the environment. Due to the high toxicity of these compounds, their removal from the environment is vital.

RESULTS

In this study, two yeast strains, Yarrowia lipolytica and Trichosporon cutaneum, were selected as the superior strains for the bioremediation of tellurium and selenium. The reduction analyses showed that exposure to selenite induced more detrimental effects on the strains compared to tellurite. In addition, co-reduction of pollutants displayed almost the same results in selenite reduction and more than ~ 20% higher tellurite reduction in 50 h, which shows that selenite triggered higher tellurite reduction in both strains. The selenite and tellurite kinetics of removal were consistent with the first-order model because of their inhibitory behavior. The result of several characterization experiments, such as FE-SEM (Field emission scanning electron microscopy), dynamic light scattering (DLS), Fourier-transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), X-ray diffractometer (XRD), and dispersive X-ray (EDX) on Te-Se nanoparticles (NPs) revealed that the separated Te-Se NPs were needle-like, spherical, and amorphous, consisted of Te-Se NPs ranging from 25 to 171 nm in size, and their surface was covered with different biomolecules.

CONCLUSIONS

Remarkably, this work shows, for the first time, the simultaneous bioreduction of tellurite and selenite and the production of Te-Se NPs using yeast strains, indicating their potential in this area, which may be applied to the nanotechnology industry and environmental remediation.

Selenite bioreduction by a consortium of halophilic/halotolerant bacteria and/or yeasts in saline media

Selenium oxyanions are released into environments by natural and anthropogenic activities and are present in agricultural and glass manufacturing wastewater in several locations worldwide. Excessive amounts of this metalloid have adverse effects on the health of living organisms. Halophilic and halotolerant microorganisms were selected for selenium oxyanions remediation due to presence of significant amount of salt in selenium-containing wastewater. Effects of aeration, carbon sources, competitive electron acceptors, and reductase inhibitors were investigated on SeO₃^2- bio-removal. Additionally, NO₃^--containing wastewater were exploited to investigate SeO₃^2- remediation in synthetic agricultural effluents. The results showed that the SeO₃^2- removal extent is maximum in aerobic conditions with succinate as a carbon source. SO₄^2- and PO₄^3- do not significantly interfere with SeO₃^2- reduction, while WO₄^2- and TeO₃^2- decrease the SeO₃^2- removal percentage (up to 35 and 37%, respectively). Furthermore, NO₃^- had an adverse effect on SeO₃^2- biotransformation by our consortia. All consortia reduced SeO₃^2- in synthetic agricultural wastewaters with a 45-53% removal within 120 h. This study suggests that consortia of halophilic/halotolerant bacteria and yeasts could be applied to treat SeO₃^2--contaminated drainage water. In addition, sulphates, and phosphates do not interfere with selenite bioreduction by these consortia, which makes them suitable candidates for the bioremediation of selenium-containing wastewater.

Predictive modelling and optimization of an airlift bioreactor for selenite removal from wastewater using artificial neural networks and particle swarm optimization

Selenite (Se⁴⁺) is the most toxic of all the oxyanion forms of selenium. In this study, a feed forward back propagation (BP) based artificial neural network (ANN) model was developed for a fungal pelleted airlift bioreactor (ALR) system treating selenite-laden wastewater. The performance of the bioreactor, i.e., selenite removal efficiency (RE_selenite) (%) was predicted through two input parameters, namely, the influent selenite concentration (IC_selenite) (10 mg/L - 60 mg/L) and hydraulic retention time (HRT) (24 h - 72 h). After training and testing with 96 sets of data points using the Levenberg-Marquardt algorithm, a multi-layer perceptron model (2-10-1) was established. High values of the correlation coefficient (0.96 ≤ R ≤ 0.98), along with low root mean square error (1.72 ≤ RMSE ≤ 2.81) and mean absolute percentage error (1.67 ≤ MAPE ≤ 2.67), clearly demonstrate the accuracy of the ANN model (> 96%) when compared to the experimental data. To ensure an efficient and economically feasible operation of the ALR, the process parameters were optimized using the particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm coupled with the neural model. The RE_selenite was maximized while minimizing the HRT for a preferably higher range of IC_selenite. Thus, the most favourable optimum conditions were suggested as: IC_selenite - 50.45 mg/L and HRT - 24 h, resulting in RE_selenite of 69.4%. Overall, it can be inferred that ANN models can successfully substitute knowledge-based models to predict the RE_selenite in an ALR, and the process parameters can be effectively optimized using PSO.

Evidence and Mechanisms of Selenate Reduction to Extracellular Elemental Selenium Nanoparticles on the Biocathode

Intracellular selenium nanoparticles (SeNPs) production is a roadblock to the recovery of selenium from biological water treatment processes because it is energy intensive to break microbial cells and then separate SeNPs. This study provided evidence of significantly more extracellular SeNP production on the biocathode (97-99%) compared to the conventional reactors (1-90%) using transmission electron microscopy coupled with energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. The cathodic microbial community analysis showed that relative abundance of Azospira oryzae, Desulfovibrio, Stenotrophomonas, and Rhodocyclaceae was <1% in the inoculum but enriched to 10-21% for each group when the bioelectrochemical reactor reached a steady state. These four groups of microorganisms simultaneously produce intracellular and extracellular SeNPs in conventional biofilm reactors per literature review but prefer to produce extracellular SeNPs on the cathode. This observation may be explained by the cellular energetics: by producing extracellular SeNPs on the biocathode, microbes do not need to transfer selenate and the electrons from the cathode into the cells, thereby saving energy. Extracellular SeNP production on the biocathode is feasible since we found high concentrations of C-type cytochrome, which is well known for its ability to transfer electrons from electrodes to microbial cells and reduce selenate to SeNPs on the cell membrane.

Selenite and tellurite reduction by Aspergillus niger fungal pellets using lignocellulosic hydrolysate

The performance of Aspergillus niger pellets to remove selenite and tellurite from wastewater using batch and continuous fungal pelleted bioreactors was investigated. The acid hydrolysate of brewer's spent grain (BSG) was utilized by A. niger as the electron donor for selenite and tellurite reduction. The dilution of BSG hydrolysate using mineral medium had a positive effect on the selenite and tellurite removal efficiency with a 1:3 ratio giving the best efficiency. However, selenite and tellurite inhibited fungal growth with a 40.9% and 27.3% decrease in the A. niger biomass yield in the presence of 50 mg/L selenite and tellurite, respectively. The maximum selenite and tellurite removal efficiency using 25% BSG hydrolysate in batch incubations amounted to 72.8% and 99.5% Two fungal pelleted bioreactors were operated in continuous mode using BSG hydrolysate as the substrate. Both the selenite and tellurite removal efficiencies during steady state operation were > 80% with tellurite showing a maximum removal efficiency of 98.5% at 10 mg/L influent concentration. Elemental Se nanospheres for selenite and both Te nanospheres and nanorods for tellurite were formed within the fungal pellets. This study demonstrates the suitability BSG hydrolysate as a low cost carbon source for removal of selenite and tellurite using fungal pellet bioreactors.

Te(IV) bioreduction in the sulfur autotrophic reactor: Performance, kinetics and synergistic mechanism

A laboratory-scale sulfur autotrophic reactor (SAR) was first constructed for treating tellurite [Te(IV)] wastewater. The SAR had excellent Te(IV) bioreduction efficiency (90-96%) at 5-30 mg/L and conformed to the First-order kinetic model. The Te(IV) bioreduction was elaborated deeply from extracellular polymeric substances (EPS) functions, microbial metabolic activity, key enzyme activity, microbial community succession and quorum sensing. Te(IV) stimulated the increase of redox substances in EPS and the improved cell membrane permeability led to the increase of electron transport system activity. Catalase and reduced nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide (NADH) alleviated the oxidative stress caused by Te(IV) toxicity to maintain metabolic activity. The increase of sulfur dioxygenase activity (SDO) suggested that more ATP produced by sulfur oxidation might provide energy for various physiological activities. Meanwhile, nitrate reductase (NAR), nitrite reductase (NIR) and sulfide: quinone oxidoreductase (SQR) played an active role in sulfur oxidation and Te(IV) bioreduction. Combined with the above results and dynamic succession of three functional microbial communities, a synergistic mechanism was proposed to explain the excellent performance of SAR. This work provided a promising strategy for Te(IV) wastewater treatment process and Te(IV) bioreduction mechanism.

Aerobic granular sludge for efficient biotransformation of chalcogen SeIV and TeIV oxyanions: Biological nutrient removal and biogenesis of Se0 and Te0 nanostructures

Simultaneous removal of selenite (Se^IV), tellurite (Te^IV) and nutrients by aerobic granular sludge (AGS) was investigated. A sequencing batch reactor (SBR) was operated with increasing Se^IV and Te^IV (up to 500 µM each) for 205 days to evaluate metalloid oxyanion and nutrient removal. AGS efficiently removed Se^IV and Te^IV by readily converting them to biomass associated forms. The total Se and Te removal efficiencies were higher at 98% and 99%, respectively. Formation of biomass-associated Se⁰ and Te⁰ was confirmed by XRD, Raman spectroscopy and SEM-EDX. Feeding of Se^IV and Te^IV elicited inhibitory action on ammonium removal initially, nonetheless removal performance was recovered during the subsequent cycles. Ammonium, total nitrogen and phosphorus removals were stabilized at 85%, 80% and 75%, respectively, at 500 µM of Se^IV and Te^IV. Sequencing of 16S rRNA gene confirmed enrichment of known Se^IV and Te^IV reducing bacteria in the granules. qPCR and removal kinetics supported ammonia removal via nitritation-denitritation. This work demonstrates functional capabilities of AGS for effectively removing toxic Se^IV and Te^IV oxyanions apart from performing simultaneous COD, nitrogen and phosphorus removal. Efficient biological nutrient removal in the presence of toxic Se^IV and Te^IV concentrations, suggests robustness of AGS and its resilience to toxic contaminants.

Microbial reduction and resistance to selenium: Mechanisms, applications and prospects

Selenium is an essential trace element for humans, animals and microorganisms. Microbial transformations, in particular, selenium dissimilatory reduction and bioremediation applications have received increasing attention in recent years. This review focuses on multiple Se-reducing pathways under anaerobic and aerobic conditions, and the phylogenetic clustering of selenium reducing enzymes that are involved in these processes. It is emphasized that a selenium reductase may have more than one metabolic function, meanwhile, there are several Se(VI) and/or Se(IV) reduction pathways in a bacterial strain. It is noted that Se(IV)-reducing efficiency is inconsistent with Se(IV) resistance in bacteria. Moreover, we discussed the links of selenium transformations to biogeochemical cycling of other elements, roles of Se-reducing bacteria in soil, plant and digestion system, and the possibility of using functional genes involved in Se transformation as biomarker in different environments. In addition, we point out the gaps and perspectives both on Se transformation mechanisms and applications in terms of bioremediation, Se fortification or dietary supplementation.

UV-Induced Redox Conversion of Tellurite by Biacetyl

Tellurium (Te) is a rare element of great value, but it exists mainly in the toxic form of tellurite (Te^IV) in water. Effective approaches that are able to reduce the toxicity and recover Te from contaminated water are highly needed. Here, we developed a simple but effective way to reduce toxic Te^IV to widely applicable elemental Te⁰. With the combination of ultraviolet (UV) and biacetyl (BD), the oxidation state of Te could be feasibly changed from IV to 0 or VI. The consumption of dissolved oxygen (DO) was a key factor in the redox conversion of Te^IV. Under UV irradiation, BD was first cleaved to acetyl radicals, which could then combine with water molecules to form more reductive diol radicals or combine with DO to form strongly oxidative peroxide radicals. Even without deoxygenation, the UV/BD system could rapidly change from being oxidative to being reductive because of the fast depletion of DO. Owing to the high quantum yield of the acetyl radical, the reduction efficiency of the UV/BD system was about 1 order of magnitude higher than that of UV/sulfite and was more efficient than the commonly used biological methods. This work provides a proof of concept for the reduction of tellurite, which could have relevant implications for water treatment and resource recovery applications.

Simultaneous removal of lead and selenium through biomineralization as lead selenide by anaerobic granular sludge

This study demonstrated the simultaneous removal of lead (Pb) and selenium (Se) as lead selenide biomineralization using anaerobic granular sludge. The microbial community of the granular sludge was first enriched for 140 days in the presence of Pb(II) only, selenate and selenite only, Pb(II)+selenate, and Pb(II)+selenite. In the absence of Se, removal of Pb(II) mainly occurred via biosorption and deposited on the biomass as lead oxide and lead carbonate. The Pb removal efficiency (94% of initial 50 mg L^-1) was reduced to 90% and 86% in the presence of selenate and selenite, respectively, due to biosorption. Addition of Pb(II) didn't exert any toxic effect on the Se-reducing microbial community, on the contrary: Pb(II) addition improved the Se removal efficiency for selenate from 85% to 90%, but did not affect selenite removal after 14 d of incubation. The bioreduction of the Se-oxyanions produced elemental Se (Se(0)) and selenide, which later interacted with Pb(II) to produce lead selenide (PbSe). Adsorption of Pb(II) onto the Se(0) nanoparticles and precipitation as the Se(0)-Pb complex might also have contributed to the simultaneous removal of Pb and Se. XPS and XRD analysis further confirmed the immobilization of Pb as PbSe, PbO and PbCO₃ in the biomass.

Green Synthesis of Selenium and Tellurium Nanoparticles: Current Trends, Biological Properties and Biomedical Applications

The synthesis and assembly of nanoparticles using green technology has been an excellent option in nanotechnology because they are easy to implement, cost-efficient, eco-friendly, risk-free, and amenable to scaling up. They also do not require sophisticated equipment nor well-trained professionals. Bionanotechnology involves various biological systems as suitable nanofactories, including biomolecules, bacteria, fungi, yeasts, and plants. Biologically inspired nanomaterial fabrication approaches have shown great potential to interconnect microbial or plant extract biotechnology and nanotechnology. The present article extensively reviews the eco-friendly production of metalloid nanoparticles, namely made of selenium (SeNPs) and tellurium (TeNPs), using various microorganisms, such as bacteria and fungi, and plants' extracts. It also discusses the methodologies followed by materials scientists and highlights the impact of the experimental sets on the outcomes and shed light on the underlying mechanisms. Moreover, it features the unique properties displayed by these biogenic nanoparticles for a large range of emerging applications in medicine, agriculture, bioengineering, and bioremediation.

Cathodic selenium recovery in bioelectrochemical system: Regulatory influence on anodic electrogenic activity

Metal(loid)s are used in various industrial activities and widely spread across the environmental settings in various forms and concentrations. Extended releases of metal(loid)s above the regulatory levels cause environmental and health hazards disturbing the ecological balance. Innovative processes for treating the metal(loid)-contaminated sites and recovery of metal(loid)s from disposed waste streams employing biotechnological routes provide a sustainable way forward. Conventional metal recovery technologies demand high energy and/or resource inputs, which are either uneconomic or unsustainable. Microbial electrochemical systems are promising for removal and recovery of metal(loid)s from metal(loid)-laden wastewaters. In this communication, a bioelectrochemical system (BES) was designed and operated with selenium (Se) oxyanion at varied concentrations as terminal electron acceptor (TEA) for reduction of selenite (Se⁴⁺) to elemental selenium (Se⁰) in the abiotic cathode chamber. The influence of varied concentrations of Se⁴⁺ towards Se⁰ recovery at the cathode was also evaluated for its regulatory role on the electrometabolism of anode-respiring bacteria. This study observed 26.4% Se⁰ recovery (cathode; selenite removal efficiency: 73.6%) along with organic substrate degradation of 74% (anode). With increase in the initial selenite concentration, there was a proportional increase in the dehydrogenase activity. Bioelectrochemical characterization depicted increased anodic electrogenic performance with the influence of varied Se⁴⁺ concentrations as TEA and resulted in a maximum power density of 0.034 W/m². The selenite reduction (cathode) was evaluated through spectroscopic, compositional and structural analysis. X-ray diffraction and Raman spectroscopy showed the amorphous nature, while Energy Dispersive X-ray spectroscopy confirmed precipitates of the deposited Se⁰ recovered from the cathode chamber. Scanning electron microscopic images clearly depicted the Se⁰ depositions (spherical shaped; sized approximately 200 nm in diameter) on the electrode and cathode chamber. This study showed the potential of BES in converting soluble Se⁴⁺ to insoluble Se⁰ at the abiotic cathode for metal recovery.

Developments in the study and applications of bacterial transformations of selenium species

Microbial bio-transformations of the essential trace element selenium are now recognized to occur among a wide variety of microorganisms. These transformations are used to convert this element into its assimilated form of selenocysteine, which is at the active center of a number of key enzymes, and to produce selenium nanoparticles, quantum dots, metal selenides, and methylated selenium species that are indispensable for biotechnological and bioremediation applications. The focus of this review is to present the state-of-the-art of all aspects of the investigations into the bacterial transformations of selenium species, and to consider the characterization and biotechnological uses of these transformations and their products.

Extreme Environments and High-Level Bacterial Tellurite Resistance

Bacteria have long been known to possess resistance to the highly toxic oxyanion tellurite, most commonly though reduction to elemental tellurium. However, the majority of research has focused on the impact of this compound on microbes, namely E. coli, which have a very low level of resistance. Very little has been done regarding bacteria on the other end of the spectrum, with three to four orders of magnitude greater resistance than E. coli. With more focus on ecologically-friendly methods of pollutant removal, the use of bacteria for tellurite remediation, and possibly recovery, further highlights the importance of better understanding the effect on microbes, and approaches for resistance/reduction. The goal of this review is to compile current research on bacterial tellurite resistance, with a focus on high-level resistance by bacteria inhabiting extreme environments.

Bioreduction of selenate in an anaerobic biotrickling filter using methanol as electron donor

The anaerobic bioreduction of selenate, fed in step (up to 60 mg.L^-1) or continuous (∼7 mg.L^-1) trickling mode, in the presence of gas-phase methanol (4.3-50 g m^-3.h^-1) was evaluated in a biotrickling filter (BTF). During the 48 d of step-feed and 41 d of continuous-feed operations, average selenate removal efficiencies (RE) > 90% and ∼68% was achieved, corresponding to a selenate reduction rate of, respectively, 7.3 and 4.5 mg.L^-1.d^-1. During the entire period of BTF operation, 65.6% of the total Se fed as SeO₄^2- was recovered. Concerning gas-phase methanol, the maximum elimination capacity (EC_max) was 46.4 g m^-3.h^-1, with a RE > 80%. Methanol was mainly utilized for acetogenesis and converted to volatile fatty acids (VFA) in the liquid-phase. Up to 5000 mg.L^-1 of methanol and 800 mg.L^-1 of acetate accumulated in the trickling liquid of the BTF.

Optimization of Soil Washing to Reduce the Selenium Levels of Seleniferous Soil from Punjab, Northwestern India

Seleniferous soil collected from the wheat ( L.)-grown agricultural land in Punjab, India, was characterized and the Se concentration in various soil fractions was determined by sequential extraction. The soil had a total Se content of 4.75 (±0.02) mg kg, of which 44% was observed in the oxidizable soil fraction. Soil flushing as an in situ technique was performed to simulate the Se migration pattern in case of rainfall or irrigation. Significant migration of Se from the upper layer to the lower layers was observed during water percolation through the soil column at a flow rate of 1 mL min, which could be attributed to Se reduction in the lower anoxic layers of the soil column. For ex situ treatment, the soil washing technique was optimized by varying different parameters such as treatment time, temperature, pH, liquid to solid (L:S) ratio, and presence of competing ions and oxidizing agents. Selenium extraction from soil was significantly improved by the presence of oxidizing agents in the washing solution: ∼38% Se was removed from the soil in the presence of 0.5% KMnO. In contrast, parameters such as treatment time, temperature, pH, L:S ratio, and competing ions did not significantly enhance the Se extraction efficiency. In this research, laboratory-scale in situ and ex situ treatment techniques for Se removal from soil were studied and optimized. The results provide an insight for large-scale Se removal and recovery from seleniferous soils.

The biomineralization process of uranium(VI) by Saccharomyces cerevisiae - transformation from amorphous U(VI) to crystalline chernikovite

Microorganisms play a significant role in uranium(VI) biogeochemistry and influence U(VI) transformation through biomineralization. In the present work, the process of uranium mineralization was investigated by Saccharomyces cerevisiae. The toxicity experiments showed that the viability of cell was not significantly affected by 100 mg L^-1 U(VI) under 4 days of exposure time. The batch experiments showed that the phosphate concentration and pH value increased over time during U(VI) adsorption. Meanwhile, thermodynamic calculations demonstrated that the adsorption system was supersaturated with respect to UO₂HPO₄. The X-ray powder diffraction spectroscopy (XRD), field emission scanning electron microscopy (FE-SEM) equipped with energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDX), Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR), and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) analyses indicated that the U(VI) was first attached onto the cell surface and reacted with hydroxyl, carboxyl, and phosphate groups through electrostatic interactions and complexation. As the immobilization of U(VI) transformed it from the ionic to the amorphous state, lamellar uranium precipitate was formed on the cell surface. With the prolongation of time, the amorphous uranium compound disappeared, and there were some crystalline substances observed extracellularly, which were well-characterized as tetragonal-chernikovite. Furthermore, the size of chernikovite was regulated at nano-level by cells, and the perfect crystal was formed finally. These findings provided an understanding of the non-reductive transformation process of U(VI) from the amorphous to crystalline state within microbe systems, which would be beneficial for the U(VI) treatment and reuse of nuclides and heavy metals.