Flat panel CT following stapes prosthesis insertion: an experimental and clinical study

Titanium and Platinum-Fluoroplastic Stapes Prostheses Visualization on Cone Beam Computed Tomography and High-Resolution Computed Tomography

Objective: The aim of this study was to evaluate whether stapes prostheses can be visualized with less metal artifacts and therefore more accurately on cone beam computed tomography in comparison to computed tomography imaging. Recent studies have shown that cone beam computed tomography has advantages when imaging metal artifacts. Patients with hearing loss or vertigo, who have undergone stapedotomy, often present a challenge for otologic surgeons. Imaging studies can deliver crucial additional information. Methods: A retrospective analysis of imaging studies and clinical data in a tertiary care center were carried out. Forty-one patients with forty-five implanted ears were evaluated in the study. All included patients had been implanted with a platinum-fluoroplastic (n = 19) or titanium (n = 26) piston and subsequently had undergone imaging months or years after surgery for various reasons. Patients underwent computed tomography or cone beam computed tomography of the temporal bone depending on availability. Piston visualization, prosthesis length, vestibular intrusion and audiologic results were compared between the groups. Piston position on imaging studies were compared to intraoperative findings. Results: Functional length measurements of all prostheses were carried out with a mean error of -0.17 mm (±0.20). Platinum-fluoroplastic protheses were significantly underestimated in length compared to titanium prostheses. To analyze the material-dependent difference in the measurement errors of the imaging techniques the interaction was tested in an ANOVA model and showed no statistically significant result (p = 0.24). The blinded neuroradiologist viewed two implants, both platinum-fluoroplastic pistons, as located outside of the vestibule due to an underestimation of the prothesis length and the missing radiodensity of the lower end of the prosthesis. Conclusion: Surgeons and radiologists should be aware of the different types and radiologic features of stapes prostheses and the missing radiodensity of some protheses parts. Cone beam computed tomography is an imaging alternative with a potential advantage of reduced radiation in patients after stapes surgery suffering from vertigo or hearing loss to evaluate piston position.

Virtual Quality Control in Middle Ear Surgery: Is Image-guided Tympanoscopy a Valuable Tool for Depicting Borderline Situations?

HYPOTHESIS

Before modern imaging was introduced, revision surgery was the only way to evaluate possible reasons for inadequate improvement in hearing after ossicular replacement during reconstructive middle ear surgery.

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to evaluate freely navigable virtual tympanoscopy using different computed tomographic modalities. We compared cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT), flat panel computed tomography (FPCT), and conventional computed tomography in helical mode (CTH), volume mode (CTV), and ultra high resolution mode (CTD).

METHODS

Four temporal bone specimens were reconstructed with partial or total ossicular replacement prostheses. The best functional results for prosthetic coupling were achieved under the control of laser Doppler vibrometry (LDV). Afterward, a progressive step-by-step decoupling of the prostheses was carried out. Different prosthesis positions were evaluated by LDV as well as different computed tomographic modalities with 3D reconstruction of each dataset.

RESULTS

Anatomical structures were better depicted and the best position and coupling of inserted prostheses were achieved using CBCT. All imaging techniques could be used to control the position of middle ear prostheses, but CBCT provided the highest resolution and the best image quality in both 2D and 3D reformations and in 3D-animated video representation.

CONCLUSION

Compared with several other imaging modalities, CBCT was best at depicting miscellaneous coupling problems. Noninvasive detection of coupling problems caused by minimal loss of contact between prostheses and middle ear ossicles will influence the clinical outcome. This early detection will help to determine whether revision surgery is needed.

Image quality of flat-panel computed tomography using 2 different acquisition times versus multidetector computed tomography in whole-head temporal bone specimen

PURPOSE

Imaging of temporal bone and skull base acquire high resolution due to the small anatomic structures with high clinical relevance. The purpose of this study was to compare image quality of the temporal bone in standard 20 s protocol flat-panel computed tomography (FPCT) with the new time- and dose improved 10 s protocol as well as with 128 slice multidetector computed tomography (MDCT). The aim was to evaluate the new time- and dose improved 10 s protocol.

METHODS

10 whole-skull preparations-20 temporal bones-were scanned with either 128 slice MDCT CT (SOMATOM Definition AS + , Siemens, Erlangen) or FPCT (AXIOM-Artis, Siemens, Erlangen) using 10 s or 20 s protocol.

RESULTS

We show here that overall FPCT provides significantly better image quality and improved delimitation of clinically relevant structures in the temporal bone compared to 128 slice MDCT. Especially the shorter, dose saving 10 s protocol of the FPCT is still superior to 128 slice MDCT. The 20 s FPCT protocol was only significantly superior in identification of the cochlear apical turn and can thereby be used specifically in clinical cases with pathologies in this area.

CONCLUSIONS

The 10 s FPCT protocol yields a significantly better image quality than MDCT in imaging finer structures of the temporal bone.

Stapes piston insertion depth and clinical correlations

Background: The insertion of the stapes piston within the vestibule provides the physical basis for a successful stapedotomy. An insertion depth of 0.5 mm is recommended to avoid the dislocation of the stapes prosthesis (e.g. sneezing). Aims: The objective of this study is to analyze the depth of stapes prosthesis insertion and its correlation with clinical outcome. Material and methods: We observed in a retrospective case series 39 otosclerosis patients after a stapedotomy and a postoperative performed flat panel tomography/cone beam CT. The evaluation included the radiologically found depth of prosthesis insertion within the vestibule, the vestibule depth, and the correlation with the bone conduction (BC) threshold, vertigo, and tinnitus. Results: Insertion depth varied between 0.2 and 1.6 mm (mean 0.74 mm). The ratio of insertion depth versus the vestibule depth was between 8% and 59% (mean 26.6%). We observed no correlation between the insertion depth, the length of the prosthesis, the ratio of insertion depth/vestibule depth, postoperative BC, appearance of vertigo, or tinnitus. Conclusions and significance: In our group, we observed no significant relation between insertion depth of the stapes piston, postoperative vertigo, tinnitus, or decrease of the BC.

Stapes Prosthesis Length: One Size Fits All?

BACKGROUND

The insertion of the stapes piston into the vestibule provides the physical basis for a successful stapedotomy. In routine clinical practice, two different ways to handle prosthesis length are performed: (1) an individualized measurement of the stapes prosthesis length or (2) a standard prosthesis length for all cases.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to compare both ways of handling prosthesis length and the effect of these methods on insertional prosthesis depth.

MATERIAL AND METHOD

We retrospectively evaluated 39 patients after performing a stapedotomy for radiologically estimated vestibular stapes prosthesis insertion depth. The individual measured length data were hypothetically changed to a standard length of 4.75, 5, 5.25, and 5.5 mm, and the insertion depths were compared.

RESULTS

The individually measured prosthesis lengths led to an insertion depth between 0.2 and 1.6 mm (mean 0.74 mm). The ratio of insertion depth/vestibular depth was between 8 and 59.1% (mean 26.6%). The different assumed standard lengths led to different rates of the vestibulum positions and possible bony contacts at the vestibulum floor.

CONCLUSION

The individual measurement led to a zero rate of the vestibulum positions of stapes prosthesis pistons with a low insertion depth/vestibular depth ratio.

Flat Panel Angiography in the Cross-Sectional Imaging of the Temporal Bone: Assessment of Image Quality and Radiation Dose Compared with a 64-Section Multisection CT Scanner

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Cross-sectional imaging of the temporal bone is challenging because of the complexity and small dimensions of the anatomic structures. We evaluated the role of flat panel angiography in the cross-sectional imaging of the temporal bone by comparing its image quality and radiation dose with a 64-section multisection CT scanner.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively collected 29 multisection CT and 29 flat panel angiography images of normal whole-head temporal bones. Image quality was assessed by 2 neuroradiologists, who rated the visualization of 30 anatomic structures with a 3-point ordinal scale. The radiation dose was assessed with an anthropomorphic phantom.

RESULTS

Flat panel angiography showed better image quality than multisection CT in depicting the anterior and posterior crura of the stapes, the footplate of the stapes, the stapedius muscle, and the anterior ligament of the malleus (P < .05). In contrast, multisection CT showed better image quality than flat panel angiography in assessing the tympanic membrane, the bone marrow of the malleus and incus, the tendon of the tensor tympani, the interscalar septum, and the modiolus of the cochlea (P < .05). Flat panel angiography had a significantly higher overall image quality rating than multisection CT (P = .035). A reduction of the effective dose of approximately 40% was demonstrated for flat panel angiography compared with multisection CT.

CONCLUSIONS

Flat panel angiography shows strengths and weaknesses compared with multisection CT. It is more susceptible to artifacts, but due to the higher spatial resolution, it shows equal or higher image quality in assessing some bony structures of diagnostic interest. The lower radiation dose is an additional advantage of flat panel angiography.

Experimental Simulation of Clinical Borderline Situations in Temporal Bone Specimens After Ossiculoplasty

OBJECTIVES

One reason for insufficient hearing improvement with a distinct air-bone gap after ossiculoplasty with implantation of partial or total ossicular replacement prostheses can be the dislocation or minimal shifting of the prosthesis. The aim of this study was the simulation of common clinical borderline situations with minimal shifting of the prosthesis in temporal bone specimens after ossiculoplasty. It was furthermore the goal to identify these specific situations through imaging by cone beam computed tomography (cbCT) and direct visual inspection using the operation microscope. Additionally, the functional status was evaluated using laser-Doppler vibrometry (LDV).

DESIGN

We used a total of four temporal bone specimens for this study. A reconstruction with a partial ossicular replacement prostheses was performed in three specimens and with a total ossicular replacement prostheses in one specimen, with good initial acoustic properties. Subsequently, one specific type of prosthesis failure was simulated in each specimen, respectively, by minimally shifting, tilting, or bending the prostheses from their initial positions. These changes were introduced step-by-step until a borderline situation just short of complete acoustic decoupling was reached. Each step was examined using both LDV and cbCT and observed through the operation microscope.

RESULTS

LDV was able to quantify the mechanic function of the ossicular chain after most of the manipulation steps by demonstrating the effect of any shifting of the prosthesis on the middle ear transfer function. However, in some situations, the middle ear transfer function was better with a visually more advanced failure of the prosthesis. In addition, cbCT showed most of the steps with excellent resolution and was able to delineate changes in soft tissue (e.g., cartilage covering).

CONCLUSION

cbCT seems to be a promising imaging technique for middle ear problems. As cbCT and LDV exhibited slightly different advantages and disadvantages regarding the demonstration of borderline situations, the combination of both techniques allowed for a more precise evaluation of middle ear reconstructions. Knowledge of the specific characteristics of these methods and their possible combination might help otologists and otosurgeons to refine indications for revision surgery and improve their personal patient counseling.

Contemporary imaging of auditory implants

There have been significant advances in the diversity and effectiveness of hearing technologies in recent years. Implanted auditory devices may be divided into those that stimulate the cochlear hair cells (bone conduction devices and middle ear implants), and those that stimulate the neural structures (cochlear implants and central auditory implants). Contemporary preoperative and postoperative imaging may be used to help individualise implant selection, optimise surgical technique and predict auditory outcome. This review will introduce the concepts behind auditory implants, and explains how imaging is increasingly used to aid insertion and evaluation of these devices.

MPR-CT Imaging for Stapes Prosthesis: Accuracy and Clinical Significance

OBJECTIVES

The aims of this article are: 1) to re-evaluate the accuracy of multiple planar reconstruction computed tomography (MPR-CT) imaging on stapes-prosthesis parameters, and 2) to clarify possible relationships between prosthesis intravestibular depth and postoperative hearing outcomes.

PATIENTS

Seventy patients (46 women and 24 men; 32 right and 38 left sides) with the mean age of 40 years (range, 19-62 yr) with clinical otosclerosis.

INTERVENTION(S)

All patients underwent stapedotomy and were implanted with the same type of titanium piston prosthesis by the same surgeon.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Postoperative MPR-CTs were obtained at patients' follow-up visits. The length and intravestibular depth of the stapes prosthesis (including absolute and relative depth) were calculated from the MPR-CT imaging. Relationships between the intravestibular depth of the prosthesis and hearing outcomes (pre- and postoperative audiograms) were analyzed using Spearman correlation analyses.

RESULTS

The length of the prosthesis was overestimated by 1.8% (0.1 mm) by the MPR-CT imaging. Axial and coronal measurements were significantly correlated (p < 0.05). There was great intersubject variability in hearing outcomes differed insignificantly, regardless of intravestibular depth within the security range. No relationships were found between the intravestibular depth of the stapes prosthesis, as measured with MPR-CT, and postoperative hearing results.

CONCLUSIONS

MPR-CT can provide an accurate estimation of stapes prosthesis parameters. However, the prosthesis intravestibular depth did not seem to affect postoperative hearing outcomes.

The role of imaging in the diagnosis and management of otosclerosis

OBJECTIVE

To examine the evidence for the role of radiologic imaging in the diagnosis and management of otosclerosis.

DATA SOURCES

A review of contemporary (1990 to present) English medical literature via MedLine using the terms imaging, otosclerosis, otospongiosis, stapes surgery, computed tomography, magnetic resonance, CT, and MRI was performed.

STUDY SELECTION

Abstracts were reviewed independently by 2 authors and relevant articles were then evaluated. Exclusion criteria included editorials, non-English language, comments, and letters.

DATA EXTRACTION

Level of evidence was assigned in accordance with the Oxford Centre for Evidence-based Medicine guidance (Levels I-V).

RESULTS

Thirty-seven articles met the inclusion criteria, of which, 11 were of Level III, 22 of Level IV, and 4 of level V evidence. High-resolution computed tomography (CT) of the temporal bones is the imaging technique of choice in the diagnosis of otosclerosis with newer multidetector scanners demonstrating a sensitivity and specificity in excess of 90%. There is Level III evidence that CT densitometry and extent of disease on CT correlates with hearing thresholds. Extensive and multifocal disease on CT has a poorer prognosis (Level III/IV). The potential use of CT in staging classifications, surgical planning, predicting surgical outcomes and risk of complications has also been described and evaluated.

CONCLUSION

This systematic review indicates that imaging has a useful role in both the diagnosis and management of otosclerosis, supported principally by Level III/IV evidence.

[Quality control following reconstructive middle ear surgery: from bench to bedside]

BACKGROUND

The ongoing improvement of imaging quality nowadays focuses increasingly more on immediate quality evaluation of surgical measures.

METHODS

Rotational tomography (RT) has been experimentally proven to be an alternative imaging technique to computed tomography (CT) in terms of quality and postoperative localization of middle ear implants in temporal bones. Based on these results imaging parameters were determined in the form of a surgical check list in order to systematically check individual but important surgical reconstructive steps.

RESULTS

The positive benefit of RT concerning immediate and significant postoperative quality control was confirmed by a patient study. The surgical check list was successfully implemented under clinical framework requirements. Among these standardized parameters the determined angulation of inserted middle ear implants was given outstanding significance due to the predictive value concerning functional outcome.

CONCLUSION

The RT procedure has been proven to be a reliable imaging tool for postoperative quality control following reconstructive middle ear surgery.