Atlas posterior arch and vertebral artery’s groove variants: a classification, morphometric study, clinical and surgical implications

Thickness Asymmetry of the Vertebral Artery Groove: A Dried Vertebrae Study

BACKGROUND

The vertebral artery groove (VAG), located on the posterior arch of the first cervical (atlas) vertebra plays a pivotal role in guiding the vertebral artery's (VA) third part (V3). Deviations in VAG morphology and morphometry (dimensions) can influence vascular dynamics and pose clinical implications.

AIM

The current study delves into the morphometric variants and explores the less-explored morphometric variable of the VAG thickness, highlighting possible laterality (asymmetry).

METHODS

A morphometric investigation was conducted on 141 dried atlas (73 male and 68 female) vertebrae from a Greek adult population. The VAG's minimum thickness was investigated by considering the laterality (sides' differences), gender, and age impact on it. Measurements were performed by two independent researchers, ensuring the data reliability.

RESULTS

A significant asymmetry was identified in the VAG thickness between the left (3.9 ± 0.9 mm) and right (4.1 ± 1.1 mm) (p=0.005) sides, with the left side having the mean minimum thickness. Gender had a significant impact on VAG thickness only on the left side, with females presenting a significantly thinner left-sided VAG (3.6 ± 0.9 mm) than males (4.10 ± 0.7 mm) (p=0.001). Age had no significant impact on the VAG thickness.  Conclusion: The present study underscores the significance of asymmetry in the VAG thickness in craniocervical interventions. This less-explored morphometric variable warrants careful consideration by surgeons during preoperative planning to minimize potential complications. The current findings highlight the importance of understanding the VAG thickness asymmetry and its clinical implications, as this osseous variable may be an index of a different diameter of the VA by side. It is recommended that surgeons incorporate this variable into their preoperative assessments to improve the safety and efficacy of craniocervical interventions.

Systematic review and meta-analysis of the prevalence of the retrotransverse foramen of the atlas

The retrotransverse foramen (RTF) is a nonmetric variant of the atlas vertebra that can accommodate an anastomotic vertebral vein and occipital nerve. An understanding of this variation and its occurrence is crucial, as it could aid in explanation of the unidentified cause of the high prevalence of variability in this region. The aim of this meta-analysis was to obtain data on the prevalence of the RTF and its variations according to anatomy, sex, and ethnicity. A large-scale search was conducted through the major online databases to establish and determine the pool of studies reporting data relevant to the RTF. No date or language restrictions were applied. The data collection was categorized by prevalence, type (incomplete/complete), side, sex, ethnicity, laterality, and diameter. A total of 17 studies (n = 1979 subjects) were incorporated into our analysis. The overall pooled prevalence for a complete RTF was 11.4% and the overall pooled prevalence of an incomplete (partial) RTF was 9.6%. A complete RTF was most prevalent in Africa (Sub-Saharan population) (12.1%), followed by Europe (11.8%) and Asia (9.7%). As this variant occurs in a significant number of patients in all of the aforementioned populations, recognition, and awareness, especially with thorough investigation with computer tomography angiography (CTA) should be implemented, as it is the only possible way to visualize the possible contents of RTF.

Prevalence of Ponticulus Posticus and Migraine in 220 Orthodontic Patients: A Cross-Sectional Study

BACKGROUND

Ponticulus posticus (PP) is a medical term that describes an anomaly of the atlas (C1), which has a complete or partial bone bridge over the vertebral artery (VA) groove. The purpose of the study is to estimate the prevalence of PP in patients with a diagnosis of migraine.

METHODS

Cone beam CT (CBCT) scans (n = 220) were reviewed for the detection of PP in the University "G. D'Annunzio" of Chieti in the Department of Medical, Oral and Biotechnological Sciences. The sample included 220 Italian patients between 18 and 87 years. Pearson chi-square analysis (p < 0.05 and 95% CI) was used to establish an association between migraine and PP.

RESULTS

The present study found a prevalence of PP of 20.9% and a prevalence of migraine of 12.272%. The association between migraine and PP was confirmed by the chi-square statistic, since the p-value was 0.008065 (significant at p < 0.05). PP was more frequent in the migraine without aura group, without a statistical difference relative to the migraine with aura group.

CONCLUSIONS

The study concluded that PP is positively associated with migraine.

The morphological classification and clinical significance of atlas vertebral artery sulcus based on computed tomography three-dimensional reconstruction

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to research the morphological classification and clinical significance of vertebral artery sulcus on atlas based on CT three-dimensional reconstruction.

METHODS

Three-dimensional reconstruction images of 300 adult atlases were collected. A total of 600 atlas vertebral artery sulci were selected in this study. The parameters required for placement of C1 pedicle screw, including depth of grinding drilling (ao), width (cd), length ab), height (H), lateral wall thickness (L1), inner wall thickness (L2), medial angle (∠α), and the cephalad angle to the transverse plane of atlas pedicle (∠β), were measured.

RESULTS

CT three-dimensional reconstruction images showed that there were five types of atlas vertebral artery sulci: no process type (n = 494 cases, 82.33%), upper process type (n = 29, 4.83%), lower process type (n = 25, 4.17%), double process type (n = 19, 3.17%), and posterior ring type (33, 5.50%). One-way ANOVA tests showed that the five groups differed significantly in the parameter of ao, L2, H, ∠α and ∠β. One-way ANOVA with the LSD post hoc tests showed that the parameter ao of the group of no process type was less than that of the group of upper or lower process type (P < 0.05), and ao of the group of lower process or posterior ring type was less than that of the group of the upper type (P < 0.05). The parameter of ao of the male group was larger than that of the female group.

CONCLUSION

No process type of the atlas vertebral artery sulcus was the most common, and the medial angle and cephalad angle of the atlas pedicle in this type were the smallest. When pedicle screws are inserted, the above two angles should not be too large. Male's ao was larger than that of female's. All these findings should be considered to avoid the deviation of the nail track.

Biomechanical analysis of odontoid and transverse atlantal ligament in humans with ponticulus posticus variation under different loading conditions: Finite element study

PURPOSE

Ponticulus posticus (PP) is a variation of the bone bridge that appears in the first cervical vertebra and through which the vertebral artery passes. Odontoid fractures are common spinal bone fractures in older people. This study aims to investigate the effect of neck movements on the odontoid and transverse atlantal ligament (TAL) of people with PP variation from a biomechanical view.

METHOD

C1, C2, and C3 vertebrae of the occipital bone were analyzed using the finite element method (FEM). In this study, solid models were created with the help of normal (N), incomplete (IC), and asymmetric complete (AC) PP tomography images. The necessary elements for the models were assigned, and the material properties were defined for the elements. As boundary conditions, models were fixed from the C3 vertebra, and 74 N loading was applied from the occipital bone. Stress and deformation values in the odontoid and transverse atlantal ligament were obtained by applying 1.8 Nm moment in flexion, extension, bending, and axial rotation directions.

RESULTS

The stress and deformation values of all three models in odontoid and TAL were obtained, and numerical results were evaluated. In all models, stress and deformation values were obtained in decreasing order in rotation, bending, extension, and flexion movements. The highest stress and strain values were obtained in AC and the lowest values were obtained in N. In all movements of the three models, the stress and deformation values obtained in the TAL were lower than in the odontoid.

CONCLUSION

The greatest stresses and deformations obtained in spines (AC) with PP were found in the odontoid. This may help explain the pathogenesis of odontoid fractures in older people. First, this study explains the mechanism of the formation of neck trauma in people with PP and the need for a more careful evaluation of the direction of impact. Secondly, the study reveals that the rotational motion of the neck independent of PP has more negative effects on the odontoid.

Prevalence of ponticulus posticus on the posterior arch of the atlas in symptomatic and asymptomatic patients

OBJECTIVE

To calculate the prevalence of ponticulus posticus and its association with headache.

METHODS

The presence and types of ponticulus posticus were investigated on 640 digital lateral cephalograms. Patients with complete or partial ponticulus posticus were further evaluated and questioned for a history of cervicogenic headache. Dissemination of attain values was analyzed using a Chi-Square test, and p values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

The prevalence of ponticulus posticus in our study was 9.8%, with complete form in 45 (7%) patients of which 29 (64.5%) were male and 16 (35.5%) were female. Partial ponticulus posticus was found in 18 (2.8%) of patients, of which 12 (66.6%) patients were male and six (33.33%) were female. In patients with the complete form of ponticulus posticus, 37 (82.22%) were symptomatic. Among these 37 patients, 22 (59.45%) were male and 15 (40.54%) were female. In complete ponticulus posticus patients, symptoms were slightly worse in males than females. Whereas in partial ponticulus posticus, 13 (72.22%) patients were found to be symptomatic. Of these 13 patients, seven (53.84%) were male and six (46.15%) were female. Of the 72 patients with a history of cervical pain, 50 (69.44%) showed ponticulus posticus on a lateral cephalogram. Of the 568 patients with no history of cervical pain, only 13 (2.2%) showed ponticulus posticus on the lateral cephalogram.

CONCLUSION

This study examination showed that ponticulus posticus is a common anatomic variation often associated with tension-type headaches.

Research Progress of Ponticulus Posticus: A Narrative Literature Review

Study Design

Narrative review.

Objective

The purpose of this review was to consolidate the current literature related to ponticulus posticus (PP) and to improve the systematic understanding of this anatomical variant of atlas among spine surgeons.

Methods

Articles reviewed were searched in PubMed, Ovid MEDLINE, and Embase. All articles of any study design discussing on PP were considered for inclusion. Two independent authors read article titles and abstracts and included appropriate articles. The relevant articles were studied in full text.

Results

A total of 113 literatures were reviewed and consolidated in this narrative review. These articles are roughly divided into the following five subcategories: (1) epidemiology, (2) pathology and anatomy, (3) clinical presentation, (4) surgical significance, and (5) radiographic examination.

Conclusion

The PP is non-negligible with a high prevalence. The PP compresses the V3 segment of the artery, the suboccipital nerve, and the venous plexus, consequently contributing to the incidence of neurological pathologies. When a PP is observed or suspected on a lateral radiograph, we recommend that a computed tomography (CT) scan of a patient who is about to receive a C1 lateral mass screw (C1LMS) should be performed, which could determine a safe entry point and the right trajectory of screw insertion.

Accuracy of patient-specific drill guide template for bilateral C1-C2 laminar screw placement: a cadaveric study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the accuracy of using patient-specific drill guides to place bilateral laminar screws in C1 and C2.

METHODS

Nine cervical specimens (8 male; mean age: 66.6 (56-73)) with the occiput attached (C0-C3) were used in this study. Pre-operative CT scans were used to create digital anatomic models for templating and guide creation. A total of 36 screws were placed with the aid of 3D printed patient-specific guides (2 screws at C1 and C2). Post-operative CT scans were performed following screw insertion. The planned and actual trajectories were compared using pre- and post-operative imaging based on the angular and entry point deviation. After screw placement and post-operative imaging, each specimen was dissected and performed a visual inspection for breaches.

RESULTS

No breaches or violations were observed on post-procedure CT and visual inspection. The average variation of the entry point in the X, Y, and Z-axis was 0.3±0.28, 0.41±0.38, and 0.29±0.24, respectively. No statistically significant difference (p>0.05) was observed between the planned and obtained entry points. There was no significant difference (p>0.05) in the deviation analysis between the planned and obtained angles in the axial and coronal planes.

CONCLUSION

The study demonstrates that patient-specific drill guides allow for accurate C1 and C2 bilateral laminar screw placement, with a low risk of cortical breach.

Morphometric Anatomy of the Posterior Aspect of the Atlas and the Vertebral Artery Groove in Relation to Lateral Mass Screw Placement

BACKGROUND

 Atlantoaxial instability is an important disorder that causes serious symptoms such as difficulties in walking, limited neck mobility, sensory deficits, etc. Atlantal lateral mass screw fixation is a surgical technique that has gained important recognition and popularity. Because accurate drilling area for screw placement is of utmost importance for a successful surgery, we aimed to investigate morphometry of especially the posterior part of C1.

METHODS

 One hundred and fifty-eight human adult C1 dried vertebrae were obtained. Measurements were performed directly on dry atlas vertebrae, and all parameters were measured by using a digital caliper accurate to 0.01 mm for linear measurements.

RESULTS

 The mean distance between the tip of the posterior arch and the medial inner edge of the groove was found to be 10.59 ± 2.26 and 10.49 ± 2.20 mm on the right and left, respectively. The mean distance between the tip of the posterior arch and the anterolateral outer edge of the groove was 21.27 ± 2.28 mm (right: 20.96 ± 2.22 mm; left: 21.32 ± 2.27 mm). The mean height of the screw entry zone on the right and left sides, respectively, were 3.86 ± 0.81 and 3.84 ± 0.77 mm. The mean width of the screw entry zone on both sides was 13.15 ± 1.17 and 13.25 ± 1.3 mm.

CONCLUSION

 Our result provided the literature with a detailed database for the morphometry of C1, especially in relation to the vertebral artery groove. We believe that the data in the present study can help surgeons to adopt a more accurate approach in terms of accurate lateral mass screw placement in atlantoaxial instability.

Arterial Vascular Structures Running Through Retrotransverse Foramen and Retrotransverse Groove of the Atlas Vertebrae

OBJECTIVE

Retrotransverse foramen (RTF) and retrotransverse groove (RTG) are anatomic variations of the atlas (C1) vertebrae. RTF contains an anastomotic vein connecting atlanto-occipital and atlanto-axodian venous sinuses. The purpose of this study was to analyze the arterial vascular structures running though the RTF and RTG.

METHODS

Three-dimensional volume rendered computed tomography angiography (3D VR CTA) images of 427 patients (264 men, 163 women; age 17-87 years) were reviewed and evaluated using the RadiAnt DICOM Viewer (version 5.0.2; Medixant, Poznan, Poland). The incidence of RTF or RTG, the incidence of the V3 segment of vertebral artery variants, and the artery vascular structures inside the RTF and RTG anatomic variation of C1 were analyzed.

RESULTS

Fifty (11.7%) atlases presented RTF anatomical variant; 113 (26.5%) atlases presented RTG anatomical variants. The incidence of the V3 segment of vertebral artery variants was 0.94% (4 of 427). Three (0.7%) were persistent first intersegmental artery and 1 (0.2%) was the fenestration of the vertebral artery on left side. In 4 cases of C1 vertebral artery V3 segmental variants, there were no RTF and RTG. No artery vascular structure was found in RTF or RTG.

CONCLUSIONS

The RTF or RTG of C1 was a common anatomical variant. No arterial vascular structure runs though the RTF or RTG. The presence of C1 RTF and RTG variants had no effect on the V3 segmental course of the vertebral artery. Preoperative understanding of these variations using 3D CTA are helpful for the safe execution of the upper cervical posterior approach surgeries.

An alternative way of C1 screwing: Supralaminar C1 lateral mass screws

Study Design:

This study involves literature review, technical note, and case series.

Objectives:

The objectives were to analyze indications and contraindications, advantages, and disadvantages for C1 lateral mass screw (LMS) insertion above or partially above the arch, to descript technical features, and to give examples of the practical application of this technique and investigated its safety.

Methods:

A literature review was carried out in English and Russian in PubMed, Google Scholar, and eLibrary databases. We selected four patients, treated in our clinic, which was carried out partially supralaminar C1 LMS.

Results:

Only three descriptions of supralaminar C1 LMS were found in the literature. Four adult patients underwent posterior C1–C2 screw fixation with C1 LMS along the superior edge of the C1 arch at our clinic. Partially supralaminar C1 screws were inserted on one of the sides due to the difficulties of using classical techniques. The main reasons for supralaminar screw fixation were narrow C1 lamina, hypertrophied venous plexus, and intraoperative failures of classic techniques application (broken screw trajectory, profuse venous bleeding from the plexus). The average follow-up time for the patients was 2.7 years, no complications were noted, and all had a satisfactory spinal fusion.

Conclusions:

The proposed types of C1 LMS above or partially above the C1 arch can be useful alternative method of C1 screwing in selected patients. Indications for the use of the supralaminar C1 LMS method can be narrow C1 posterior arch and pedicle, pronounced C1-C2 venous plexus, some V3 segment anomalies at C1 level, small arthritic inferior part of lateral mass, and intraoperative failures of classic techniques application.

Retrotransverse Foramen and Retrotransverse Groove Anatomic Variations of the Atlas Vertebra in the Chinese Population

OBJECTIVE

To analyze the prevalence of retrotransverse foramen (RTF) or retrotransverse groove (RTG) anatomic variations in Chinese atlas vertebra (C1).

METHODS

Three-dimensional volume-rendered computed tomography angiography images of 427 subjects (264 males, 163 females; 17-87 years old) were reviewed and evaluated using dedicated software. The prevalence of RTF and RTG anatomic variation of C1 was analyzed.

RESULTS

RTF anatomic variants were present in 50 (11.7%) atlases. Bilateral RTF, unilateral left RTF, and unilateral right RTF were present in 16 (3.8%), 20 (4.9%), and 14 (3.3%) vertebrae. Comparison between males and females revealed differences in bilateral RTF (P = 0.010) and unilateral left RTF (P = 0.008). RTG anatomic variants were present in 113 (26.5%) atlases. Bilateral RTG, unilateral left RTG, and unilateral right RTG were present in 39 (9.1%), 30 (7.0%), and 44 (10.3%) vertebrae. Comparison between males and females revealed differences in RTG (P = 0.000), bilateral RTG (P = 0.006), and unilateral left RTG (P = 0.034). RTF was detected in 36 cases on the left and 30 cases on the right. RTG was detected in 69 cases on the left and 79 cases on the right. There were no side differences in the prevalence of RTF and RTG.

CONCLUSIONS

The incidence of RTG is higher than the incidence of RTF. Incidence of bilateral RTF, bilateral RTG, unilateral left RTF, unilateral left RTG, and RTG differed between males and females. Preoperative understanding of these variations using three-dimensional computed tomography angiography is helpful for safe execution of upper cervical posterior approach surgery.