Long-term risks in hyperthyroid patients treated with radioiodine: is there anything new?

Papillary thyroid carcinoma in cervical lymph nodes with vanished thyroid gland after ablation of Graves' disease by radioactive iodine

Primary thyroid carcinoma after thyroid ablation by radioactive iodine is rare. We present a very rare condition of lateral apparent papillary thyroid carcinoma eight years after receiving radioactive iodine for thyrotoxicosis, which led to complete anatomical and functional involution of the thyroid gland.

Efficacy of radioactive iodine treatment of graves' hyperthyroidism using a single calculated 131I dose

Objective

To evaluate the success rate of therapeutic administration of a single calculated ¹³¹I activity for eliminating hyperthyroidism due to Graves’ disease.

Methods and materials

Patients with Graves’ hyperthyroidism underwent pinhole thyroid imaging, 24-h radioactive iodine uptake (RAIU) measurements and clinical examination and received a calculated ¹³¹I activity of 0.2 mCi per estimated gram of thyroid tissue, adjusted for the 24-h RAIU. The goal of RAI treatment was to achieve hypothyroidism within 3–6 months of ¹³¹I administration. Response to RAI therapy was assessed at 7 weeks and 3 months by clinical and biochemical follow-up.

Results

The study included 316 hyperthyroid patients with Graves’ disease (F238:M78, mean age 42.1 ± 16 y, 4–94). 179 patients (56.6%) had no prior therapeutic intervention (treatment-naive patients), whereas 6 patients had prior thyroid surgery, and 131 (41.5%) had been treated with anti-thyroid medications.

The mean estimated thyroid gland size was 50.2 g ± 18, range 15–100. Mean RAIU was 0.57 ± 0.17 (normal 0.07–0.30). RAI doses ranged from 5 to 70 mCi (mean dose = 18.1 mCi). Successful treatment of hyperthyroidism at our institution was obtained after a single therapeutic 131-I activity administration in 295 of 316 (93.3%) patients. Multivariate logistic regression analysis demonstrated that failure of ¹³¹I therapy was associated with previous PTU therapy (p <  0.001).

The mean response time after successful RAI therapy was 110.2 days, with cumulative response of 25% at 61 days, 50% by 84 days and 75% by 118 days after radioiodine administration. The mean time to respond for those on prior PTU medications was 297 days compared to 116 days for those on MMI and 109 days for those not previously treated with antithyroid medications. In patients with persistent hyperthyroidism, failure of RAI therapy was documented in 16 patients (76.2%) within (less than) one year after ¹³¹I administration and in 5 patients (23.8%) more than one year after initial therapy, considered late failure.

Conclusion

Successful ¹³¹I therapy for Graves’ hyperthyroidism with a single calculated dose can be achieved in the majority (> 90%) of patients, adjusting for the thyroid size and 24 h uptake measurement.

Treatment of adult Graves' disease

Treatment strategy in Graves' disease firstly requires recovery of euthyroid status by antithyroid therapy. Treatment modalities, precautions, advantages and side-effects are to be discussed with the patient. No particular treatment modality has demonstrated superiority. Pregnancy or pregnancy project affects choice of treatment and monitoring. Graves' orbitopathy is liable to be aggravated by iodine-131 treatment and requires pre-treatment assessment. Iodine-131 treatment aims at achieving hypothyroidism. Thyroid surgery for Graves' disease should preferably be performed by an expert team. In case of recurrence of hyperthyroidism, the various treatment options should be discussed with the patient. Empiric treatment of thyroid dermopathy uses local corticosteroids in occlusive dressing.

Anaplastic thyroid carcinoma following radioactive iodine therapy for graves' disease

Radioactive iodine (RAI) therapy has been used as a treatment option for Graves' disease, and it has been widely accepted to be safe. On the other hand, some evidence suggests that RAI therapy is possibly associated with a small increased risk of thyroid cancer. Herein, we report a rare case of anaplastic thyroid carcinoma (ATC) associated with Graves' disease, following RAI treatment. A 42-year-old woman had been diagnosed with Graves' disease and although she was treated with an antithyroid drug, she remained in a hyperthyroid state, which led to two RAI treatments. More than 10 years later, the patient revisited our clinic due to hoarseness, dysphagia, and dyspnea, which had lasted for 2 months. Neck computed tomography suggested thyroid carcinoma and a lymph node biopsy showed metastatic papillary carcinoma. The patient underwent total thyroidectomy and was finally diagnosed as having an ATC. It is not clear if the occurrence of ATC reported here was influenced by the RAI therapy or alternatively, it may only represent the delayed recognition of a rare change in the natural history of Graves' disease. Nevertheless, this report is worthwhile since it presents a very rare case of ATC that occurred eleven years after the RAI therapy for Graves' disease.

Cancer risk after medical exposure to radioactive iodine in benign thyroid diseases: a meta-analysis

Radioiodine-131 ((131)I) is widely used for diagnosis and treatment of benign thyroid diseases. Observational studies have not been conclusive about the carcinogenic potential of (131)I and we therefore conducted a meta-analysis. We performed a literature search till September 2011 which included (131)I as a diagnostic or treatment modality ((131)I for treatment of thyroid cancer was excluded). Data on 64 different organ or organ group subsets comprising 22 029 exposed subjects in the therapeutic cohorts and 24 799 in the diagnostic cohorts in seven studies were included. Outcome was pooled as the relative risk (RR) using both standard and bias adjusted methods. Quality assessment was performed using a study-specific instrument. No increase in overall (RR 1.06, 95% CI: 0.94-1.19), main organ group or combined organ group (four groups known to concentrate (131)I; RR 1.11, 95% CI: 0.94-1.31) risks was demonstrable. Individual organs demonstrated a higher risk for kidney (RR 1.70, 95% CI: 1.15-2.51) and thyroid (RR 1.99, 95% CI: 1.22-3.26) cancers with a strong trend for stomach cancer (RR 1.11, 95% CI: 0.92-1.33). A thyroid dose effect was seen for diagnostic doses. While there is no increase in the overall burden of cancer, an increase in risk to a few organs is seen which requires substantiation. The possible increase in thyroid cancer risk following diagnostic (131)I use should no longer be of concern given that it has effectively been replaced by the use of 99mTc-pertechnetate.

Striving for euthyroidism in radioiodine therapy of Graves' disease: a 12-year prospective, randomized, open-label blinded end point study

BACKGROUND

In China, use of radioiodine therapy is problematic because of the need for lifelong levothyroxine substitution. Our aim was to find an optimum dosing strategy for (131)I treatment of hyperthyroidism due to Graves' disease (GD). We attempted to achieve euthyroidism to avoid long-term levothyroxine treatment.

METHODS

Six hundred patients with GD were randomized into five groups, each comprising 120 individuals, to receive an individual (131)I activity selected from five different ascending activity ranges. The ranges were modulated according to a clinical score system. Follow-up was extended over a 12-year time frame. The primary outcomes were euthyroidism, hyperthyroidism, hypothyroidism, and recurrent hyperthyroidism. The secondary endpoint was the accumulated (131)I activity needed to achieve euthyroidism.

RESULTS

Out of 682 screened patients, 600 entered the study in 1997. Five hundred twenty-nine completed the last follow-up visit at the end of the study in 2009. Group 3 was identified as the study arm that received the optimum radioiodine activity, with 71.8% of the patients maintaining a euthyroid status, 5.8% remaining hyperthyroid, and 22.3% becoming hypothyroid by the end of the study. This group received 1.85-4.07 MBq per gram of thyroid tissue (average administered activity 261 ± 162 MBq). Over the 12-year follow-up period, the recurrence rate was 13.6%. The efficacy of (131)I treatment was related to activities modulated by a clinical score (χ(2) = 82.1, p = 0.000).

CONCLUSION

Our protocol effectively treated hyperthyroidism and significantly reduced the hypothyroidism rate. It may be preferable to the intentional induction of permanent hypothyroidism recommended by many experts.

(131)I therapy in patients with benign thyroid disease does not conclusively lead to a higher risk of subsequent malignancies

Due to its excellent tolerability and low incidence of side effects, 131I therapy has been the treatment of choice for benign thyroid diseases for over 60 years. A potentially increased risk of malignancies due to this therapy is however still subject of debate.

AIM

To review the literature pertaining to 131I therapy of benign thyroid diseases in order to establish whether there is an increased incidence of, or increased mortality due to malignancies of the thyroid or other organs.

METHODS

In order to allow for sufficient long-term follow-up time after 131I therapy, only literature after 1990 was reviewed. Two criteria were applied to consider an increased incidence of malignancies linked to 131I therapy: a) there should be a latency period of at least 5 years between 131I therapy and the observation of an increased risk b) an elevated risk should increase with increasing radiation exposure.

RESULTS

A total of 7 studies reporting cancer incidence and / or mortality in 4 different patient collectives spanning a total of 54510 patients over an observation period varying from 2-49 years were found. Although some studies detected a slightly increased risk for malignancies of the thyroid or the digestive system, others did not find these effects - while other studies even reported a slightly lower risk of malignant (thyroid) disease after 131I therapy for benign thyroid diseases.

CONCLUSION

As over 60 years of experience has thus far failed to produce conclusive evidence to the contrary, it can be concluded that there is no increased risk of malignancies after 131I therapy for benign thyroid disease.

PET/CT colonography: a novel non-invasive technique for assessment of extent and activity of ulcerative colitis

PURPOSE

Extent of involvement and activity of ulcerative colitis (UC) is best evaluated by colonoscopy. Colonoscopy however carries risk during acute exacerbation. We investigated the utility of PET/CT colonography for assessment of extent and activity of UC.

METHODS

Within a 1-week window, 15 patients with mild to moderately active UC underwent colonoscopy and PET/CT colonography 60 min after injection of 10 mCi of (18)F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG). PET activity score based on the amount of FDG uptake and endoscopic mucosal activity in seven colonic segments of each patient was recorded. The mean maximum standardized uptake value (SUV(max)) of seven segments was compared with activity in liver. A PET activity grade of 0, 1, 2 or 3 was assigned to each region depending upon their SUV(max) ratio (colon segment to liver).

RESULTS

The extent of disease was left-sided colitis in five and pancolitis in ten. The mean Ulcerative Colitis Disease Activity Index (UCDAI) was 7.6. The number of segments involved as per colonoscopic evaluation and PET/CT colonography was 67 and 66, respectively. There was a good correlation for extent evaluation between the two modalities (kappa 55.3%, p = 0.02). One patient had grade 0 PET activity, nine had grade 2 and five had grade 3 PET activity. In six patients, there was one to one correlation between PET activity grades with that of endoscopic grade. One patient showed activity in the sacroiliac joint suggesting active sacroiliitis.

CONCLUSION

PET/CT colonography is a novel non-invasive technique for the assessment of extent and activity of the disease in patients with UC.