Functional and aesthetic results of immediate reconstruction of traumatic thumb defects by toe-to-thumb transplantation

Second Toe-to-thumb Transfer Using Intramedullary Screw Fixation after Traumatic Thumb Amputation

Loss of the thumb secondary to trauma leads to significant disability due to the digit contributing 40% of overall hand function. Toe-to-thumb transfer has been a well-studied reconstructive method as a means to restore function after thumb amputation. First described in 1969 by Cobbett and colleagues, toe-to-thumb transfers have undergone several modifications in technique to better improve functional and aesthetic outcomes, including toe wrap-around flaps, trimmed great toe transfer, and second toe transfers. Although these methods have allowed patients to retain use of the thumb, traditional interosseous wire reattachment often leads to significant stiffness and need for prolonged rehabilitation to regain maximal function. Intramedullary screw fixation has been increasingly used in phalanx and metacarpal fractures, but its implementation outside of these contexts is not well reported. Here, we present a case of a patient who presented with traumatic thumb amputation and was treated with second toe-to-thumb transfer with intramedullary screw fixation, a novel mode of interosseous rigid fixation in toe-to-hand surgery. Postoperatively, our patient was able to begin mobilizing the new thumb immediately, which allowed for earlier return to work. We believe our technique can be applied to other cases of second toe, as well as great toe, transfers to improve length of recovery and rehabilitation postoperatively.

Reconstruction of Fingers Using Skin-Bone Grafts with Microvascular Anastomoses

The aim of the study was to present a clinical and anatomical rationale for transplantation of skin-bone grafts with microvascular anastomoses for treating terminal and segmental defects of the hand and fingers.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Finger and metacarpal bones were reconstructed in 25 hands of 25 patients by transplanting skin-bone tubular fragments with microvascular anastomoses. Transplants from the second metatarsal bone (n=22) and fibula (n=3) were used. Clinical, radiological, morphological, biomechanical, biophysical, and statistical research methods were used. The developed technology is adjustable to individual vascular anatomy of the foot. The proposed use of non-free skin-fat flaps and skin-bone fragments with microvascular anastomoses has been implemented for reconstructing lost segments.

RESULTS

The engraftment of skin-bone fragments was observed in 25 cases. In two cases, partial necrosis of the transplants was detected. Sufficient resistance of the transplanted bone graft to resorption was noted. According to the X-ray evidence, the length of the finger with the metacarpal bone after surgery was 8.44±0.32 cm, in the short term after surgery - 8.10±0.36 cm, and in the long term - 7.87±0.45 cm, indicating mild resorption. We used an individual approach to the transplant selection, which made it possible to obtain generally good long-term results in 3 patients, and satisfactory results - in 22 patients.

CONCLUSION

The study showed the feasibility of transplanting skin-bone fragments with microvascular anastomoses for replacing various anatomical defects of the hand and fingers. The proposed modification takes into account the variability of vascular anatomy of the donor region.

Emergency toe-to-hand transfer for post-traumatic finger reconstruction: A multicenter case series

BACKGROUND

The aim of this paper was to evaluate the outcomes of a homogenous series of emergency with a toe-to-hand transfer reconstructions with a different timing: immediate (same surgical step with the debridement), primary (in the first 24 h), early (24-72 h after the debridement) or delayed (72 h-7 days).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 2001 and 2011, 31 patients received an immediate reconstruction with a toe-to-hand transfer. Data on indications, timing, type of surgery, complications and outcomes (sensory and motor recovery, patient satisfaction) were extrapolated and recorded.

RESULTS

Most of the procedures in our series (71%) were performed in the first 24 h. Survival rate was 100%. The only complications were 3 venous thrombosis (10%), solved with surgical re-exploration. Only 1 patient required secondary surgery for web deepening. No functional problems were recorded at the donor site. Sensibility recovery was acceptable in all patients; toe mobility was higher for the reconstructed thumb (85%) than for other digits (77%). Patient satisfaction was high with regard to functional results and lower but acceptable with regard to the aesthetic outcome. There was no difference in satisfaction rate of patients treated within 24 h or within 7 days.

CONCLUSION

No conclusive evidence exists in favor of an immediate versus a primary, early or delayed emergency reconstruction. Emergency toe transfer for finger reconstruction is a safe procedure and its outcomes are comparable to those reported in the literature for secondary reconstruction. Immediate reconstruction has the advantage of an easier dissection, but early or delayed reconstruction gives more time to discuss with the patient and to plan surgery.

Patient-Reported Outcome Measures for Toe-to-Hand Transfer: A Prospective Longitudinal Study

BACKGROUND

Patient-reported outcome measures are an important metric in evaluating treatment efficacy of reconstructive surgery. Toe-to-hand transfer can restore vital prehensile function; however, this surgery is complex, extensive rehabilitation is required, and there are concerns about donor-site morbidity. This study longitudinally explores the benefits of this procedure, from the patient's perspective, using patient-reported outcome measures.

METHODS

Twenty-three patients who underwent free toe-to-hand transfers from 2012 to 2015 were evaluated preoperatively and postoperatively using the following validated questionnaires: the Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire, the 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey, and the Lower Limb Outcomes Questionnaire. Subgroup analysis was performed between dominant and nondominant reconstructed hands.

RESULTS

Mechanism of injury was crush in 83 percent; the remainder sustained cutting, avulsion, and burn injuries. Thirty-four toes were transferred: nine great toes, 20 second toes, and five third toes. Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire results showed significant improvement in overall activities of daily living, work, aesthetics, and patient satisfaction (p < 0.05). The results of the 36-Item Short-Form Health Survey showed significant improvements in physical and emotional roles (p < 0.05). The Lower Limb Outcomes Questionnaire showed no deterioration of foot function (p = 0.55). Subgroup analysis showed significant improvement in patient-reported outcome measures for patients undergoing dominant hand reconstruction but no difference between thumb reconstruction and finger-only reconstruction.

CONCLUSIONS

Patient-reported outcome measures demonstrate the significant utility of toe-to-hand transfer procedures in both functional and psychosocial domains in that there are relatively greater benefits in reconstructing the dominant hand, and that donor-site morbidity is well tolerated.

CLINICAL QUESTION/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic, IV.

Thumb reconstruction with combination of the wrap-around flap prefabricated by medialis pedis perforator flap with nail bed and phalanx banked from the amputated thumb: A case report

Thumb reconstruction has been a very challenging issue for hand surgeons. In this report, we present a case of thumb reconstruction with combination of the wrap-around flap prefabricated by the medialis pedis perforator flap with phalanx and nail bed banked from the amputated thumb. A 22-year-old man suffered from the left thumb amputation as well as large soft tissue defect of hand and comminuted fracture in wrist due to a crush accident. The distal phalanx and nail bed of left thumb were exposed and no suitable vessels for microsurgical anastomosis could be found, resulting in the great difficulty of replantation. After debridement, nail bed of the amputated thumb was dissected and banked on the medial side of foot, while the distal phalanx was buried in the abdominal subcutaneous tissue. The fracture was fixed with an external fixation and the soft tissue defect was covered with a free anterolateral flap. Wound and bone healing was achieved 6 months after the initial treatment. Thumb was reconstructed with combination of the banked phalanx and a wrap-around flap prefabricated by the medialis pedis perforator flap and the banked nail bed. The postoperative course was uneventful with complications from both reconstruction and donor sites. The nail of the reconstructed thumb grew normally. Thumb oppositional function was rebuilt. The patient was satisfied with the aesthetic and functional outcome at 5-year postoperative follow-up. We propose that tissue banked from the nonreplantable amputated thumb could be used for secondary reconstruction with the technique of flap prefabrication.

The Biomechanical Impact of Digital Loss and Fusion Following Trauma: Setting the Patient up for Success

Surgeons managing mutilating hand injures are faced with difficult decisions between attempting to salvage remaining or injured digits or proceeding to amputation and fusion. Through application of a basic understanding of hand biomechanics, the surgeon may more accurately predict what motion and function can best be salvaged. This article provides an explanation of how amputation, fusion, and tendon loss can affect postoperative hand motion. The surgeon can use these concepts in planning the reconstruction or preparing the foundation for secondary reconstructive procedures to achieve the highest functional outcome for the patient.

Combined two foot flaps with iliac bone graft for reconstruction of the thumb

The purpose of this report was to retrospectively review the results of reconstruction of the thumb by use of combined two foot flaps with an iliac bone graft. From 2009 to 2014, nine patients with traumatic amputation of the thumb had their thumbs reconstructed. The two flaps were based on one pedicle. All flaps survived completely. Patients were followed for a mean of 15.6 months (range, 6-35 months). The appearance of the reconstructed thumb was comparable to a normal one, except for one thumb which required debulking. The appearance of the nail was satisfactory without deformity. The range of joint motion was satisfactory. The two point discrimination of the pulp ranged from 6 mm to >15 mm. The Michigan Hand Questionnaire outcome score was a mean of 76.2 ± 11.3 points and the Maryland foot rating score a mean of 94.8 ± 3.4 points. The combined two foot flaps with iliac bone graft might provide an option for the reconstruction of the thumb.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Enhancing aesthetic outcomes of soft-tissue coverage of the hand

Hand aesthetics in general and aesthetic refinements of soft-tissue coverage of the hand in particular have been increasingly considered over the past few years. Advancements of microsurgery together with the traditional methods of tissue transfer have expanded the number of techniques available to the reconstructive surgeon, thus shifting the reconstructive paradigm from simply "filling the defect" to reconstructive refinement to provide the best functional and aesthetic results. However, drawing the boundary between what does and what does not constitute "aesthetic" reconstruction of the hand is not straightforward. The selection among the vast amount of currently available reconstructive methods and the difficulties in objectively measuring or quantifying aesthetics have made this task complex and rather arbitrary. In this article, the authors divide the hand into several units and subunits to simplify the understanding of the basic functional and aesthetic requirements of these regions that may ultimately bring order to complexity.

Functional reconstruction of subtotal thumb metacarpal defect with a vascularized medial femoral condyle flap: case report

Devastating hand injuries require customized reconstructive strategies to maximize functional outcomes. We report a case of thumb metacarpal reconstruction using a vascularized medial femoral condyle osteocutaneous flap in the setting of nearly complete metacarpal loss. In addition to achieving the traditional goals of reconstructing thumb length and providing stability, the medial femoral condyle flap allowed motion at the carpometacarpal joint. The patient's hand function was further optimized by a component transfer of a proximally injured but distally preserved index finger to the amputated middle finger position. The patient regained satisfactory grip and thumb function with minimal donor site morbidity. This case highlights the role of both creative and established approaches to reconstruct composite tissues following devastating hand injury.

Toe-to-hand transfer: evolving indications and relevant outcomes

Toe-to-hand transfer is indicated for many types of congenital and traumatic thumb absences. This review will highlight the applications of toe-to-hand transfer and their functional, aesthetic, and psychosocial outcomes. Despite its technical complexity, toe to hand reconstruction techniques can provide an elegant option to restore function for patients with difficult hand disabilities.

Treatment of thumb soft-tissue defects using a bipedicle island flap of the index finger: anatomical basis and clinical application

PURPOSE

Reconstruction of the thumb with exposure of bone and tendon is challenging. We designed a bipedicle island flap from the dorsum of the index finger to repair thumb defects. One pedicle includes the radial proper palmar digital artery (PDA) of the index finger, another pedicle includes the first dorsal metacarpal artery (FDMA). The aim of the study was to investigate the anatomical basis and clinical application of this flap.

METHODS

Eleven fresh cadaver hands were dissected, the FDMA and the radial proper PDA were exposed. Their origin, distribution and diameter in different locations, especially in the dorsum of the proximal phalanx of the index finger, were examined. Ten patients (11 hands) underwent thumb reconstruction using this flap. During follow-up, the flap survival and hand function were evaluated.

RESULTS

The origin of the FDMA in three cadaver hands was abnormal. The FDMA was mainly distributed in the proximal area of the dorsum of the proximal phalanx. The radial proper PDA of the index finger formed one constant dorsal branch, mainly distributing in the middle and distal area of the dorsum of the proximal phalanx. All flaps survived. At follow-up, the span of the first web and the range of motion of the thumbs and index fingers reached more than 94 % of the contralateral finger. All patients were satisfied with the hand function according to the Michigan Hand Outcomes Questionnaire (MHQ).

CONCLUSIONS

The bipedicle island flap has two arterial systems to provide sufficient blood supply. This technique provides another option for thumb reconstruction when a large supercharged FDMA island flap needs to be designed, or when there is an additional injury to the radial side of the dorsum of the hand or if there are anatomical variations of the FDMA, or if damage to the FDMA occurs during surgery.

A systematic review of outcomes of toe-to-thumb transfers for isolated traumatic thumb amputation

BACKGROUND

Toe-to-thumb transfer is an established procedure for reconstruction of traumatic thumb amputations. The four types of toe-to-thumb transfers are the second toe, the great toe, the wrap-around great toe and the trimmed great toe transfers. The purpose of this study is to conduct a systematic review of the literature to compare outcomes amongst different methods of toe-to-thumb transfers.

METHODS

A literature search using 'toe-to-thumb transfer' combined with 'thumb injury' and 'thumb reconstruction' as keywords and limited to humans and the English language identified 633 studies. Studies were included in the review if they: (1) present primary data, (2) report three or more toe-to-thumb transfers for isolated complete traumatic thumb amputation between the metacarpophalangeal joint and the interphalangeal joint (both excluded) and (3) present functional outcome data.

RESULTS

Twenty-five studies representing 450 toe-to-thumb transfers met the inclusion criteria. They included 101 second toe transfers, 196 great toe transfers, 122 wrap-around transfers and 31 trimmed toe transfers. The mean survival rate was 96.4%. No statistically significant differences could be detected between the four transfers with regards to survival, arc of motion, total active motion, grip and pinch strength and static two-point discrimination.

CONCLUSIONS

All four types of toe transfer procedures have predictably high survival rates and good patient satisfaction scores. The current data are inadequate to make any comments with regards to donor site morbidity. Till such data are available, an evidence-based recommendation for the superiority of a specific type of toe-to-thumb transfer cannot be made.