The use of tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove indices based on joint size in lower limb evaluation

Tibial Tubercle-Trochlear Groove Distance Has Better Diagnostic Reliability Than Tubercle-Posterior Cruciate Ligament Distance For Predicting Patellar Instability: A Systematic Review

OBJECTIVE

The tibial tubercle-trochlear groove (TT-TG) distance is now routinely utilized to help determine whether a realignment procedure is necessary for patients with patellar instability. The tibial tubercle-posterior cruciate ligament (TT-PCL) distance has been explored as an alternative measurement. The aim of this study is to compare the reliability of TT-TG and TT-PCL; to explore whether there is a relationship between the TT-PCL and the TT-TG distance; to determine whether there is a relationship between the TT-TG and TT-PCL distances and knee rotation; and to compare the abilities of the TT-PCL distance and the TT-TG distance with predicted patellar instability.

METHOD

This systematic review was performed in accordance with PRISMA guidelines. Three databases, PubMed, EMBASE, and Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, were searched from inception to September 2021 to identify clinical studies comparing TT-TG and TT-PCL distances to patellar instability. Data on patient baseline characteristics, TT-TG and TT-PCL distances, inter-observer reliability, and area under the receiver-operating characteristic curve (AUC) were recorded. The methodological quality of the studies was assessed using the quality assessment form recommended by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ).

RESULT

Twenty studies were included in the final analysis, comprising 2330 knees from 2260 patients. The current study showed that TT-TG and TT-PCL have similar observer reliability. The inter- and intra-observer reliability of TT-TG ranged from 0.807 to 0.98 and 0.553 to 0.99, respectively. The inter- and intra-observer reliability of TT-PCL ranged from 0.553 to 0.99 and 0.88 to 0.981, respectively. Six studies compared the AUC for predicting patellar instability and showed that TT-TG had better predictive performance than TT-PCL. Three studies reported a correlation between TT-TG and knee rotation, but no such relationship was found for TT-PCL. Eight studies reported a weak or moderate correlation between TT-TG and TT-PCL.

CONCLUSION

TT-TG and TT-PCL have similar inter- and intra-rater reliability (as measured by ICC), but TT-TG has greater discriminatory power to predict patellar instability than TT-PCL (as measured by AUC values and odds ratio). However, considering trochlear dysplasia and individual variations, future studies need to find more accurate and individualized methods to predict patellar instability.

Assessment of the reliability and validity of imaging measurements for patellofemoral instability: an updated systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To provide an update on the reliability and validity of all radiological measures used to assess patients presenting with patellofemoral instability.

METHODS

A search of the CINHAL, EMBASE, MEDLINE, and SCOPUS databases and the Cochrane library was conducted. All studies assessing the validity, reliability, sensitivity, and specificity of radiological measures of the patellofemoral joints of patients with patellofemoral instability from 2010 onwards were considered for inclusion. Discrimination validity, inter- and intra-observer reliability, and the sensitivity and specificity of specific imaging measures were evaluated.

RESULTS

Seventy-three studies met the selection criteria and were included for analysis. We identified eight radiological measures in four categories with good reliability and validity: the tibial tubercle to trochlear groove distance, specific measures of patellar height (Blackburne-Peel index, Caton-Deschamps index and Insall-Salvati ratios), three measures of trochlear dysplasia (sulcus angle, trochlear depth, and lateral trochlear inclination), and the tibial tubercle to posterior cruciate ligament distance. No included studies examined the reliability and validity of patellofemoral instability ultrasound measures.

CONCLUSION

Our updated review demonstrated good inter- and intra-observer reliability and discrimination validity for the tibial tubercle-trochlear groove distance, specific patellar height, and trochlear dysplasia measures on MRI. The tibial tubercle to posterior cruciate ligament distance, an indirect measure of rotational asymmetry, was a valid and reliable measure on MRI. Due to a lack of assessments across more than one study, there are a variety of proposed measures with insufficient evidence to determine their validity, reliability, sensitivity, and specificity.

Higher pathologic threshold of increased tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance should be considered for taller patients

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the correlation between tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance (TT-TG) and body height or knee size, and to find height-related pathologic thresholds of increased TT-TG.

METHODS

One-hundred and fifty-three patients with recurrent patellar instability and 151 controls were included. The TT-TG was measured on axial computed tomography (CT) images. Femora width and tibial width were selected to represent knee size. The correlation of TT-TG and gender, body height, femora width, and tibial width was evaluated. The height-related pathologic threshold of increased TT-TG was produced according to Dejour's method. To combine TT-TG with body height and knee size, three new indexes were introduced, ratio of TT-TG to body height (RTH), ratio of TT-TG to femoral width (RTF), and ratio of TT-TG to tibial width (RTT). The ability to predict patellar instability was assessed by the receiver-operating characteristic (ROC) curve, odds ratios (ORs), sensitivity, and specificity.

RESULTS

In patients with patellar instability, TT-TG showed significantly correlation with patient height, femoral width, and tibial width respectively (range r = 0.266-0.283). This correlation was not found in the control group. The pathologic threshold of TT-TG was 18 mm in patients < 169 cm (53%), and the mean TT-TG was 21 mm in patients ≥ 169 cm (54%). There was significant difference in RTH, RTF, and RTT between the two groups. RTH, RTF and RTT have similar large area under the curve (AUC) with TT-TG.

CONCLUSIONS

TT-TG showed significant correlation with body height and knee size, respectively. The pathologic threshold of increased TT-TG was suggested to be 21 mm for patients [Formula: see text] 169 cm and 18 mm for patients [Formula: see text] 169 cm. Body height-related pathologic threshold provided a supplement for indications of tibial tuberosity medialization.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

IV.

Tibial Tubercle-Trochlear Groove/Trochlear Width Is the Optimal Indicator for Diagnosing a Lateralized Tibial Tubercle in Recurrent Patellar Dislocation Requiring Surgical Stabilization

PURPOSE

To identify the individualized method of quantifying lateralization of the tibial tubercle with the best diagnostic effectiveness, as evaluated by measurement repeatability using the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), the size of the difference between the case group and the control group, and receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve analysis.

METHODS

Patients who had undergone surgery for recurrent patellar dislocation (the case group) and patients who had no history of patellar dislocation (the control group) from January 2014 to December 2019 were included in the study. Six indices that describe lateralization of the tibial tubercle were calculated using either computed tomography (CT) or magnetic resonance imaging (MRI): tibial tubercle lateralization (TTL), tibial tubercle-trochlear groove (TT-TG) ratio, tibial tubercle-posterior cruciate ligament (TT-PCL) ratio, TT-TG index, (TT-TG)/patellar width (PW), and (TT-TG)/trochlear width (TW). Diagnostic effectiveness was evaluated by 1) intra-rater reliability (measurements on two occasions) and inter-rater reliability (measurements by two assessors) using the ICC, 2) the size of the difference between the case group and the control group, and 3) ROC curve analysis, measuring the area under the ROC curve (AUC) and the post hoc power.

RESULTS

100 knees in 88 patients who had undergone surgery for recurrent patellar dislocation and 55 knees in 53 patients who had no history of patellar dislocation were analyzed. The ICC for all the methods were higher than .75. The mean differences between the case group and the control group for TTL, TT-TG ratio, TT-PCL ratio, TT-TG index, (TT-TG)/PW, and (TT-TG)/TW were 2%, 8%, 2%, 12%, 24% and 56%, respectively. The mean differences between the case group and the control group for (TT-TG)/TW was significantly greater than those for the other methods (P < .0001, unpaired t-test). AUC of TTL, TT-TG ratio, TT-PCL ratio, TT-TG index, (TT-TG)/PW, and (TT-TG)/TW were .708, .880, .630, .814, .882, and .905. AUC of (TT-TG)/TW was significantly greater than those of TTL and TT-PCL ratio (P < .0001). The post hoc power for TT-PCL ratio, TT-TG index, (TT-TG)/PW, TT-TG ratio, (TT-TG)/TW, and TTL were 78%, 81%, 88%, 88%, 91%, and 71%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

Of the six indices evaluated in this study, (TT-TG)/TW showed the greatest mean difference between the two groups, had the greatest diagnostic utility (as measured by AUC values) and had excellent inter-rater and intra-rater reliability (as measured by ICCs). Thus, it may be the best individualized index for diagnosing a lateralized tibial tubercle in patients with recurrent patellar dislocation requiring surgical stabilization compared to patients with no history of patellar dislocation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, diagnostic study, retrospective cohort study.

Editorial Commentary: The Best Index to Determine Whether to Medialize the Tibial Tubercle In Patients With Patellar Instability May Be Tibial Tubercle to Trochlear Groove Distance/Trochlear Width, But Check the Intraoperative Patellar Tracking as Well

An excessively lateral tibial tubercle is a well-accepted risk factor for recurrent patellar dislocation. Generally, it is measured on magnetic resonance imaging as the TT-TG distance (tibial tubercle-trochlear groove distance), and recent meta-analyses have suggested that a value as low as 12.5 mm can be used as the threshold for deciding when to medialize the tibial tubercle. However, a problem with using the TT-TG distance is that it is influenced by the size of the knee. An individualized index helps overcomes this problem, and dividing the TT-TG distance by the trochlear width may be the most promising method. The suggested cut-off value of (TT-TG)/trochlear width is 0.572.

Tibial Tuberosity-Trochlear Groove Distance and Its Components in Patients with and without Episodic Patellar Dislocation: A Study of 781 Knees

BACKGROUND

The purposes of the present study were (1) to measure the tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance and its components with the knee in extension, (2) to determine their diagnostic performance in distinguishing between patients with and without episodic patellar dislocation, and (3) to investigate the relationship of each component to the total tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed computed tomography (CT) images of the knee joint in a group of patients with episodic patellar dislocation and a group of control subjects who were treated for another type of knee disorder in our institution between 2015 and 2021. Tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance, tibial tubercle lateralization, trochlear groove medialization, and knee rotation were measured on axial images. Partial correlation analysis of the measured parameters was performed after adjusting for remaining variables. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and the areas under the ROC curves (AUCs) were assessed to assess the diagnostic accuracy. A subgroup analysis based on femoral trochlear dysplasia classification was also performed.

RESULTS

After screening of 653 patients (947 knees) in our hospital's patient registry, a total of 521 patients (781 knees) were analyzed, including 541 knees (69.3%) with episodic patellar dislocation and 240 knees (30.7%) without episodic patellar dislocation (control group). The tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance demonstrated the best diagnostic performance, with the AUC being significantly better than that for other parameters (p < 0.001). The tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance was moderately to strongly correlated with knee rotation and trochlear groove medialization in the control and episodic patellar dislocation groups (p < 0.001). However, tibial tubercle lateralization showed a weak correlation with the tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance in the control group and moderate correlation in the episodic patellar dislocation group (p < 0.001). Knees with a type-D femoral trochlea had a significantly greater tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance than those with a type-A, B, or C femoral trochlea (p ≤ 0.011).

CONCLUSIONS

Tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance, a reliable predictor of episodic patellar dislocation, was affected more by knee rotation and trochlear groove medialization and was less affected by tibial tubercle lateralization, and it increased with an increasing grade of femoral trochlear dysplasia. The correlation of the tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance and its components as noted in the current study will help to achieve a better understanding of the tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Prognostic Level IV. See Instructions for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Abnormal femur rotation in patients with recurrent patellar dislocation: A study on upright standing three-dimensionally reconstructed EOS images

BACKGROUND

The measurements of lower extremity rotational deformities in patients with recurrent patellar dislocation (RPD) in the standing position are available with the application of the EOS imaging system. The aim of our case-control study was to identify the differences on the femur rotation between the supine and standing positions, and to investigate the differences of anatomical and functional femur rotation between RPD patients and controls.

METHODS

Thirty-five lower extremities affected by RPD from 30 patients and 27 intact lower extremities from 27 controls with acute meniscus tear or anterior cruciate ligament injury were recruited. Anatomical femoral anteversion (AFA), functional femoral anteversion (FFA), femorotibial rotation (FTR) and distal femoral torsion (DFT) of all subjects were measured with the EOS imaging system. Computed tomography scans were carried out to analyze the AFA and FFA in the supine position in PRD patients. The differences in FFA between supine and standing position and in AFA, FTR and DFT between RPD and controls were analyzed. The predictor importance of each variable on RPD was observed after cluster analysis.

RESULTS

The EOS images were available in all subjects. The FFA was significantly smaller in the standing position than in the supine position (P < 0.05) in RPD patients. When comparing with the controls, RPD patients showed higher AFA, FTR and DFT (P < 0.05) but comparable FFA (P < 0.05). The cluster model prompted that FTR and DFT had higher predictor importance than AFA.

CONCLUSION

Larger AFA but comparable FFA in patients with RPD than the controls in an upright standing position suggested more internally rotated distal femur in the RPD patients. AFA may be inadequate and FFA should also be considered while planning the treatment for RPD. DFT and FTR should be taken into consideration when evaluating the abnormalities in femur rotation in RPD patients.

The patellofemoral morphology and the normal predicted value of tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove distance in the Chinese population

Background

Our objective was to obtain normal patellofemoral measurements to analyse sex and individual differences. In addition, the absolute values and indices of tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove (TT-TG) distances are still controversial in clinical application. A better method to enable precise prediction is still needed.

Methods

Seventy-eight knees of 78 participants without knee pathologies were included in this cross-sectional study. A CT scan was conducted for all participants and three-dimensional knee models were constructed using Mimics and SolidWorks software. We measured and analysed 19 parameters including the TT-TG distance and dimensions and shapes of the patella, femur, tibia, and trochlea. LASSO regression was used to predict the normal TT-TG distances.

Results

The dimensional parameters, TT-TG distance, and femoral aspect ratio of the men were significantly larger than those of women (all p values < 0.05). However, after controlling for the bias from age, height, and weight, there were no significant differences in TT-TG distances and anterior-posterior dimensions between the sexes (all p values > 0.05). The Pearson correlation coefficients between the anterior femoral offset and other indexes were consistently below 0.3, indicating no relationship or a weak relationship. Similar results were observed for the sulcus angle and the Wiberg index. Using LASSO regression, we obtained four parameters to predict the TT-TG distance (R² = 0.5612, p < 0.01) to achieve the optimal accuracy and convenience.

Conclusions

Normative data of patellofemoral morphology were provided for the Chinese population. The anterior-posterior dimensions of the women were thicker than those of men for the same medial-lateral dimensions. More attention should be paid to not only sex differences but also individual differences, especially the anterior condyle and trochlea. In addition, this study provided a new method to predict TT-TG distances accurately.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12891-021-04454-8.

Tibial tuberosity-tibial intercondylar midpoint distance measured on computed tomography scanner is not biased during knee rotation and could be clinically more relevant than current measurement systems

PURPOSE

The purpose of this retrospective cross-sectional case-control study was to evaluate an alternative imaging test for lateralization of the tibial tuberosity, unbiased towards knee rotation.

METHODS

On axial CT images of 129 knees, classified as cases (two or more patellar luxations) and controls (no patellar luxations), two raters gauged the standard tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove (TT-TG) distance, tibial tuberosity-femoral intercondylar midpoint (TT-FIM) distance, and new tibial tuberosity-tibial intercondylar midpoint (TT-TIM) distance singly, and knee longitudinal rotation angles (LRAs), and the presence of femoral trochlear dysplasia (FTD) jointly.

RESULTS

All imaging tests intercorrelated and discriminated between stability groups. TT-TIM had the lowest values with the highest precision. Though poorly, TT-TG and TT-FIM negatively correlated with age and LRAs regarding femur, but positively with presence of FTD, whereas TT-TIM was unbiased. The accuracy of TT-TG (> 20 mm), TT-FIM (> 20 mm), and TT-TIM (> 13 mm) was good with almost perfect reproducibility. Only TT-TIM was sex-biased (p = 0.009), with > 12 mm cut-off in females and (presumably) > 14 mm in males.

CONCLUSION

TT-TIM is an alternative imaging test for lateralization of the tibial tuberosity, unbiased towards knee rotation.

Tibial Tubercle-Trochlear Groove Distance Is a Reliable and Accurate Indicator of Patellofemoral Instability

BACKGROUND

Tibial tubercle-trochlear groove (TT-TG) distance is a measurement generally made on CT scans that is commonly used to quantify the risk of patellofemoral instability (PFI); however, its interrater reliability and accuracy as an indicator of PFI in patients is poorly characterized.

QUESTIONS/PURPOSES

The purposes of our study were (1) to primarily analyze interrater reliability of the TT-TG distance among orthopaedists with varied experience as measured by MRI, (2) to secondarily compare TT-TG distances between PFI and control groups, and (3) to determine an accurate TT-TG distance threshold indicative of PFI.

METHODS

The electronic medical records of a senior fellowship-trained orthopaedic sports medicine surgeon were surveyed between 2012 and 2016 for patients who had experienced at least one episode of patellar subluxation or dislocation, who reported no other knee-related history, and who underwent MRI due to persistent PFI signs and symptoms. The records of 48 PFI patients (23 males, 25 females; 19 ± 4 years of age) were compared with 83 controls (60 males, 23 females; 31 ± 8 years of age) having no history of PFI, presenting with an isolated meniscal lesion as determined from MRI and treated by the same orthopaedist during this time. All records meeting study criteria were consecutively included to offset selection bias of the retrospective analysis. Two sports medicine fellows, one who had just completed orthopaedic residency training, and another with a year of experience after residency, and a sports medicine subspecialist with more than 15 years of experience in practice independently recorded TT-TG distance, indicative of tibial tubercle lateralization relative to the femoral trochlea, to the nearest millimeter (mm) in a blinded and randomized fashion. Intraclass correlation coefficient computed interrater reliability accompanied by standard error of measurement (SEM); a one-tailed, two-sample t-test analyzed group differences with accompanying effect size per Cohen's d; receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve determined accuracy and threshold for PFI risk. A p value < 0.05 denoted statistical significance.

RESULTS

Interrater reliability was excellent, at 0.93 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.84-0.97; SEM = 0.6 mm) for PFI patients and 0.95 (95% CI, 0.91-0.97; SEM = 0.4 mm) for controls. Distance was greater (95% CI, 2-5; p < 0.001) in PFI patients (14 ± 4 mm; range = 7-24 mm) than controls (10 ± 3 mm; range = 3-19 mm) with an effect size of 1 (95% CI, 0.3-2). Area under the ROC curve was 0.75 (95% CI, 0.66-0.83) and threshold was 13 mm (sensitivity = 0.52, 1-specificity = 0.25), suggesting the measure is a fairly accurate indicator of risk and values of 13 mm or greater are better suited to rule in PFI. Respective positive and negative likelihood ratios of 2 and 0.6 at this threshold confirm that this distance yields a small increase in probability for PFI and a minimal decrease in probability for risk; specifically, a 13-mm TT-TG distance is two times more likely to be found in patients with PFI. Furthermore, this threshold is estimated to increase a correct PFI diagnosis by approximately 15%.

CONCLUSIONS

The MRI-specific TT-TG distance, based on a single measurement using cartilaginous-tendon landmarks within a standardized trochlear range, is reliable as performed by orthopaedists of varied experience. Patients with PFI display a 4-mm greater distance than controls, which may represent a difference large enough for clinicians to discern in practice using MRI. A 13-mm TT-TG distance is two times more likely seen in patients with PFI. However, this threshold increases a correct PFI diagnosis by only about 15%; therefore, clinical decision-making should not be influenced by this criterion alone and instead used in conjunction with other relevant variables.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, diagnostic study.

Preoperative planning of tibial tubercle medialisation according to the trochlear groove angle

The tibial tubercle-trochlear groove distance (TT-TG) was first described four decades ago. Since then, a considerable body of research has become available on the pathophysiology of chronic patellar instability, whose diagnosis and treatment remain challenging. Tibial tubercle medialisation can correct an abnormal TT-TG. Preoperative planning based on the TT-TG and trochlear angle may avoid both under-correction inducing persistent instability and overcorrection responsible for pain. Preoperative planning should be patient-specific. With appropriate preoperative planning, compensation for moderate trochlear dysplasia can be achieved without any additional procedure.

Medial patellofemoral ligament reconstruction fails to correct mild patella alta in cases of patellofemoral instability-a case-control study

PURPOSE

Medial patellofemoral ligament reconstruction (MPFL-R) is the gold standard in patella soft tissue surgery for patellofemoral instability. Although claimed, recent reports indicate that MPFL-R may fail to distalize the patella in mild cases of patella alta. The present study is a retrospective case-control study to compare radiographic patella height between MPFL-R and historical Insall's proximal realignment (IPR) pre- and post-operatively with respect to distalization and assess redislocation rates at a mid-term follow-up.

METHODS

Sixty-four patients were age/sex matched (1:1), yielding 32 patients for group 1 MPFL-R (cases) and 32 patients for group 2 IPR (controls). Insall-Salvati, Blackburne-Peel and Caton-Deschamps indices were analyzed for differences pre- and post-operatively. An additional inter-rater reliability analysis was performed by means of intra-class correlation (ICC). Redislocation rates were considered as treatment failures in this study.

RESULTS

ICC was excellent for all three patella indices. MPFL-R failed to show significant differences if compared to IPR with respect to distalization in mild stages of patella alta. Moreover, redislocation rates significantly favored MPFL-R (3.1%) over IPR (12.5%; p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

MPFL-R has become a popular option to restore native patellofemoral biomechanics after ligament rupture. However, the procedure's potential to correct concomitant patella alta should not be overestimated and indications considered carefully.

Effects of knee flexion and extension on the tibial tuberosity-trochlear groove (TT-TG) distance in adolescents

Background

Measurement of the tibial tubercle–trochlear groove (TT–TG) distance is used to assess patellofemoral instability and rotation. Since patellofemoral instability and acute patellar dislocation are common among adolescents, it is important to clarify the relationship between TT–TG distance and various flexion and extension angles in asymptomatic children. The purpose of the present study was to determine how knee flexion and extension influence TT–TG-distance values measured using 3D imaging in an anatomic axial plane among asymptomatic adolescents.

Methods

We performed magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of 26 knees in 13 adolescents (8 boys and 5 girls) of 11–17 years of age, with no known patellofemoral disorders. Imaging was performed with 3.0 T MRI with the knee at four separate angles of flexion between 0° and 30°. Measurements were made by two independent blinded raters.

Results

The mean TT–TG distance in millimetres was 11.1–0.29 × the angle in degrees. TT–TG distance decreased with greater flexion, showing a mean decrease of 0.29 mm (SD, 0.04) per degree of increased flexion (p < 0.001). We found significant inter-observer (Pearson’s r = 0.636, p = 0.03) and intra-observer (Pearson’s r = 0.792, p ≤ 0.001) correlations. TT–TG values were not significantly correlated with age, length, weight, or body mass index. The rate of TT–TG change (change between consecutive TT–TG values/change between consecutive angles) was significantly negatively correlated with length (p = 0.014), weight (p = 0.004), and body mass index (p = 0.025).

Conclusions

Our data revealed that TT–TG distance assessed in the anatomic axial plane decreased with greater flexion in adolescent. Moreover, this effect of knee angle was stronger in smaller subjects. These findings support the need for a standardized protocol for TT–TG distance measurement in adolescents.